❌

Normal view

There are new articles available, click to refresh the page.
Before yesterdayMain stream

AI and Psychological Safety

20 October 2026 at 19:07

AI and Psychological Safety

When we opened this research pulse in March, we had some expectations about where we thought it would land. For individuals, especially neurodivergent folks, we expected AI to sometimes make speaking up a little easier; we’ve had many conversations in workshops with folks who have said they use AI tools as a way to rehearse a difficult conversation, or to find the words for something they want to say and aren’t sure how to put. For organisations though, we expected AI might pull us in the opposite direction, with the risk of jobs being replaced by AI and raising expectations about pace and quality of work leaving people feeling more precarious and that they have less room to get things wrong.

We asked three questions: whether you use AI tools at work, how that has affected how psychologically safe you feel with colleagues, and what’s behind your answer. 110 people replied. Some of what people told us matched our hypotheses closely, some of it somewhat complicated them, and one theme turned up that we hadn’t thought to look for at all.

The headline figures

Of the 90 people who use AI at work and answered our main question, the largest group said AI had made no real difference to how safe they feel with colleagues. The rest split in both directions, with about a third feeling safer and about a fifth feeling less safe.

For us, that spread is more interesting than the average. It points to several different experiences sitting side by side, and the comments people left to elaborate on their responses give an indication of what those experiences are.

AI is a place to rehearse

This was the clearest pattern in the comments, and it held up across people who otherwise appeared to have little in common. Those who said AI had made them feel safer mostly described using it to get ready for interacting with a colleague. One person has built meeting simulations and profiles of colleagues they find difficult, and now goes into tense meetings feeling much more prepared. Another asks it for “lines to take” because, in their words, “sometimes in the heat of a conversation I can’t immediately frame what I want to say well.” Someone else gets it to think like their manager and point out what they’re missing. One respondent described the whole cycle: practising emails, being coached through a situation with a colleague before speaking to them and stress-testing ideas before sharing them.

Only one person connected this to neurodivergence directly, explaining that they have ADHD and use AI to practise what they want to say.

All of these examples speak to change that happens in the person rather than in the team. Rehearsal helps us feel more prepared to walk into the room, and perhaps better able to predict what will happen next, even though the room itself, and what happens there when we say the thing, hasn’t changed.

One respondent raised a concern though around what might happen if rehearsal turns into replacement. A colleague had told them they talk things through with an AI chatbot, and this led them to wonder whether people who feel unsafe at work are now working through it with AI instead of raising it with a person, and whether that may leave them feeling more isolated. Rehearsal that leads into the real conversation looks like a potential benefit of using AI, but replacing interaction with AI conversation instead may leave the team less connected, and potentially feeling less safe than before. Interestingly, no one in our research described actually doing this, but the concern was there that others might. 

AI leaves less room to get it wrong

Our second prediction, that AI might make people feel less secure in their roles held up too, though the comments were actually a little more nuanced than we’d anticipated. Very few people who felt less safe said they were frightened of AI itself. What came through instead was a sense that their own value had become harder to see. One person summed it up in a phrase they’d heard from colleagues: “You can use AI for that.” Someone working with developers described the boundary between their roles blurring, so that it was suddenly obvious how little they knew about code, and the power, along with some impatience, now sat with the developers. Others wrote about AI adding strain to existing overload, feeling that it was “yet another thing to learn and be good at, just to prove I can do my job”. In a similar vein, others described feeling pushed into using it, and feeling that it was leading to workplaces where there was “more pressure and less time to think”.

Admitting you don’t know something is one of the everyday risks that a psychologically safe team makes affordable. When AI seems to make those gaps in knowledge less forgivable, and is perceived to be continually raising the bar for performance at work, understandably people are going to find it harder to admit when they don’t know.

One comment pointed to where this might lead: “There’s worry about competence gap, there’s more isolation, more ‘team of one’ than before.” If people respond to feeling exposed by withdrawing, the team loses the conversations that would help everyone work out how best we work with this rapidly evolving technology.

Keeping it to yourself: stigma around AI use

Separate from worries about jobs, a handful of people described AI use as something they keep from colleagues, perhaps because in certain areas it is considered lazy, or even a form of cheating. Someone in academia put it bluntly: “everyone is using AI, but nobody dares admit it. The choice is either to use it and pretend we’re not, or not use it, and be left behind.” Another, also from higher education, said AI can feel like cheating, and wondered whether acknowledging it diminishes their capabilities in the eyes of their team. Given that so much of the discussion in higher education has been around detecting and potentially punishing students for inappropriate AI use, it makes sense that staff would find it hard to say openly that they use it themselves.

A trainer who has seen similar fears play out with e-learning described themselves as a “quiet AI enthusiast”, because their colleagues are scared enough that discussing how to use AI at work doesn’t feel safe. A team leader told us their own position makes it less risky for them to be honest about using AI, while recognising that people in their team seem nervous about saying what they use it for.

