❌

Normal view

There are new articles available, click to refresh the page.
Before yesterdayMain stream

Google faces calls for AI moratoriums in schools after Gemini pilot backlash

12 November 2026 at 18:57

CHICAGO—Families joined protests in seven cities nationwide on Wednesday, rallying against what they see as Google’s bid to entrench its AI models in schools, turn kids of all ages into Gemini guinea pigs, and hook them on AI.

The backlash follows a Google statement last week, confirming that there will be no way for students to use Google Search without AI. While Google claimed it was giving schools “more choice, not less”—by turning off Search, Gemini, and Gemini Notebook by default—it would not provide an option that allowed Search without AI. For students, the only way to avoid interacting with AI was to remember to add “-ai” to every query, parents worried.

In Chicago, many families showed up to protest Google, despite cold, rainy weather. Waving signs, dozens of protesters marched up to Google’s downtown office as workers seemed to be leaving for the day, shouting chants like “Hey Google, nice try, we don’t want your Gemini” and “Hey, Google, leave our kids alone!”

Read full article

Comments

© Ashley Belanger

Google will let schools skip AI tools, but they have to give up search, too

3 November 2026 at 17:54

While Google is trying to move beyond Chromebooks, the ubiquity of these devices has made the company's education products huge in schools. Now, Google says it will let educators choose whether to allow its AI tools in the classroom. However, blocking AI tools also means giving up search, leaving schools with a difficult decision.

Google's new overarching approach to AI in K-12 classrooms sounds good on the surface. After consulting educators, researchers, and lawmakers, Google has decided that schools using its education products will be opted out of AI tools by default. It will be up to administrators to manually enable them when these changes roll out in the coming months.

When you look at what Google considers to be an AI tool, the nature of the Faustian bargain becomes clear. The affected products are Gemini, Gemini Notebook, Gemini in Classroom, and Google Search. There's no picking and choosing—you either allow all the AI or none of it.

Read full article

Comments

© Aurich Lawson

Thousands of “ghost students” use AI to steal millions in student loans, DOJ says

30 October 2026 at 16:53

The US has charged five individuals as part of the first broad federal crackdown on “ghost students”—fraudsters who steal the identities of hundreds of Americans to pose as fake college students and steal student loans.

In a press release Thursday, the Department of Justice said it had uncovered a large-scale scheme relying partly on AI. The DOJ seized more than $750,000 in cryptocurrency from “a network associated with Kenyan nationals" after data analysis helped flag likely fraudsters. Assistant Attorney General Colin M. McDonald of the DOJ’s National Fraud Enforcement Division credited new fraud-detection measures implemented by the Trump administration for the arrests. He said that “this is the first international seizure of its kind in Kenya,” while warning fraudsters that the crackdown has only just begun.

“If you steal American identities, if you steal taxpayer dollars, if you exploit programs meant to help students build a future—we will find you,” McDonald said. “Whether you are in Nebraska, New Jersey, Virginia, or Nairobi, we will pursue you.”

Read full article

Comments

© Siro Rodenas Cortes | Moment

Introducing Our New Surveillance Self-Defense Guide: Online Privacy for Parents and Youth

The internet is a vast and confusing place no matter your age. Trying to help youth engage with it safely and privately is a complicated topic that touches on many different skillsets and ideas. But just because it’s complicated doesn’t mean it’s impossible. We’ve launched our Online Privacy for Parents and Youth Surveillance Self-Defense guide in hopes to provide a framework for finding solutions that work for you. 

EFF rolls out this crucial resource as state and local governments consider ill-advised laws that cut young people off from essential information and experiences. This particularly harms vulnerable youth and marginalized groups who often find safety in supportive online communities they can't access offline. Such laws also entail age gating, which compromises the privacy of all internet users and stifles young users’ ability to learn, grow, and express themselves.

Young people have unique needs and those needs change over time. Trying to protect from everything all the time is an exhausting process, but the security community has long had a solution for this: security planning (also called threat modeling). The idea is to provide a series of questions designed to help you focus on what’s truly important. When it comes to online privacy, this is as applicable for youth and parents as it is for anyone else. 

We used a security plan as our foundation for this guide because deciding what is and isn’t important is the first step we should all take when assessing our privacy risks. But this isn’t a place for quick fixes, and every young person has their unique needs and considerations. There is no single tool or technology fix that can substitute for spending time learning, and then teaching a young person, how the internet works, how to use it, what sorts of harms exist, and how to navigate those harms.

Solutions are rarely about the tools or software you use. It’s about understanding the threats and concerns you have, and then determining what steps you can take to mitigate those risks. We hope our Online Privacy for Parents and Youth guide can help provide the outline to get the conversation started.

Donate Today!

Amnesty International slams UK universities for ‘crackdown’ on pro-Palestinian solidarity

Several UK universities have restricted Palestine solidarity activism among students and academics, a new report from Amnesty International has claimed.

According to Amnesty, universities have cancelled meetings and events, framed peaceful protest as ‘disruption’, shut down encampments, and taken pre-emptive punitive measures against campaigners – all of which the campaign group says indicates attempts to restrict campaigning in solidarity with the Palestinian people.

Amnesty conducted research looking at events between 7 October 2023 and 30 September 2025 while also examining the preceding 18 months to contextualise patterns of practice.

According to the report, different universities took different approaches over this period. The report stressed that each interference or violation of rights Amnesty found was present in at least one case study, not all were found at each university it looked at.

Amnesty International found that the restrictions highlighted in case studies documented in the report often didn’t meet the high bar in international and UK law for interfering with political speech and peaceful assembly.

The report did, however, find that students and academics have been sanctioned for actions like chanting, clapping and wearing keffiyehs, with these sanctions including suspensions, campus bans, withdrawal of degrees and threats to visa status. Students who are visibly Muslim and those displaying symbols of Palestinian identity have been disproportionately impacted, Amnesty has alleged.

In several cases, Amnesty found that sanctions were imposed before disciplinary hearings had concluded. Amnesty argues that this effectively transformed precautionary measures into punishments and contributes to a chilling effect.

In some cases documented in the report, universities prolonged investigations without clarifying timelines, outcomes or routes for appeal. These prolonged investigations combined with campus bans, restricted access to services, and uncertainty about potential outcomes – had severe impacts on people’s education, mental health and future prospects, Amnesty claims.

Amnesty International found that some universities have relied on overly broad disciplinary codes to restrict solidarity actions, such as by unduly characterising protests as ‘disruptive’, or ‘offensive’, with no apparent evidence of targeted harm. The report found instances of universities treating peaceful protest as trespass, even in spaces such as campus squares, foyers and union buildings which have been used for protests for decades.

According to Amnesty, some universities have adopted measures that require advance approval for protests and others have resorted to court injunctions which impose blanket bans across large parts of campus, exposing students and staff to risk of fines and imprisonment for engaging in protest.

Kerry Moscogiuri, CEO of Amnesty International UK said: “This is an attack on our freedom of speech and the right to protest from the very institutions who are supposed to encourage free thought.

“Students and academics care about the victims of Israel’s genocide in Gaza. It’s beyond belief that some of our prominent universities see this as a threat that requires punitive measures like court injunctions, and harsh punishments that leave students with their lives turned upside down.

“This is part of a wider crackdown on communities coming together to make their voices heard on Israel’s genocide of Palestinians in Gaza and other issues they care about. Just as we’re seeing students facing sanctions for clapping and chanting on our campuses, we’re seeing grandparents, amongst many others, facing arrest for holding placards at the Defend Our Juries protests.”

Through its report, Amnesty argued that UK universities are not acting in isolation when responding to Palestine solidarity protests, but are operating within a network which encouraged repressive responses and that their responses reflect sector-wide practices, shaped by direct government pressure, regulatory direction, lobbying by advocacy groups, and advice from private law firms and security contractors. 

Amnesty has found that some universities have shared legal strategies, received instructions from the Department for Education, and shared their security planning with the effect of clamping down on those perceived to be showing support for the victims of Israel’s apartheid and genocide in Gaza.

In cases profiled in this report, Palestine-related expression frequently came under greater scrutiny, or appeared to have been regulated differently from the way that other student protests at universities might generally be regulated. Students and staff who are Palestinian, Arab, Muslim and from other racialised communities, as well as students who are not British nationals, have experienced particular and disproportionate impacts, Amnesty claims.

22 year old student Usama Ghanem was suspended by Kings College London in 2025 over his involvement in pro Palestinian activism, and told to “return to [Egypt] during this period of suspension”, where he had previously been detained and tortured. His suspension was lifted after review in September 2026. 

Usama said: “I left an authoritarian regime in Egypt to find one at King’s College London. For protesting a genocide our university was funding and demanding divestment, I was indefinitely suspended, monitored, and threatened with deportation to the very authoritarian regime I had fled. As a lead negotiator for our Palestine encampment, I saw King’s discipline 25 other students too. This was about more than punishment, it was an attempt to intimidate us into silence. A university should protect dissent, not surveil and punish students for challenging its complicity in genocide.”

Other universities criticised in the report include Oxford, Cambridge and LSE.

Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward

Image credit: Scotgunn – Creative Commons

The post Amnesty International slams UK universities for ‘crackdown’ on pro-Palestinian solidarity appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

A Week of Lapidary Learning

11 October 2026 at 21:25

I attend a week-long lapidary class at the William Holland School of Lapidary Arts in Young Harris, GA.

It all started when I watched a YouTube video about lapidary intarsia. I thought the resulting cabochons were very cool and had the potential to help my take my jewelry work to the next level.

Some definitions might be in order before I go on:

  • Lapidary is the process of shaping and polishing stones into decorative items such as cabochons, engraved gems (such as cameos), and faceted designs. Read more on Wikipedia.
  • Intarsia is a method of seamlessly combining stones, normally to make cabochons, but possibly as part of an inlaying process. (The Wikipedia entry discusses wood intarsia; stone intarsia is similar but with stone.)
  • Inlay is similar to intarsia but the stones are cut to fit precisely into a pre-made metal frame. (I’m also interested in learning how to do inlays.)

Why Build Lapidary Skills?

CabKing
I bought a CabKing like this one about 8 years ago when I first began working with stones and making jewelry.

When I first got started making jewelry, I had a real interest in lapidary work, too. So much of an interest, in fact, that I bought a CabKing cabochon making machine and quite a bit of stone rough and slabs. I quickly realized, however, that I’d rather make jewelry than cut and polish stones. And when I discovered a very affordable source of cabochons for my work, I simply stopped using the CabKing and put all those unpolished stones in storage.

The trouble with using off-the-shelf (so to speak) cabochons in my work is that I was forced to design around the stones I had instead of designing what I wanted to make and then making the custom stones I needed. But I didn’t feel confident about my cabochon-making skills. And I was doing okay designing around what I could get.

Over time, my work improved to the point where I had the skills I needed to make interesting jewelry. My work was better than average at most of the art shows I attended. I had no trouble selling work priced at up to $250. But my work wasn’t good enough to make it at the fine art shows where finished pieces could fetch $500 or more. My “statement pieces” were stuttered phrases, not real statements. (So to speak.) And I was unable to get into the shows where true statement pieces were sought by people who had the money to spend on them. I was caught in a sort of netherworld between low-end high-quality jewelry and high-end fine art jewelry. I wanted to step up, not down.

I had seen jewelry by lapidaries who were able to achieve what I wanted to. John Heusler, who I was introduced to back in 2018 (?) in Quartzsite, AZ, by a mutual friend, made cabochons for the jewelry he designed and made. Jeff Fulkerson was another artist who made stunning jewelry with his own intarsia and inlay work. Both of them had numerous articles in the now defunct Lapidary Journal magazine that stuffed my reference shelves. They made work similar to what I wanted to make. Something better than I was already making.

Watching the video about intarsia and thinking about inlays got me thinking about how custom stones could help me raise my work to the next level with true originality. I could start with a vision of a final piece and construct it from scratch with raw metal and stone.

At least that’s what I think is possible.

The William Holland School of Lapidary Arts

The video I saw about intarsia showed a facility called the William Holland School of Lapidary Arts in Georgia. I think there was a plug for it at the end. I tracked down its website. I was interested in taking a class over the winter months — my brain said Georgia is south so it should be a good winter destination — but soon discovered that they don’t offer winter classes. (The mountains in Georgia get snow — who knew?) But I did find a class during a narrow window of availability in my calendar between some time training people on my boat in September and my boat’s haul out date in October. It was called Forbidden Lapidary and it was being taught by a familiar name: Jeff Fulkerson.

Here’s the description:

FORBIDDEN LAPIDARY: WHAT YOUR MOTHER NEVER TOLD YOU
INSTRUCTOR: JEFF FULKERSON

This is the class you always wanted but didn’t know it! In this class I’ll reveal several shortcuts, new techniques, giving old tools new uses, and totally unrelated tricks that will shoot your lapidary skills to the next level. In this class you will learn to back stones, we’ll explore different dopping techniques, and how to make cabettes (small cabochons for stone on stonework).

You will learn alternative methods to polish soft stones, how to line up & make small dots or round cabochons, cutting earring pairs, how to polish flat cabochons on a lapidary arbor and we will make some odd shaped and sharp cornered cabs including concaved shapes. Finally, we’ll look at making an intarsia cab, the mystery of superglue & silver dust, as well as Un-dopping different dopping techniques.

Students must provide rough stones for the intarsia. I recommend lapis, jaspers, as well as some rough turquoise. Think about what colors you’d like when selecting your rough. Bring more than you think you’ll need. The instructor will have a very limited supply of
rough.

Class Fee: $295
Kit Fee: $35 to cover consumables
Prerequisite: Students must have taken a lapidary class & have a basic knowledge of cab making

Yes, it included intarsia, which is what I wanted most to learn. The prerequisite was a lapidary class and basic knowledge of cab making. I had experience making cabs but had never taken a formal class. But I had confidence I could keep up without a lot of special attention.

I did some research about the school. It was well-reviewed. The campus was in a wooded area in the mountains of northern Georgia. There was lodging and all meals were included in the lodging fee. There was also a campground. The classrooms were well equipped and class size was limited to six students.

In late August, I felt like I needed to treat myself to a self-improvement trip. Maybe something that would motivate me to get back to jewelry making was just the ticket. The insane price increase of silver — which has come back down, but not to pre-increase levels — had pretty much put a stop to my silversmithing activities. And the sickly economy was making it difficult to sell the inventory I already had (other than earrings and bracelets, which always sell well). I was going to try (again) to spend the entire winter at home and was willing to dedicate a part of that time to my jewelry making work. Learning new skills would fire me up.

So I worked my logistics skills, signed up for the class with lodging, booked plane tickets, found a somewhat affordable rental car, and arranged for a dog sitter. Later when my dog sitter backed out (for good reason), I found another dog sitter. Then I booked two hotel rooms. The trip was not going to be cheap — and I can blame that on my hatred of cross-country tube flying prompting me to get a first class ticket to Atlanta — but I felt I deserved it.

Forbidden Lapidary

Last week was the week. It was an extremely informative, confidence-building event that had me feeling relaxed and full of both questions and answers. And a real desire to take more classes.

First Jeff was a great instructor. His demonstrations clearly showed how to perform a task and were followed up with time to try it on our own with him standing by to help if needed.

Class Photo
We each got a copy of our class photo. Do I look like someone who has had her hands in cold water all week? (That or worse!)

Second, there were only two students: me and a woman about my age named Cathy. With fewer students and skill levels to deal with, Jeff was able to give us all the attention we needed during the 4 1/2 days of class time.

Jeff could have called his class “Real Life Lapidary” because he covered the kinds of things real lapidaries need to know. This included turning scrap pieces into usable cabochons and “repairing” stones that need a little work before they can be used in jewelry. Of these techniques, I think that filling crevices in stones like turquoise with silver filings and backing uneven or unstable stones before cutting and polishing them are at the top of my list. Anyone who has made a cab has experienced a stone breaking during the cutting process; Jeff gave us some good, working suggestions for salvaging that stone. It may not sound like a big deal, but with turquoise rough selling for $3 or more per gram, anything you can do to maximize the amount of usable stone saves money and keeps costs down.

I will also benefit from his discussion on different dapping techniques. Dapping is the process of affixing a handle to the bottom of a stone to better grip it when cutting and polishing on the cab machine. When I first made cabs, I didn’t use dapping sticks. But I got some practice in class and definitely think it’s helpful. I’m looking forward to making my own dapping sticks out of nails and trimmed hex keys.

Earring Pair
One of the three earring pairs I made in class.

We learned how to create matched pairs of stones for earrings by slicing a rough cab in half and then polishing the two halves. I made three of these but Cathy went nuts and made at least a half-dozen pairs. I think that was her favorite part of the class; she’s already taken a bunch of lapidary classes there.

And then there was the intarsia, which I got to try three times. Two projects were stones attached to other stones and one was the inlaying of a circle inside a hole drilled into a stone. My work wasn’t bad for first efforts; I look forward to seeing what kinds of designs I can come up with for future jewelry pieces.

Petosky Stone
Here’s a perfect example of the kind of work I can do with the right equipment. I bought a Petosky Stone about the size and shape of a medium potato at the auction on Tuesday night. The next day, I cut it into slabs and then cut and polished one of the slabs to make this hexagon shaped cabochon that drew a lot of complements. I even sold one of the slabs at the tailgate that night.

Another benefit of the class was having every kind of equipment needed right there at our fingertips. In addition to enough cab machines that we could all use them at the same time, there were also a pair of flat laps, trim saws in two sizes, a slab saw, and even an intarsia machine. (Imagine a flat lap laid on its side with a 90° angle shelf to support stones being trimmed.) My equipment is limited to my CabKing with a flat lap on the side, a tile saw I sometimes use for trimming rocks, and another flat lap I’ve never used for stone work. After taking the class, I’ve realized that I could probably benefit with a real trim saw and could possibly convert that tile saw for intarsia grinding. I don’t want to invest in any more equipment than I have to.

Agate w/Druzy
On Sunday, the day before class started, I visited two local rock shops. I bought an agate cab with this bit of druzy (crystals) in it. I made good use of the trim saw to cut a shape out of the stone. Lots of pieces broke off but the main shape survived through the cutting and polishing process.

Jeff also shared information about supplies he uses in his work, including specific brands of super glue (used for intarsias) and epoxy (used for backing stones) and types of drill bits (for drilling stones).

Intarsia
I brought two composite bricks from home: white buffalo and Kingman turquoise. I cut two slabs from each and used pieces to make my first basic intarsia. I’m not terribly keen on it, but Jeff said it was a big hit at Show and Tell.

A plus for me was getting some of my Kingman Turquoise Mine composite bricks cut on the slab saw. I didn’t cut much because I was cutting them too thick, but I have a good feel for how they cut and think I can cut the rest at home.

I’ll be honest: the topics covered in class could have been covered in less time. Maybe 3 days instead of 4 1/2? But then we would have missed out on the extra practice we were able to get with all that time in class. And it was great to have an experienced jeweler and lapidary artist on hand to grill with questions. We asked him lots of things; he even commented how much he liked being asked things that weren’t included in the curriculum.

Outside of class time, I made a few friends and got to poke my head into other classes to see what they were up to. Not all of the classes focused on lapidary work. There were several silversmithing and beading classes. Another class did knife handle inlays and yet another glass was dedicated to inlays. A Master Class focused on the creation of dies that could be used to punch custom shapes out of metal sheet for production work — I could really benefit from that, too.

