❌

Normal view

There are new articles available, click to refresh the page.
Before yesterdayMain stream

The AI Con

29 November 2025 at 17:57

Some thoughts on a recently read book — and “AI” in general.

The AI Con (book cover)

I just “read” The AI Con: How to Fight Big Tech’s Hype and Create the Future We Want by Emily M Bender and Alex Hanna. I put “read” in quotes because I got it from the library as an audiobook and listened to it as I was making my long annual drive south. It wasn’t a long book — just 8 hours in audio format — and there was some repetition, but it was a good read. I highly recommend it, especially if you believe that true artificial intelligence currently exists and it is making our world better. (Spoiler alert: real AI doesn’t currently exist — at least not at the average user level — and what is being pushed as AI is failing miserably at making most things better.)

The authors take great pains to explain that what a lot of what’s being sold as artificial intelligence (AI) is nothing more than a generative large language model (LLM). Their explanation of exactly what an LLM is and how it works is thorough, clear, and easy to understand. Generative LLMs are designed to create text that seems like it could be right. They don’t think or reason and they’re just as likely to make things up as they are to pull facts from a reliable reference. They just string words together. There’s nothing intelligent about them.

They also talk about the history of machine learning, which is what AI proponents are trying to say today’s AI is:

There are applications of machine learning that are well scoped, well tested, and involve appropriate training data such that they deserve their place among the tools we use on a regular basis. These include such everyday things as spell-checkers (no longer simple dictionary look-ups, but able to flag real words used incorrectly) and other more specialized technologies like image processing used by radiologists to determine which parts of a scan or X-ray require the most scrutiny.

But in the cacophony of marketing and startup pitches, these sensible use cases are swamped by promises of machines that can effectively do magic, leading users to rely on them for information, decision-making, or cost savings—often to their detriment or to the detriment of others.

That’s the AI con of the title — AI “boosters” are trying to sell today’s AI as something it is not.

The authors refer to generative AI as “synthetic media machines” and remind readers that these systems are trained on mostly copyrighted text and images, usually accessed without the permission of the copyright holders or creators. Responding to user prompts, they basically regurgitate source content to create new versions of it. With the right prompts, however, they can be made to spit out exact copies of the source material, thus removing any “fair use” argument the promoters of these systems might try to use to defend their outright theft of material.

As I read through the book, I felt as if they were preaching to the choir. My feelings about AI are pretty much identical to theirs. I’m seeing the reality of what it is, what it can do, and what it can’t do. I’m perpetually annoyed by the spread of AI slop and the way the general public seems so willing to accept it — if not generate it. The hype — and the fact that investors and politicians are buying into it to the detriment of our world — enrages me.

The book has the following chapters, each of which are full of sometimes horrifying examples:

Chapter 1: An Introduction to AI Hype
Chapter 2: It’s Alive! The Hype of Thinking Machines
Chapter 3: Leisure for Me, Gig Work for Thee: AI Hype at Work
Chapter 4: If it Quacks Like a Doc: AI Hype and Social Services
Chapter 5: Artifice of Intelligence? AI Hype in Art, Journalism, and Science
Chapter 6: I’m Sorry, Dave, I’m Afraid I Can’t Do That: AI Doomers, AI Boosters, and Why None of That Makes Sense
Chapter 7: Do You Believe in Hope after Hype?

Again, I recommend the book. If you already feel as I do about AI, you’ll likely come away with more examples of why we should be outraged about its hype. If you, for some reason, have fallen for the hype, it will educate you about the reality of the situation. The only people really benefiting from today’s version of AI are the boosters stuffing their pockets with investor money.

My Anthropic Copyright Claim

2 October 2025 at 18:01

I file my claim in the Anthropic copyright case — and sit back to wait for the results.

I wrote about the Anthropic copyright case in three blog posts here, so I’m not going to go into the details again. If you want to get up to speed on my thoughts, read these:

My Claim

My infringed work
This is the official list of my work that Anthropic illegally accessed, violating copyright law.

The case went back and forth and it seemed for a while that the $3,000 per title settlement was not going to be accepted. But then it was and recently the legal team handling the claims for copyright holders including authors like me published the definitive list of infringed works. I used the lookup feature and found nine of my books.

Of the nine, two were registered under the name of the publisher, McGraw-Hill. The rest were registered under my name.

I clicked the link to file a claim, which is required if I expect any compensation for their theft of my work. The form was time consuming to complete — it took me nearly an hour to add all nine titles. And yes, I added all nine because maybe there is a chance that I’ll get some of the proceeds for titles not registered with me as the actual copyright holder.

Theoretically, I should be entitled to $21K to $27K of compensation. I’m not sure if the lawyers’ fees come out before or after this payment. For all I know, I might only get $100/title. But I also know that I won’t get anything if I don’t submit a claim.