This isn’t the case across all teams and organisations, and indeed some respondents described a very different experience. One respondent who felt much safer wrote: “We all use AI in some form and discuss our use openly. We have frameworks to govern how we use it.” Another team treats anything from AI as not fully credible by default, which they said gives them an easy way to start conversations and question assumptions together. 

It seems openness and transparency around use, and guardrails of using AI help to make it a safe conversation. 

The biggest group: no change, for now

The largest single answer was to how AI was affecting people’s psychological safety was “no change”, and the reasons people gave for it fall into two camps. One was the people who are using AI but not in a way which has (yet) impacted on their interactions with colleagues, the things that actually shape psychological safety. One person, for instance, uses AI only as a starter for ideas and then abandons it; others said they’re “still at the experimenting stage” or that it’s early days where they work. For them, AI hasn’t yet reached the part of work that happens between people, so it’s had little chance to change how safe that feels. One respondent also captured the job security angle of this, saying fear of being fired isn’t a threat for them, “yet”.

The second camp said their team was already a safe place to speak up, and AI hadn’t shifted that. One described a very psychologically safe culture where the conversation about AI had been transparent from the start; another said their workplace had given people time in workshops to explore it together. That fits the pattern in the previous section. Where AI arrives into a team that already talks openly, and people are given time and space to explore AI, people can then talk openly about AI too.

Psychological Safety by proxy

Writing in HBR, Jayshree Seth and Amy Edmondson describe what they call safety by proxy: people using AI to surface a concern when they don’t feel safe enough to raise it directly. They argue that when that happens, it tells leaders something about the culture.

Nobody in our survey described passing a concern onto the team through AI in place of saying it themselves, but the person who described their team openly acknowledging the fallibility of AI as an easy way into questioning assumptions hits on an important point. If the idea on the table belongs to the tool and not to a colleague, it can be easier to critique it without worrying about the interpersonal cost. It is easy to see how that may extend to presenting your own ideas or concerns through AI as a way of slightly distancing yourself from them and lowering the perceived interpersonal cost of raising them. 

A group that needs a proxy at the interface before it can disagree is a group where disagreeing directly still feels risky. Safety by proxy might become a rehearsal for the ‘real thing’ of disagreeing person to person. It might just as easily become a more comfortable way to avoid it completely.

What this means for teams and managers

One interpretation of this is that AI amplifies whatever a team already does with uncertainty. Where people can say what they’re trying, what they don’t understand and what worries them, AI becomes one more thing to learn about together. Where they can’t, it becomes one more thing to manage alone.

For managers, that points to a few practical suggestions:

  • Go first. Say how you use AI, including where it has gone wrong for you. The team leader in our survey noticed that seniority made disclosure less risky for them, which makes them the person best placed to take the first step.
  • Make “I don’t know how to do this yet” an ordinary thing to say. The people who felt least safe were the ones who felt exposed by having gaps in their knowledge.
  • Agree how the team uses AI, explicitly. Several of the people who felt safest had shared ground rules, or a shared habit of treating AI output as a starting point for discussion. Shared norms make the space more predictable and therefore (usually) safer.
  • Notice if anyone has gone quiet or appears to be pulling away from the team. If someone has become a “team of one”, ask what’s changed for them.
  • Welcome the rehearsal, whilst encouraging people to make sure the real conversation still happens afterwards.

The most hopeful comment in the whole survey was also one of the shortest. “We all use AI in some form and discuss our use openly.” What matters when it comes to psychological safety perhaps isn’t the use of AI as much as the habit of talking about it; making AI itself a safe topic of conversation. 

About the data

This research pulse ran on an open survey link from 25 March to 6 October 2026, with a sticker-pack prize draw as a thank you. We received 110 responses (97 complete and 13 partial). 96 people said they use AI tools at work, and 90 of them answered the question about psychological safety. Around 60 left a comment.

It’s a small, self-selected sample, and people who already care about psychological safety are more likely to have taken part, so we should read the findings as a snapshot of experiences rather than a measure of how universally common they are. The themes above reflect our reading of the comments. Quotes have been lightly tidied for typos, and we’ve left out anything that might identify the person who wrote them.

Thank you to everyone who took the time to answer, and especially to those who told us what was behind their answer.

Further reading:

What leaders need to know about AI and psychological safety 

Academic integrity has become a pedagogy of suspicion

The post AI and Psychological Safety appeared first on Psych Safety.

Who gets to decide if psychological safety matters?

5 June 2026 at 02:00

Who gets to decide if psychological safety matters?

Is scepticism about psychological safety a luxury position?
What the LinkedIn discourse reveals about who has positive or negative opinions on psychological safety, and why it might matter more than we think.

Psychological safety is one of the most discussed (and critiqued) concepts in the workplace. It generates a vast amount of research papers, conference talks, podcasts, blogs and videos, and an almost continuous stream of LinkedIn posts. But the conversation about psychological safety is also a thing in its own right, distinct from the concept itself. So we wanted to ask who is actually having it, and what do they think?

To do this, we carried out a small exploratory study into the LinkedIn discourse around psychological safety: who is talking about it, what they are saying, and whether patterns emerge around gender and organisational position. 