My Lapidary Retreat

My room at the campus was in Otto’s Lodge, which happened to be a long uphill walk from the main building. I walked it three times, one of which was in the dark. (It was very dark there at night.) The rest of the time I drove up in my rental car, taking everything I needed for the day. The accommodations were simple but comfortable. I paid extra for single lodging; at my age, I really can’t deal with unknown roommates and would not like to subject strangers to my potentially loud snoring.

William Holland from the Air
Here’s the main building and one of the other lodges from the air. (Of course I brought a drone with me.) The classrooms and cafeteria are on the lower level, which is ground level at the back of the building. There’s lodging on the upper level. Otto’s Lodge was down the hill, beyond the trees, and is not visible in this image.

There was lots of social time at meals — breakfast, lunch, and dinner every day. The food was good enough. Nothing special, but every meal was balanced and there was a nicely stocked salad bar available. I totally pigged out on chicken pot pie night, although the “pot pie” was a sort of chicken stew with pastry pieces baked on top. What got me was the noodles they served with it. Breakfast was tough for me; I usually eat homemade granola and fiber cereal with fresh berries and all they had was sugar cereal like Honey Cheerios. I ate eggs and grits or oatmeal instead.

There were special events after dinner. There was a fundraising auction on Tuesday for a wide range of lapidary related (and other) stuff; I bought some stones and back issues of Lapidary Journal, and stone backing material. There was a tailgate event on Wednesday where many of us laid out stones and jewelry for sale; I sold two slabs I’d brought along and one of the silver crosses I’d made and bought one really nice cabochon. There was show and tell on Thursday, where each class put their finished and in-progress projects on display.

Show and Tell
Here’s my Show and Tell tray. I labeled everything (as if the people there couldn’t identify the stones).

In all, the experience could easily be described as an immersive retreat. Not only did I learn a lot, but I felt relaxed, slept reasonably well, ate well, and made friends.

Would I Do It Again?

Hell Yes!

Hell, yes!

But I won’t do it the same way. Instead, I’ll plan to be there three to four consecutive weeks, staying in the campground, which was nestled in the woods near the main building. Lodging is cheaper there, so I can save some money. I just need to make the cross-country drive to Georgia. I’m thinking of next summer, possibly after my big boating trip. I’d like to take at least one inlay class and possibly a class on creating and using dies.

Honestly, I’d love to be an instructor there. My silversmithing skills are totally up-to-speed and I’d like to teach some project-based classes where we create specific pieces using a wide variety of skills. I’m already making big plans to teach in my home-based studio this winter. Teaching in the summer in such a well-equipped environment would be a blast.

Web Design Schools Have a Giant YouTube University Problem — And AI Just Made It Worse

8 October 2026 at 15:45
A web design degree used to be the obvious way to learn the craft. Now it’s competing with YouTube, AI, and people who spend those same years actually building things — so if universities can’t offer something better, students have every right to ask what they’re paying for.

Doxxing Safety Part II: Incident Response

31 August 2026 at 19:02

Doxxing, also known as the deliberate sharing of personal information to harass or endanger someone, is a tricky thing to protect against. It often happens by some ill-intentioned person accessing publicly available information, then sharing that information more widely in the hopes it will intimidate their target or worse. 

This guide is a followup from a previous post that describes a methodology for you to clean up your digital footprint and get a firm entry into the art of open source intelligence. There's a slight bit of repetition here, but with a slant towards using those now-familiar tools and methods toward what to do in the context of incident response. The best thing you can do is familiarize yourself with this post and its tactics before something happens, then return back to it for reference when needed.

Incident Log

An incident log is a way to keep track of suspicious or harmful activity online. It doesn't need to be beautiful or complex, just a place where you can quickly note details around the different things you're seeing online. Noting times, places, people, and the general nature of what you see ought to be enough. In the event that law enforcement gets involved, this sort of record will be helpful. 

 Where/Site, Date & Time, Brief Description of Action, Threat-Actor Name/Description, Any Other People Involved.

The process of finding and noting hateful incidents online can be incredibly stressful, so now is a good time to revisit the team roles you might have already thought of in the previous blog post. If you haven't yet done that, here's a brief refresher:

Assign Team Roles

Remember, privacy–and responding to doxxing–is a team sport. Knowing who you trust is as important as identifying threat actors. Having trusted people ready to assist is invaluable in this type of situation. Refer them to this blog post or specific recommendations in it. If you've already plotted out a list of designated team roles, now is the time to remind everyone of their responsibilities. That might look like monitoring the hate forums where activity happens, keeping track of events in the incident log, setting up web alerts, locking down your social media accounts, or contacting law enforcement to reduce the likelihood of SWATing (a type of attack where bad actors call the police on their target, hoping to incite violence or disruption of peace by bringing law enforcement to their door).

Monitoring Hate Forums

So often the victims of doxxing and harassment campaigns are positioned that way because of bias or bigotry. If you're a part of a community who is the target of such abuse, you are likely already aware of the places where such bigots gather and the language they use. Safely and privately accessing those sites to check for organizing against you or those in your community is a crucial step to take. Take great care to do so privately. We recommend you use the Tor browser for such information-gathering missions. It’s also advisable that you don’t engage with anyone in those places.

Again, this step can be particularly stressful; asking a friend for help is a good idea, or you can thoughtfully apply some of the advice from the next section to automate the process.

Set Up Search Alerts

Google alerts is a free service that Google offers to alert you when a particular keyword—like your name—is freshly indexed by their search engine. Doxxing efforts done by anonymous trolls may not trigger an alert, but if you're the target of smear campaigns in the media, or the victim of abuse by very prominent media figures, those things are more likely to appear. Updates can come pretty frequently, so we advise leaving the monitoring of these alerts to a person that you trust.

For a more sophisticated approach, you could use a tool like Open Measures to automate the task of tracking coordinated campaigns. It's important to note that this type of tool is more likely to miss nuanced language or oblique references to you and your community.

Hardening Your Public Facing Accounts

For accounts that you can't or don't want to shut down, at the very least you must review the privacy and security settings on them and consider raising that bar. If two-factor authentication isn't already on, now is the time to do so. For social media accounts, consider switching the account to "private," where users have to request to have access to your page. For peace of mind, especially on accounts that you have to keep using, consider muting certain terms and blocking accounts so that you're less likely to encounter stressful content when on the app. Every app's options are different for this sort of thing, so be prepared to spend a few minutes figuring out what the menu is like and where the options are.

Shut Down Affected Accounts

If a particular account is being targeted with hate, or signs are pointing to an account of yours being the source of information people are using against you, shutting down that account may be the best decision for now. Depending on the app, account deletion may be temporary and you may be able to recover the account after you've done so and things have cooled off.

Revisit Your Data Broker Removal Strategies

Although this is more of a doxxing preventative measure, it's a good idea to get on top of removing the information that's available about you via data brokers. In case you're unaware, the data broker industry is an unregulated viper’s nest of privacy threats, often contributing to or directly supplying the sources of information that are used in doxxing campaigns. Although there are plenty of services that offer to file data broker opt-out requests on your behalf, a recent study revealed that doing it DIY is still more effective than relying on these paid services. That said, a paid service may still be worth its money if you'd rather have someone else take care of it.

Revisit Public Records

As covered in the previous blog post, your information may be made available through public records that you have little to no control over. You may be able to limit the convenience of that information being available by requesting to have it taken down from sites that republish it. Check through voter records, business registration records, court and property records, and the like. If you aren't able to limit that information from appearing on such mirroring sites, at least gaining awareness of where they are and the specific contours of what they contain will help you strategize against the harms they may cause.

Consider Contacting Law Enforcement

For many, talking to law enforcement will only make things worse. On the other hand, SWATing is a tactic often used in these types of coordinated attacks. If you think that's a possible outcome in your situation, it could be a good idea to get ahead of it and contact law enforcement to let them know what you're dealing with. It's in their best interest to be aware of fraudulent calls, and will make them less likely to show up at your door with guns drawn.

Revisit PACE Documents, Enact Those Steps

If you're involved in any kind of activism or community organizing you may be familiar with PACE documentation. It’s an acronym for coming up with contingency plan reactions if unwanted things come up: Primary, Alternate, Contingency, Escape/Emergency. Think of it like a panic button, a routine checklist of things to do if shit hits the fan. Maybe it involves some of the recommendations from this blog post. The point is to have something readymade, and some thoughts and strategies prepared, if the doxxing escalates to increased levels of harm and danger.

Example spreadsheet of a PACE document for a hypothetical group attending a protest. It has four columns, Primary, Alternate, Contingency, and Emergency. Each column describes what the hypothetical group plans to do in the event of various disruptions taking place, with agreements to each other about communications strategies, meeting times and places.

This is another step that's best done in a community with trusted people. The point is to keep your community organizing or community work moving, but with special contingency measures enacted to keep you and everyone else safe while remaining aware of this incident. This step is highly personalized and relies on a bit of prep work having already been done.

Put A Lock on Your Bank Accounts and Cell Subscriptions

One of the tactics those who are doxxing you might use is trying to get into your social media or other accounts through “SIM swapping,” an attack where they contact your cellular provider pretending to be you in order to hijack your phone number. They can then use that number and pivot to stealing other accounts you authenticate yourself to with your phone. Likewise, those targeting you might try to steal access to or disrupt your bank accounts through similar techniques. 

Get ahead of them by placing security passwords or pin codes on these highly sensitive accounts, if your bank or cellular provider provides this extra security measure. Most cell providers offer some sort of SIM swapping prevention method, but they all use different names for this feature, so be sure to look up the process in your provider’s documentation (here are guides for the major U.S. providers: Verizon, AT&T, and T-Mobile).

Regulate Your Nervous System

It’s an understatement to say that being doxxed is scary and potentially very dysregulating. You're much more likely to make safe, smart decisions if you are able to maintain a sense of control around your mental state. Recognizing that capability, as well as having a strategy to keep calm in the face of a crisis is just as important as having good digital security hygiene. Do what you need to do, be it involving the help of friends, taking a break, or whatever else, to stay afloat during this process. 

Flexibility and Resiliency

The reality is that the more you experience cultural marginalization, the higher the chances are that adversarial actors will resort to such tactics as doxxing and coordinated harassment campaigns. The fervor of those adversaries is often stoked by hateful public figures and politicians. And the plausible deniability of public records can limit the recourse you have to stop them. We hope that after reading this and the previous post, we’ve also brought to surface the idea that you can have great control over your digital footprint. Even more, that you can continue to share information online without unnecessarily compromising your safety and security. 

Until we have digital privacy protections for everyone, it’s up to us to take matters into our own hands. Privacy, security, and dignity online are achievable. If you follow this guide, the previous one, and stay clued into the strategies laid out on Surveillance Self-Defense, you're well on your way.

Doxxing Safety Pt I: Prevention and Footprint Management

31 August 2026 at 18:52

Doxxing is the deliberate disclosure of personal information in order to bully, harass, intimidate, or instigate a chain of harms against someone. It's a tricky thing to protect against when the jerk doing it is often able to use legal and accessible means to do so. The odds are stacked against everyday internet folk when there's little to no comprehensive data privacy legislation keeping us safe. The responsibility is on each of us to protect ourselves, but the good news is that there's a lot you can do to reduce your digital footprint and take control of your data.

This post is part one of a two-part series discussing safety and response to doxxing. This first part focuses on prevention and ways to reduce your overall footprint. The second focuses on incident response, as in, steps to take if you're in the midst of being doxxed. There will be some crossover and redundancy between these two posts, so it's worth reading each and gaining familiarity with the steps well ahead of time.

OSINT

Open source intelligence (OSINT) is a broad term within information security. It focuses on the tools and means available to us for investigation and information retrieval. OSINT sits at the heart of doxxing campaigns but is also an important part of the process of preventing them. Typically it is a way of describing a methodology of piecing together scraps of information to form a dossier on a subject.

There are fancy multipurpose tools (like Maltego or Lampyre) that combine many datapoints into accessible graphs and datasets. As helpful as they can be for traditional penetration tests or corporate OSINT campaigns, they’re best used for investigations focused on organizations, mapping together details like employee email charts, LinkedIn profiles, and company network maps. They may not fit the needs of everyday people or liberation movement workers. Instead, we recommend referring to different OSINT resource lists that index together a bunch of different tools, then using those resources to create a list for yourself of which tools may be most helpful. 

Many, if not all, of the resources we cover below will be referenced in those guides, and themselves fall under the OSINT category. It’s important to note that the tools we reference in this particular blog post are only relevant at the time of publishing. The bigger ideas have a much longer shelf life than various tech tools. That said, in no particular order:

Breach Databases

When a company gets hacked and their customer data is leaked, that information often ends up in “breach databases,” that is, troves of peoples' data available for sale and reuse in illegal trades online. Because of the sensitivity of that type of information, it can potentially be used in doxxing campaigns. Some resources, like haveibeenpwned, note pieces of vulnerable identifying information in those databases and make it easy for people to see if their information is included. Others, like DeHashed, offer a similar sort of tracking, but for a fee. 

You may not have control over a company's digital security that could put your own data at risk, but you can gain insight into whether your information is already out there. This gives you the opportunity to control the accuracy of that data (such as changing your email address or phone number). Doing so is extremely inconvenient, but unfortunately, it may be the only agency you have when another’s company’s digital insecurity puts your own safety at risk.

Open Records

Public records (such as voter records, property records, business registration, medical licensing information, and more) present a dilemma. It is in the public interest for there to be levels of transparency on such information. On the other hand, making such personally-identifiable information accessible to those with ill-intent can lead to serious consequences. 

Instead of requiring a formal request through the courts, mirroring sites make this information easy to find online. Such sites often have forms where you can request your information be taken down. This doesn’t necessarily remove the records from existing, but it does remove a layer of convenience in accessing them.

Some states have programs called “Address Confidentiality Programs” that offer people the right to supplant address information with proxy addresses, keeping public records open but that specific piece of information potentially hidden.

Social Media

Going through and tightening the security and privacy settings of your various social media accounts is always a good idea, but it’s especially important if you are in the process of minimizing your digital footprint. Consider turning your discoverability to “private” or “hidden” (verbiage and details depend on the app) so that only users vetted by you are able to see your account.

To get a quick overview of the various accounts you have registered online, especially if you've been online for a long time, use a username search engine like What's My Name or Namechk to see where your usernames have been registered. They may not be entirely accurate, but they are effective and quick. These tools are also helpful if you are at risk of being impersonated online and want to get an overview of where that may be taking place.

Data Brokers and Removals

Data brokers are craven, pernicious companies that present an existential risk to everyone in the digital age. Until that industry is no more, it's up to us to protect ourselves and the ways that it endangers us by selling personal, sensitive information. The most effective way to get your information removed from their stores is to file requests manually. Yael Grauer's BADBOOL project compiles and prioritizes the worst offenders in this industry and the means you can use to request data removals from them. This process can be grueling and time-consuming, so it may be worth investing in a service that automates the process. Though they've been found to be less effective than the DIY approach, there are some services that have stood out amongst the others in terms of efficacy when tested by third-party reviewers. If you’re a resident of California, you can more easily opt out through the new and exciting DROP tool.

Reverse Image Searching and FR Services

Services like PimEyes and Lenso have jumped on the profit-driven opportunity to create facial recognition as a service. They contribute to law enforcement investigations and predictive policing systems, as well as providing commercial services to abusers and stalkers. The gist of their service: upload a picture of someone (in this case, yourself) and it will use facial recognition technology to determine where else online that person has appeared. If your image is being shared online without your consent, this service will find out. 

Willfully participating in these services does mean having your image mapped, scanned, and stored by their systems. But if you believe you're under the type of targeted harassment that includes your image being shared online against your will, it may be worth that tradeoff.

Extra Monitoring, Automated

This section is less about data minimization, and more about laying extra protections down in the event that doxxing or other coordinated harassment seems imminent. If you're in the Google ecosystem of products, consider enrolling in their Advanced Protection Program, which offers a number of different features to keep you and your account safe. 

If you're the focus of coordinated attacks that span from online communities to media outlets participating in the harassment, a service like Open Measures is worth looking into. It tracks, maps, and analyzes the spread of hateful information online. They provide free access to their open-source API, so with some technical fancy-footwork, you can automate this process.

Get Others Involved

Coordinated harassment is often a process of daisy-chaining targets and tactics together until there’s a meaningful process of harm being inflicted. This means that people in your community are also at risk. As we always say, privacy is a team sport. Get others involved in the process; there’s strength in numbers. 

A great way to do this is think of the activities you and your group are up to. What roles do individual members take on? Figure out a way to tack on some of the responsibilities you’re coming up with here onto those team members. Find ways to talk about it and share strategies, preferably using secure technology like Signal. You can coordinate together which tasks each person could take on, perhaps pulled from this blog post.

It's a Process; Keep Yourself Apace for the Marathon, Not the Race

The process of data minimization and reclaiming agency over your digital footprint can be grueling and stressful. Don't underestimate the toll it can take on your mental health. Take breaks, employ the help of friends, and take the time to make sure you're first addressing the parts that are most relevant to your threat model. It may feel like there’s nothing to be done about protecting your digital privacy, but that’s just a symptom of surveillance capitalism’s psychological effect on its victims. There’s much you can do to stay safe, to protect yourself and others. Refer to this post and to the Surveillance Self-Defense project. 

#223 – Ivana Ćirković on How WordPress Credits Bridges Education and Industry in the WordPress Ecosystem

1 July 2026 at 14:00
Transcript

[00:00:19] Nathan Wrigley: Welcome to the Jukebox Podcast from WP Tavern. My name is Nathan Wrigley.

Jukebox is a podcast which is dedicated to all things WordPress, the people, the events, the plugins, the blocks, the themes, and in this case how WordPress Credits bridges education and industry in the WordPress ecosystem.

If you’d like to subscribe to the podcast, you can do that by searching for WP Tavern in your podcast player of choice, or by going to wptavern.com/feed/podcast, and you can copy that URL into most podcast players.

If you have a topic that you’d like us to feature on the podcast, I’m keen to hear from you and hopefully get you, or your idea, featured on the show. Head to wptavern.com/contact/jukebox and use the form there.

So on the podcast today we have Ivana Ćirković. Ivana is a digital marketer with 18 years of experience working both in and out of the tech industry, and currently leads marketing at WPBakery. She’s an active participant in WordPress events, having attended, and spoken at, numerous local and international word camps over the years.

In this episode, our focus is on the WordPress Credits initiative. We learn how this program, launched by the WordPress Foundation, connects students with real world opportunities to contribute to the WordPress ecosystem, earn certifications, and increase their competitiveness in the job market.

Ivana discusses her own experience as a WP Credits mentor, working with students as they learn about digital marketing, remote work, and other open source contributions. We explore, how universities can modernise their curriculums, and real world value for students by participating in the initiative, and how businesses can get involved, not just to support the community, but to help shape and discover future talent.

The program’s evolving structure also gets attention, and we learn how students are guided through hands-on activities such as translation or documentation, and how their progress is tracked publicly via profiles on wordpress.org. Ivana shares the opportunities and challenges for both educators and businesses with thoughts on accountability, mentorship, and the need to bring new faces into the WordPress community.

