❌

Normal view

There are new articles available, click to refresh the page.
Before yesterdayMain stream

Scottish Web Folk 2026: UX team reflections

11 November 2026 at 10:24

With others from the Website and Communications team, Nick and Mel headed up to Dundee to attend the Scottish Web Folk conference. In this post, they share their reflections on the day.

Nick’s reflections 

This was my fourth trip to Dundee for the Scottish Web Folk conference and my third time presenting. Scottish Web Folk is a great chance to hear from people working in digital roles in higher education, and catch up with how people across the sector are approaching similar challenges. 

We presented about optimising content for AI summaries 

This year, Mel Batcharj, Katie Spearman and I presented about AI summaries, such as the ‘AI Overview’ that Google now presents at the top of a search results page. These summaries take information from our websites and repackage it for users, who in some cases no longer click through to the websites themselves. 

In our presentation, we talked about how to create content that is optimised for these summaries, and how we created a Content Improvement Club session to address this topic. 

We emphasised that much of the guidance for creating content optimised for search engines hasn’t completely changed in the age of AI. It’s still important to write clear, structured content that addresses user needs and presents people with the information they need to take their next step. It’s also still the case that following good  digital accessibility practices will help AI tools and search engines to process the information included in your content. 

Read Katie’s write-up of our  Content Improvement Club training session ‘Is your content AI ready?’ 

Speakers discussed the theme of ‘Human versus machine’ 

There were various talks looking at how we can use AI to support and inform our work with websites in higher education. 

In the panel discussion, Marta Krukowska (Web and Digital Manager at Bangor University) described her experiments with using AI tools to interview colleagues to gather information for course pages. If asked to describe their course, colleagues sometimes provided vague information. For example, they might talk about how the university provides access to “state-of-the-art facilities”. But the AI interviewer could push back and ask for the names of specific facilities, and what their availability means for students. This turned out to be a more efficient way to get the information needed to write marketing copy for a course. 

The panel also addressed questions of how prospective students are using AI tools to support their search for a university course. The discussion made me reflect on how difficult it can be to identify a starting point for a complex user journey like this. It’s easy to fall into the trap of thinking that a user journey is a linear process or a series of steps, but this frequently isn’t the case. When people are thinking about what they want to study and where they want to study it, there are typically a wide range of information sources feeding into that decision. The information is coming in from these disparate sources over a broad period of time. So it’s probably not accurate to say that the journey starts with an AI search, even if that forms part of the information environment that a prospective student is using. 

The Prospective Student Web team presented about their content playbook and how they’re appraising degree finder 

Two presentations I particularly enjoyed during the day were from our Edinburgh colleagues Lauren Tormey and Pete Watson. 

Lauren was presenting about how her team had put together a content playbook: a set of patterns that staff can follow when working with content. The playbook helps content designers to take a consistent approach when using page elements such as feature boxes, pull quotes and page summaries. It was interesting to hear Lauren’s account of how they found alignment within their team to produce the guidance in the playbook. I’d sat in one of the alignment sessions myself and liked how everyone had had a chance to put forward their views by editing the same page of content. In her talk, Lauren described how meeting up to discuss a piece of content helped to clarify shared standards and supported a more consistent approach to editorial work. 

Pete’s talk was about how he has been appraising the performance of Edinburgh’s degree finder. Pete used a scorecard similar to the one Lou Rosenfeld describes in his article ‘Stop redesigning and start tuning your site instead’. The scorecard lays out your most important audiences, and for each one, a prioritised list of their tasks and information needs. The final column on the scorecard is a grade for how easy it is to complete those tasks or find that information on your website. 

The challenge then was to find a robust way to give these grades. To do this, Pete created a set of marking criteria of the type you might see associated with educational assessments. With this in hand, he ran a series of usability tests to see how easily people could complete tasks on Degree Finder. The result was a table showing how effectively we’re supporting prospective students to complete their key tasks, and highlighting where further development effort is needed. 

Read Pete’s blog post about appraising the new postgraduate study website 

Thanks to the Dundee team for hosting the event 

As always, the day was brilliantly organised, with a wide range of interesting talks. We’re still learning about how AI is changing our use of digital tools, and this event was a good chance to reflect on how this is having an impact on those of us who work on websites in the higher education sector. 

Mel’s reflections 

This was my second time attending Scottish Web Folk in Dundee, but my first time presenting. I’d been looking forward to returning, as it’s always a welcoming room and a great opportunity to hear what others across the sector are working on. 

We took our AI research into a wider conversation 

Our session, ‘AI search summaries: a new lens on old content problems’, built on a Content Improvement Club training session we’d run recently. Preparing that training was the first time I’d really explored how AI relates to the content we produce, and it involved a lot of research. So it felt like a nice full-circle moment to bring some of that learning to Scottish Web Folk and share it as part of a wider discussion about AI. 

Our presentation focused on AI and content design, while some of the other sessions took a more technical angle. It was interesting (and reassuring!) to hear that our points resonated with others, particularly the idea that well-structured, maintained and accessible content matters for AI as well as for people. 

It was also a lovely surprise to find Claire Gregory from the University of Dundee in the room. Her UCISA talk, ‘Feeding the bot: making content work beyond the webpage’, had been a really useful source when preparing our training. 

Watch Claire Gregory’s talk: ‘Feeding the bot’ 

We also had questions about the training itself and how we get people involved. Our sessions have developed quite a bit over the past year, so it was nice to have a moment to reflect on that and chat about the process with a room of peers. 

Andrew Millar’s opening talk put AI in a wider context 

Beginning the day, Andrew Millar’s got us thinking about how we approach new technology. He took us through a timeline of major technological turning points, from the printing press to the web, and asked what became less scarce, what became more valuable and who lost out. With the printing press, for example, copying text became easier, but judgement and trust became more important. 

We’d actually considered using a timeline in our own presentation, so it was interesting to see a similar approach being used elsewhere. It felt like a useful way to tackle the AI elephant in the room, putting the changes we’re seeing into a wider context rather than treating AI as something entirely without precedent. 

A new acronym has really stuck with me from Andrew’s talk: GIGO, or ‘garbage in, garbage out’. It’s a simple idea, but an important one in the context of AI. If the information we’re putting out there isn’t good in the first place, we can’t expect the systems using it to produce reliable answers. Definitely relevant to what we were talking about! 