I’ve done my part; now I have to wait and see.

Further Thoughts

My thoughts on this matter are pretty straightforward. No person or organization should be allowed to access and use copyrighted work without going through legal channels to do so. Anthropic committed piracy; that’s accepted and is the reason they’re paying up. But did they get permission to use the works to train an AI system? Clearly, they did not. That’s the real reason they should be paying.

I’m in a weird situation. In my mind, these books were dead. They cover topics that are no longer current and have very little (if any) value. I never expected to see another dime in compensation for writing them. So this is all icing on a cake I’ve already eaten. I’ll take it!

But what of the people whose work still has legitimate current value? Or of future books I might write that don’t go out of print in 2 years? How often will our work be used without our permission to train systems designed to replace us?

I’ve got a real problem with that — and you should, too.

Copyright Basics

10 September 2025 at 14:00

The correct answers to your questions are pretty easy to find if you just look.

Making Trouble on Mastodon
Here’s my exchange with an angry self-published author. I’m not surprised that he’s blaming someone else for his problem; that seems to be a big trend these days.

Yesterday, I wrote an update to my August blog post about the Anthropic copyright case. In it, I mentioned that in order for a title to be included, it must be listed in the database of books Anthropic illegally obtained and used to train their AI and have its copyright registered with the US Copyright Office.

Apparently, it’s this second qualification that has a lot of authors freaking out — especially self-published authors. This came to light when I replied to an Ars Technica post on Mastodon — the same one I linked to in yesterday’s post. Yes, I was being flip, but I was also being honest. As someone who has books that qualify, I’ll definitely settle for $3,000 per qualifying title.

Apparently a lot of self-published authors have books that were illegally used by Anthropic but because they never bothered to register copyright of their work, they’re not eligible to receive compensation under this settlement. And they’re pissed.

As this angry self-published author stated:

I consider the qualifying rules too restrictive, in a legal culture in which the vast majority of self-published authors are told by their publishing platform, “A copyright declaration in your book is sufficient to guarantee all of your legal rights.”

(And, by the way, I’ve blurred his identity here because I don’t want to embarrass him. If he wants to take credit for his words here, he should let me know and I’ll share an unblurred image. He should understand that anything we write on social media can be excerpted for fair use.)

So basically, he (and others) are told by their “publishing platform” — Amazon and others I’m not familiar with because I don’t self publish that way — that they don’t need to register their work with the US Copyright Office to be protected. I’m not sure how true that is, but he sure seems to believe it.

But the facts about this are easy to find on the most obvious resource of copyright information: the US Copyright Office website. It took me less than 2 minutes to find this page, which clearly states how a work is copyrighted and the benefits of copyright registration (emphasis added):

When is my work protected?
Your work is under copyright protection the moment it is created and fixed in a tangible form that it is perceptible either directly or with the aid of a machine or device.

Do I have to register with your office to be protected?
No. In general, registration is voluntary. Copyright exists from the moment the work is created. (You will have to register, however, if you wish to bring a lawsuit for infringement of a U.S. work. See Circular 1, Copyright Basics, section “Copyright Registration.”

Why should I register my work if copyright protection is automatic?
Registration is recommended for a number of reasons. Many choose to register their works because they wish to have the facts of their copyright on the public record and have a certificate of registration. Registered works may be eligible for statutory damages and attorney’s fees in successful litigation. Finally, if registration occurs within five years of publication, it is considered prima facie evidence in a court of law. See Circular 1, Copyright Basics, section “Copyright Registration” and Circular 38b, Highlights of Copyright Amendments Contained in the Uruguay Round Agreements Act (URAA), on non-U.S. works.

So I ask you this: who would you believe when you ask whether copyright registration is required? The company eager to make money off of your hard work or the government organization that provides official information about copyright law and helps to enforce that law?

I’m fortunate. My publishers registered copyright in my work for me, although not all of them registered my work in my name. (I’m not sure if they’ll get the money for those books or I will, but I’m not being greedy here; what’s a few thousand more when I’m looking at a $30K payday I never expected?) I’ve self-published a handful of books and did not register them. They are not listed among the stolen works.

But I have learned a valuable lesson here and will register copyright for all of my books in the future. I suspect we’ll have more of these cases and I want to be protected on a go-forward basis.

If you’re a writer who plans to publish your work, I highly recommend you register copyright for it.

Is Any Book Really Dead These Days?

9 September 2025 at 19:21

Good news and bad news about that copyright lawsuit I’m part of.

Since writing a post last month about my participation in the huge copyright lawsuit against Anthropic, there have been a few developments.

The Good News

First, a settlement was reached between the plaintiffs and Anthropic. A big settlement: $1.5 billion to be paid to affected authors. This came out to $3,000 per infringed work. Whoa.

Partial Copyright List
Here’s part of the first page of my copyright registrations.