If you’re interested in the future of WordPress, education, or bridging the gap between academia and industry, this episode is for you.

If you’d like to find out more, you can find all of the links in the show notes by heading to wptavern.com/podcast, where you’ll find all the other episodes as well.

And so without further delay, I bring you Ivana Ćirković.

I am joined on the podcast by Ivana Ćirković. Did I get that right?

[00:03:14] Ivana Ćirković: Yes. Excellent.

[00:03:16] Nathan Wrigley: Thank you. This is my first interview at WordCamp Europe 2026. I’m guessing because we’re on the first day of the event and it’s quite early in the morning, it’s 10 in the morning, I’m guessing you cannot have done your presentation yet?

[00:03:30] Ivana Ćirković: Not yet. Tomorrow.

[00:03:32] Nathan Wrigley: Do you get nervous with these kind of things?

[00:03:34] Ivana Ćirković: I get nervous all the time. I’ve been doing this for 12 years, it never gets easier. It is what it is.

[00:03:39] Nathan Wrigley: Well, the presentation that you are doing is going to be the focus of what we’re talking about today. So do you just want to tell us a little bit about the topic that you’re talking about, but also just give us a bit of a general bio about who you are and what you do. So just tell us about you and about your presentation basically.

[00:03:56] Ivana Ćirković: Okay. First thing first, I would like to introduce my presentation, or the talk, that is build up around WordPress Credits initiative, which is something that WordPress has rolled out late last year in December. And I applied to be a mentor to support students into their entering into WordPress. Got accepted, did my courses, passed them and started working with students on their, first entering the WordPress society, how everything works, contributing.

And out of all of this, I came up with the idea of sharing the story about WordPress Credits. What it is, why it is important, not just for the WordPress community, but also for universities all around the world for businesses to support, because there is an angle and huge opportunity for them too. And hopefully inspire people to join and become part of it more.

As far as I’m concerned, my name is  Ivana Ćirković and I am a digital marketer for 18 years. I’ve been working inside tech organisations, tech industry, but also outside of it. So I’m the multiverse. And lately, for past couple of years, I’ve been working in WPBakery, in marketing their product, and talking to people, sharing knowledge of what we do, how we do it, and so on. In the meantime I am attending many, many WordCamps, local and international ones, giving lectures, giving talks about digital marketing and all things related.

[00:05:39] Nathan Wrigley: So are you here at this event, not just to give your presentation, are you also here on behalf of WPBakery to represent them and the products that they have as well?

[00:05:47] Ivana Ćirković: Yes, we are sponsors. I am speaker, I was table lead for marketing on Contributors Day. So we are wide into the ecosystem.

[00:05:56] Nathan Wrigley: I have to say, having only been in this event space for about an hour, I’m actually deeply impressed by this particular event. It really is a gigantic venue. It’s so pleasurable as well to see the WordPress community in such large numbers here. And so we’re looking forward to a really good event.

Okay, let’s kick off with the topic at hand then. So it occurs to me that many people listening, whilst they’re using WordPress and they’re kind of, I don’t know, they’re building websites for people, and they’ve got products and plugins and they’re just general users. It may be that the community piece, and the educational piece, is nothing that they’ve heard of before. So would you just tell us a little bit about what WP Credits is as far as you’re concerned, just to give us that broad background of what it is?

[00:06:40] Ivana Ćirković: Okay. So WP Credits program is initially made to bring new young people into the WordPress, to broaden the ecosystem with the new fresh blood, new contributors. And to do so, WordPress Foundation initiated this program to connect with universities all across the world. To connect students to some programs, to learn about WordPress through contribution. For that, they will get graded and get certification, which in the end will help them be more marketable, and have more modern knowledge of what is needed in today’s job market, and to be more competitive and more appealing to potential employers.

So by doing so, WordPress Credits aims to broaden the ecosystem, to strengthen the WordPress community, and WordPress itself. But also to put new generations in more marketable place, and to help them get more profitable jobs.

[00:07:45] Nathan Wrigley: Thank you. That was a really nice summary. In terms of your personal commitment to it and what have you, how did you fall into it as a thing that you were doing? And is this something that you get sponsored for from WPBakery, or is it personal and simply a sort of philanthropic thing that you are doing on the side?

[00:08:01] Ivana Ćirković: Yeah, so basically, I’ve been doing education my whole professional life. So it’s something that comes natural to me. In my local country, in Serbia, I do informal education for high schoolers and primary school’s children about digital marketing, digital literacy. This is like very natural to me. I’m being sponsored by WPBakery to do so.

And the program works like, initiative needs people, needs more mentors to get involved. More than it needs like product and businesses to support with their products. So if there are businesses who are maybe interested in support through their product, know that you need to put your people first to actually get involved and contribute, and then you can offer products as the side piece, so to say.

[00:08:52] Nathan Wrigley: So yeah, it seems that you’ve got a lifelong interest in education as well. Okay, that gives me some sort of hook there.

Okay, if I was to say WP Credits to the people outside, the people who already knew about it, I think would probably peg it as entirely educational in nature, just an education initiative. But curiously, your presentation, the notes that went with that and the blurb that went on the WordCamp Europe website, you kind of make the point that it’s much bigger than that, and you get into businesses and the students themselves and universities.

So the students in universities bit, well, that’s the education piece. But the business bit, what’s going on there? Because I definitely hadn’t drawn that intuition. I thought education from top to bottom. But business, okay, where does that fit in?

[00:09:37] Ivana Ćirković: I will get the hot insights from the talk. So basically, there is more than what meets the eye, so to speak. Businesses have unique opportunity to shape people they want to employ by getting involved as mentors. They also get the chance to see firsthand how those young minds work in real environments, in real contribution. And they get the chance to pick and choose who they want to employ by seeing them work on some real things. Whether it’s documentation, whether it’s translation or programming, developing something, AI.

We need more people who know what they do, although they are young. By having students in this program, they are working on not fictional things, but actual things that really contribute to community and businesses as a whole. By supporting this initiative, businesses then in relations to that can get more insights into who they want to employ. So on top of that, they are building the better market for themselves as well.

[00:10:42] Nathan Wrigley: I guess the student university piece is fairly obvious. You know, WP Credits and the people working on that project communicate with universities, they’re probably easy to find. You know, if you go to a phone directory for example, they’ll all be there. And it’s an easy thing to do. You phone up the university and see if there’s interest. And I know that some universities have taken up the WP Credits program. And it seems to be, as far as I can work out, it seems to be working very successfully.

How are you going to make the connection with businesses? Because that seems like a much more scattered, I don’t know if you’re going to be working with big businesses, you know, huge companies or if it’s going to be kind of more the businesses on the street, the smaller businesses, that kind of thing. So, I’ll just sort of hand it over at that point.

[00:11:23] Ivana Ćirković: So basically, web agencies, businesses around WordPress, we know they have an issue with new employees onboarding last, let’s say three to six months. That cost time and money and other people who are teaching them what needs to be done and how.

Then we have WordPress Credit students who are already doing that junior type of work within contribution. They’re already onboarded through using Slack, knowing how to do remote work, what needs to be done. So businesses supporting WordPress Credits initiative can choose those students and spend less time and money and energy in onboarding them because they already went through that by doing WordPress Credits program.

[00:12:10] Nathan Wrigley: Yeah, I guess if you are a small web agency, it’s highly likely that you won’t necessarily have an induction program finely tuned, so that the young people that are coming through have this sort of specialised system where they can get some accreditation. It’s probably more, okay, I’m going to assign you to John this week and then next week you’re going to go over to Susan and follow what they’re doing.

So is there a sort of structured program that, let’s say a web agency based in London could drop into and receive documentation about? Where are we at with that whole process for the busineses?

[00:12:44] Ivana Ćirković: Yeah, so since this initiative is still fairly new and we already have just one generation of students that are passed the program, this is something in development. So at the moment, we still don’t have like a specific structure that is based just for agencies and businesses in general, but it is something that we are considering and working towards too. So definitely.

On the other hand, the upper management organisational team might not be aware to the fullest what am I about to talk. So it might come as a surprise to them, but also it is something in the works as well. So give us some time and we will come up with something.

[00:13:26] Nathan Wrigley: Yeah, it feels like that would be something really credible. Because if you’re a small business owner, the last thing you want to be doing is kind of wasting time. And onboarding somebody might be something that you’d have to divert weeks into, you know, syphoning employees off, writing documentation, SOPs, those kind of things. And if you could just pick something up off the shelf that was tried and tested over many years, that would actually be really handy. So good luck. I hope that that initiative comes off.

In terms of students, if you were a student, let’s say you are at a university, or you are looking for work, what would you say would be some of the top line items that you would mention as to why WP Credits is worth looking at? Because, you know, if I’m at a university, there’s probably a thousand different things that I could be doing. WP Credits would be in competition with all of those. Why do you think it’s something that young people should be taking care of to look at?

[00:14:17] Ivana Ćirković: Yeah, I would think differently, in that sense. Universities curriculums are outdated comparing to the industry that we are living and working in. So WordPress Credits gives something that is in trend. That is happening now that people are using and working now. So students who choose to go to this program are gaining the most efficient and not outdated curriculum, and things that are being worked on in this moment.

And this is bigger than WordPress. It is initially for WordPress, but the knowledge students get, nobody can take that away. They learn to be outspoken. They learn to use all the necessary remote work tools that is applicable in all the industry.

So we are really encouraging them to be very marketable employees and people who have portfolios, whether they choose that category that brings them portfolio. That is very transparent throughout whatever they do. Because on wordpress.org, every contribution is noted. So they’re building their own business brand by doing WordPress Credits. And in that way they are more marketable and can get more business opportunities.

[00:15:42] Nathan Wrigley: I didn’t realise that the wordpress.org profile, is it the profile that you mean?

[00:15:47] Ivana Ćirković: Yes.

[00:15:47] Nathan Wrigley: Each time you participate in one of these credit programs, that will be a badge, for want of a better word, that you can display and it will be freely available for the public. And presumably that will be difficult to acquire. That’s the wrong word. What I mean is, it won’t be simple to acquire. You will genuinely have had to.

[00:16:07] Ivana Ćirković: Yes, you need to do the work. Let’s say students are interested in translation. So they go to Polyglots team and they get assigned to a mentor who is on weekly basis working with them on onboarding, helping them how to navigate through wordpress.org website, translation, what needs to be done. And basically, for that student, they need to translate to have approved translation, 150 strings approved.

So that doesn’t mean, okay, I will translate 150 words. No, no. You might need to translate 500 words out of which 150 is approved. And this is the bare minimum you need to do in order to get that badge that you contributed. Because that contribution, each contribution needs to be something very specific and tailored to help other people. That is very open and helpful.

[00:17:00] Nathan Wrigley: So you mentioned translations there, which obviously is just one of multiple things that you could do, and we could list them all out, but we won’t. How is that curriculum, I’m doing air quotes, how is that curriculum decided upon? In other words, how do you decide, okay, I’m going to do a bit of translation, I’m going to do a bit of work on Core, I’m going to work for the Plugin Review Team? How is that decided? And, how is it decided by the institution, I guess that that’s going to equal something which our university will stamp as part of your degree, let’s say?

[00:17:33] Ivana Ćirković: Yeah. So basically, that is all arranged between the foundation and universities. You won’t get IT students doing marketing if that’s not their preferable choice. So students opt in. They’re given the whole like curriculum, categories of things they can contribute to. And the one they choose, this is the one they stick to throughout all the programs.

So you cannot switch in between like translation and documentation, or plugins, or WP-CLI whatever. The whole program stick to one chosen category. And that is all aligned with the, let’s say, topic of university. So IT is preferable for IT related contributions. Communications are also more favourable towards translation community, marketing. So it’s aligned that way.

[00:18:23] Nathan Wrigley: So flipping that round, so we’ve been talking about it from the point of view of the students. Now let’s just flip it around to the point of view of the university. I guess the same thing applies. They would have to communicate with the Foundation and say, okay, these are the kind of things that we wish our students to do. These particular strands, we will, you know, if they do 500 translation strings, that will count as something. I guess there’s got to be some interface between the Foundation and each university to establish what a credit equals.

[00:18:50] Ivana Ćirković: Yeah, common ground as to how WordPress Credits adds to the official curriculum of the university. And the thing that university get out of it, they are in position to offer modern, in trend, teachings, and that makes them more appealing to next generation of students. Because the more their existing students who are in the WordPress Credits program are succeeding, the more desirable the university gets to newer generations because they don’t teach outdated curriculums. They’re aligning to what is now efficient and needed in the job market.

[00:19:30] Nathan Wrigley: I suppose also as well, when I was at university, there was a choice of about, I don’t know, four things to do each year. Something like that. You could do this or this or this. And you had to pick one of them and that was your pathway. This feels much more wide open because knowing the WordPress ecosystem, I know that there’s dozens, maybe multiple dozens of different things that you could be involved in.

So that’s quite appealing as well, isn’t it? You know, you can just take a little nibble of this one thing, and another nibble of this. And so there’s potentially multiple dozens of different pathways that you could pick. And whilst you say that, once you’ve decided you’ve got to stick to that, well, that’s fair enough, but the fact that you’ve got so many different ways that you could choose. That to me as a university student would’ve been really appealing. The fact that there’s so many different things that you could do.

[00:20:15] Ivana Ćirković: Yeah. And once they got in, the overall input that we get from students that, first they don’t know that something like this exists. And once they go deep and start work, it’s like, wow. The whole mind just shifts, and they are amazed by all the possibilities that they can do within WordPress that isn’t talked about.

[00:20:36] Nathan Wrigley: Yeah. And I presume they get to do it in the way that the WordPress community works, which is remotely distributed and when you wish to do it. So long as I, you make the end of the university period of whatever a semester is or something, so long as you make the deadline, you can do it at night or in the early morning or.

[00:20:57] Ivana Ćirković: Exactly. So they are training to be like workers as we all are today, that are not restrained with some deadlines or by official university rules. They’re accountable for the final output. How will they come to that output? It’s entirely up to them because, yes, they are young but they’re not so young that they cannot be held accountable for their actions. So they need to do the work. We got weekly mentorships and assessments. So it’s a fun ride.

[00:21:31] Nathan Wrigley: So just touching on that, the sort of ongoing support that every student needs, because with the best rule in the world, there’s a proportion of students who will leave everything to the last minute. I’m looking at myself in the mirror when I say that. So that ongoing support, it’s a weekly sort of huddle. And is that like a one-to-one thing or is it a one to many thing?

[00:21:50] Ivana Ćirković: Yeah, so depending on the number of students, if a mentor has a one or two students, it can be one-to-one. If there are more like five or six, it’s better to have a group meeting on a weekly basis, and then Slack chats in between if anything is more needed than that.

So basically we go through what they did last week, are there any setbacks or they need additional help, or do they need information from other parts of the team? Are they interested in something else? So we are really trying to get them involved in a way that matters to them.

One of the things that each student needs to do, no matter section they chose, is to create a blog and to have weekly blog posts. So we discuss about that. What interests them. Whether they want to be something personal like, or professional like. So it’s very interesting to see how they think and how they express themself and how they build their online persona.

[00:22:55] Nathan Wrigley: Do those huddles take place on a, let’s say university by university basis? So for example, when you join and you mentor students, are they from the entire WP Campus project, or are you doing it from the university of this town and the university of that town?

[00:23:13] Ivana Ćirković: No, it’s mixed and matched.

[00:23:14] Nathan Wrigley: So, okay, well that’s a real strength as well it feels, because presumably then you’re on a call with people potentially from all over the world. Certainly people that you may not have encountered before. And those sort of serendipitous chance encounters can sometimes be some of the more meaningful ones. You know, work comes out of those things, and meetups come out of those things, and unexpected things come out of those things. So that must be really nice as well, watching those kind of things happen.

[00:23:42] Ivana Ćirković: Yeah, it’s like nothing I experienced before. And just to have the privilege to talk and work with those people, you never know what can come up out of them, and out of our connections. And I get inspired every time we have chats and they make me want to be a better educator.

[00:24:03] Nathan Wrigley: Oh, that’s interesting.

[00:24:04] Ivana Ćirković: So, yeah, that’s my take out of all this.

[00:24:06] Nathan Wrigley: Yeah. Okay, so there’s actually some psychological benefit for you as well. You get a real nice feeling of it. Okay, that’s really good.

So with the best will in the world, a university, every year there’s a cohort of children, young adults, whatever it may be, whichever institution it is, and a proportion of them will work diligently and hard and they will succeed. And some others maybe not so much.

How does that work? How do you ensure that everybody gets through it? And I don’t know if there’s enough data to answer this question. Again, I’m doing air quotes, how is the pass rate? Do most people that embark on this get through the necessary things? Or is there a fair bit of, I don’t know, discipline, for want of a better word, that needs to be applied and cajoling people to get through it?

[00:24:46] Ivana Ćirković: Yeah, so I touched base on the accountability. So we have not strict rules, but recommendations. Weekly mentor chats, async communication through Slack. They all have weekly tasks that needed to be done. So if a student don’t answer the message or come to weekly mentor call three times, they are no longer WordPress Credit students. And that is the accountability.

You need to show yourself that you are willing to do the work. So if you don’t care, we won’t force you to do that if you don’t want to. We will set reminders, we will call back, we will reach out. But if you are no show, no tell anything for three times, then evidently you are not for that. You don’t wish to be there, and we won’t force you to be there.

[00:25:40] Nathan Wrigley: And then in some way, are you required then to report that back to the institution and sort of say, okay, we’ve reached the end of the road here, and then it’s for them to figure out how that impacts. And presumably the students can.

[00:25:53] Ivana Ćirković: Their grades, yeah.

[00:25:53] Nathan Wrigley: Yeah, their grades what have you, okay. Touching back on the sort of business side, because we’ve dwelled a lot with students and universities and we’re going to stay with students, because that’s really the underpinning of the whole thing. How has the business side of things, is it taking off? You were describing that it’s kind of like a new thing. Have you got any sort of success stories or anecdotal evidence that people do in fact want this?

[00:26:15] Ivana Ćirković: Yeah, so it’s still fairly new, so we don’t have those anecdotes yet. One of the reasons why I’m here at the WordCamp Europe is to find out and to get new perspective from businesses to like reach out to them to see what they think about the program. Would they want to be evolved. And how to give tips, maybe how we can improve. So stay tuned for more.

[00:26:38] Nathan Wrigley: Yeah. And it is interesting, when you walk around an event like this, I don’t have the exact numbers, but the demographic is definitely skewing older. There’s not so many 18 year olds. And if this community wishes to carry on, at some point the age demographic will get to retirement age.

[00:26:57] Ivana Ćirković: Yeah. Just last night we were talking. I’ve been in the community for 11 years. And for 11 years all the same faces are here. And we really need new faces. But to get new faces, WordPress Credits is one part of the solution. But then again, we need to meet young people where they are. And they are not on the conferences, they are not on websites, they don’t use websites, they don’t care about websites. They are on very specific social media channels. And if we want to get fresh, new, young blood, we need to go there and to present what we do in a way that matters to those kids.