Executive summary

This exploratory study analysed sentiment in 14 LinkedIn threads discussing psychological safety, covering approximately 170 substantive comments from around 200 unique authors across 12+ countries. We coded sentiment and inferred demographics from names, profile photographs, and job titles.

Three distinct discourse communities emerged: an advocacy stratum, an academic-critical stratum, and an inner circle stratum.

The data directionally supports a privilege hypothesis: scepticism about psychological safety appears to correlate with societal advantage. In regard to professional status, senior academics and executives are the most negative groups; clinical and operational safety professionals are among the most positive. With regard to gender, women are substantially more positive (55%) and less negative (9%) than men (42% positive, 24% negative). The single most over-represented group among negative voices is senior men, who account for 46% of negative comments despite being a much smaller share of the dataset overall.

The most significant finding may be structural: the people most likely to benefit from psychological safety (junior employees, frontline workers, those in genuinely unsafe workplaces) are almost entirely absent from the LinkedIn discourse. The conversation is conducted among the relatively privileged, largely in the absence of the people it is ostensibly about.

Methodology

We manually collected 14 LinkedIn threads in which psychological safety was discussed substantively through March 2026 – the criteria were that there had to be more than 15 comments on it, more than a day old at the time of collecting them, and the posts were not explicitly promotional or commercial. The Linkedin threads were selected to represent a range of post authors, sectors, and audience types. This gave us the best chances of analysing the most substantive posts. 

Some important context to add. I’m a practitioner, researcher and facilitator in the psychological safety field, with an active (though somewhat reluctant) LinkedIn presence including in threads of the type analysed here. I am, in other words, part of what I’m describing. That seemed worth saying out loud: who gets to write a piece about who is having the conversation is itself a question about who is having the conversation. Also, as a practitioner in this space, I sit in the “advocacy” stratum, and by my own hypothesis, that is precisely the stratum most likely to hold positive views about psychological safety. To manage that bias where possible, my own comments have been excluded from the dataset. 

Across the 14 threads we collected approximately 320 comments, of which around 170 were substantive (through excluding tag-only entries, hashtag-only comments, and too-brief affirmations) from around 200 unique authors (after excluding commercial actors – a small number of individuals who used comment threads to promote their own products or services rather than engage substantively). One commercial actor appeared across five separate threads with near-identical promotional content. This itself is an observation that says something about the commercial ecosystem that has grown around psychological safety.

We used Linkedin names, profile photographs, and profile text to infer the various demographics that we’re interested in – gender, seniority and job function. Gender presentation was inferred from typical first name conventions, and profile photos were used to increase confidence. We wanted to look at ethnicity too, and tried name origin as a proxy. However it was, frankly, too crude, even if only treated as directional. So we left it out of the findings. Seniority and function were established from LinkedIn headlines and job titles. We coded comment sentiment into five categories: positive, mixed, negative, contextualising, and affirmation only. Comment sentiment was coded using an AI assistant (Claude, Anthropic), with categories reviewed and verified by the team.

There are some key limitations, of course: LinkedIn itself is a platform of the already relatively privileged. The most marginalised voices (junior employees, frontline and gig-economy workers, manual workers and tradespeople, for example) are much less likely to be on LinkedIn discussing the concept. This is not an incidental limitation. It is, in fact, part of the finding.

Three distinct discourse communities

One of the clearest patterns to emerge was that the LinkedIn psychological safety conversation is not one conversation. It is at least three almost distinct conversations running in parallel, with limited crossover.

The first is an advocacy stratum: these are posts by practitioners, coaches, healthcare workers, HR professionals, organisational leaders and more who are broadly positive about psychological safety and engage with fostering psychological safety as a practical concern. The post authors were predominantly women, and generated little negative sentiment in the comments: negative sentiment was only around 3% of organic comments across these advocacy threads.

The second is an academic-critical stratum: posts by researchers, scholars, and subject matter experts who engage critically with psychological safety – its evidence base, construct validity, and the various claims made about it. This stratum generated a high proportion of mixed and contextualising sentiment, suggesting genuine intellectual engagement and interest in the concept. It also contained the most methodologically rigorous engagement with the concept in the dataset, and several of the critiques raised deserve serious attention. It was also the most negative stratum in the dataset, with approximately 38% of comments expressing critical or negative views. The commenters were predominantly men.

The third is an inner circle stratum: posts by and around the psychological safety field’s most prominent figures: people who have written books and built professional identities around the concept. This stratum, predictably, was almost entirely positive. It generated the highest engagement figures and the least substantive debate. When a concept reaches this mature stage of its life, much of the conversation around it largely functions as a community of agreement, which is neither sinister nor surprising. It is, however, worth noticing.

Three strata, three different conversations, with surprisingly little crossover between them. The advocacy stratum generates warmth, support and agreement. The academic-critical stratum generates intellectual friction. The inner circle generates celebration. It’s the same concept with three almost completely separate conversations. 

It’s worth noting that these strata are descriptive rather than fixed categories – individuals move between them, and occupy more than one at once. We use the framing as a way of seeing the discourse, not as a claim about stable groupings of people.