Andrew also talked about how, more than ever, we need to advocate for users who aren’t in the room. That really resonated with me. I don’t think the rise of AI search tools means we should start rewriting everything for bots. Rather, it’s another ‘audience’ to consider, while keeping our human audiences at the centre. The things we already think about as content designers (understanding user needs, using plain language and making content accessible) still matter.  

The morning panel discussed making university information work harder for prospective students 

The panel discussion was another highlight for me. I enjoyed the conversational format, which offered something a little different from listening to a series of presentations. 

A key part of the chat was around how prospective students’ questions go well beyond course details. They’re also thinking about the cost of living, student welfare and the practicalities of studying, including whether they’ll be able to work alongside their course. These priorities are changing, and universities need to be upfront about the answers rather than burying the lead. 

This is particularly important as AI search tools may draw on information from outside university websites, such as forums and online discussions. If universities don’t provide clear answers themselves, AI may turn to other sources that aren’t always accurate or complete. There’s an opportunity here for universities to answer people’s questions directly and reliably. 

I also enjoyed hearing about Marta Krukowska’s (Bangor University) example of using AI to introduce a bit of friction when gathering course information from colleagues. Rather than accepting vague descriptions, AI could push people to dig deeper and provide more specific answers. I liked this idea of using AI not simply to speed things up, but to challenge people to provide the useful detail that prospective students actually need. It was another example of finding a suitable use for AI that wasn’t about creating content. 

A day of shared learning 

Overall, it was a really good day and well worth the early start. The ‘Human vs machine’ theme could easily have made the day all about the latest AI tools and technologies. What I took away instead was how much of the conversation came back to the human side. 

Big thanks again to the Dundee team for hosting.

Scottish Web Folk 2026: Humans vs Machine

There is no doubt that there has been a step change in how Higher Education has delivered web services over the past few years. However, stepping foot in the University of Dundee’s conference hall for another Scottish Web Folk, I’m delighted to report that it’s still very possible to fill a room with brilliant people who are happy to nerd out about our work!

You can read about my previous experience here:

Scottish Web Folk 2025: Challenging times, brilliant people

Old rules no longer apply

As is tradition, the University of Dundee’s Andrew Millar, opened the conference with a presentation which presented the theme of the day: “Human vs Machine”.

He put forward the idea that the amazing technologies which are transforming digital services also come with significant risks and challenges.

For example, indicators which were once used to assess the effectiveness of a web service can no longer be relied upon: Page views are less relevant now that many users will find an answer from a chat bot without visiting a website. A site’s ranking in search engines is less relevant now that a chat bot can find answers from anywhere on the web. And so on.

There is tension between the perception of human- and AI-generated content

While there is undoubtedly an increase in the use of chat bots to find information, a recent Gallup survey of 14-29 year olds found that only 3% trust work solely made by AI, 28% trust AI-assisted work, and 69% trust work made without AI.

Andrew Millar presenting a slide which includes the statistics of the trustworthiness of AI among Generation Z

In a panel discussion, Marta Krukowska from the University of Bangor described a situation in which an image purchased from a major vendor and used on their website turned out to be AI-generated. This caused some reputational damage in the student community as it put the doubt in users’ minds that other content might also be AI-generated.

The perception of these technologies is clearly in flux and are likely to shift significantly over the coming years. While it may be beyond us to influence this process, Millar put forward what he sees as our role:

  • Advocate: Speak for the user who is not in the room through research, accessibility, and plain language.
  • Defend: Protect accuracy and our voice. Ensure that what AI says about us is correct. Guard our data and intellectual property.
  • Decide: Own what is published in our name through approval thresholds, escalation, and a working stop button.

Digital practitioners have moved from theory to practice

Ensuring that our web content is correct and parsable by AI tools is essential going forward.

Only thinking about human users can have unintended results

Rob Ryder-Richardson from the University of Dundee described a situation in which something that was designed to help human users had unintended consequences when interfaced with AI.

Their course information pages dynamically displayed different data depending on the geographical location of the visitor – good for humans, but AI crawlers are almost exclusively based in the United States.

Therefore, when asked about course entry requirements, some chatbots were confidently asserting that the University of Dundee only accepts US SATs and that UK-based qualifications were ineligible.

The solution was to essentially develop a dataset which AI crawlers could use to find information, invisible to human users who would likely find such information unnecessary and overwhelming – structured in a way which is clear and unambiguous.

AI can be used proactively to improve the quality of web services

Richard Saunders from Zengenti described the benefits of developing a collaborative toolkit which team members can use to assess their webpages proactively to improve quality.

As a manager of a service which contains a surprising amount of content, one of the biggest challenges I have is ensuring that this content is accurate, pertinent, and accessible. While this task is currently done manually, there is certainly benefit in automating this task with AI skills.

In contrast with using one-off prompts, AI skills are plaintext workflows which provide a consistent instruction to the LLM. These work best when each one is focused on one particular outcome, and so developing a library of these within a team can provide a toolkit which can be used to consistently audit a website’s content.

I look forward to applying new best practice

While the technical implications for AI often dominate the conversation, Scottish Web Folk reminded me that successful digital transformation is fundamentally a human endeavour. Two sessions from the University of Edinburgh highlighted to me that before we can deploy such technologies, we must first master collaboration.

Neil Allison presented a masterclass on delivering effective workshops. Too often, digital teams conflate “meetings” and “workshops” and gather stakeholders only to disseminate information rather than create it. He outlined common pitfalls that cause a workshop to be ineffective: such as a lack of clear objectives, prominent voices stifling creativity, and lack of tangible outputs.

A slide featuring a diagram of a good workshop: the opening phase is divergent, the exploring phase is emergent, and the closing phase is convergent

Lauren Tormey delivered a case study on developing content design playbooks. Tormey explained how to co-create a set of best practices using a repeatable, structured workshop format.

As part of a team who hopes to deliver significant changes to our digital services in the near future, I found this talk to be invaluable and look forward to employing these strategies in my workshops soon.

We have a responsibility to help deliver better, future-proofed web services

AI is no longer a distant, theoretical concept, but an immediate operational reality. The path forward requires focusing on both delivering effective technology and ensuring excellent collaboration on the human level.

To take this forward, I propose the following action plan:

  • Ensure our success metrics are defined according to user requirements.
  • Audit our content for AI readability.
  • Deliver excellent workshops to determine our course of action.

Or in other words:

Advocate. Defend. Decide.

At Scottish Web Folk 2026, the theme was Human vs Machine. The takeaway was Human plus Machine.