[00:27:35] Nathan Wrigley: In terms of success, if you were to, I don’t know, let’s imagine that we could cast our minds forwards five years, let’s go for that. What would you like to have happened with WP Credits? Would you like, for example, to see a bunch of 20 somethings wandering around in an event like this? Does it matter that they’re involved in the community and doing WordPress events and contributing to Core and those kind of things? Or is success just more broadly, people are using WordPress? You know, it’s still a project. What’s your take on, what does success look like in five years?

[00:28:08] Ivana Ćirković: For me, I would like to see more young people involved. Yes, we will always have users because in its core, WordPress is a very useful tool. And I’m happy to stumble upon that tool many, many years ago to use it both personally and professionally. But I really want to see young people involved in a way that we were involved 10, 15 years ago, and to see what can happen with WordPress.

I strongly believe it’ll be transformed, not with AI or all other flashy trends. WordPress has always been about people. And we need new people, we need young people to get it where it needs to be.

We are getting older and don’t have strengths or stamina to do so for how many long years. By having new kids, fresh perspectives, I’m really excited to see what they can come up with next.

[00:29:08] Nathan Wrigley: Yeah, it’s kind of handing over the baton in a way, isn’t it? Seeing what the future holds. Yeah, I definitely have concerns that the age demographic is skewing. And no matter what has happened in the past, I don’t see it being backfilled with younger people moment.

But I think that’s largely because we just assumed that that age demographic would fill itself, because we were excited about it, so the younger generation will be excited about it. Well it turns out the world moved on. And TikTok came along, and YouTube became a massive thing and mobile phones and all the different platforms became a thing. And so the attention was put elsewhere by many young people.

And so I suppose we needed to come up with a system where we are, in a sense, just putting it in front of their face and saying, look, it’s here. You know, you’re a university student, you are somebody looking for work in a small business. Here’s a credible way of getting involved in something which potentially could change your life. That seems like the most credible way of doing it at the moment. And I guess we’ll just have to see what the next five years brings.

In which case, is there anything that you felt you wanted to touch on that you wanted to get out of this chat before we finished?

[00:30:15] Ivana Ćirković: No, I think you did it masterfully. And we touched base on everything that needed to be said.

[00:30:20] Nathan Wrigley: Perfect. In that case, I will say Ivana, thank you for chatting to me today. Fingers crossed that your presentation goes well tomorrow, and that you pack the place out, and that by this time next week, you are extremely busy with the WP Credits program. Thanks for chatting to me.

[00:30:34] Ivana Ćirković: Thank you. Thank you for inviting me.

So on the podcast today we have Ivana Ćirković.

Ivana is a digital marketer with 18 years of experience working both in and out of the tech industry, and currently leads marketing at WPBakery. She’s an active participant in WordPress events, having attended and spoken at numerous local and international WordCamps over the years.

In this episode, our focus is on the WordPress Credits initiative. We learn how this program, launched by the WordPress Foundation, connects students with real-world opportunities to contribute to the WordPress ecosystem, earn certifications, and increase their competitiveness on the job market.

Ivana discusses her own experience as a WP Credits mentor, working with students as they learn about digital marketing, remote work, and open source contributions. We explore how universities can modernise their curriculums and add real-world value for students by participating in the initiative, and how businesses can get involved, not just to support the community, but to help shape and discover future talent.

The program’s evolving structure also gets attention, and we learn how students are guided through hands-on activities such as translation or documentation, and how their progress is tracked publicly via profiles on WordPress.org. Ivana shares the opportunities and challenges for both educators and businesses, with thoughts on accountability, mentorship, and the need to bring new faces into the WordPress community.

If you’re interested in the future of WordPress, education, or bridging the gap between academia and industry, this episode is for you.

Useful links

WordPress Credits

WPBakery

What it (really) means to be a part of the WP Credits program?

💾

Primed for Malware: Stop Selling Compromised Android Devices

Time and time again, researchers have found numerous compromised Android devices for sale at large online retailers like Amazon. When these devices get individually reported, we have seen some noted efforts to take them down. But this is a systemic problem and Amazon and other major online retailers must make a corresponding systemic and intentional effort to stop these devices from entering people’s homes and ultimately their networks.

As a refresher: Last year, Google wrote that one major campaign, deemed BADBOX, affected 10 million uncertified devices that were running Android’s open-source software (Android Open Source Project or AOSP). These devices span from TVs and streaming devices to digital picture frames. Even now, someone can go on Amazon and Walmart and buy one of these devices. Not all of them come from Amazon and Walmart, but it’s fair to assume since they have the lion’s share of the market.

Most well-known Android-based devices don’t come with just “stock Android.” The operating system is usually Android plus additional features that the manufacturer wanted. These custom versions of Android often come with pre-installed applications that range from useful to innocuous bloatware to actual malware. Many Android OEMs (original equipment manufacturers) pre-install apps that may not be visibly represented by an icon in your list of installed apps. This obscurity makes the issue particularly hard for users to identify any potential threats.

Since the initial BADBOX analysis, there have been more reports of large campaigns and clusters of different devices participating in malicious activities that utilize people’s home networks to engage in illegal activity. Task forces in the private sector have made an effort to take down these existing Command and Control structures, but these actors may pivot and evolve to flood the market with more devices. 

Online retailers can stop this cycle. A multi-billion dollar company like Amazon should offer more resources, like their anti-fraud efforts, given that these products may have facilitated conditions for large scale attacks and illegal activity. It would also be helpful if they communicated malware-related take downs in a more visible way to consumers who are seeking very similar devices with shared characteristics.

Identifying these devices can be tricky, but it’s not impossible because they tend to follow a pattern. For example, the FBI warned consumers this year to avoid TV streaming devices that claim to provide free sports, tv shows, and movies, a common tactic used by the makers of these malware-filled Android devices that leverages people’s exhaustion from spending money on countless streaming services. We detailed what sorts of indicators to look for on a device you’ve purchased.

But it’s not just the storefronts. There are other parts of this ecosystem that need to improve too, like increased engagement in firmware transparency and the actual manufacturers of the devices themselves being held accountable for these malware laced products.

On Prime Day, we urge retailers like Amazon to better empower users with information they need to make safe and smart decisions.

#222 – Destiny Kanno, Anand Upadhyay, Maciej Pilarski on How WordPress Education Programs Are Growing

24 June 2026 at 14:00
Transcript

[00:00:19] Nathan Wrigley: Welcome to the Jukebox Podcast from WP Tavern. My name is Nathan Wrigley.

Jukebox is a podcast which is dedicated to all things WordPress. The people, the events, the plugins, the blocks, the themes, and in this case, how WordPress education programs are growing.

If you’d like to subscribe to the podcast, you can do that by searching for WP Tavern in your podcast player of choice, or by going to wptavern.com/feed/podcast, and you can copy that URL into most podcast players.

If you have a topic that you’d like us to feature on the podcast, I’m keen to hear from you and hopefully get you, or your idea, featured on the show. Head to wptavern.com/contact/jukebox, and use the form there.

So on the podcast today, we are joined by three WordPress Education Initiative leaders, Destiny Kanno, Anand Upadhyay and Maciej Pilarski.

Together, they have spent years at the heart of WordPress training and outreach, working in roles spanning community education management, plugin development, and credit program administration. Their efforts have helped shape student engagement and university partnerships across the globe, introducing thousands of learners to WordPress.

The conversation focused on the current landscape of WordPress education with particular attention to three key initiatives, the WordPress Credits Program, Campus Connect, and Student Clubs.

Each initiative is designed to provide unique entry points for students of all ages and education levels. From high schoolers building their first site in a library to university students earning official credits for open source contributions.

We discussed the different approaches these programmes take. WP Credits ties student work directly to academic credit and mentorship. Campus Connect provides flexible, community driven, events in diverse locations and Student Clubs foster sustainable, peer led, learning within schools and other institutions. We explore how these models feed into each other, building a sustainable ecosystem for ongoing growth in the WordPress community.

We also get into the importance of repeat campus partnerships, the need for scalable facilitator training, and the role of recognition, certificates, badges, and public showcases in keeping students motivated and validated in their journey.

If you’re curious about the growing movement to bring WordPress knowledge to the next generation, or are looking to get involved with education in your local community, this episode is for you.

If you’re interested in finding out more, you can find all of the links in the show notes by heading to wptavern.com/podcast, where you’ll find all the other episodes as well.

And so without further delay, I bring you Destiny Kanno, Anand Upadhyay and Maciej Pilarski.

I am joined on the podcast by Destiny Kanno, by Anand Upadhyay and Maciej Pilarski. Hello, one and all. Nice to have you with us.

[00:03:29] Destiny Kanno: Hello. Thank you.

[00:03:30] Anand Upadhyay: Hello.

[00:03:31] Maciej Pilarski: Hello.

[00:03:32] Nathan Wrigley: So a few months ago, back in, I think it was September 2025, I was joined by two of the three participants on the call today. I was joined by Destiny and I was joined by Anand. We were also joined at that point by Isotta, but she’s not on the call today. We’ve obviously got a wonderful replacement, Maciej who’s going to do a fabulous job explaining the bits and pieces here.

But the intention of that episode, which you can find on the WP Tavern website, it’s episode number 183, was to find out about all of the overlapping education initiatives in the WordPress space. And it was born, I think, largely out of a sense of curiosity on my part, but also a somewhat sense of confusion, because there were lots of things which were going on. Some of them seemed to be slightly overlapping. There was a conflict of names in some cases. So that episode was laying out the groundworks of what has been happening in the WordPress space.

When that conversation finished and we’d click the stop record button, I said, that was absolutely fascinating. This seems to be moving at such a rate, wouldn’t it be good to revisit this whole subject in about six months time?

Well, we missed that target, but here we are, maybe eight months later. I think my intuition at that point was correct, because being a close observer of what’s going on in the WordPress community, I think it’s fair to say that the educational space has been somewhat turbocharged during the last eight months.

And so today’s episode, with the help of the three people I’ve just mentioned, is to describe what’s going on, what’s changed, maybe some things that have been mothballed, but certainly a lot of things that are new and interesting and have gained a lot of momentum.

But I think, dear listener, the intention of this episode is to get you involved. Is to get to the end of this episode and for your curiosity to have been turned into action. To have gotten you out of your chair, written an email, turned up to an event, helped organise a thing.

So please have that in the back of your mind. If you’re sitting listening to this in a car, at your desktop, there is actual action that could be taken at the end of this. I think the intention of all four of us on this panel would be dearly for that to happen.

Okay, let’s establish the credentials of the people that we’re going to be talking to today. So we’ll just do a little potted bio of you one at a time. So we’ll begin with Destiny, if you could just tell us a little bit about you, your relationship with education in the WordPress space, I suppose would be apropos.

[00:06:01] Destiny Kanno: Yeah, absolutely. So again, Destiny Kanno. I’m currently working as an education program manager sponsored by Automattic. And I work directly with the Make WordPress Community Team. And I also work adjacently with the training team as well, because education training materials, they go pretty hand in hand. And I’ve been doing this now for about four years and, yeah, it’s just evolved since my original time working on Learn WordPress, and that relaunch that happened, to now, yeah, these wonderful programs that are spreading like wildfire as you said.

[00:06:37] Nathan Wrigley: Fantastic. Thank you so much. Okay, we’ll move over to Anand for the same sort of introductory moment.

[00:06:43] Anand Upadhyay: Yes. So my name is Anand Upadhyay, and I run the WordPress plugin development company, WPVibes. Apart from that, I’m very much involved in the WordPress community and I contribute in multiple ways. It can be documentation, it can be Core, Polyglots. But I’m also keenly involved in the community part, and specifically I can say with the education initiatives, I started with WP Campus Connect in WordPress Campus Connect in 2024. And since then, after that we started joining hands with Destiny and we started evolving this program in a much bigger shape. So that’s it.

[00:07:16] Nathan Wrigley: Okay. Thank you so much. And last, but by no means least, Maciej.

[00:07:20] Maciej Pilarski: Yeah. Thanks for having me. My name is Maciej Pilarski. So I’ve been doing anything related to WordPress pretty much since 2007, so that’s been a while. But the biggest breakthrough for me was 2014 when I actually volunteered to WordCamp Europe in Sovia, Bulgaria. That opened my eyes to the whole community, everything that is happening around WordPress.

And since then, pretty much I’ve been working for multiple companies from the WordPress ecosystem. I joined Automattic in 2016. For many years I’ve been a Happiness Engineer, and since October last year, I’ve joined Isotta as one of the admins of the WordPress Credit program. And since that time, I will have been helping her out to grow that initiative.

And Destiny mentioned, it spreads like fire because at that time we had six universities onboarded, now we are at 21. The 21st, we got it after WordCamp Asia actually through a connection made there. And it’s our first institution from Africa, from Uganda. A huge shout out to Stephen Dumba, who I connected with during the event. And after that, pretty much a week after we signed our first partnership from Africa. So we’re actively growing and getting new institutions on board.

[00:08:42] Nathan Wrigley: Thank you so much. Gosh, there was an awful lot in there, wasn’t there? That was really interesting. We’ll try and unpack quite a lot of that.

Firstly, a sort of slightly personal message from me. I don’t usually reveal much about myself on this podcast. I take the position that I’m a, kind of like an interested party, but don’t really give much of my own thoughts. However, this is different because I cannot think of a more interesting, meaningful, moral, let’s go with that word as well, use of time than educating people. It simply is the most profoundly useful thing to do with your life.

Now, obviously people will have different opinions about that, but the juxtaposition of free open source software, in this case WordPress, and education is a real sweet spot for me. I just think that is such an amazing thing to be involved in, to have going on in the background.

If you think about it, an open source project, like how many open source projects have this level of stuff going on in the education space, this real international footprint. Things going on which we’ll find out about in a minute. It’s really fascinating.

And I am sure that the listenership to this podcast, the vast majority of people listening will never have encountered much of this before. Maybe they’ve seen stuff on Learn because they want to technically learn about WordPress in an online capacity, but we’re going to be delving into real world events affecting real adults, real youngsters.

And so anyway, that’s my little bit at the beginning, just how curious it is that the project is so big that we’ve got this international footprint of education. And so I suppose what we should do right at the beginning is lay out the different initiatives and just name them, and try to figure out how they differ from each other. Just so that we’ve got some kind of awareness.

So I don’t know which one of you wants to take that, but if maybe you take one each or something, I don’t know. If we just want to lay out the, just erect that tent basically so that we know what the initiatives are called, and how they differ from one another. So I’ll open that up. Whoever wants to step in.

[00:10:48] Maciej Pilarski: I can start with the Credits Program. So the Credits Program is based, it’s a contribution based program, internship, initiative by the WordPress Foundation that connects higher education students with the global open source community. So basically it’s an opportunity for the students as part of the educational curriculum to contribute to the WordPress community.

There are two types of courses that the students can do. One of them is 50 hours, the second one is 150 hours. Usually the students do that during a full academic semester. And as part of that, students are first onboarded into the WordPress ecosystem and the wider open source ecosystem where they learn not only about WordPress, but open source as a whole, and how crucial it is for the internet.

Then the second phase is picking the contribution area to which they would like to contribute. All the contributions areas basically are the ones that are listed at make.wordpress.org. So any team that is listed there, students can pick from that area. During that phase, they work on a particular area that they have selected.

And finally, during phase three, they wrap up the whole achievements, the contribution, what they did, they publish a final post. And what is also very important as part of the credit scores, students have also assigned a mentor from the WordPress community that guides them through the whole process. We don’t leave them alone. We connect them with actual mentors from the WordPress community that are vetted by us, that guide them through the whole journey into the contribution and the whole WordPress ecosystem.

So it works on multiple levels. For me, this connection is also special because it builds this bridge between the previous generation of WordPress contributors to the new one where they are introduced and can start working on any fields of contribution.

What is also important is that this is not limited to technical universities. Pretty much any type of university can participate in the program. The first university that we started with was University of Pisa, and it was the humanity studies. So the students from humanity field were the first group who started the Credits Program. There’s room for pretty much anyone from any field.

[00:13:18] Nathan Wrigley: Okay. There’s a lot there. Wow. I’ve just been taking notes and I’ve almost filled an entire A4 page. So WP Credits, the WordPress Credits Program, I guess the name sort of gives it away. The idea here is that you trade time for university or higher education credit. So credit being, I suppose if you were to atomise your three year degree, you might do, I don’t know, 12 modules or something like that. The idea is that one of those modules, perhaps it’s more, becomes something in the WordPress, but also curiously the free open source software space as well. I didn’t actually know that.

The idea is that you link up with real world institutions. So the first one was Pisa, and maybe we can get into which other ones have come along. And in exchange for 50 hours or 150 hours, you will be given that credit, which can then go to the overall awarding of a degree or whatever it is that you are hoping to get.

You’re then linked up with team members, WordPress community team members who will mentor you and shepherd you through this process. And the idea is that it culminates, I think you said in a final post, which I suppose in a sense is a bit like a dissertation or something like that, you sum up all the different bits and pieces. Yeah.

[00:14:29] Maciej Pilarski: Once that happens, the students also receives an official certificate from the WordPress Foundation, signed by Matt himself, that certifies that they completed the course. And what is also important to know, the whole progress through the course and what they did during the course, it’s also stored on the wordpress.org profile. So any contributions that they did, for example, photos that they’ve uploaded, this all will be visible on the wordpress.org profile. And they also receive a special badge dedicated to students who graduated from that program.

So it really gets them started into the WordPress ecosystem, and at the same time creates something like a small portfolio for any future company that would like to, for example, hire them. Because they have a proven history of contributing to the ecosystem.

[00:15:20] Nathan Wrigley: Okay, so that’s an interesting quid pro quo, isn’t it? So the idea is you do all this work, which on the face of it, I suppose looks very philanthropic, you know, you’re giving up your time, but you get a real thing at the back end of it. You get a certificate. You can then presumably apply for jobs and indicate, okay, I’ve done this, I’ve contributed in this meaningful way.

What I think is really interesting there, and it kind of gets lost, I’ve worked in education in the past and I know the red tape that’s involved in doing anything in the education space. There is so much red tape. And I can only imagine what’s happened in the background to enable these kind of things. You know, the back and forth, the tennis of emails that go on and on and the proof that’s required to categorically show that this thing that we are doing is worth something. You know, it’s not just this Mickey Mouse. We use that expression, Mickey Mouse kind of qualification that really, it doesn’t actually require any hard work. It’s just there, nothing really in it, but you get an accreditation anyway.

I can only imagine the hard work that has gone in every single time you touch a new institution, trying to convince them that this is legitimate, that this is real. You’ve just kind of glossed over all of that by just describing what is in existence, not necessarily what has gone on to make it happen. I know that there’s probably more than the three of you involved in this, but my profound thanks for all of that hard work, which presumably is utterly and completely invisible. And I can only imagine what’s going on there. So yeah, thank you for all of that.

[00:16:54] Maciej Pilarski: Thank you for that.

[00:16:54] Nathan Wrigley: So that was WP Credits. So that was one wing of the things that we’re going to discuss today. Should we move on to another one and maybe somebody else wants to take the helm?

[00:17:03] Anand Upadhyay: I think Destiny can take Campus Connect and then I will take Student Clubs.

[00:17:06] Nathan Wrigley: Okay. Destiny, let’s move over to you and see what you can tell us about something different.