The privilege hypothesis

Our core research question was whether patterns exist linking gender, ethnicity, and position in the organisational hierarchy (a proxy of positional/formal power) to sentiment about psychological safety. We had a working hypothesis that we considered this data might disprove: 

People who are most sceptical of PS tend to be those for whom speaking up has been, or is, less costly. 

This may be (typically, but not always) men, people from non-marginalised backgrounds, those in secure, senior or tenured positions, and people operating nearer the “blunt” end of organisations rather than the “sharp” end.

The data supports this hypothesis directionally, with some caveats, namely that the demographic categories were inferred rather than self-reported, the sample is small enough that subgroup percentages should be read as indicative rather than precise, and LinkedIn is itself a platform of the relatively privileged – which means the full range of the pattern we’re describing is likely underrepresented in the data rather than overstated. With that in mind, the findings were as follows.

On gender, the pattern was a consistent finding in the dataset. Women were substantially and consistently more positive about psychological safety (approximately 55% positive) and substantially less negative (approximately 9% negative) than men (approximately 42% positive, 24% negative). This gap was widest in the academic-critical stratum, where men were around twice as likely as women to express outright critical or negative views about psychological safety. This is an interesting pattern that supports the privilege hypothesis.

Figure 1: Sentiment by gender. Women and men are roughly equally represented in mixed and contextualising comments; the gap appears almost entirely at the two ends, with women leaning positive and men carrying most of the negative sentiment.

On seniority and positional power, the pattern was the most striking. Using a blunt-end to sharp-end framing borrowed from Human and Organisational Performance (where blunt end describes those furthest from the work, and sharp end those closest) the gradient was very clear. Academics were the most negative group in the dataset at approximately 48% negative. Founders and C-suite executives came next at approximately 20%. In contrast, workers closer to the “Sharp End”, such as clinical NHS staff, operational safety professionals, and frontline practitioners were among the least negative at approximately 6%. 

Figure 2: Sentiment by organisational position. The gradient runs the way the privilege hypothesis predicts: positivity rises and negativity falls as we move from blunt end towards sharp end. 

At least on Linkedin, it appears that the people who are most sceptical of PS tend to be those with the most institutional power. The people who appear most enthusiastic for it are those whose working lives most regularly involve the difficult and precarious dynamics that a lack of psychological safety describes: very hierarchical environments (where they are typically lower) and less agency in rapidly changing, complex, sometimes high-risk, environments.

It is worth acknowledging one obvious objection directly. Is it possible that the negative sentiment groups are simply more knowledgeable about psychological safety, and that their scepticism reflects greater expertise rather than greater privilege? The data can’t rule this out. However, the advocacy stratum contains clinical psychologists, safety scientists, NHS consultants, and human factors specialists: people with deep professional knowledge of the conditions that psychological safety describes. The academic-critical stratum contains organisational psychologists and management researchers whose expertise is in the evidence base, though not necessarily in the lived experience of the concept. These are different kinds of knowledge, and neither outranks the other. A surgeon who has spent twenty years navigating the dynamics of clinical hierarchy understands something about psychological safety that a management professor who has read every paper on it may not. A nurse who has seen a colleague punished for raising a concern knows a lot that a think-piece cannot capture.

The hypothesis is not that critics are ignorant. The hypothesis is that those who engage most critically with psychological safety tend to be people whose professional lives have not required them to test the concept against personal cost – that this shapes which questions feel urgent to them, and which feel abstract. For the people at the sharp end, psychological safety isn’t abstract, it’s very real, and incredibly important.

Figure 3: The composition of positive and negative voices, broken down by gender and seniority. Broadly, women and non-senior people are more likely to feel positively about psychological safety. Senior men make up 11% of positive comments and 46% of negative ones. 

Who isn’t in the conversation

As we mentioned, there is also another angle that the data points towards.

The people that the hypothesis most predicts would be positive about psychological safety: junior employees, frontline workers, and people in genuinely unsafe workplaces, are broadly absent from this dataset. LinkedIn is by its nature a platform of the relatively privileged. A warehouse worker, in one of the threads, described starting a new job and being laid off seven days later. They had heard all the right language about psychological safety from their employer in those seven days and they were one of the very few genuinely front line voices in the entire dataset. Their working life is the kind of life this discourse is supposedly about, but their voice is the kind of voice the discourse mostly doesn’t contain. The people who get hurt by low psychological safety at work are not in this conversation whilst the people who write articles about it (like me) are. The lack of these voices is an important finding in itself.

The popular psychological safety discourse is a conversation among the relatively privileged, conducted almost entirely in the absence of the people it’s ostensibly about.

If scepticism about psychological safety is correlated with more rarely having needed it (as this data suggests), that is not an argument that psychological safety is unimportant, not real, not useful or is invalid. It’s an argument that those doing the most publicly sceptical work are operating from a position of structural advantage that may well be invisible to them. 