The theme of this year’s Scottish Web Folk conference in Dundee was “Human vs Machine”, and AI dominated the programme, as you’d expect. But session after session told another story: the successes came from humans and machines working together, with people firmly in charge of the judgement calls. Here’s my reflections from a day packed with very interesting sessions and networking with colleagues from the Higher Education sector.

Four years in, and still the friendliest room in Scottish higher education

The annual Scottish Web Folk conference began in 2023 to bring Scottish universities’ digital and web professionals back together after the hiatus of the pandemic. Colleagues from University from Dundee (can’t say thank you enough to Andrew Millar and Rob Ryder-Richardson enough for keeping this community together) organise a day of more than twenty sessions, with teams from across the UK and Ireland attending. When I reflected on the 2024 edition, I called it a ceilidh, and the description still fits.

The Scottish Web Folk ceilidh at Dundee – Blog post by Stratos Filalithis, October 2024

Alistair Campbell used the title of “Challenging times, brilliant people” for last year’s conference, and this description still stands, even stronger.

Scottish Web Folk 2025: Challenging times, brilliant people – Blog post by Alistair Campbell, November 2025

A large lecture theatre, with people sitting on the foreground and a large screen welcoming attendees of the Scottish Web Folk 2026 conference.

The opening of the Scottish Web Folk 2026 conference.

This is a working conference rather than a showcase: people turn up to talk about their challenges and successes and leave with valuable insights, ideas and new friends to follow up after the day. The University of Edinburgh was very well represented, with colleagues from our teams sharing their work.

Scottish Web Folk 2026 conference programme

In Edinburgh and Glasgow, we “never waste a crisis”

During the last few years, Kris Purdy, Head of Digital Experience at University of Glasgow, and I have met regularly to exchange thoughts and ideas, and compare your approaches against very similar challenges in our web estates. In this year’s conference, we were given the opportunity to stand and share our stories, findings and action plans to bring order to our chaotic web estates. We agreed to “freestyle” the session, having an open discussion without any slides. This allowed us to be frank in an informal environment, and, hopefully, better engage with our audience, allowing questions to be asked during our discussion and not waiting until the end, as is the usual format.

We spoke about our common challenges, like the risk of not knowing the size, shape and individual ownership of our websites, and differences, for example Glasgow’s web estate counts approximately 900 websites, half of which are hosted in their corporate website, while Edinburgh’s web estate counts more than 2,000 websites, with less than 8% using the centrally-supported web platform, EdWeb 2. Some of these numbers triggered audible gasps from the crowd, like the fact that Google regularly indexes more than 2 million pages and files under our corporate domain (ed.ac.uk), which is way more than those hosted in our web platform, or expected to manage.

There was a very special mention to last week’s PHP2Shell vulnerability incident which highlighted the need for an up-to-date web estate registry, as well as the immediate and quick action everyone took to update it with information about ownership, technology usage, which helps identify those websites that need to be retired immediately. This is a crisis we will not waste.

Through our journeys, though, we identified a very strong conclusion: the lack of clear web estate governance and ownership increases multiple risks across reputation, ability to stand out in search results, content accuracy, compliance, cyber security and higher costs associated with the web services. As I have blogged recently, these risks are untenable in the are of the great amplifier: Artificial Intelligence (AI).

2,117 websites and counting: welcome to our Wild West Web Estate – Blog post by Stratos Filalithis, October 2026

With a day full of insights and interesting sessions, here are the main themes that stood out for me:

The threat was never the machine

The customary introduction by Andrew Millar, Head of Digital Engagement & Marketing at University of Dundee, sets the tone for the rest of the day, and this time was not different. I fully agree with his argument that humanity had always had a challenge with transformative and disruptive technologies. AI is the most recent addition in a list having the printing press, factory power, office computers and the web, all of which provided a turning point making some things scarce and other more valuable.

Slide titled “Not the first turning point”, comparing the printing press, steam power, office computers, the web and AI. Each earlier shift made one skill cheap and another valuable, such as judgement and trust after the printing press. For AI, drafting and summarising are no longer scarce, but what becomes valuable and who loses out are marked with question marks. Caption: “It worked out previously…

Andrew Millar’s slide listing the human technology turning points and their impacts.

Each of these technologies had an impact relative to their era and world, making AI the most impactful (yet). What we do with it, though, is up to humans since technology by itself is not a threat. How we use it and for which purposes and benefits is. Andrew concluded by pointing out that to achieve this, we need to make sure to ask the right questions, like “Did the user get the right answer, anywhere in our website?” instead of “How many people viewed this page?”, or “Does key content have an owner and a review date?” instead of having “Machines make unlimited content”.

Most of the sessions in the day were focussing on just that, how to leverage the powerful technologies at hand to enhance our capability, experience and skills to fulfil our objectives.

AI bots are an audience too

This wasn’t the first time that I attended a session about building website and webpages for AI bots. This is a very real subject because optimizing how AI bots scan and index our content, supports what they respond on our behalf to a rising number of user using them as their first point in searching for a programme, degree or research opportunities.

Rob Ryder-Richardson shared how University of Dundee improved their programmes’ entry requirements presentation to ensure both humans and AI bots got the most out of it. The journey through each iteration of the page exposed that the human experience is not necessarily useful for an AI bot, which then impacts the accuracy of their responses. More specifically, personalised content via location was triggering wrong answers by AI bots, since they had indexed their responses based on their location, the United States of America, and not the visitor’s location, which could be any other country in the world.

The current solution is to publish a single, plain HTML page containing all information in structured tables. This page more than 60,000 lines, making it unusable by humans but perfect for AI crawlers, allows AI bots to provide accurate answers per location. His “five things to check on Monday” slide provided an easy guide for everyone to check on their websites (higher education or not):

  • check what bots are allowed to reach.
  • turn JavaScript off and look at your key pages.
  • check what a US visitor sees on any content personalised by location.
  • write ten questions applicants really ask.
  • put them to Google, Gemini, ChatGPT, Claude and others, then see what they say about you.

And yet, humans still hold the keys

However much AI might have dominated the sessions and discussions, the human element was hard to miss. From Andrew’s opening session, highlighting human-verified as a key element for a good website, and Ulster University’s Mark Kennedy highlighting the role a very small team of 4 plays to support a community of around 400 publishers, to the very informative panel discussion where Marta Krukowska, from Bangor University, highlighted how students are asking real-life questions to make their decision to apply for any University, and Neil Allison, from The University of Edinburgh, raising the issue of cost of living for those considering Edinburgh as their study destination, all had one thing in common: real people.