[00:17:11] Destiny Kanno: Yeah, so I’d love to tell you more about WordPress Campus Connect. And the way we ended with WordPress Credits, I think is also very critical to the story of Campus Connect because, you know, it started with Campus Connect first, and that’s how organisers such as Anand and Pooja like were able to get those connections with the universities through being boots on the ground, you know, having those relationships. Proving through action that these activities that we’re doing with the students are having real impact and are showing real results.

Slowly building up these kind of case studies in a way has helped open a lot of doors, especially with Campus Connect now, we’ve done a lot of events, especially since we last talked. Like I think this year alone, we’ve already had 22 Campus Connect events. So, like it’s not even half the year and it’s quickly becoming one of the biggest run events, WordPress official series.

But these events are like a way of opening the door, right? Hey, here’s a free learning opportunity for your students. And as you said, like the red tape is there. A lot of institutions are like, wait, so what’s in it for you? Why is, there’s a little bit of dubiousness sometimes in the reaction, right? You’re going to give your time to educate our students, why? But once they see, it’s like, no, we really are just passionate about spreading WordPress, showing students what’s capable with their website, how it applies to different skillsets as well. Like it’s not just for coders, it is for marketers, it is for designers.

You know, there’s so many career opportunities that once we just get the foot in the door and we’re able to showcase that, a lot of institutions are like, okay, now I get it. I do want to highlight in Anand’s case, like they’re going to have their third WordPress Campus Connect in Ajmer this year. You’ve got repeat institutions. I’ve heard you also have institutions that are like, when are you going to come to our place and teach WordPress? You know, once the fire is lit and people see how bright and shiny it is, like people want to get involved.

But as you said, like getting it to click for people, that is like the most difficult part. And I’ll give an example of, right now in Japan, we had our first WordPress Campus Connect event on the 9th of May. So I’m like, woo hoo. Like it finally happened. But we have this community in Japan that is like very passionate, very active. So when I first was like introducing the concept of Campus Connect, people were like, okay, but like how do we do this? What’s it about? It takes like a lot of presentations, a lot of going to people in person and talking. Helping them even shape the conversation that they’re going to have with the institution to sell this amazing gift of WordPress on their campus.

And after this one on the ninth, like now we have a case study in Japan that others can now use to be a starting point for those conversations going forward. So I think, once you have that one step, the gate just slowly opens until it’s just, the doors bang open in each way. But yeah, we’ve seen really great success with Campus Connect and it’s just like honestly, it just keeps growing.

[00:20:30] Nathan Wrigley: Can I just ask a quick question? So I just want to draw a very clear line for everybody that’s listening to this, what the difference may be between Campus Connect and WP Credits. Because from the description that we’ve had so far, it may be that you’ve fallen into the trap of thinking, well, they sound like they might be the same thing. So could you just, Destiny, just tease out where Campus Connect differs? Maybe in the nature of the event, the timing of the event, the availability, the age group, those kind of things that separate WP Credits from the Campus Connect initiative.

[00:21:02] Destiny Kanno: Yeah. Thank you, that’s like a really great distinction to make. So whereas WordPress Credits is geared toward higher education, Campus Connect is geared toward, honestly any level of students as long as they’re able to browse the web safely, and enjoy and participate.

So that means, Elementary school students now are pretty good at devices. High school students, college students, vocational students. We honestly kept the door pretty open in terms of what a campus means. We’ve even had a Campus Connect event in Uganda in a library, the Lira Public Library because students were able to go there right?

We were trying to make it as barrier free for students wherever their campus is. And so that’s, I think, the main difference. It’s more wide ranging in terms of who can participate as a student. And then also the fact that it could be a one-off event, so a one day event. A lot nowadays are multiple day events, they’ll maybe go two times out of a month, or a couple days consecutively. And then after that it’s up to really the organisers in the institution whether or not we have another addition on their campus the same year, or the next year.

[00:22:15] Nathan Wrigley: I’m going to tease out a few things. I just want to point out to, me as an English person, that is to say, not an English speaker, but somebody from England, campus has a really defined definition, and it’s usually bound to a university. Whereas it sounds like the description here, campus literally means the place where education happens, not it’s 18 years old and older, you know, people doing degrees, bachelors and PhDs and that kind of thing. Basically, if there’s an institution somewhere, that’s what the campus is in this case. Okay.

So the WP Credits program sounds like you forge your relationship with the university, and correct me if I’m wrong, it sounds like it takes place inside that institution, and it’s part of that program and what have you.

The Campus Connect initiative is much more ad hoc. It could be a one-off, it could be monthly, it could be inside a library, it could be inside the school, it could be an inside an institution. It feels a bit more like, I don’t know, a WordPress Meetup, but geared towards a younger audience or something like that.

And the minimum age requirement is really driven by your capacity to type on a keyboard and hold a mouse and those kind of things. And that’s kind of curious to me because I think my educational experience was always younger children. It’s really interesting how patterns are laid down at a very, very early age. Patterns that go on into much later life get laid down, typically at incredibly young ages. So this is fascinating for digging into that.

And it’s not just about, say, the code, it sounds like code is on the menu, but it could be about marketing, it could be about design. Basically the gamut of anything online, CMSy, those kind of things. Okay, is there anything you want to add? Did I misunderstand anything there, or misstate anything there?

[00:24:02] Destiny Kanno: No, I think you’re completely right. We’re trying to convey that WordPress isn’t just a blogging software that I think is still a lot of people have a mentality of. Like there are many ways to utilise it that goes beyond that.

And one thing I did want to add are a couple numbers. So since WordPress Campus Connect became official in May of 2025, an official WordPress event series, I should say, we’ve had 42 completed events, with 71 participating institutions, and over 5,500 students have been reached.

[00:24:37] Nathan Wrigley: That’s something else. 42 events, 71 institutions, and I think you said five and a half thousand individuals. Good grief. I don’t know what the measure of success is for this, but that feels like success to me.

I mean, imagine turning up to a WordCamp, like a flagship WordCamp and five and a half thousand people descending on you. You’d feel slightly overwhelmed. That’s a lot, isn’t it? Gosh, that’s pretty remarkable. Wow. Congratulations.

[00:25:05] Destiny Kanno: And the majority, the outcome, the students make a website. So we could almost count those students as also new WordPress websites that are live now on the web. So within a year, organisers around the world have been able to make that happen.

[00:25:19] Nathan Wrigley: Could I just perhaps draw another distinction as well, just very quickly, because it sounds like the WordPress Credit system, because it’s binding itself to institutions, it sounds like there might be more paperwork going on there, and maybe more high level meetings that need to take place. Whereas Campus Connect feels much more community driven. It’s the kind of thing that, quite literally, anybody listening to this podcast with a fair wind could have one of those going in a handful of months. If they’ve got the right initiative and they can find the audience for that.

Again, is that about right? There’s sort of more opportunity to become involved with the Campus Connect initiatives. You don’t need to have that academic background or have a point of contact at a university. You basically just need a building, some interest and a bunch of students.

[00:26:02] Destiny Kanno: Yeah, the key thing is, you know, having a real connection to the campus that you’re going to present at. But you’re exactly right. We tried really hard to lower the barrier to organise these events. Because I don’t know if you’ve organised a WordPress event before, there’s kind of a lot of hoops you have to jump through. And we’re like, okay, how can we think about this in a different way?

And I think that also has positive repercussions for how we organise other events too, that are, changes are being thought about too so that we can enable people and empower them to put these events, instead of bogging them down and process and a little bit of bureaucracy to say.

[00:26:38] Nathan Wrigley: So what’s really curious about that as well is we’re all in different parts of the world, aren’t we? People on the call today are in Japan and I’m in Europe and, Anand, are you in India? I think.

[00:26:47] Anand Upadhyay: Yeah.

[00:26:47] Nathan Wrigley: Yeah. Each of those events, I guess would look quite different. The kind of nature of the attendees, the nature of the kind of building it might be in, the institution. And it really is, you just grab what’s around you I suppose, and work with that. If you’ve got a connection to an institution, you can go for it. Maciej, I feel like I crosstalked you. I think you wanted to say quite a few times and I’ve just interrupted. I’m very sorry.

[00:27:08] Maciej Pilarski: No worries about that. So I wanted to add that those initiatives set backgrounds for each other. Because in some uni institutions, the interest sparks with a Campus Connect event, and that gets the institution interested in those initiatives, which sets background for WordCamp Credit.

And it happens also the other way around, where we start with an institution that starts credits and then we get the students interested in WordPress in general, the community, which leads to a Campus Connect event during the Credits Program. What is important is that those initiatives don’t compete with each other. They support each other.

[00:27:51] Nathan Wrigley: Right, so there’s a lovely virtuous cycle there, isn’t there? Where the two things can be going on in harmony, one promoting the other and they’re definitely not in competition. Okay. That’s really interesting.

One final question on Campus Connect, and I’ll direct this at Destiny, just because she’s been handling that. With the WP Credits thing, there is this moment where you hold the certificate in your hand and you go, yay, did it.

Is the same thing true of Campus Connect or is it more of a show up to the one event, you know that you did that, that was great, you can file that away in your own head as a thing? Or is there some sort of accreditation, or certificate giving, or badge giving, or profile updating that might go on on wordpress.org? Is there any sort of thing that the attendees receive, and I suppose that the people that are organising might receive as well?

[00:28:37] Destiny Kanno: Yes. So we do have a certificate of participation that students can receive signed by WordPress Foundation Executive Director, Mary Hubbard. And that just needs to be requested by the organisers ahead of time, because we need to get the signature and all that. So yes, they can come away with that. And we’ve heard really positive things about that, like it motivates them. They’re like, yeah, I did something, which they did.

[00:29:01] Nathan Wrigley: There we go. That was WP Credits and WP Campus Connect.

Can I just say at this point, dear listener, if at this point you’re thinking hang on a minute, there’s a lot going on here, don’t worry, there’ll be show notes. If you go to the WP Tavern website, there’ll be show notes. I’ll try to list out as many sensible links to get you to the root of each one of these initiatives, so that you can begin your journey and fan out from there.

I’m not sure what episode number this will be, but if you just go and search for, oh, I don’t know, Destiny or Anand or Maciej, you could probably find the episode that way. And all the show notes will contain all of the links.

Right, in which case, I think it might be Anand’s turn. What have you decided to take on Anand?

[00:29:39] Anand Upadhyay: So I will be sharing my thoughts on the third part of this whole education initiative ecosystem. So that is a Student Club. Just a few minutes before you were giving the analogue of meetup with this Campus Connect. So I would like to share the same analogue with us because we are more accustomed with like other terms of WordCamps and Meetups and contributer days.

WordPress Campus Connect is kind of like a WordCamp happening in the campus, because it’s like a big day event that holds everything happening, different kind of sessions, maybe workshops happening. So I would compare it with that thing.

And same way, credits thing, Credit Program is kind of like ongoing contribution series because more focused on the contribution part because the student devote 150 hours of their program. A lot of period goes to the contribution.

And now the same way we, if we talk about the Student club, it’s similar to like the Meetups that we have. But these are the in campus meetups for the students and by the students. How do things get started? Like the Campus Connect introduce the WordPress to those campuses and to those students, but since most of the campus, it’s a once in a year event. So once this event has sparked something about the WordPress in the students. So keeping that momentum going on, that’s where the Student Clubs come in.

So with the Student Club, it’s kind of like, as I mentioned, it’s like an in campus meet program. So a student can gather themselves, they can form a club and a couple of students can be nominated as club organisers, student club organiser from their campus. And then they organise the in-campus events, maybe like once in a month or twice a month, depending on academic calendar. There are a lot of hurdles in doing those things continuously.

But they usually do once or twice a month. They do a kind of a meetup in their campus. The students gathered together. They learn from variable resources available from WordPress. And from those resources, they share with the other students. It’s kind of a group learning, group study, that we use. Education live, we always do that. It’s kind of a group study. They’re learning from themselves. If someone has learned something, they are helping others to learn those things.

So I would just like to give some of the examples from my city. There are multiple Student Clubs are going on. When we went to the campus, we just taught like a small group of students about the WordPress, because we’d have some limitations of the resources, of the setting arrangement. We cannot call all the students of the campus and, okay, come together and I have a amazing workshop. So we have given the WordPress walk through to the limited number of students.

After that, they form a Student Club in their campus because they got very much interested. Then the first session they did was like, they started teaching to their juniors, like the students who have just entered the campus. They took a session for them. So they told, whatever we have told them, they have taught the same thing to the juniors.

After that, in the next few session, they experimented different things. Like in some session they’re just doing a fun quiz around WordPress. And in some sessions they are doing a kind of like a, I would say like a hackathon kind of thing. So they are just picking up a website. Or you can, just similar to the speed build challenge that Jamie do. So they have just one website open on the screen and everybody’s like cloning that website.

So there are different ways students are engaging through those student clubs. So it is helping to keep the momentum going on so that the student keep learning about WordPress and they are also connecting with the community members for the guidance about how they can learn more. What should they learn next if they are sharing their experience. Like we have covered these things and, what should we go next?

And in the recent WordCamp Asia, they’re also one of the Student Club lead from my city. She joined the event and there are conversation with the, like other community members who has offered them like, okay, we can come to your campus, or we can do, have a webinar for your campus where we can teach you particular subjects, particular topics. Maybe they can talk about SEO, maybe they can talk about plugin development.

So this is also opening the horizon for them, to learn from people across the world. So that is how the Student Clubs are happening. The examples I’ve gave, again, from my own city because I’m closely mentoring them, but there’s similar things are happening across the world.

So it is helping to create a kind of sustainable environment for the long-term sustainable environment in the campus. So the next time when we go to that campus, we are not going to teach like the basics of WordPress, because we want like, the ecosystem should be built within the campus, so every student know about the WordPress. Because last time when we went to the campus, we have to tell everything about WordPress because why you should learn WordPress.

So the Student Clubs, my ambition is that, wherever the Student Club is from, next time a Campus Connect event is happening, next time we should not tell them about what is WordPress and why they should learn this thing. There should be already a sustainable ecosystem.

And I feel that all these three programs are like very much interconnected. And the real impact of these programs, we will be able to see in the next two or three years. And there will be a regular ongoing activities around WordPress in the campus.

And these are also kind of a balance program as well. Like the Campus Connect is introducing WordPress to the students, Credits Program is motivating them more towards like the contribution part. And I would say that Student Clubs is more inclined towards getting new users to the WordPress. Because if we keep on focusing on the contribution, contribution, but if we discard the like increasing the number of new users, so we are not going to win. We need a balanced state.

The Student Club is trying to, learning how to build website, how to mastering the skills of the WordPress. And later on, many of them are going to join the contribution part as well.

So this whole ecosystem is built around bringing more people to the contribution, bringing more people to use WordPress, build websites, as in, for the individuals as a business as well. So that’s how all these three programrs are very much interconnected, and growing together fast.

[00:35:16] Nathan Wrigley: It feels like, of the three things that we’ve talked about, so WP Credits, Campus Connect, the Student Club, this final one that you’ve just covered, it feels like that’s got a very flat hierarchy to it. In other words, there’s like this peer learning. So it feels like more or less anybody can show up and demonstrate anything, which might then lead to somebody else thinking, okay, that was interesting, I’ll take on next month’s one because I’ve now seen that’s doable. Less hierarchy, if you know what I mean? So a much more flat structure.

[00:35:45] Anand Upadhyay: Because when we started Campus Connect, we also get a lot of attraction in the local community as well. And people join our Meetup groups. But then it becomes difficult for us, how to plan about the topics for our meetup. We have some experienced professionals coming in. We have some students coming in, and we plan the topics that suits the professionals. The student will feel like, okay, what’s they’re talking, we are not getting anything in our mind. If we bring the topics, very basic topics and the professionals who are joining the community meetups, they’ll feel like, okay, these are very basic stuff, why am I coming here?

Student Clubs giving them their own platform, giving them a own opportunity. Okay, these are all the familiar faces. It is also giving the opportunity to come on the stage, come onto the stage and get out of your fear as well. It is also generating leadership qualities in them. Okay, we have to keep this momentum going on and we have to keep the activities going on. So there are a lot of ways, apart from learning WordPress, there are a lot of other ways it is helping the students as well.

[00:36:40] Nathan Wrigley: When you have to stand up in front of a bunch of people and deliver something, obviously there’s a whole bunch of us that are just really confident at doing that, quite happy to stand up and do that kind of thing off the bat. But equally, there’s people for whom that is just the most terrifying experience possible. You know, standing up in front of two or three people, oh boy, you know, anything above that is just off the books.

And I was just wondering about that, whether or not there’s, in this particular style of event, the Student Club, whether there is a growing corpus of, I don’t know, previously done topics or topic suggestions or slide decks or anything like that, which might enable people to feel that level of confidence? I don’t know if that’s something which is being put together. Just resources which enable somebody who doesn’t have the confidence, let’s go with that word, who then may gain that confidence. And I’m going to pass this to Destiny because she’s waving her hand.

[00:37:30] Destiny Kanno: I was really hoping I could shamelessly plug this project. This is like, you’ve said the most opportune thing. So I’m actually developing right now what I’m like tentatively calling the Meetup Activity Library. It comes with like kits on certain topics. So for example, WordPress Playground was the first one I built. But it comes with the facilitation guide, which is a doc. So the facilitator can read through, understand the steps they’re going to go through in the activity, how to pace it. And then a presentation deck which they would display, if that’s available to them, to the folks that they’re presenting to. And it’s a hands-on activity only. So it’s not only presentation. The facilitator of course guides and talks them through things, but then people are getting hands-on experience with that topic along the way.

[00:38:16] Nathan Wrigley: That is a beautiful remover of barriers, because I think just having that little document, that little crutch, you don’t have to feel that you, okay, I’ve got to come up with a topic. Not only have I got to come up with a topic, but then I’ve got to research the topic, deliver the topic. If you can have it all on a thing that you can crib from, I don’t know, it just arms you with that confidence as you walk in. I think that’s such a brilliant topic. And, Maciej.

[00:38:40] Maciej Pilarski: Both Destiny and Anand mentioned two keywords, sustainability and facilitator. The goal of also getting all those educational initiatives going is also create in a sustainable way. We’re not pushing for numbers, but growing them in a smart way where we don’t get too many students so we get overwhelmed. We need to have enough mentors to accommodate those students, and also enough facilitators to be able to scale the program, to grow it in the future.

And it’s exactly what Destiny is now doing, the Facilitator Training Program, which gets more people from the educational sectors, community organisers, everyone on board, to jump on those educational initiatives and help us to grow. Because the number of every, all those students involved in participating in those programs is increasing and we need to be able to accommodate them. And through the Facilitator Training Program, this allows us to do that.

[00:39:42] Nathan Wrigley: It’s so interesting in open source software spaces as opposed to corporate spaces. I suppose the metric of success for anything like this in the corporate universe would be how many people showed up and gave us money in exchange for this knowledge or, you know, something akin to that. Basically a metric of humans in a room and money gained. And of course, the measurement of this is so not that.

I did wonder, Destiny obviously very proudly rattled off the statistics for Campus Connect, you know, the five and a half thousand attendees and all of that. I wondered if there were success criteria of some kind in the background, which guide you. You know, it’s not like, okay, well we didn’t meet that we’re going to abandon it all. But more, things like you would like to see happen, so aspirational goals. It sounds from what Maciej was saying that maybe the attendance growing slowly over time is some kind of measure of success. Maybe there is none of that, but I’ll just open that one up to see if you want to take that.