To qualify, the work needed to not only be on the list I mentioned and searched for that post, but registered with the Copyright Office. If you recall, I had 16 titles on the list. I hurried over to the US Copyright Public Records System and did a search for my name. I came up with a list of 91 records, more than half of which were for my books. I was very pleased to see that Peachpit Press registered my titles in my name, although McGraw-Hill, Sybex, and O’Reilly did not. Still, at least 10 of the titles on the first list were registered in my name. (I did not bother to cross-reference the two lists, although I might do so later.)

So it looked to me as if I might be able to pull in at least $30,000 on this case.

Holy crap.

I’ve been part of class actions before and I think the most I’ve ever gotten was about $130, which was for an Apple keyboard issue I barely remembered. But this — well, this was real money.

The Bad News

Just when I was starting to think of how I would spend this little windfall, the bad news broke: The judge overseeing the Anthropic case rejected the settlement.

Alsup [the judge] expressed grave concerns that lawyers rushed the deal, which he said now risks being shoved “down the throat of authors,” Bloomberg Law reported.

Well, this is something I don’t mind being shoved down my throat.

Look at it from my point of view: I wrote how-to books about using computers. The vast majority of them had a “shelf life” of less than a year. That means royalty income for each title lasted about a year — if the book even earned out. I had to keep writing them to keep earning a living. That’s why I wrote more than 80 of them between 1991 and 2012.

To me — and probably everyone other than a greedy and mindless AI consumer — these books were dead. No one was buying them — heck, I assume all inventories were destroyed. I could not expect any more income from them. In most cases, I couldn’t even use part of them as the basis for an updated book about the same topic. Some of the software I wrote about doesn’t even exist anymore.

The thought of earning $3,000 per title on these dead books is pretty appealing. Knowing that Anthropic isn’t the only AI copyright infringer out there and that its settlement could be the first of many that benefit me is even more appealing.

But the judge put the brakes on the deal and threw everything back to the parties.

As you can imagine, I’ll try to stay involved in this process to make sure I’m on any list out there. I just hope it doesn’t drag on too long.

And a lesson to writers…

Intellectual property is a real thing that deserves protection. It is the fruit of your labor. Whether your book sells three copies or a million, it has real value. And who knows? It could end up on a list that earns you $3,000 (or more) when AI companies are brought to court.

Register your copyrights. Go to the Registration Portal on the US Copyright website and follow the links and instructions to register all of your work. Yes, it’s copyrighted without registration, but it’s only really protected when it’s registered.

Fighting Against AI Copyright Theft

28 August 2025 at 13:49

I join the class action suit against Anthropic for the use of text in 16 of my books to train their AI without permission or compensation.

I didn’t expect to spend part of my morning filling in a form on a lawyer’s website to provide information about myself and the books Anthropic apparently used to train their AI. After all, I haven’t written much in the past 10 years and all of what I’d written before then was about using computers. Surely all of those books were so sorely out of date that even an AI wouldn’t be interested in them.

But here I am.

I’d heard about the lawsuit:

Bartz v. Anthropic PBC is a class action lawsuit under the Copyright Act brought by authors on behalf of copyright holders against Anthropic PBC, an AI company. The Class of copyright holders — consisting of authors and publishers – claims that Anthropic took books from pirate websites Library Genesis (“LibGen”) and Pirate Library Mirror (“PiLiMi”) without authorization.

The Court recently certified a LibGen & PiLiMi Pirated Books Class made up of all legal or beneficial owners of the exclusive right to reproduce any ISBN- or ASIN-bearing book that Anthropic copied from the two pirate sites. The Class’s claims are scheduled for trial on December 1, 2025.

The latest update to that is that the parties have apparently settled and money will be paid out to the 7 million authors affected by the theft. You can read about that in an article on Ars Technica.

Toot about Books that Trained AI
This toot jump started this morning’s efforts to get myself on the list of authors affected by Anthropic’s theft of my copyrighted work.

I knew that the lawyers were looking for affected authors but didn’t do anything about it because I didn’t think I was an affected author. (See above.) But then Dave Mark on Mastodon posted a toot with a link to an Australian Website that had a link to an Atlantic website page with a tool for searching which books were used to train the AI. And yes, 16 of my books (plus some repetitions) were on it.

So I tracked down the article about it on the Author’s Guild website and clicked the big button to provide my contact information. That put me on the lawyers’ website where I could provide my contact info and list all 16 titles.

I’m done now and can get on with my day. I don’t expect to get much from this, but I do think it’s important that authors stand up for their rights — especially when money- and resource-hogging for-profit organizations are stealing our work to build systems to replace us.

If you’ve written any books in the past 20 years, I urge you to see if you’re on the list and take action if you are. Theft of our work has to stop. Let’s work together to protect our work and our livelihoods.

❌
❌