Later in the day, Neil’s session focussed on how to make the most of stakeholder workshops, He provided easy, practical guidance and real-life examples to maximize engagements and outcomes in a very useful, and directly applicable, guide to human input. His premise is that workshops take many forms, but a few fundamentals sit underneath every successful one: bringing people together, solving a problem and ending with something tangible that everyone can get behind.

A slide with the title "What should a workshop facilitate?" listing Sharing, Collaboration, Democratisation, Ideation and Prioritisation as the key goals of a workshop. A diagram showing a workshop journey from diverging to exploring ideas and then covering to those that matter at the end.

Neil’s slide listing a successful workshop’s facilitation phases and goals.

A slide with the title “What should a workshop facilitate?” listing Sharing, Collaboration, Democratisation, Ideation and Prioritisation as the key goals of a workshop. A diagram showing a workshop journey from diverging to exploring ideas and then covering to those that matter at the end.

Human plus Machine

The theme of the day was “Human Vs Machine”, but the best sessions were about both: bots that need clean structure and humans who need honest answers, AI that speeds up the build and people who still decide what is worth building. The old, but always relevant acronym GIGO: Garbage in, garbage out, that Andrew referenced in his opening talk, has never been more true, and people are still the ones deciding what goes in.

As for what’s next? I have already booked Wednesday 27th of October 2027 in my calendar to travel back to Dundee for the 5th Scottish Web Folk conference.

Thank you to everyone who spoke, sponsored and chatted over coffee and lunch. If any of this sparks a thought, a challenge or a question, I would love to hear from you. Please get in touch directly at stratos.filalithis@ed.ac.uk.

Jamie Driscoll interview: How the UK can make the economy work for everyone

Jamie Driscoll served as Labour mayor of the North of Tyne from 2019 to 2024. Since then, he’s joined the Green Party and serves as a councillor on Newcastle City Council.

Since his election as a Green councillor, he’s been pushing for the Greens to up their game on economic policy. Part of this has been the release of a detailed new report – Hostage Nation – which seeks to make the case for a new approach to the economy.

LFF spoke to Driscoll at the Green Party’s autumn conference in Brighton about that report and his wider views on how Greens in local government can deliver transformative agendas in the context of more than a decade of austerity.

At the beginning of our conversation, Driscoll explained the underpinning issues the report seeks to address. He told LFF: “Pretty much everyone with any kind of social conscience knows we have serious problems with poverty – we have a housing crisis. Anyone who’s scientific literature knows that we are in a serious era of climate change.

“Yet we keep being told we haven’t got any money to build council houses, we’re going to have to wait for the market to sort us out on clean energy, we can’t build youth clubs or swimming pools anymore. So any idea of public luxury is out.

“And that’s told to us as if it’s scientific fact as if it’s a law of nature. The reality is we’ve got loads of money.”

He went on to argue that the UK government should be able to utilise the wealth that exists in the country to invest in public services and take the measures needed to address the climate emergency. Driscoll said: “There’s £70 billion a year goes in cash ISAs. We’ve got a pension pool of over two trillion in occupational pensions. Only 5 per cent of that is invested in British companies, and yet you get tax relief on it.

“So why don’t we just change it so that you can’t have tax relief for investing in silicon valley or fossil fuel exploration in the Middle East? If you want tax relief from British taxpayers, that money has to be invested in something socially useful for Britain – which is the building of council houses, retrofitting every home.”

He continued: “So if you went street by street and retrofitted every home in Britain, every pound you spend would get 40p back in tax immediately. And you can’t outsource this stuff. A crew of people working down Cedar Avenue in Leeds – that can’t be outsourced to a factory in China. So you crank the jobs, and if you crank the jobs, you’ve lowered the welfare bill.”

Some of the rhetoric that Driscoll uses is similar to that being used by the prime minister Andy Burnham. Burnham has spoken about ending neoliberalism, about bringing more control into the economy, and about not being ‘in hock’ to the bond markets.

What does Driscoll think of the early days of the Burnham government and its direction on the economy? He started his response by questioning the veracity of Labour leaders’ public rhetoric and pledges.

Driscoll told LFF: “I thought Keir Starmer’s 10 pledges were very good. I still think they’re good pledges. My opinion of Keir Starmer is somewhat different”.

He then continued: “How can you say we’ve got to get past this thing of being in hock to the bond markets and then say we will follow the fiscal rules?” before adding: “These are a political fiction not for managing the economy but for managing public opinion. If they’re going to lock themselves in a room and pretend they’re hostages then they’re not getting rid of neoliberalism.”

What should the Green Party do in light of Driscoll’s view that Burnham’s rhetoric doesn’t match reality?

Driscoll told LFF: “We should call it out. But you don’t call it out by saying that’s not ending neoliberalism because then the public will say ‘I don’t know what neoliberalism means’.

“So this is why you say look Andy, are you actually going to build 100,000 council houses every year? Are you going to make sure that everybody is on a living wage not a minimum wage? Anyone who’s serious about reducing the welfare budget has to get serious about structural wealth inequality.”

For the Greens, questions of national economic policy are – for now at least – a question of what concessions they can secure from the government, what they want to offer the electorate, and possibly what they would seek to deliver in the event they end up a partner in government after the next election.

But economic policy on a local level is a different matter entirely. The Greens are in sole or joint administration in dozens of councils across the country. In the context of more than a decade of austerity, rising costs of social care and temporary accommodation, and the reduction of economic levers at their disposal, delivering the kind of radical agenda Driscoll supports is a challenge.

He nonetheless thinks there are opportunities to utilise local government to improve people’s lives.

Driscoll told LFF: “The climate they’re operating in is extremely difficult, because not only is the financial effect of austerity on their services, on their staff extremely difficult, we’ve also stored up a huge amount of problems there. There are more people with mental ill health. There are more people who have been in financial distress for a much longer period of time. So the pressures are greater.”

He went on to say: “So you’ve got to be realistic. You are not going to build a people’s republic anywhere under the current financial system.

“That said, there are things you can do about engaging communities directly. There are things you can do about leaving money in. And there are still substantial budgets that are not procured in a way that either create the best possible jobs, the best environmental outcomes, or the best social outcomes”.