[00:40:38] Destiny Kanno: I think one definite measure of success is repeat events on certain campuses. So if the campus is saying, we love that, please come back, or please come again soon. I think that is a really great indicator that, not only did the students get something great out of it, but the school believes in it. And that’s what we want to do. We want to create these systems that, not only bring people into WordPress, but also continue this cycle of, you know, growth within the community, but also ownership by the institution.

Another measurement of success is the institution is like, okay, great, how do we learn how to do that ourselves? So we have some folks now working in the institution that are organising WordPress Campus Connect events that are helping facilitate these Student Clubs. So the faculty and educators themselves, they’re directly getting involved. And that for us as community members too, whose volunteer time is quite limited, as Maciej was saying, like it is a great multiplier that makes everything much more sustainable.

[00:41:45] Maciej Pilarski: So from the WordPress Credits perspective, we don’t hope all the students to turn into contributors. That would be amazing but that might not happen. I can share with you some numbers. So currently we have 450 students globally enrolled. For the whole program so far, 75 graduates.

We hope that some or as many as possible of those graduates who completed the program will stay and become active contributors to the WordPress community, stay engaged.

That’s one of the goals we are aiming for the Credits Program, to not just get this done, but this is building the next generation of contributors. We know that like we are ageing, we’re getting older every year. We are not getting younger, unfortunately. Getting those students staying in the community allows us to build those next generations of WordPress contributors that will also have completely different perspectives to how the community functions, how it was built.

What brought us here might not move us forward. So these new students will bring us this new, fresh perspective of how they would like the community to function and move it to the future, to be current, to stay up to date with what’s happening globally.

[00:43:00] Anand Upadhyay: That’s why it’s very difficult to like measure the impact in numbers because how it is impacting in the longer term. But yeah, it’s going to impact. And I would say also, like Destiny mentioned, one of the metrics is like this campus is willing to have the Campus Connect again and again in the campus.

So I just want to share one more. Like I just recently got a call from one of the faculty coordinators from one of the campus where we have a Student Club. And now they have like two months of vacations. And he called me like, okay, now the vacations are going on, students will not be here, so what can we do for the students to keep their involvement with the WordPress in those two months? So can we do something online? Can we do something like this?

When we get these calls, these kind of communications, that these are interactions that we have, this gives us a sense of like accomplishment. Okay, yeah, we were able to create some kind of interest in the students. Because we cannot expect that if we are going to like any campus and 100 or 200 students are participating in our Campus Connect, they are all going to jump into the WordPress. They are getting a lot of different kind of opportunities as well.

There are other technologies as well, which are, some students are going into that, some students are going into that. But we are showcasing the WordPress as one of the career opportunities. And they have a choice of multiple options, so they will choose what they do. But yeah, the impact will be seen in the next few years. Just like Maciej said, mentioned that he went to the WordCamp as a volunteer and it’s bring him into the community.

And the same is with me. I attended the WordCamp and just after coming out of the WordCamp, I started the Meetup group in my city. So I got inspired from that. So that is a result of that WordCamp. And that cannot be measured in the numbers. That can only be sensed when we are doing this kind of conversation. Okay, that WordCamp helped me, that WordCamp helped me.

The same way in future, these students who will join the community or the WordPress industry, they will be talking about, okay, I got first introduced about WordPress through a WordPress Campus Connect event or I got introduced to the contribution through WP Credits Program. So when these conversation will be happening in the future, then we will say that those are the real metrics that we are looking for.

[00:45:00] Nathan Wrigley: That’s really interesting, and I like that. It sounds like there’s not so much a focus on statistics, you know, literal, brutal numbers, more kind of playing it forwards and measuring the impact over many years, not, you know, a handful of months into the future.

[00:45:15] Destiny Kanno: So yes, we’re not like, okay, here’s our KPIs, you know, and here’s our hard metrics. But one thing I really noticed that our community is, it could be better at doing, is just talking about what happened. Because then you hear all these success stories and there are numbers in that. So like for example, Ajmer again, Women’s Day event this year. 50% of tickets sold were to students. And that’s directly because of the involvement in going to these campuses and teaching WordPress. And I’m like, that’s amazing, that’s direct injection of 50% youth into the WordPress community.

[00:45:52] Anand Upadhyay: And they sold out so fast.

[00:45:53] Destiny Kanno: And they sold out really fast, yeah.

[00:45:55] Anand Upadhyay: The organisers were hoping like, now we have to pitch out to sale our tickets. And they have planned a social media campaign around that. Okay, we will be periodically pitch a student on the social media to encourage the ticket purchase. And within one day, we sold out. And the whole social media campaign was like their whole planning was gone. We don’t have tickets.

[00:46:14] Nathan Wrigley: It’s really interesting that there’s all this success going on, and yet, as Destiny said, it is hard to get that discovered. Maybe it’s a case of shouting louder about the previous success. Maybe things like this podcast will help in some small way for things like that.

But I know what you mean. There’s a lot of people talking about the code, and there’s a lot of people talking about the plugins and the themes and whether or not we’re going to get collaborative editing in version 7 or 7.1. All of that seems to suck up all of the oxygen in the room. And yet, without a throughput of, let’s go for young adults, coming into the WordPress space, there’s not really a great deal of hope for a project over decades unless we get people of a much younger age beginning now. And I’ll just hand the torch to Maciej because I think he’s got something to add.

[00:47:05] Maciej Pilarski: But this is also changing because at WordCamp Asia, we were able to introduce the educational table during the contributor day. And I’m also organiser of WordCamp Europe that’s going to happen really soon in two, three weeks, beginning of June. And during WordCamp Europe, we will also have a contributor table, dedicated to education, but for the first time also educational track.

During the second day, we will start the whole day with topics related to education. We will have a discussion panel rethinking learning in WordPress that Mary will be participating. And later in that afternoon, we will have actual students, who take part in the program. Sharing the experience, presenting the results. Not only students from universities, but I’m also leading a group of high school students who’ve been working for the whole past semester with a teacher on some projects related to WordPress building websites. So they are super eager and excited to show them.

We will also showcase some students, teachers stories, how both of those sites motivated each other, learn from each other, and basically help us keep growing the community.

So WordCamp Europe definitely will feature some of those things. And we’re slowly introducing more and more those things into those flagship events and into the broader community.

[00:48:28] Nathan Wrigley: Really nice. Yeah, that’s really nice to hear. I think it’s a difficult circle to square, the idea of making this stuff visible so that everybody’s aware of it. Even if they’re only interested in running their agency, or writing code or whatever it is. Maybe to realise that this is some version of the underpinnings of the WordPress community without which the software ultimately doesn’t exist.

And it is quite curious. I don’t know if I’m reading between the lines here, I think I’m not, but I get the impression that, I’m going to use the phrase like, I don’t know, from higher up, let’s put it that way. It feels like education is taking a more central place. It feels like for example, Mary Hubbard, it feels like you’ve got a real advocate there. Again, I could be reading between the lines, but it feels like the words coming out of her mouth, I hear the word education coming out of her mouth quite a lot when she’s on stage.

So it feels like you’ve got some big hitters, let’s go with that. I don’t know if you’ve got anything you want to add to that, but it feels like the importance of this is more profound this year than it was a few years ago.

[00:49:33] Maciej Pilarski: You are correct. Mary is a big supporter of that and she also created this space for us to grow those initiatives that like allows us to grow that. Isotta started the first Credits Program at the Pisa University as an experiment. And from there it was proven that this actually works. It gets us universities and new contributors.

And then on the other side, there was those Campus Connect events that also organically grew up on their own. So basically there was a need. It feels like there was this hive mind somehow that worked also for all of us. All of us felt this need to introduce those things. It looks like we’ve reached a certain growth level for the community that we organically felt that that’s the direction that we should start heading.

[00:50:24] Nathan Wrigley: Yeah. What’s interesting there as well is that it very much overlaps with maybe a concern. So we’ve touched on this at various points without saying it out loud quite. If you go to, and I’m going to exclude WordCamp Asia 2026 from what I’m about to say, because that event was very different. If you go to a typical WordCamp, the age skews, and I’m doing air quotes, older. You don’t typically look around and see a bunch of teenagers.

So that’s a concern. There’s this, like a pyramid, like a reverse pyramid, and if we don’t get the younger people coming up, the edifice of this entire project kind of becomes a lot more shaky. And we’ve lived through 22 plus years of WordPress, and I think quite a lot of those people began, a lot of the people who’ve been involved in the community began their careers using WordPress and they’ve kind of moved through WordPress as it’s evolved over those 22 years.

And not to, I don’t know quite how to say this. At some point they’re going to stop contributing. Their age will become something, you know, they want to retire or they want to move on or do some other things. Unless we build the scaffolding and put things in place so that young people feel they’ve got a place here, feel that, I don’t know, some proprietary system is not the way they want to go, they want to support the ethic of open source.

Unless these building blocks, these educational building blocks are put in place, then that’s going to be a bit of a concern. So to your point, Maciej, it organically grew. And what a nice thing that it did kind of organically grow because it’s sorely needed at the same time. There isn’t really a question in there. But anyway, there’s my observation. Anand, did you have something to say? I think you did.

[00:52:04] Anand Upadhyay: Yeah. So just want to add that thing you have raised recently. So the way that we want to teach the students about the open source as well, because if you go to the WP Credit curriculum, so the initial lessons, they learn through the, given to them to learn from the learn.wordpress. So it’s all about like open source ethics, and how the WordPress community, WordPress project works.

So this opens up their mind about the open source. Because in the education system, it is something that is not clearly mentioned. There are simple, just simple definitions around the open source. But open source is much more than those definitions.

And especially the open source community like WordPress. It’s more about the people. So the students also learn about how the community is working, how the people are working from the different time zones, people are joining hands for running the bigger events like WordCamp Asia or these Credits Programs. The students will learn all those things as well, and I’m sure when they will join as a contributor in the future, they will have lot of experience before joining as well.

[00:53:02] Nathan Wrigley: Thank you. I love that expression, by the way. You just dropped it in in the middle of a sentence there. You said people are joining hands. What a perfect summation of the entire enterprise being discussed today. Maciej, you raised your hand.

[00:53:14] Maciej Pilarski: Yeah, and besides the community goals and keeping it going, I have also a very personal goal that also is behind all of those things that I do. From my own experience, I had a pretty difficult and bumpy educational path, let’s call it. Unlocking those possibilities for those students, helping them out, making it easier for them, it’s one of my very personal goals, because I know it does not need to be very difficult or crazy when you study, especially when you are young. You’re not sure fully which direction you would like to go. So creating for them, one of those opportunities that might click for them is also something very personal and close to my heart. Because not everyone needs to struggle or have like difficulties, so.

[00:53:58] Nathan Wrigley: I am so glad you said that because that encapsulates all of it. That’s the entire point. It’s got to be that, right? So we’ve spent a long time talking about the minutiae of this, that, and the other thing. It all goes, like they’re spokes on a wheel. And the whole point is that little bit in the middle, which is the child, the adult, the human being somewhere who just wants to make use, wants to grow, wants to learn things, wants to figure things out.

With open source, with this kind of learning, there is potentially zero impediment, or at least very few impediments to actually get that learning underway. And so I think maybe we lost sight of that in this conversation a little bit. So I’m glad that you grounded it there, Maciej, right towards the end. That’s perfect. Destiny, was there anything you wanted to say? I don’t know if you were indicating that you did.

[00:54:48] Destiny Kanno: I know we’re like probably over time, but there’s still so much to share. Like even thinking about keeping WordPress relevant, right? For us and then also for youth. I think about the new AI Leaders Credential that was announced and is being worked on. And how tying WordPress to AI is like really helping students engage more, and see like the relevancy of it in a different way. Not even for the students, like for me, that’s challenging me and I think other organisers and learners of WordPress to be adaptable and think about WordPress differently in a new way of this year as AI keeps advancing.

And then you were also talking about wins, right? How do we celebrate that? I did want to surface, we have the Education Buzz Report, which goes out every month, which aims to try to surface all of these educational wins that are happening in the community. And I just have received some further collaboration from marketing to hopefully also broadcast that on our socials going forward so that we do get the word out.

And lastly, like celebrating the students too. There was a post that went out about the Student Clubs and the success. And we just want to make sure that in this, that they feel seen, right? And that this feels like a space for them. And I know WordPress Credits, we’re working on something to showcase, no, something went out recently. A post went out recently to showcase some of the successes of the students. And we just want to keep highlighting that as well. Because their work and the way they operate, especially because they’re coming in with different lenses, is really important to showcase and highlight and make sure that they feel like they deserve that.

[00:56:26] Nathan Wrigley: Yeah, there was a post, I’ll try and link to it. I think it was like a week ago about the Student Clubs. There were three or four images, three or four photos and there were so many smiling faces in those pictures. It was absolutely lovely. Lots of people gathered in classrooms. I couldn’t exactly tell where, but it was just so nice seeing people kind of enjoying WordPress, having a nice time, bit of camaraderie, hanging out with each other, learning things. It was absolutely wonderful.

Unfortunately, I think time might have got the better of us. Hopefully, dear listener, what you’ve gained is an understanding that there’s so many layers to this educational initiative. It doesn’t appear to be in any way standing still. It’s growing. It’s interesting. There’s a lot going on, and you can be involved.

I will put links in the show notes to any of the places where I feel you would be best making a start with that. Maybe the contributors to this panel can drop some things, you know, if they’ve got a particular link. So again, wptavern.com. If you want to go over there, we will look for the links.

This giant edifice that you maybe know nothing about, and maybe at the end of this episode, some parts of you is tuned in and thinking, I would like to be involved in that. And the truth is, you can be. It’s all available to you to get involved and you could start today.

So there we go. With that said, I’m just going to say a great big thank you to Destiny, to Anand, and to Maciej. It kinds of feels like we need to come back. Let’s do it again in six months or so, and we’ll see where we’re at. Oh, I’ve got a lot of nodding faces. That’s nice. So maybe we’ll revisit this in a few months time.

But seriously, from the bottom of my heart, Destiny, Anand and Maciej, profound respect to you and all of the different things that you are doing. Thank you so much for chatting to me today.

[00:58:13] Anand Upadhyay: Thank you.

[00:58:13] Maciej Pilarski: Thank you.

[00:58:14] Destiny Kanno: Thank you.

On the podcast today we’re joined by three WordPress education initiative leaders, Destiny Kanno, Anand Upadhyay and Maciej Pilarski.

Together, they have spent years at the heart of WordPress training and outreach, working in roles spanning community education management, plugin development, and credit program administration. Their efforts have helped shape student engagement and university partnerships across the globe, introducing thousands of learners to WordPress. You can see their bios further down.

The conversation focused on the current landscape of WordPress education, with particular attention to three key initiatives: the WordPress Credits Program, Campus Connect, and Student Clubs. Each initiative is designed to provide unique entry points for students of all ages and education levels, from high schoolers building their first site in a library, to university students earning official credits for open source contributions.

We discussed the different approaches these programs take: WP Credits ties student work directly to academic credit and mentorship, Campus Connect provides flexible, community-driven events in diverse locations, and Student Clubs foster sustainable, peer-led learning within schools and other institutions. We explored how these models feed into each other, building a sustainable ecosystem for ongoing growth in the WordPress community.

We also got into the importance of repeat campus partnerships, the need for scalable facilitator training, and the role of recognition: certificates, badges, and public showcases, in keeping students motivated and validated in their journey.

If you’re curious about the growing movement to bring WordPress knowledge to the next generation, or are looking to get involved with education in your local community, this episode is for you.

Useful links

Previous episode of the podcast related to this episode:
#183 – Destiny Kanno, Isotta Peira and Anand Upadhyay on how WordPress is shaping the future of education for students worldwide

WordPress Community Team

Welcome to WordPress Campus Connect

Stephen Dumba’s WordPress.org profile

WordPress Credits: Contribution Program for Students

WordPress Student Clubs

WordPress Campus Connect in Ajmer

Peer Review Needed: Hands-On WordPress Meetup Activity Library

Introducing the WordPress Facilitator Training Program

Piloting the AI Leaders Micro-Credential

Monthly Education Buzz Report – May 2026

Learn WordPress

WordPress Student Clubs Build Momentum

Links provided by the guests

Guest bios:

Destiny Kanno

Destiny Fox Kanno, sponsored contributor acting as a Community Education Programs Manager at Automattic. Destiny works closely with the Community team and Training Team, with a focus on growing, enabling and amplifying WordPress Campus Connect, Student Club, WordPress Credits and other education initiatives.

Anand Upadhyay

Anand Upadhyay is a long-time WordPress contributor and community advocate based in Ajmer, India. Active in the ecosystem since 2010, he has contributed to several Make WordPress teams including Core, Docs, Community, and Polyglots, with a strong focus on empowering others to get involved. He is the founder of WPVibes, a WordPress plugin development company that builds performance-driven tools for WordPress and WooCommerce users.

Anand is also a regular WordCamp speaker, Meetup organiser, and someone deeply committed to bringing WordPress education to students. In 2024, he launched the first WordPress Campus Connect event, which went on to become a global program officially recognised by the WordPress Foundation. Anand continues to support and mentor student communities through events, workshops, and open-source advocacy.

Maciej Pilarski

Maciej Pilarski is a Community Wrangler at Automattic, where he works on WordPress.org with a focus on educational initiatives that connect the next generation of contributors to the global WordPress community.

As one of the admins behind the WordPress Credits Program, Maciej works with universities across Central & Eastern Europe and Asia to bring students into open source contribution, pairing them with mentors, building institutional partnerships, and helping turn academic coursework into real-world impact on software used by 43% of the web.

Originally from Poland and now based in Okinawa, Japan, Maciej brings a uniquely cross-cultural perspective to community building, bridging local ecosystems in places like Kraków, Riga, Tallinn, and Tokyo with the wider WordPress world. He’s passionate about making open source contribution more accessible and making sure the WordPress community reflects the full diversity of the people who use it.

💾

40+ Best Academic & Educational PowerPoint Presentation Templates

18 June 2026 at 10:45

A convincing presentation is important whether you’re a student or an educator. It requires a professional approach and clearly defined ideas.

The right PowerPoint template can help you communicate effectively. You’ll want one with great typography, professional graphics, and an easy-to-follow layout. A template that matches your subject matter is also a must. It resonates better than something generic.

This simple asset will make your presentation easier to understand. And it’s something your audience can reference later.

We’ve compiled this collection of PowerPoint templates to cover all your academic needs. Below, you’ll find templates for various subjects and use cases. Everything from science, math, and language are here. There are also options for student portfolios, events, and more.

If you’re new to the application, you might like to take a look at our collection of PowerPoint tutorials for beginners.

Lecture PowerPoint Templates

Make sure your lecture stands out using one of these beautiful PowerPoint templates. They feature clean typography and attractive color schemes. They’re also easy to customize to match your subject.

EduTalks Lectures Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

EduTalks Lectures PowerPoint Template

Educational Medical Lecture Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Educational Lecture for Medical Students PowerPoint Template

Research PowerPoint Templates

Present your research findings clearly and concisely using one of these templates. You’ll find easy-to-read layouts and plenty of space for your ideas. Perfect for sharing data at events or in the classroom.