Reading the pattern

The data shows that the distribution of sentiment across the LinkedIn psychological safety discourse isn’t random, and that the pattern of who feels positively about psychological safety and who does not correlates with structural characteristics in ways that are hard to explain without reference to lived experience. People who operate in environments where speaking up is potentially higher stakes, such as clinical staff, operational safety professionals, people further down organisational hierarchies, are more consistently positive about psychological safety than those who do not. That pattern is consistent across our Linkedin thread analysis, as well as our previous research on socioeconomic background and willingness to take interpersonal risks at work.

None of this is claiming that sceptics of psychological safety are wrong, or that their critiques lack substance. Some of the most intellectually serious engagement with psychological safety in our dataset came from the academic-critical stratum, and several of those critiques around measurement confounds, misinterpretation and misapplication, and the gap between some claims and evidence are valid critiques and deserve engagement. We often find ourselves saying the same thing as the critics.

Neither is it claiming that being senior and male makes someone’s views on psychological safety invalid.

The privilege hypothesis is one explanation, but not the only one. Several alternatives plausibly account for at least part of the pattern. Academia rewards critique, and the professional incentives of research careers may shape how scholars appear to engage with applied concepts. The advocacy and academic strata may also simply differ in their relationship to the concept: practitioners use psychological safety as a working tool, while academics tend more to study it as a body of literature, and people who use a concept practically tend to be more positive about it than people who study it in the abstract. Some scepticism is also likely an understandable reaction to concept dilution (due to the wellness industrial complex, the LinkedIn thought-leadership ecosystem, and the commercialisation of the term) rather than to the genuine underlying construct. 

We don’t think any of these alternatives entirely displace the privilege hypothesis. The pattern we’ve identified is consistent with several explanations, not just one. What we are confident about is that there is a pattern worth paying attention to, and that the absence of frontline voices from the discourse is significant regardless of which causal story best explains the rest.

Scepticism about psychological safety, then, may be a luxury position. One can afford to question whether psychological safety matters when speaking up has rarely cost you much. 

The question worth asking

What people say about psychological safety on LinkedIn tells us something, but certainly not everything, about what people experience in workplaces. In a subsequent piece, we will explore the different types of scepticism we surfaced: the various distinct critiques, their positions, intellectual grounds, and what psychological safety advocates might learn from them.

For now, the conversation about psychological safety is happening. This isn’t a debate about whether psychological safety is “real” or not – it’s about how much it matters to us. And maybe it matters most to those for whom the stakes are highest – to the people we are least likely to hear from. Which is, of course, the point.

“…the powerful play goes on, and you may contribute a verse.”
Walt Whitman


This research was conducted using publicly available LinkedIn posts and comments. All individuals have been anonymised. Demographics were inferred and should be treated as directional only. 

The post Who gets to decide if psychological safety matters? appeared first on Psych Safety.

How Childhood Socioeconomic Status Shapes Psychological Safety and Career Risk-Taking at Work

27 November 2025 at 10:29

How comparatively well-off we feel as children affects our later appetite for interpersonal risk taking in the workplace.

Authors: Tom Geraghty & Jade Garratt, Psychsafety.com

In our work and experience with teams and organisations all over the world, we always suspected that people’s early experiences, their socioeconomic status in more formative years, and resultant perspective on the workplace, shaped how safe they felt to take interpersonal risks. Those risks include speaking up with an idea or a mistake, as well as putting oneself forward for a high-profile, risky, but potentially rewarding (in a career sense) project. 

Our sense was that people who experienced more financially precarious childhoods may be more likely to feel an innate risk aversion, partly due to learned behaviour, and partly as a result of having less of a  financial safety net if it went wrong. We decided to carry out a survey to explore whether data would support this hypothesis. Our research question was “Do early-life socioeconomic conditions shape interpersonal and career-based risk-taking at work, and does that relationship change with age?”

Executive Summary

To test our hypothesis that there was a relationship between early-life socioeconomic status (SES) and interpersonal and career-based risk taking at work, we carried out a short survey and shared it with newsletter readers, community members, and via social media channels. We asked about respondents’ age, their comparative socioeconomic status through childhood, and two questions about risk in the workplace:

  • One focused on general psychological safety (admitting mistakes, asking for help, etc) and
  • One specifically on taking career risks: putting oneself forward for high visibility and/or high value projects and opportunities. 

The results showed that greater comparative childhood socioeconomic status correlated with higher psychological safety (p=0.185) and opportunity taking (p=0.221) in the workplace. The effect was more pronounced and consistent for opportunity taking than for interpersonal psychological safety and both effects were relatively small (reflecting the myriad antecedents to interpersonal risk appetite in the workplace), but significant. Both effects appear to attenuate with age – suggesting that the advantage conferred by greater socioeconomic status in childhood lessens over time as people build experience, seniority, and accumulated social capital. 

After accounting for age, there’s a positive, statistically significant association between higher childhood SES and feeling safer to speak up and safer to step into high-profile opportunities, and this effect declines over time. Respondents who ranked their childhood SES highly (scores 5–6) consistently reported the highest average safety scores for both interpersonal risks and putting themselves forward for high-profile career opportunities. For instance, the High SES group reported the highest average score for career risk-taking, whilst conversely, individuals reporting a low childhood SES (scores 0–2) showed the lowest average safety scores for both types of risk. Career progression and age appear to offset the disadvantages of a lower socioeconomic starting point.