Driscoll would later add: “So it is about coming up with a manifesto and looking at the things that don’t cost a lot of money that at least signal that you’re doing the right things and will make people’s lives better. So it may be that there’s a park where the cafe’s been closed for ages – we’ll find a way to give that lease for peanuts to a local charity and get something out.”

Driscoll then argued that councils should be looking to bring public services back in house. He told LFF: “Perhaps you should be looking at a different procurement framework – if you are one of these councils that’s previously outsourced to Capita and the contract’s coming to an end, how are we actually going to not just roll that over again, how are we going to do some decent insourcing? Those are the kinds of things you can do.”

Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward

The post Jamie Driscoll interview: How the UK can make the economy work for everyone appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Kemi’s Thatcher tribute act has a Truss-shaped problem

If anyone thought the Conservatives might use their time in opposition to reflect on why they lost power after 14 years, Kemi Badenoch’s conference blitz offers a pretty emphatic answer – apparently, they think they simply weren’t right-wing enough.

At this week’s Conservative Party conference in Birmingham, Badenoch unveiled a raft of policies that would take the party further to the right, promising tax cuts, deregulation, a smaller state and a series of measures that would disproportionately benefit wealthier households.

In the process, the Tories aren’t only abandoning the centre ground. They are also junking, attacking or attempting to rewrite policies introduced by their own governments.

And then there is Andrew Griffith, Badenoch’s newly appointed shadow chancellor, a former Liz Truss minister who backed her leadership bid and was heavily involved in her disastrous economic strategy.

If this is the Tories’ economic reset, the Truss-shaped elephant in the room is hard to miss.

Kemi’s Thatcher tribute act

In her essay The Right Way, a 100-page statement on her guiding principles and a deliberate echo of Margaret Thatcher’s 1976 essay The Right Approach, Badenoch argues that the last Conservative government failed because it didn’t know what it stood for.

“The next Conservative government will have one central principle: business, not government, creates growth,” she writes, promising to deliver it through tax cuts, cutting red tape and reducing the civil service to pre-pandemic levels.

She also says politicians need to have “the stomach to say no to good causes when the resources simply are not there to do everything”.

The Tory press, unsurprisingly, lapped it up.

“Kemi’s the new Thatcher,” declared the Daily Mail, praising Badenoch’s pledge to remake the party in the Iron Lady’s image and return it to “old-school” values.

But beneath the Thatcherite rhetoric is a familiar political choice: shrinking the state while finding ways to make life easier for those at the wealthier end of the income scale. In the words of the old music hall song, as ever ‘it’s the tich wot gets the pleasure, it’s the poor wot gets the blame.’ 

A policy blitz for the better-off

Take childcare. Badenoch wants to abolish the £100,000 household income cut-off for free childcare, allowing all parents working 16 or more hours a week to claim the support.

On the face of it, extending childcare provision sounds like a welcome policy. The Tories acknowledge that the measure would cost around £700m a year, money they propose to find partly by cutting jobs at organisations including Arts Council England and the Environment Agency.

In other words, more state support for higher earners, paid for by shrinking public bodies and cutting elsewhere.

Then there is stamp duty.

Badenoch wants to abolish most stamp duty, presenting it as a measure that would help homeowners. But the distributional impact tells a rather different story.

Many first-time buyers already pay no stamp duty on properties worth up to £300,000, meaning the biggest gains from abolition would go to those buying more expensive homes. And because 60 percent of stamp duty is paid in southern England, according to Zoopla, the benefits would be concentrated disproportionately in London and the South.

In other words, scrapping the tax rather than reforming it would do little for many first-time buyers while handing a much bigger benefit to wealthier homeowners and those purchasing more expensive properties.

As would the abolishing of inheritance tax on a family home, another old-school Tory manoeuvre that would shovel £6bn of taxpayer money to the already-wealthy.

The proposal prompted accusations that the Tories were prioritising wealthy families over those struggling to make ends meet.

Tax Justice UK condemned it as a massive giveaway to some of Britain’s richest people, warning that it would deprive public services of vital funding at a time when they are already under pressure.

The Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) also warned it would disproportionately benefit people who already have substantial property wealth.

“The biggest beneficiaries would be those with the highest wealth and the most valuable homes – and their descendants. This is a very well-off group, mainly living in London and the South-East of England.”

Let’s not forget, it was George Osborne’s headline-grabbing promise to “take the family home out of inheritance tax” in 2007 that put Gordon Brown off calling a snap general election.

While Andy Burnham talks about levelling up the country and taking power and wealth away from London, Badenoch’s economic agenda promises the opposite, concentrating more of the gains in the wealthiest parts of the country.

More prisons, less overseas aid

The policy blitz doesn’t stop there.

Badenoch has promised 50,000 new prison spaces in England and Wales, a 50 percent expansion in capacity, partly funded by slashing overseas aid to £1bn a year, around a 90 percent cut from current plans.

That echoes a proposal previously made by Reform UK, which prompted warnings from aid organisations that such a cut would not even cover Britain’s existing contributions to international institutions such as the UN and World Bank, thereby shredding Britain’s influence in these spaces.

“UK aid is an investment in a safer, healthier and more resilient world. Protecting the UK aid budget protects us all,” said Gideon Rabinowitz, director of policy and advocacy at Bond, the UK network of NGOs.

And then came the high-profile pledge of an ‘Iron Dome’ for Britain. £10bn for an Israeli-style missile defence system to protect the country from missile and drone threats of Russian and Iranian aggression, paid for by welfare reform and reprioritisation of
other spending.

It’s quite a pitch from a party whose 14 years in government cut defence spending to the bone.

Yet the Tory press loved it.

“Britain needs an ‘Iron Dome’ to keep us safe,” screamed the Daily Express’s front page.

“Iron Dome lady,” announced the Sun.

The headlines may have been loud but the argument behind them is rather less convincing.

Enter the Truss connection

Perhaps the most ironic part of the Conservative conference was not Badenoch’s Thatcher-harpooning rhetoric but the man standing beside her economic agenda: Andrew Griffith, the party’s newly appointed shadow chancellor.

Griffith backed Liz Truss for prime minister in 2022 and served as her financial secretary to the Treasury, where he was closely involved in her disastrous mini budget, which led to a surge in gilt yields triggering her abrupt exit from Downing Street.

When Griffith was appointed shadow chancellor in August, Truss herself took to X to congratulate him.