Research PowerPoint Presentation

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Research Presentation PowerPoint Template

Tech Research Presentation

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Tech Research Presentation PowerPoint Template

Thesis PowerPoint Templates

A successful thesis demonstrates your knowledge and your attention to detail. The templates below help by providing a visually appealing place to show what you know. Use them to share your methodology, findings, and conclusions.

Thesis Presentation Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Thesis PowerPoint Presentation Template

Thesis PowerPoint Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Thesis PowerPoint Template

Classroom Lesson PowerPoint Templates

Use one of these classroom lesson presentation templates to give your students a head-start on learning. The available custom charts and design elements will help you bring facts and figures to life. Add images to reinforce key concepts.

School Classroom PowerPoint Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Classroom School PowerPoint Template

Minimalist Classroom Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Class Room - Minimalist PowerPoint Template

E-Learning PowerPoint Templates

Online education is becoming the norm for many learners these days. The templates featured here are to help tout the benefits of e-learning. Create presentations for parents, prospective students, and administrators.

College e-Learning PowerPoint Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

e-Learning College PowerPoint Template

E-Learning Presentation Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

E-Learning PowerPoint Template

Workshop PowerPoint Templates

Workshop events are a great way to collaborate on projects and introduce new ideas. Use one of these PowerPoint templates to guide participants through each step. They’re here to help kick-start the learning process for groups of all sizes.

Workshop PowerPoint Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Workshop PowerPoint Presentation Template

Workshop Presentation Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Workshop Presentation PowerPoint Template

Seminar PowerPoint Templates

Reach your audience with a detail-oriented seminar presentation template. Add infographics, charts, and tables to emphasize your points of interest. The flexibility offered here means you can customize them for any subject.

Training PowerPoint Templates

Use a training presentation template to help students or colleagues learn new skills. Provide background information and the steps they’ll need to take. An effective presentation can be a difference-maker for learners.

Training Template for PowerPoint

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Training PowerPoint Template

IT Training Presentation

PowerPoint PPTX Template

IT Training PowerPoint Template

Education Course PowerPoint Templates

These templates are perfect for sharing the details of your course. Provide students with a syllabus that includes topics covered, special projects, and expectations. It’s a handy and informative document that can be referenced anytime.

Online Course Education Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Online Course - School Education PowerPoint Template

Guru Online Course for PowerPoint

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Guru Online Course PowerPoint Template

Student Portfolio PowerPoint Templates

A portfolio presentation can help students shine a light on their accomplishments. Highlight projects, extra-curricular activities, awards, and biographical information. Use it to introduce yourself to universities or prospective employers.

Balmand Education Student Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Balmand – Education & Student PowerPoint Template

Violet Portfolio PowerPoint Template

PowerPoint PPT Template

Violet Portfolio PowerPoint Template

Academic PowerPoint Templates

The academic templates here are appropriate for a wide range of uses. Share course materials, research findings, and project data. You can even use them to create a portfolio or resource document.

Academic PowerPoint Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Academic PowerPoint Template

Academic School Presentation Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Science Research PowerPoint Templates

Share your research, hypothesis, and conclusions with one of these PowerPoint templates. Present your data using the customizable chart and graph elements. Use color and imagery to make your key points stand out.

Science Presentation Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Science PowerPoint Presentation Template

Science Research Presentation

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Science Research Presentation PowerPoint Template

School Project PowerPoint Templates

Create a presentation to document your school project work using one of these templates. Highlight your process, key findings, and data points. It will help you connect with the audience and show what you’ve learned.

High School Education PowerPoint

PowerPoint PPTX Template

High School Education PowerPoint Template

School Presentation Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

School Presentation PowerPoint Template

Historical Timeline PowerPoint Templates

A timeline of events is key to understanding history. These templates help you show the who, when, and where with beautiful visual elements. They’ll help students solidify their knowledge of the past.

Timeline History PowerPoint Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Timeline History PowerPoint Template

History PowerPoint Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Geography PowerPoint Templates

The earth is a big place, but you can condense it using one of these geography presentation templates. Add maps, cultural history, data, and images to take your audience someplace new. They’re an excellent resource for teachers and students.

Geology Presentation Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Geology Presentation PowerPoint Template

Country Maps PowerPoint Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Country Maps PowerPoint Templates

Language Learning PowerPoint Templates

A PowerPoint presentation can help language learners better understand key concepts. Use one to introduce lessons or as a home for resource materials. You might also add some international flavor using one of these easy-to-customize templates.

Math Lesson PowerPoint Templates

Use a math lesson template to help students navigate and better understand their studies. They’re great for explaining concepts, and diagramming formulas and equations. Students may also find them to be a helpful study guide.

Math Lesson Presentation Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Math Lesson – Mathematics Presentation PowerPoint Template

Math Module Presentation

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Math Module Presentation PowerPoint Template

Physics PowerPoint Templates

Let’s be honest: not everyone fully appreciates or understands physics. However, an effective presentation has a way of condensing ideas into something more approachable. It makes learning that much easier and fun.

Physics Presentation Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Physics Presentation PowerPoint TemplatePhysics Presentation PowerPoint Template

Quantum Physics Class for PowerPoint

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Quantum - Physics Class PowerPoint Template

Biology PowerPoint Templates

Explain the ins and outs of biology using one of these PowerPoint presentation templates. Add images to reinforce your lesson materials and keep students engaged. You’ll find plenty of tools to help learners understand life in all its forms.

Biology Course Presentation

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Biology Course PowerPoint Template

Biology Education PowerPoint Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Biology Education PowerPoint Template

Chemistry PowerPoint Templates

Chemistry is a powerful subject filled with complex ideas and formulas. The templates below offer a space to simplify these concepts and accelerate learning. That sounds like a formula for success!

Chemistry PowerPoint Template

PowerPoint PPTX Template

Share Your Ideas and Knowledge in Style

Educational presentations are a great way to share what you know. Teachers use them to communicate key facts about a subject. Meanwhile, student presentations demonstrate what they’ve learned.

The great thing about the above templates is they help to effectively deliver your message and save you time. You don’t have to worry about designing a presentation from scratch. All of this has been done for you.

That frees you to focus on your thoughts and ideas. We’ll give that an A+ in our grade book.


The post 40+ Best Academic & Educational PowerPoint Presentation Templates appeared first on Speckyboy Design Magazine.

Field Notes from a Year of OPSEC Training

Late last year, as part of our annual “Year in Review” series, we summarized our efforts providing digital privacy and security advice to at-risk communities. OPSEC trainings (short for operational security, a catch-all term we use to describe any kind of workshop, advising session, assessment, or presentation about operational security for individuals and organization) are something we've long provided, but until recently, something we’ve never broadcasted.

This has become a critical aspect of our work over the years, keeping us grounded and in touch with the realities of tech-enabled violence as well as evolving resistance strategies used by movement workers. Hoping other security trainers and organizers copy our homework, here’s a more thorough breakdown.

NOT TRADITIONAL PENTESTING

To be clear, we're not a 'pentesting' company, which refers to the methodological process of testing a person or organization's security and privacy posture, nor an information security (infosec) firm that offers anything within scopes of traditional security assessments.  Infosec companies almost always adhere to a cycle of: discovery/reconnaissance; > vulnerability scanning and testing; > exploitation of vulnerabilities found; > and a reportback of recommended mitigation strategies. Such full-spectrum audits can run the gamut of testing network security, physical security, organization posture against phishing or ransomware attacks, web app security, and more. For many organizations, the value of such engagements is immeasurable.

Such companies—although equipped with the technical sophistication to do full-spectrum digital security auditing and testing—often lack the critical points of view of human rights defenders and activists. Many human rights defenders and liberation movement workers are critically under-resourced and unable to meet the high costs of engagement with such infosec companies.  But that’s not what we offer. Our trainings center the needs of people on the ground, and offer this work pro bono. 

The cycle of engagement our work tends to take is similar to the lifecycle of pentesting outlined above, but with some key differences better suited to people-powered movements. 

We begin with a period of discovery about the organization we’re engaging with, learning about their work, the issue space they’re working in, and the types of threats their peers have faced in the past. Relying on our knowledge of known threat actors (state-operated threats, non-state actors, surveillance mechanisms, and more), we conduct a thorough threat modeling and risk assessment exercise, surfacing critical pieces of information about what we ought to prioritize protecting and from what. Sometimes that’s enough for a group to get started on improving their security plans, and we send them on their way.

After receiving consent from the group to do so, we may perform some OSINT (open source intelligence) investigation and map out a sketch of their digital footprint. This often looks like some combination of discoverability through public records, data broker ecosystems, and breach databases, as well as risks they may incur through the services they rely on for their web presence. That latter part can be done with typical pentesting reconnaissance tools, as well as our own project Privacy Badger for mapping the trackers on their website, which pose them and their users some amount of risk. Working from this sketch of their digital footprint, opportunities to lessen the reach of their data exposure, or at least the more sensitive areas they ought to be aware of, become apparent.

For a more in-depth engagement, we take the information gathered from the guided threat modeling exercises, as well as the digital footprint we’ve developed for them, and we move on to training the participants on what they need to address their threats. Sometimes that looks like a deep dive on encryption and how it can be used to protect data backups and secure communications. Other times it looks like getting very knowledgeable and practiced on the various ways to stay safe from surveillance threats encountered at a protest. Often though, our engagement with those asking for advice on how to strengthen their OPSEC is as simple as presenting materials covered in our Surveillance Self-Defense (SSD) project, but with EFF staff to help apply those lessons to their context.

MOVEMENTS AND COMMUNITIES ADVISED

Requests for such training mostly arise organically, either via referral, from our participation in external media, or driven by an interest in SSD. Naturally, the demand for accessible OPSEC advice escalates along with the general sophistication and reach of surveillance technology. And as authoritarianism creeps and continues to threaten the movement workers fighting against it, there's a marked urgency for that demand.

The types of communities and liberation movement workers that reach out run a wide array of experiences, but some commonalities stick out. Since the fall of Roe v. Wade, we've seen a huge uptick in abortion access activists like clinic escorts and information distribution networks reaching out. So too are providers of criminalized healthcare services, both abortion services and gender affirming care alike. The list goes on: advocates for transgender rights such as art collectives and archivists, sex worker rights activists, survivors of intimate partner violence, climate justice activists, legal defense groups focusing on immigrant justice and Black liberation. And many, many others, often stemming from experiences of distinct marginalization and state-powered violence.

We’re dressing the wounds the violence of surveillance inflicts.

TAXONOMY OF THREATS

When there's a cast of common threat actors that so often emerge during risk assessment (ideologically motivated harassers, lawmakers, cops, negligent leadership at large tech platforms, etc) there is a level of predictability about their capabilities. We use that information to make knowledgeable risk assessments for those we’re working with, determining the means that threat actors have to cause them harm, as well as the likelihood.

For community organizers and grassroots activists we most often see concerns around doxxing (and harassment driven by OSINT), social media monitoring, content suppression on tech platforms, and insider threats such as infiltration within trusted communication channels. Often this comes with a tension between publicity and privacy—needing to spread their message and further their cause, while recognizing that digital privacy has a profound impact on their personal safety. Some activists may instead hope to organize other more covert forms of direct action. They're more likely to be concerned about the types of street level surveillance that they may encounter.

Small organizations nonprofit and otherwise may share the concerns around doxxing, as well as traditional digital security concerns around their web presence. Website defacement and data exfiltration are particular concerns for organizations that don't have the resources to commit to IT security staff. And for those that do have meager budgets for such things, organizational compliance and ease-of-use regarding privacy and security technologies are a whole other concern. The question then becomes how to manage a system of distributed devices that are uncontrolled by the organization, but operationally necessary for each member of their community. 

Generally speaking, the threats most commonly encountered in these spaces have to do with the opacity and unchecked reach of surveillance systems. With every single individual or group that we encounter in this type of work, threat modeling comes number one in terms of priority. There is no way to protect against every theoretical threat. Instead, we walk others through the process of identifying and then prioritizing known and perceived threats, based on their specific context and the type of work that they do, before moving on to recommended mitigation and resistance strategies. 

STRATEGIES OF RESISTANCE

Developing a threat model without a course of action often does more to stoke privacy nihilism than remedy the risks communities face. The more we engage with at-risk communities and offer reasonable, accessible OPSEC advice, the greater our instinct develops for recognizing such strategies. At the core of these recommendations lie the backbones of privacy and security fundamentals, such as encryption, access controls, sophisticated backup plans, OSINT skills, and resistance to online tracking.

Over the years, we've found it easiest to begin with non-technical recommendations first. These strategies often mesh well with the community's extant organizing procedures, such as designating team roles and thought out contingency plans for specific risks. This may look like identifying those extant plans and tacking on responsibilities like data backups, code words for community vetting, and developing workarounds or contingency plans for if they lose access to specific technologies. 

Eventually, though, the strategies must become more technical, like switching to more private and secure technology alternatives, developing a sophisticated and encrypted data backup plan, and having technical contingency plans in place for if/when they are deplatformed or their services interrupted. Developing patience and compassion when walking groups through unfamiliar technologies is an essential tool of this work. So too is the habit of checking ourselves, as privacy and security nerds, to know the difference between the most secure technologies and those which will actually be used by at-risk community members. Any step towards more thoughtful OPSEC is better than one too difficult to use. The last thing we want is a recommendation that results in people frustratedly giving up on doing anything at all. After all, the whole point of this is to empower movement workers, not inhibit them.

HOLISTIC MITIGATIONS

It is painfully obvious how many identified threats could be protected against if there were comprehensive data privacy legislation protecting all people. The lack of such is an existential threat to everyone. Bills that undermine peoples' right to privacy are never clear about what they're doing, and often come wrapped in some paternalistic guise of addressing some other harm elsewhere. They often use confusing, oblique language that preys on the public's interest to correct the course of other social harms. The reality is that when it’s clearly explained, every person online wants better privacy. And as we know, every individual's personal security and wellbeing are entwined with their access to privacy. The capacity with which a person can decide what to share online, rather than have sensitive information non-consensually taken from them by creepy surveillance technologies, is a matter of self-determination. And it's in all our best interests to fight for the right to self-determination.

WHAT WE GET BACK

An unexpected outcome of identifying so many common threat actors across such varied issue spaces is revealing potential avenues of collaboration and camaraderie. Some movements are already keen on this allyship, such as those focusing on various aspects of bodily autonomy and self-determination. Abortion access activists and trans liberation activists are often in concerted allyship. Other less obvious connections are legal defense groups that offer "know-your-rights" style educational materials and other issue-specific activists who have questions about the legal threats they're facing while fighting for their cause. 

Recognizing the common threat actors across different issue spaces begins to highlight opportunities for collective action against those threats. As a digital rights organization, this is very much our wheelhouse, and precisely why our technologist team is self-described as one working toward the public interest. It’s also from this point of view that we continue to win. And why it’s critical for lawmakers to pay attention when we say particular pieces of bad legislation are harmful to public safety. And finally, why it is necessary for public interest technologists and digital rights activists to connect with other communities to learn about the specific technology risks they’re worried about. As Mariame Kaba says, “Nothing that we do that is worthwhile is done alone.” This very blog post is in an effort to provoke thought for digital security trainers, so that we as a community don’t work atomized and alone, reproducing the same work, exhausting ourselves and creating unnecessary redundancy.

We do what we can to keep up. And thankfully, we participate within an ecosystem of digital security providers that have a keen mind towards fighting for digital rights. We share resources, referrals, and expertise. Our Surveillance Self-Defense project is stress-tested by the experiences shared by the liberation movement workers we engage with and provide this work to. If you’re interested in becoming a digital security resource for your community, start with the SSD. If you’re a human rights defender with questions about how to stay safe, reach out. And if you’re not sure what else to do, you can always help us keep it going.

How Push Notifications Can Betray Your Privacy (and What to Do About It)

A phone’s push notifications can contain a significant amount of information about you, your communications, and what you do throughout the day. They’re important enough to government investigations that Apple and Google now both require a judge’s order to hand details about push notifications over to law enforcement, and even with that requirement Apple shares data on hundreds of users. More recently, we also learned from a 404 Media report that law enforcement forensic extraction tools can unearth the text from deleted notifications, including those from secure messaging tools, like Signal. The good news is that you can mitigate some of this risk. 

There are two points where notifications may betray your privacy: when they’re transmitted over cloud servers and once they land on the device. Let’s start with the cloud. It might seem like push notifications come directly from an app, but they are typically routed through either Apple or Google’s servers first (depending on if you use iOS or Android). According to a letter sent to the Department of Justice by Senator Wyden, the content of those notifications may be visible to Apple and Google, and at the very least the companies collect some metadata about what apps send a notification and when. App providers have to make the decision to hide the content from Apple and Google and implement that functionality; Signal is one app that does this. 

Then, once the notifications land on your phone, depending on your settings, the notification content may be visible on your lock screen without needing to unlock the device. This can be dangerous if you lose your device, someone steals it, or it’s confiscated by law enforcement. 

You may clear notifications after looking at them. But it turns out the content notifications get recorded in your device’s internal storage, which then makes them susceptible to recovery with certain types of forensic tools. Notification content may even persist after the app is deleted, if the OS doesn’t fully purge the app’s notification data. 

We still have a lot of unanswered questions about how the notification databases work on devices. We do not know how long notifications are stored, or whether they’re backed up to the cloud, in which case the cloud provider could get backdoor access to the content of messages if the backups are enabled and not end-to-end encrypted. This may also make backups vulnerable to law enforcement demands for data. 

Which is all to say that there are myriad ways that law enforcement can access the content or metadata of push notifications. Let’s fix that.

Consider the Strongest Notification Protections for Your Secure Messaging Apps

Secure chat tools are designed to keep the content of the messages safe inside the app. So, for secure chat apps like WhatsApp and Signal, that means the company that makes those apps cannot see the content of your messages, and they’re only accessible on your and your recipients’ devices. Once messages land on a device, it’s still important to consider some privacy precautions, particularly with notifications. 

Signal
Signal offers three levels of information to include in notifications, all which are pretty self explanatory:

  • Name, Content, and Actions (Name and message on Android) shows the entirety of a message as well as who sent it (on iPhone you can also slide to reply, mark as read, or call back). 
  • Name only only shows the name of the sender. 
  • No Name or Content (No name or message on Android) will only show that you have a message from Signal, not who sent it or what it’s about. 

To change your settings:

  • On iPhone: Tap your profile picture, then Settings > Notifications > Show.
  • On Android: Tap your profile picture, then Notifications > Show. 

WhatsApp
WhatsApp only has one option for this, and it’s currently limited to iPhone, but you can at least tell the app not to include the content of a message in the notification:

  • Open WhatsApp for iPhone, tap the “You” bar, then Notifications, and disable the Show preview option.

Check your other apps to see if they offer similar settings.

Limit Your Notifications Device-Wide

Since Apple and Google manage push notifications for their respective devices, they also have some visibility into certain data. Push notification data can include certain types of metadata, like which app sent a notification and when, as well as the account ID associated with the phone. In some cases, Apple and Google may have access to unencrypted content, including the content of the text in a notification or other information from the app itself. 