Qualitative comments reinforce this correlation, suggesting that growing up in comparatively lower SES contexts taught people that there was “much more at stake” for them in the workplace. 

Cite as: Garratt, J., Geraghty, T. (2025) How Childhood Socioeconomic Conditions Shape Psychological Safety and Career Risk-Taking at Work. psychsafety.com. Available at: 

Why Socioeconomic Status Matters

Psychological safety: “the belief that one can speak up with ideas, questions, concerns or mistakes, and the team is safe for interpersonal risk taking” (Edmondson, 1999), is a prerequisite for collective learning, innovation, and workplace safety. Yet psychological safety is not evenly distributed – the interpersonal stakes are higher for some than others. Early-life socioeconomic conditions shape beliefs and expectations about what happens when you take risks: greater childhood deprivation generally predicts greater risk-aversion in economic games (Amir et al, 2018). These early conditions strongly influence our internalised beliefs about whose voice matters, who sounds more credible, who has safety nets if things don’t go to plan, and who must shoulder the higher perceived downsides of risk.

For those more accustomed to precarity in their formative years, limited family income, reduced access to professional networks, and smaller or non-existent financial safety nets, it makes sense that the voice calculus tilts toward greater caution. It’s unsurprising that this effect is exacerbated in status-visible contexts, such as presenting to senior leaders or putting oneself forward for high-profile and or high risk/high value projects. In contrast, more socioeconomically advantaged backgrounds may confer confidence, a sense of belonging, greater access to professional networks, workplace language fluency, and financial safety nets that lower the perceived cost of taking career and interpersonal risks at work.

Methodology

  • Design & audience. We carried out an online cross-sectional survey, distributed via email to Psych Safety newsletter subscribers and through social channels (from 6–31 October 2025). This was a diverse and international sample, across a wide range of sectors and roles. We received 375 responses in total.
  • Key questions (0–6 scales).
    • Childhood comparative socioeconomic status (SES): “Thinking about your childhood (up to 18 yrs), what was your family’s overall social & economic position compared with others in your country? – If all the families in a country lined up in order of socioeconomic status, where would your family be in that line?”
      • Note on rationale: Marmot’s work in public health shows that it’s not absolute SES that matters – it’s the comparative “social gradient” that most affects our ability to take part effectively in society.
    • Interpersonal psychological safety: “How safe do you feel taking interpersonal risks (e.g., disagreeing with a colleague, admitting a mistake or raising a concern) in the workplace?”
    • Attitude towards opportunity-taking: “When high-profile, higher-risk opportunities arise (e.g., cross-team projects with senior visibility), how safe do you feel putting yourself forward?”
    • Age (bands): Under 20; 20–30; 30–40; 40–50; 50–60; 60–70; 70+. (Converted to approximate midpoints for modeling.)
    • Open text for qualitative comments: “Is there anything you would like to add or comment on?”

Consent/Ethics: Participation was voluntary; and no personally identifying information was collected other than email addresses when offered in order to follow up.

Key Results

1) Childhood SES is linked to interpersonal and career risk appetite in the workplace.

Higher childhood SES is associated with greater felt safety for both:

  • Interpersonal psychological safety (p=0.185): everyday risk behaviours such as disagreeing, suggesting ideas, admitting mistakes, and raising concerns; and
  • Opportunity-taking (p=0.221): volunteering for high-profile projects or visible roles that carry reputational or job-role stakes.

These findings suggest that early-life socioeconomic advantages generalise into lower perceived costs for taking interpersonal risks in the workplace. 

Figure 1: The effect of comparative childhood SES on workplace psychological safety and opportunity-taking safety (linear regression plot). Both psychological safety and workplace opportunity taking behaviour positively correlate with childhood comparative SES.

Figure 1: The effect of comparative childhood SES on workplace psychological safety and opportunity-taking safety (linear regression plot). Both psychological safety and workplace opportunity taking behaviour positively correlate with childhood comparative SES.

2) Opportunity-taking is more SES-sensitive than Psychological Safety

The SES link tends to be stronger for workplace opportunity-taking than for generalised interpersonal safety. This is likely because career opportunities also present risks – if a high value and/or high-visibility project fails, it can damage our reputation or increase the risk of losing our job. For people accustomed to smaller safety nets and a greater sense of financial precarity, these risks may seem not worth the potential payoff. Conversely, for those with a greater safety net and stronger professional networks, the risk of losing a job, or hunting for a new one with a different organisation, may pose lower risk, and thus lower fear.3) Age Attenuates the SES Effect

The SES advantage is largest earlier in our career and declines across adulthood. Figure 2 shows age-stratified correlations show the strongest SES influence (shown in the chart as gradients – with a steeper gradient representing a stronger effect) under 35 years (orange), a flatter gradient 35–50 (blue), and the flattest (with a generally higher risk taking stance overall) at 50+ years (green). 