“Congratulations to Andrew Griffith on becoming Shadow Chancellor,” she wrote. “The economic establishment of the last three decades has failed Britain. They must be taken on.”

In his keynote conference speech, the shadow chancellor promised to follow in the footsteps of Thatcher’s chancellor Nigel Lawson by cutting at least one tax at every budget under a future Conservative government. This rather ignores the fact that the famous Lawson 1987 budget restoked the flames of inflation which the Thatcher government and even more the British people, had worked so hard to bring under control.

Griffith’s Lawson re-tread includes scrapping Labour’s so-called “mansion tax,” the additional council tax levy on properties worth more than £2m due to come into effect in 2028.

Griffith called it a “vindictive levy,” claiming it would hit people living in “ordinary homes”.

An ordinary home worth more than £2m? I’m not sure I know many people who live in one.

He also pledged to scrap the net-zero-related “grocery tax,” which is actually the extended producer responsibility levy that charges businesses for the packaging they use and is intended to encourage less environmentally damaging packaging.

Yet another policy developed under the Conservatives, during Michael Gove’s time as environment secretary no less, before being implemented by Labour.

Yet Griffith now wants to axe it in the name of cutting red tape.

The Truss lesson – apparently learned, but not quite

And here the Tories’ economic argument becomes particularly interesting.

Griffith has criticised Andy Burnham for failing to explain how his policy commitments will be funded, warning that the Labour government risks making the same mistake as Liz Truss’s 2022 mini budget.

This is a particularly bold criticism coming from someone who backed Truss.

Griffith has continued to defend the underlying tax-cutting ambitions of the mini-budget, while arguing that its fatal flaw was failing to set out clearly how the tax cuts would be paid for.

As he himself put it, that was the “mistake of Liz Truss’ mini budget”.

Quite.

Because the problem with the Conservatives’ latest blitz is not simply that it contains lots of tax cuts and spending commitments. It’s that the party appears to be repeating the same ideological impulse that helped produce the Truss experiment in the first place: slash taxes, shrink the state, deregulate and hope growth follows.

The difference, apparently, is that this time they promise to explain how they will pay for it.

Hard choices – after 14 years of avoiding them

Griffith also accused previous Conservative leaders of failing to govern as genuine free-market conservatives, attacking Burnham and John Healey for supposedly wanting to return Britain to a “socialist fever dream of the 1970s”. Of course, returning the country to the 1950s and ‘60s when levels of growth far exceeded anything achieved since is never mentioned. Strange that!

There is something rather extraordinary about hearing Conservatives who governed Britain for 14 years accuse others of avoiding hard choices.

As LabourList noted, one of the more tone-deaf moments in Griffith’s speech came when he claimed the Conservatives would be “the ones to make the hard choices”.

That is a curious boast from a party whose record in government included enormous increases in national debt, years of austerity and a mini budget that sent financial markets into turmoil.

And if Griffith’s conference speech was supposed to demonstrate the political force of this new Conservative economic agenda, it was not exactly an electrifying display.

The Guardian’s John Grace described it as the “worst speech ever heard”, noting the empty seats and lacklustre response that was “like watching a less sentient version of the PG Tips monkey.”
It’s a world apart from the Thatcher-Lawson supposedly glory days the Conservatives appear so desperate to recreate.

The same old Tory economics, just further right

Strip away the Thatcher references and Iron Dome Lady headlines and Badenoch’s vision looks remarkably familiar: more tax cuts, less regulation, a smaller state and policies tilted towards the better-off.

The Conservatives appear to believe they lost power because they were not right-wing enough. But with a former Truss minister now sitting in the shadow chancellor’s chair, their supposed fresh start looks less like a reset than a rerun – only further to the right.

Gabrielle Pickard-Whitehead is author of Right-Wing Watch

The post Kemi’s Thatcher tribute act has a Truss-shaped problem appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Lee Anderson confuses a generic Tory email with a personal plea from Badenoch

Kemi Badenoch has firmly rejected the prospect of an electoral pact with Reform UK, telling Conservatives that there will be no “unite the right” deal with Nigel Farage’s party.

While some senior figures in both parties have argued that the Conservatives and Reform should join forces to defeat Labour at the next election, Badenoch used her conference speech to draw a clear line between the two.

She said she did not want to live in a country “run by people who threaten journalists, who call veterans ‘traitors’ and debate whether my mixed-race children are English”.

Badenoch also took aim at some of Reform’s biggest controversies, including Nigel Farage’s £5m donation and the imprisonment of its Welsh leader over corruption offences.

“The circus goes on and on and it will never stop, because this is who Reform politicians are,” she said.

“To those who say ‘unite the right’, we are not uniting with that.

“People deserve better than that and we are going to give them better than that.”

GB News subsequently invited Reform chairman Lee Anderson onto one of its programmes to discuss Badenoch’s rejection of an electoral pact.

Anderson claimed that the Conservatives were “literally pleading with ex-members like myself and Rob and Suella and Layla to rejoin the Tory Party”.

“Desperate times, Martin, call for desperate measures,” he added.

Presenter Martin Daubney asked Anderson to clarify whether he had received an email from Badenoch, along with Robert Jenrick, Suella Braverman and Layla Cunningham, asking them to return to the Conservative Party.

Anderson said he had the email on his phone and claimed it said: “Please rejoin the Conservative Party, we are a different party, we have been reborn,” before dismissing the message as “all this sort of nonsense”.

He then steered the conversation back towards his wider criticism of the Conservatives.

“Nobody trusts them anymore, Martin. This is a desperate measure,” he said.

Daubney asked Anderson if he could send him the email, to which Anderson agreed, saying he would do so once he was out of the building and had a decent signal.

But the email Anderson had presented as evidence of the Conservative Party personally trying to win him back turned out to be a generic party email sent to former members.

It began by saying: “We’re sorry you couldn’t join us at Conference this time round. But don’t miss out on your chance to join us in Manchester next year.”

The message was clearly not a personal email from Badenoch to Anderson, nor, as Anderson had suggested, a bespoke appeal to a handful of prominent former Conservatives.

The issue was later discussed again in the GB News studio, where the channel showed a screenshot of the email.

GB News political correspondent Olivia Utley clarified what had happened.

“It wasn’t directly from Kemi Badenoch,” she explained. “It was simply asking people to join the comeback.”

The supposed evidence of Badenoch personally pleading with Anderson and other Reform figures to return to the Conservative Party was actually a mass email sent to former members.