For most app notifications, there’s no simple way to easily figure out what metadata might be gleaned from a notification, or if the notification is unencrypted or not. But some app developers have described details along these lines. For example, Signal president Meredith Whittaker explained on social media how the Signal app handles notifications entirely on-device. Searching online for an app name along with “notification privacy,” “notification encryption” or “notification metadata” may help answer your questions, or you may need to dig around in support forums for the app.

 push notifications for Signal NEVER contain sensitive unencrypted data & do not reveal the contents of any Signal messages or calls-not to Apple, not to Google, not to anyone but you & the people you're talking to. 1/ In Signal, push notifications simply act as a ping that tells the app to wake up. They don't reveal who sent the message or who is calling (not to Apple, Google, or anyone). Notifications are processed entirely on your device. This

It’s also good to reconsider whether any app should be sending you notifications to begin with. Aside from a potential decrease in the number of distractions you endure throughout the day, or the level of chaos on display on your lockscreen, limiting the apps that can send notifications and what content is visible in them can improve your privacy with respect to the sorts of metadata that may be gathered by the companies, as well as any content that may be viewable if someone has physically accessed your device.

To check and change your settings on iPhone

  • Open Settings > Notifications.
  • On the Show Previews option, you can choose whether to show the content of notifications on the lock screen, “Always,” which doesn’t require unlocking the device, “When Unlocked,” which does, and “Never,” which means notifications won’t have any details, just that you have a notification in an app. 
  • Alternatively, you can scroll down and change these settings per app. Just tap the app name, then the Show Previews menu, and choose how you’d like them to appear. Or, if you’ve decided you don’t want notifications from that app at all, uncheck the Allow Notifications option.

To check and change your settings on Android
The core version of Android relies on app developers to develop specific settings more than controlling them on a platform-wide level.

  • Open Settings > Notifications > App notifications to disable notifications from any app completely. Some apps may also offer internal notification options for specific types of notices, like new messages, that you can control in the app itself. Tap an app name, then tap the Addition settings in the app option to potentially customize it more.
  • You can also experiment with the sensitive content setting. This is up to the developer to set properly, but when done so, most notifications will require at least unlocking the device to see them. Open Settings > Notifications > Notifications on lock screen and disable “Show sensitive content.”

Control What Notifications AI Tools Can Access

In an attempt to make notifications easier to skim, both Android and iOS offer optional ways to get notification summaries using their AI tools that summarize the content of notifications. On an individual app level, WhatsApp offers this as well. Some of these summarization tools, like Apple’s, run on the device, while others, like WhatsApp’s, do not. This can all be a lot to keep track of, and sending data off device may create some level of risk for some messages.

Since this is a bit more complicated, we have another blog post that walks through the steps to take to protect messaging from accidentally ending up in AI tools built into Apple and Google's devices. For WhatsApp specifically, we have a blog detailing when you might want to turn on the app’s “Advanced Chat Privacy” feature, which can disable summaries for both yourself and others in the chat.

Balancing security, privacy, and usability with something like push notifications is a complicated task. At the very least, Apple and Google should better ensure that the content of these notifications isn’t transmitted over their servers in plain text. The companies need to also make sure that device operating systems don’t back up the notification database to the cloud, and when an app is deleted, that all notification data is purged.

We appreciate that apps like Signal allow you to control what’s visible with notifications on a per-app basis, and we’d like to see this level of granularity of choices in other secure messaging tools, like WhatsApp. Likewise, more apps should handle push notifications similarly to the way Signal does, where a ping is sent to wake up the app to check for messages, and the content of that message is never sent across servers.

Boating: My Unexpected Fifth Career

8 March 2026 at 19:00

I am pleasantly surprised that my boat experience and captain’s license are paying off with some fun, often challenging gigs.

A lot of folks criticize me for (or are in awe of) the number of “irons I keep in the fire.” Simply said, I have a lot of interests and when something really strikes my fancy, I dive in headfirst and do what I need to do to become an “expert.”

That’s how teaching myself how to use computers in the early 1990s paid off with a career as a computer how-to book author, speaker, and educator, freeing me, once and for all (at age 29), from the 9 to 5 grind of corporate America.

That’s how learning to fly helicopters and eventually jumping through the hoops required to get a charter (AKA Part 135) certificate got me a third career as a helicopter pilot, which started climbing to its peak in 2012, right around the time people stopped buying computer how-to books.

That’s how accumulating cabochons at rock shows led to making jewelry which led to getting good silversmith training and setting up my own fully-equipped studio and making/selling sterling silver jewelry at art shows. When I sold the helicopter and my two helicopter businesses, I really thought silversmithing would be my fourth career (and first retirement career) and I suppose I can still count it as that.

But I never expected my boating activities to lead to paying gigs on both coasts, bringing in retirement income just as silver prices skyrocketed and the economy led to people not spending much money on things they didn’t need. After a dismal winter art show season in Seattle and the Phoenix area, I’ve pretty much set my silversmithing activities aside to better explore this fifth career as a boat captain.

Getting into Boating

What started as me musing, back in 2012, whether it was possible to take a boat on a trip from the Intracoastal Waterway near my mom’s old house in St. Augustine all the way up to the Erie Canal, somehow ending in the Mississippi River and looping back to my starting point in Florida, eventually culminated with me doing that trip, the Great Loop, mostly solo in my own boat. I started in Chicago in October 2022 and ended there in August 2024. (I was still working as a pilot in the summer so I couldn’t do the summer part in 2023.)

I’d been boating on and off most of my life. Back in the summer of 2011, I bought a little jet boat. It wasn’t much and it wasn’t fast, but I eventually took it on outings in the Columbia River, Colorado River, and Lake Pleasant (Arizona).

Jet Boat
My little jetboat was extremely well travelled. In the winter of 2017/18, I took it south with me to Arizona and beyond. This picture was shot at Capitol Reef National Park in October, when I drove through on my way to a side trip in Colorado.

My life got turned upside down in 2012 and I spent the next few years rebuilding it the way I wanted, with a new home and new priorities. I’ll just say this: life is good when you don’t have anyone holding you back from enjoying it. (‘Nuff said, eh, Jim?)

By 2021, I was thinking about that boat trip again. I found a boat captain doing the trip in his 2017 Ranger Tug R-27 who was looking for two crew members. I signed up for a portion of the trip: 8 weeks from Jersey City to Chicago. It was a mostly great experience, although I did clash with the other crew member and wound up leaving the boat after 5 weeks. We traveled up the Hudson River (where I’d boated with my family as a child) through the Erie Canal, and along Lake Erie and Lake Huron. It was great experience.

Ecstasea
I spent five weeks on this Carver with Captain John. Here’s the boat parked at Bald Head Island in North Carolina.

After that trip, I was approached by another boat captain, this time in a 1985 Aft Cabin Carver 35, who was doing the trip at his own pace and needed at least one crew member for at least two weeks. I signed up for 5 weeks, returning home just in time for my summer work. This time we were on the Atlantic Intracoastal Waterway between Charleston SC and New Bern NC. (John cruised at a much slower pace.) Again, it was great experience.

I was almost ready to buy my own boat, planning to do the Loop at my own pace starting in 2024. I had one more season of summer flying to do with my helicopter and then I planned to sell it. But weird stuff happens and I got an offer I couldn’t refuse for the helicopter in May 2022. I’m not an idiot; I sold it. I wound up leasing a helicopter — long and crazy story there — for my summer work.

But that big fat helicopter payment was eating at me, telling me to buy a boat that summer and start the trip sooner. After putting off looking for most of the summer, I finally succumbed and started a search. I found the right boat in August 2022, made an offer, had it accepted contingent on the survey, got it surveyed, and completed the sale just after Labor Day weekend.

Locking Through
Here I am on the command bridge, locking through somewhere. You can almost see Alyse inside on the starboard side of the boat.

What followed was a bit of training, a bunch of days cruising around Puget Sound, and a trip across the US to Chicago where the trucking company I’d hired launched it. My friend Janet joined me for the first 3 weeks on the Loop. My friend Alyse joined me for the second 3 weeks on the Loop. I did a bunch solo and also did about 60 days with my friend Jason and another 3 days with my friend Cheri. This was all over the course of 22 months, with time home to work when I had to.

Becoming a Captain

Along the way, I stopped in Oriental NC to attend a 7-day OUPV captain course. I got my Captain’s License from the USCG in October 2023. I put that license to work in May 2024 in the Baltimore area on two separate training gigs: 3 days for a brand new boater planning to do the Loop solo starting that summer (!!) in his 2015 Ranger Tug R-29 and 1 day with a couple who had stepped up from a pontoon boat to a really nice (and relatively new) Ranger Tug R-29.

If I had to identify one thing that has helped me stay financially secure doing interesting work throughout my life while retaining a healthy work/life balance, it’s my ability to recognize and take advantage of opportunities that come up as they come up. While many people — including too many I know — will make excuses to support why they can’t do something, I look at what I need to do to make things happen.

So while I was on a flotilla with five other boats (all larger than mine) going to Desolation Sound, and one of the owners of the charter company asked if I’d ever considered training people how to drive boats, I not only said yes but told him I had some experience doing it. (He had been impressed that I docked the boat solo at every stop; basically having the boat tied up before his wife hurried over to help.) And then I took the certification classes required to qualify as an instructor for their company. The following spring, I was teaching for them.

I have to admit that the highly structured classes they were teaching to give students American Boating certification was not what I enjoy doing. It was nice to make money while boating with strangers, some of whom were really great people, but I’m not a fan of teaching to the test, especially when the test covers information not in the course material or really not necessary to know. (I’d offer an example here, but I literally tossed out those old tests two days ago when cleaning out my instructor binder.)

Maria & Janet
Here I am with my friend Janet last summer at Blake Island in Puget Sound. Janet joined me for my first three weeks on the Great Loop.

I’d prefer to teach just one or two (a couple) people at a time, focusing on what they need to know to be safe boaters and get started building skills. And that’s what I got to do twice on my own boat last summer. I took a future Ranger Tug owner and his friend on an overnight trip in the San Juan Islands where they could see whether the boat would meet their needs; they stayed in an AirBnB on Orcas Island near Deer Harbor. And I took another future Ranger Tug owner who plans to do the Loop on a four day trip in the San Juan Islands, focusing on soloing skills — which is something the training organizations don’t want me to teach for them. I was tickled pink when he picked up a mooring ball by himself on the first try!

Client Relaxes
Here’s a shot through the windscreen of my client and his friend relaxing on bow seating while we were parked at a marina.

Later that summer, in August, I accompanied a new boater and his friend on his 2024 Antares 11, a twin outboard boat he planned to do the loop in. They had to move the boat from the Florida Panhandle to Jacksonville. We had two weeks to do it and needed almost every day because of engine issues along the way. It was brutally hot and humid in Florida, but the boat had air conditioning in the staterooms so sleeping was tolerable. It wasn’t my favorite Captain gig, but it’s always nice to get out on the water, especially when someone else is picking up the tab.

This Year Is Shaping Up

Fast forward to this year. Things are shaping up nicely. It’s just March and I’ve already done one gig, have two more under contract, and a third penciled in on my calendar. These are all gigs in a client’s boat or in my boat.

In two cases (for the same female client), I got the gig partly because I’m a woman. So that’s a welcome twist.

In the other two cases, the client wants to experience cruising in a Ranger Tug. So although my boat is in a charter program with San Juan Yachting out of Bellingham and used by others when I’m not on board, I have enough time for myself reserved so I can offer a few training cruises in it. I love teaching people how to drive Ranger Tugs, especially in my own boat. I know it so well and am still excited about it, even after 3 1/2 years of ownership. I want to make them excited, too.

And I’m also doing day trips and shorter overnight trips for clients. You can check my boat’s availability calendar here. And, of course, you can charter it for yourself if you meet the charter guest requirements at San Juan Yachting. Or you can charter it and request me as your on-board captain for custom training as you cruise.

The point is, I’m able to do work I love — boating and teaching people how to boat safely — and be paid for it. And I have to admit that the work pays a lot better for the amount of effort than my silversmithing “career,” even though it’s not as creative and personally rewarding. I guess the bottom line is this: doing work as a boat captain pays the bills; doing work as a silversmith/artist pays to do work as a silversmith/artist.

Winter 2026/27?

At this point, I’m leaning hard toward towing my boat back to the Great Loop in mid October or November, probably launching it in the St. Louis area. When I did the Loop, I sped through the southern half of the Inland Waterways in December and the trip was not as good as I think it should have been. I want to do it again and then cruise on to the west coast of Florida, perhaps with another stop in the Keys.

Boat Tow
Heck, I towed it home from Chicago in August 2024. Why not tow it back to St. Louis in October 2026?

The boat would be available for passengers interested in learning more about the Great Loop or Ranger Tugs. Due to the size of the boat and stateroom limitations, I prefer to take solo cruisers, but I could probably make room for a couple. We’ll see.

What I do beyond that really depends on what plans I can make for Summer 2027. Right now, it’s too early to share my thoughts about that.

It’s All about Skills

I just want to end this post with a quick discussion of skills.

I have built multiple careers — some of them very successful — by learning skills and making those skills available to people willing to pay for them.

  • I wrote about computer books for more than 20 years, earning quite a bit of money with my ability to write and to explain how to perform tasks on a computer.
  • I took passengers for hire and did contract work in a helicopter, eventually earning a good living with my ability to fly the way a client needed me to fly.
  • I’ve earned money with my silversmithing skills, although I haven’t had to depend on the income from that endeavor (see the previous two points).
  • I’m earning money with my boating skills, teaching people how to safely maneuver their boat.

I have numerous other skills that serve me well:

  • Computer skills for building websites, creating marketing materials, and making videos.
  • Marketing skills for selling myself and my services.
  • Accounting skills for taking care of my own finances.
  • People skills that recognize the client is always right (even if he’s wrong), among other things.

I don’t learn skills because I plan to turn them into a career. I learn them because they interest me. But being able to monetize them makes it possible for me earn a living doing the things that interest me. In addition to the ones I’ve covered here, I’m also doing things with bookbinding, leather work, carpentry, photography, sewing, and more. I’m interested in a lot of things so I do a lot of things.

I guess the point I’m trying to make is this: building skills can never be a waste of time. You never know when that skill you’ve been honing because you really enjoy the work might be the skill that turns into a lifeboat if your life goes sideways one day.

The Sharp End & Blunt End of Education

3 October 2025 at 11:35

Are you at the Sharp End or the Blunt End?

Most people who’ve been to school (and many who haven’t!) have strong opinions about education. Understandably so – education speaks to how we raise our children, what we value as a society and the kind of world we want to create. Education matters. 

But it also creates a challenge. When you’re teaching, or doing any of the many wonderful roles working directly with students, you find yourself fielding a lot of these opinions about your teaching practice from people who don’t have direct experience of teaching in your context. That’s to be expected. The harder part is that you’re also navigating educational policies and decisions made by people a long way from the classroom. You’re working at what safety scientists call the sharp end. 

The language of sharp end and blunt end comes from safety science (James Reason’s Human Error, Charles Perrow’s Normal Accidents, Sidney Dekker’s Field Guide to Human Error, Rasmussen and others). It’s a way of describing how work happens in complex systems:

  • The sharp end is where the work actually gets done, in direct interaction with people, processes and sometimes hazards. Think nurses and doctors with patients, pilots flying aircraft, engineers fixing equipment.
  • The blunt end is everything that shapes the conditions of that work from a distance – policies, procedures, regulations, leadership decisions, even technology design.
sharp end and blunt end

While those working at the blunt end may well make errors or bad decisions, the consequences of those decisions will often only become visible at the sharp end of work. 

Education as sharp end work

Back when I was teaching, nobody talked about sharp or blunt ends (except perhaps in the context of pencils!). We said things like, “working at the chalk face” or, worse, the militaristic “on the front line.” But the sharp/blunt distinction really does help explain some of what happens in education.

Teachers and teaching assistants are working at the sharp end, with students. At the blunt end are senior leaders, governors, exam boards and politicians shaping the policies and processes that govern classroom life.

And while we rarely consider education as a safety-critical domain, this is probably somewhat naive. Some of my colleagues who work in especially challenging and complex educational contexts will tell you that their work can be hazardous, managing behaviour that could escalate, caring for students with significant needs, or simply coping with the chronic risks of stress and burnout. But even setting that aside, the sharp/blunt distinction matters. Because when decisions at the blunt end are disconnected from the reality of the sharp end, the gap creates unintended consequences.

A marking policy story

By Jade Garratt

Here’s one example. A school leader notices that students’ books haven’t been marked up to date. Instead of asking why, they introduce a new policy: every book must show evidence of marking at least once a fortnight.

What happens next?

  • Teachers extend their working hours just to keep up, leading to stress and burnout.
  • Marking starts happening for show, rather than to genuinely help students learn.
  • Planning time shrinks, and the quality of lessons drops.
  • Some teachers avoid giving written tasks altogether to reduce their marking load.
  • Students get fewer chances to practise writing.

The result is almost the opposite of what was intended. The policy was meant to support learning, but at the sharp end it undermined it.

Jade Garratt

A different approach: operational curiosity

So what could have happened instead? Here’s where Human and Organisational Performance (HOP) thinking is useful. In HOP, we try to become more “operationally curious”: getting closer to the sharp end of work before jumping to solutions.

That might have looked like this:

  • We’ve noticed less written marking than expected – what worries us about that?
  • Could it be that teachers are giving feedback in other ways?
  • If teachers are not giving enough feedback, what’s getting in the way?
  • How do students describe the feedback they get?
  • What do teachers actually do with students’ work once it’s handed in?

With that curiosity, leaders might find that feedback is already happening effectively through conversations, whole-class discussions or verbal comments. They might discover that teachers want to be doing more written marking, but they’re overloaded with planning lessons for a new exam syllabus. Or they could uncover duplication – teachers marking in one way for students and again in another system for accountability – leaving them without the capacity to do either well. Or they may find something else entirely.

The point is that unless we’re genuinely curious (rather than judgemental) about what’s going on at the sharp end, we risk fixing the wrong problem. The real insights come from understanding work as done – not just how we imagine it or how it’s written in policy, but the messy, adaptive and creative ways people at the sharp end actually do their jobs. There is a difference between teaching as imagined, and teaching as done.

And depending what leaders learn from this operational curiosity, the solution could be quite different: giving teachers more time, removing other workload, investing in technology for audio feedback – or perhaps deciding no new policy or action is needed at all.

Why sharp/blunt end thinking matters

The sharp/blunt distinction is a useful metaphor, and can help us see work systemically. It reminds us that what looks like “non-compliance” or “error” at the sharp end is often shaped by the conditions created at the blunt end. And it nudges us to be curious, to go and see, before we act.

And there’s another reason I value this language. Unlike more traditional leadership language, talking about people “at the top” and others “at the bottom,” the sharp/blunt metaphor doesn’t carry that same sense of hierarchy. It’s not about who’s on top, it’s about where you stand in relation to the work. Both vantage points matter, and both are essential to the system working well.

Whatever domain we’re in, we can probably benefit from this lesson: pay attention to both the sharp end and the blunt end, and especially to the gap between them. That’s where valuable learning, and change, can really happen.

Further Reading

Work as Imagined vs Work as Done

Making it safe(r) to fail in teaching

The HOP Core Principles

The post The Sharp End & Blunt End of Education appeared first on Psych Safety.

❌
❌