Figure 2: SES effect on Opportunity Taking, by age

Figure 2: SES effect on Opportunity Taking, by age. The steeper the gradient, the stronger the effect of childhood SES on workplace opportunity taking behaviour. (Download the Python scripts to create these charts here)

In other words, as we age, our early-life financial status appears to have less impact. We interpret this correlation to suggest that tenure, seniority, increasing social capital and financial stability mitigate early-life disadvantages of lower SES. As one participant shared:

“My confidence to take interpersonal risks when I first joined this organization… was much lower. As someone from a solidly middle class background with limited education (college graduate) I did not feel safe to speak up among my highly educated upper class associates. Thankfully, 7 years later that is beginning to change.”
[Note: “college” in the UK refers to post-school education, but is not university – what college may refer to in the US)

For opportunity-taking, the SES gradient persists longer than fundamental psychological safety, which is consistent with our hypothesis that workplace visibility keeps perceived career stakes high and our childhood experience permanently shapes our perception of the workplace. Another participant interpreted this as:

“I think people from a lower socio-economic status tend not to take as much risk because in their history there has been so much more at stake for them. There would have been no rescue or hand-out, it would have been all or nothing.”

Figure 3: Strength of SES effect over time. As we age and gain experience, status and workplace collateral, our early life experiences still matter, but their influence is less over time. The wider 95% confidence intervals at each end represent fewer survey responses.

Figure 3: Strength of SES effect over time. As we age and gain experience, status and workplace collateral, our early life experiences still matter, but their influence is less over time. The wider 95% confidence intervals at each end represent fewer survey responses.

Qualitative Depth

While the quantitative data revealed clear patterns in how socio-economic background correlates to perceived interpersonal and career risk, the numbers could only tell part of the story. To understand why these patterns exist, and how they feel in people’s lived experience, we invited participants to share their additional comments and reflections with us, which many did. The qualitative comments added nuance to the data, revealing how people make sense of safety, risk, and belonging at work through the lens of their own histories.

Socio-economic background during childhood can play a part in that story, but it rarely stands alone. As one person wrote, “My feelings are more influenced by my gender than my background,” while another acknowledged, “What also helps with my sense of safety is I fall into a category that has the safety net of being white. Makes a huge difference here (in the US).” For others, family dynamics, health, and personal temperament were just as important: “Highly dysfunctional family dynamic might have had a bigger influence than the socio-economic background,” one participant reflected. Several emphasised the role of context: “The work environment matters too. The cultural norms, direct supervisor, and relationships with colleagues.” Together, these stories show how layered and interdependent these factors are. They remind us that when we look at workplace risk-taking, we’re really looking at the meeting point of many personal and systemic histories.

Many respondents expressed gratitude that we are exploring this dimension at all: “chuffed to bits that you’re asking these questions,” wrote one; another said they were “so grateful that you’re digging into this – socioeconomic background in a workplace environment is a topic that needs more attention.” This encouragement perhaps reflects how seldom class and socio-economic experience are explicitly recognised in organisational conversations about psychological safety and inclusion. 

A number of participants drew attention to the quiet but persistent ways that privilege or deprivation shape confidence and opportunity. “I see a certain difference in self-confidence among peers who grew up in better conditions; they are more enterprising and slightly more self-confident,” wrote one, while another noted, “My race, class, country and education mean that I have a significant safety net — I’ve been able to fail many times and still be safe.” For some, early disadvantage became a source of motivation or moral clarity: “I used my harder environment to gain confidence by committing to not letting that hold me back.” Yet, as others described, this process of self-creation often takes years — one participant reflected:

 “It took years for me to create safety for myself. Even now I wonder if it was the effects of poverty, neurodivergence, both?”

Across responses, age and experience emerged as powerful moderators. People repeatedly described how confidence and a sense of safety grew with time: “This has certainly improved with age and job experience,” and “With age, I have become more willing to ‘go out on a limb’ and push boundaries.” Some connected this to accumulated expertise, others to a more settled sense of identity. But this was not universal. One woman nearing retirement wrote that she still felt “worried about the impact of raising [her] profile in the workplace.” 

Ultimately, what emerges from these comments is not a single narrative but a web of intersecting influences – including wealth, class, gender, race, health, family, leadership, culture and time. Each contributes to how much psychological safety we feel, and how much risk we feel that we can afford to take. 

Implications

What does this mean for practice? 

Firstly, the data makes it clear that if we simply demand that people “speak up”, “be courageous”, and adopt a “psychological bravery” stance, it won’t be enough. In fact, such approaches may even deepen existing inequalities. If people’s willingness to take interpersonal or career risks is associated with their socioeconomic background, exhortations to be braver can inadvertently privilege those who already feel safer taking those risks.

Secondly, the finding that SES appears to have a relationship with both interpersonal and career risk taking at work suggests that the effects of SES background may persist and even compound over generations. Higher SES in childhood may endow people with a greater ability to navigate and take advantage of workplace opportunities, furthering their careers and reinforcing their socioeconomic position – for both themselves and their families. Conversely, those from lower SES may be held back from taking advantage of workplace opportunities, reducing their ability to build stronger SES for their family, and perpetuating the cycle over generations.

Even if we were to disregard any societal or ethical basis for addressing inequality, there is a clear organisational case for doing so. Leaders who fail to recognise and mitigate the SES effect may overlook capable, talented people who simply feel less safe putting themselves forward. By creating environments that reduce the risk associated with speaking up or stepping up, organisations can tap into a broader and more diverse pool of skills and insights, ultimately leading to stronger performance as well as more equitable outcomes.

What Leaders Can Do To Address the SES Effect

This research suggests that how safe people feel to take risks – whether interpersonal or career-related – is about what people bring with them as well as what happens at work. And while leaders can’t change someone’s past, they can shape the present conditions that make risk-taking feel possible.

1) Open up access to ‘stretch’ work

Many workplace opportunities still depend on people putting themselves forward, and these “opt-in to opportunity” systems in the workplace favour those already confident, or financially secure enough to take a chance. As one participant reflected, the ability to take career risks often comes from “having a safety net.” 

To counter this, leaders can make opportunities more transparent and less dependent on self-nomination. Advertise internal projects openly, invite peer nominations and ensure sponsorship and mentoring aren’t reserved for the well-connected. When someone is unsure whether they “belong” in those spaces, a personal invitation can make all the difference.

2) Reduce ambiguity costs, especially for early-career employees

Ambiguity comes at a cost, especially for those without insider knowledge or access to informal networks. Several participants described how much easier it felt to take risks once they understood the rules of the workplace game. Leaders can help by offering short pre-briefs, co-presenting options, or rehearsal time for those stepping into more visible roles. Be explicit about how decisions are made and what success looks like. For people from lower socio-economic backgrounds, the perceived risk of failure may be far higher than the reality: extra clarity and reassurance can help close the gap.

3) Track equity in advancement opportunities

Use engagement surveys and feedback from employees and leaders regarding who speaks up, who gets stretch work, and who takes on highly visible projects, to notice whose voices are heard and whose potential is recognised. If you can, cross-reference this with age/seniority and, where appropriate, class-origin indicators such as first-generation university attendance. 

Are stretch projects, visibility, and promotions evenly distributed, or concentrated among those already buffered by privilege? Pair quantitative measures with qualitative listening, such as open comment boxes, focus groups or one-to-one conversations to understand the lived experience behind the numbers. If patterns emerge, treat them not as individual shortcomings but as signals that the system itself may need redesigning to enable broader and more equitable opportunities and risk-taking.

As one participant beautifully put it: 

“If you never learned that your presence in the world matters, then showing up in that world feels very risky.” 

The work of leadership, then, is to create environments where presence itself feels valued and where people can take risks not because they’ve always known they matter, but because the organisation shows them, day after day, that they do. Building psychological safety through a socio-economic lens is, in a practical sense, about widening the circle of who gets to step forward, speak up and be heard.

“…redistributive policies are needed to break the cycle of deprivation that limits opportunities and threatens social cohesion.” (Manstead, 2018)

Future Research

This was a cross-sectional survey, and shows correlation, not causation. Further longitudinal research would aim to establish causation, and the mechanisms thereof. It would also be interesting to study the intersectionality of this effect – to examine compounding and buffering by some of the additional factors participants recognised as important to them: gender, sexuality, ethnicity, neurodiversity and disability, first-gen university, and national culture. 

Conclusion

Workplaces inherit the social gradient. Our research suggests that comparative childhood socioeconomic status (SES) shapes the perceived cost of speaking up and putting oneself forward, especially early in careers, yet this gap narrows with age.

To foster environments where everyone can contribute fully, organisations need to recognise that the perceived risks of speaking up or putting yourself forward for a career opportunity are higher for some than others. These perceptions are formed from our childhood experiences and sense of where we belong in society and our comparative socioeconomic security.

Appendix

The raw data is available here to run your own analyses. Qualitative data has been removed to protect respondents’ identities. Please reference and cite appropriately.

References

Amir, D., Jordan, M.R. and Rand, D.G., 2018. An uncertainty management perspective on long-run impacts of adversity: The influence of childhood socioeconomic status on risk, time, and social preferences. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 79, pp.217-226.

Detert, J.R. and Burris, E.R., 2007. Leadership behavior and employee voice: Is the door really open?. Academy of management journal, 50(4), pp.869-884.

Edmondson, A., 1999. Psychological Safety and Learning Behavior in Work Teams Amy Edmondson. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(2), pp.350-383.

Manstead, A.S., 2018. The psychology of social class: How socioeconomic status impacts thought, feelings, and behaviour. British Journal of Social Psychology, 57(2), pp.267-291.

Marmot MG. Understanding social inequalities in health. Perspect Biol Med. 2003 Summer;46(3 Suppl):S9-23. PMID: 14563071.

The post How Childhood Socioeconomic Status Shapes Psychological Safety and Career Risk-Taking at Work appeared first on Psych Safety.

❌
❌