The exchange didn’t go unnoticed by viewers, with the clip prompting bemusement online.

One commenter described it as “Lee Anderson caught in a brutally embarrassing lie on GBNews,” arguing that he had claimed Badenoch personally sent emails to him, Robert Jenrick, Suella Braverman and Layla Cunningham, only for the programme to reveal that it was a generic email sent to former members.

Another commented: “This takes thick to a whole new level.”

The post Lee Anderson confuses a generic Tory email with a personal plea from Badenoch appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Tories overestimate net zero cost by nearly £500 billion in policy document blunder

A Conservative party conference policy document has doubled the cost of the transition to net zero in a spreadsheet blunder.

As reported by the Carbon Brief, the Tories have overestimated the cost of net zero by almost £500 billion.

The “common sense” policy document argues that “what people ultimately want is a government competent enough to solve the problems for which it takes responsibility”.

The Conservative Party document claims, incorrectly, that the government’s official adviser, the Climate Change Committee (CCC), had put the cost of net-zero at close to £1 trillion.

The document stated: “In 2020, the CCC estimated that its route to net-zero would cost £957bn.”

The CCC’s 2020 estimate was exactly half this amount – £478 billion – and last year it published a revised figure of £108 billion, largely as a result of the falling cost of electric vehicles (EVs).

The Carbon Brief’s analysis found that the Conservative party’s erroneous claim seems to have stemmed from another report that had accidentally added up numbers twice, using a spreadsheet published by the CCC in 2020.

The spreadsheet contains a list of the additional investments needed to build a net-zero economy, from low-carbon electricity to heat pumps and EVs.

These extra capital expenditures, listed as “CAPEX”, add up to a total of £1.38 trillion over the 30 years of 2020-50. They are set against operational savings, listed as “OPEX”, of £0.90 trillion.

Added up over 2020-50, the combined CAPEX and OPEX figures come to a total of £478 billion.

The Tories estimate that achieving net zero will cost £957 billion appears to have been as a result of someone adding all of these numbers together, resulting in the savings and costs being counted twice.

A CCC spokesperson said: “We don’t recognise this number. The committee has previously offered to meet with Ms Badenoch and talk her through our advice. That offer is, of course, still open.”

Olivia Barber is a reporter at Left Foot Forward

The post Tories overestimate net zero cost by nearly £500 billion in policy document blunder appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Kemi Badenoch rules out forming coalition with Reform UK

Kemi Badenoch has said she would rather have another general election than do a deal with Reform UK in the event of a hung parliament at the next election.

In an interview with Anna Foster on BBC Radio 4 Today, Badenoch said: “I don’t like the Reform party. I like their voters. I want their voters to come back to us.”

She added: “But the people in Reform, between the sleaze scandals, the people arrested, someone in prison for Russian bribes, people talking about brown envelopes as we saw in that exposé. Why are they getting personal gifts of £5 million?”

“They’re just not our kind of people.”

Speaking about the prospect of a coalition with Reform, Badenoch told Sky News: “If there is a hung parliament, then we can have another election. We had this in 1974. It’s not about, do a deal with Reform or don’t be in government. In 1974, there were two elections. I believe that the public will see who is serious and who is not.”

A recent MRP poll conducted by YouGov revealed that if an election were held tomorrow, there would likely be a hung parliament. 

The estimate, which draws on large poll as well as census data, indicates that Labour would win 241 seats, while the Conservatives would win 130 and Reform UK 123. 

With 326 seats required to form a majority, the Conservatives and Reform would still need another 73 seats to form a government, making the prospect of them forming one unlikely. 

Badenoch also insisted that anyone who defects to Reform UK will not be allowed back into her party.

The Conservative leader’s comments ruling out forming a coalition with Reform come despite the party under her leadership having been accused of trying to “out-Reform Reform”.

Examples of this include Badenoch reneging on the Tories’ commitment to net zero by 2050, and vowing to block any parliamentary candidates who support the environmental policy.

The party has also undergone a further rightward shift on immigration, with Badenoch saying people who do not support leaving the European Convention on Human Rights will also be unable to stand as a Tory candidate.

The general secretary of the TUC Paul Nowak told the Mirror: “After their crushing defeat in 2024, the Tories thought they could win back votes by copying Farage’s homework, echoing his poisonous rhetoric, and even handing him some of their MPs.

“Whether it’s the Tories or Reform, it’s the same offer. A reckless right-wing government, ripping up workers’ rights, and siding with vested interests and the super-rich. Working people deserve better than that.”

In addition, not all Tories agree with Badenoch’s stance on doing a deal with Reform. 

Former Tory minister Sir Jacob Rees-Mogg said at a fringe event at Conservative Party conference that it would be “bonkers” not to support a Tory-Reform coalition.

At a fringe event at party conference, the audience was asked to raise their hand if they were a Tory member who would support a post-election coalition between the two parties if it meant “stopping a left-wing government”.

Rees-Mogg, who was speaking in conversation at the event, said: “If anyone didn’t put their hand up, you’re bonkers.”

Katie Lam, the shadow housing secretary, has also suggested that the Tories may have to form a pact with Reform in order to stop the UK from rejoining the EU.

Olivia Barber is a reporter at Left Foot Forward

The post Kemi Badenoch rules out forming coalition with Reform UK appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Wales Green Party deputy leader resigns over Zionism is racism motion

One of the two deputy leaders of the Wales Green Party – Philip Davies – has resigned from his post and from the party following the passing of the ‘Zionism is racism’ motion at the Green Party of England and Wales’ autumn conference in Brighton.

The Greens passed a motion which described Zionism as an ethnonationalist political project and a racist ideology. It also called for the establishment of a single democratic Palestinian state with equal rights for all.

In his resignation statement, Davies made clear that the motion was “merely the final nail in the coffin”, before saying that it is one of three reasons for his departure.

Davies said: “We as a party have always supported Palestinian rights and been clear in our position that the Israeli state is committing a Genocide of the Palestinian people. This motion to me achieves nothing materially to help people in Palestine and by committing us to a single state solution act against one of our 4 pillars of Green Politics of Grassroots Democracy. It feels very imperialistic to me for us in the UK to be telling people in the middle east what their futures should look like. Much in the same way that as a proud Welshman I wouldn’t want people in England telling me what Wales future should look like.”

Alongside this, Davies said that he felt that Wales Green Party and his position as deputy leader were not sufficiently respected by the Green Party of England and Wales, and that the party lacked a “long-term strategy for gaining power”.

Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward

The post Wales Green Party deputy leader resigns over Zionism is racism motion appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Palestine Solidarity Campaign sends message of solidarity to Green Party over Zionism is racism motion

The Palestine Solidarity Campaign has sent a message of solidarity to the Green Party and its members following the party’s autumn conference voting to back a motion declaring Zionism to be a racist political ideology.

The motion passed by the conference saw the Green Party describe Zionism as an ethnonationalist political project and explicitly endorse the creation of a single Palestinian state with equal rights for all.

In their statement, Palestine Solidarity Campaign said that it “extends its solidarity to the Green Party of England and Wales and its members who are facing a barrage of media smears and abuse following their democratic conference decision to pass the ‘Zionism is Racism’ motion.”

The statement also explicitly endorsed a number of the elements of the motion. It read: “The motion supports the call from Palestinian civil society to impose boycotts, divestment and sanctions against Israel similar to those applied to apartheid South Africa and calls for the release of all Palestinian political prisoners, the de-proscription of Palestine Action and the release of all those currently imprisoned in Britain for nonviolent direct action in support of Palestinian rights – all of which we fully endorse.”

Later in the statement, Palestine Solidarity Campaign made the case for the party adopting an explicitly anti-Zionist position. The group said: “Critics of the Green Party motion have stated that Zionism is nothing more than the desire for self-determination for Jewish people. That is just not true. Zionism as a political project has been used to justify over a century of Palestinian dispossession and continues to underpin Israel’s genocide in Gaza today.”

It continued: “Palestine was never ‘a land without a people.’ Zionism’s founding ideology and political movement entailed the violent colonisation of Palestine and the establishment of a ‘Jewish state’ by removing or eliminating the indigenous Palestinian population from some or all of their homeland. Since its creation, consecutive Israeli governments have enacted a raft of policies that aim to take control of the maximum amount of land with the minimum number of Palestinians, denying their fundamental rights. No other interpretation is consistent with the history and reality of Zionism. Anti-Zionism is our opposition to that project and support for the rights of the Palestinian people. 

“Any political project that relies on ethnic cleansing, settler-colonialism and the imposition of a system of apartheid, which Zionism fundamentally does, and which is responsible for genocide, is self-evidently racist. We welcome the decision of Green Party conference to declare this truth.”

However, Palestine Solidarity Campaign stopped short of backing the Green Party’s support for a single Palestinian state. The group said: “PSC is an anti-Zionist organisation. As a solidarity campaign, it is our core aim to support the Palestinian struggle for freedom and justice – to end the systems of oppression that prevent the Palestinian people from realising their inalienable rights, including their right to self-determination and right of return. Our longstanding policy, shaped in dialogue with our Palestinian partners, is that it is for the Palestinian people as a whole, rather than the solidarity movement in Britain, to decide what form Palestinian self-determination should take, but this does not diminish our opposition to Zionism.”

Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward

The post Palestine Solidarity Campaign sends message of solidarity to Green Party over Zionism is racism motion appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Zack Polanski’s full statement following Zionism is racism motion passing at Green Party conference

Members of the Green Party voted for a motion this weekend which described Zionism as ethnonationalist political project and a racist ideology. Alongside this, the motion also committed the party to advocate for the creation of a single democratic Palestinian state with equal rights for all.

55 per cent of attendees at the party’s autumn conference in Brighton backed the motion, with 45 per cent voting against it.

That decision has – as you might expect – attracted substantial media attention and public debate.

Criticism of the position has primarily centred around suggestions that it is antisemitic in nature, and that it brands substantial portions of British Jews – two thirds of whom describe themselves as Zionist according to opinion polls – as racist. Proponents of the motion deny this, making the case that the motion refers only to the political ideology of Zionism, that not all Jews are Zionists, and that opposing Zionism is not in itself antisemitic.

Following the passing of the motion, the party’s leadership team and MPs released a statement which read: “As Greens, we will always uphold universal human rights. We will never tolerate any form of discrimination or harassment.

“We will continue to stand in opposition to genocide, ethnic cleansing, apartheid and the illegal occupation. We will continue to call out the heinous crimes of the Netanyahu government.

“And we will continue to work to ensure that the Green Party is an anti-racist party in every way. We know there is no conflict between supporting the rights of Palestinians and the rights of Jewish people.”

Since then, the Green Party leader Zack Polanski has released an additional statement. That statement reads in full:

“Antisemitism and criticism of the Israeli state are, and must always be, completely distinct – blurring the line between the two is not only wrong but antisemitic, and makes Jewish people less safe. It’s our role as a movement for justice to protect both the rights of Palestinians and our Jewish communities here in the UK. As leader I will not accept any exclusion, or refusal to engage with anyone, because of the religious or communal body they are part of.

“I take seriously my responsibility to make sure everyone feels safe and welcome in our party. Under my leadership, no-one will be made unwelcome because of their background, their faith, or where they worship. As leader, my role is to bring people together and ensure we are all working in unity for the things we believe in and care about: freedom and safety for all.

“I am proud of our party’s principled position on fighting for freedom and justice for Palestinians.

“In the UK and across the world people have been horrified by the atrocities carried out by the Israeli government in Gaza – with a classroom of children being killed every day.

“Through the Green Party’s unified stance and dedicated pressure, we have begun to shift this government away from its complicity with the Israeli government’s atrocities in Gaza, with the Foreign Secretary now taking the long overdue step of ending trade with illegal settlements.

“When I was elected leader of the Green Party of England and Wales, I was so proud to stand as a Jewish party leader, side by side with my deputy leaders Mothin and Rachel. Together, we exemplify everything this party stands for: we come from different backgrounds, faiths and traditions, but we share our deeply held values of compassion, fairness and equality for all.”

Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward

The post Zack Polanski’s full statement following Zionism is racism motion passing at Green Party conference appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Anti-Zionist and pro-nuclear: Inside Green Party conference

Just a few short years ago, Green Party conference attracted very little interest from the media. This year was very, very different.

What’s changed? First, the Greens now have five MPs, more than 200,000 members and a poll rating that is rarely out of double digits.

Second, because of a motion proposed to the conference titled ‘Zionist is racism’. The motion – which was unsurprisingly highly contentious – called for the party to formally condemn Zionism as a racist ideology and to explicitly endorse a ‘one-state solution’; ie. the creation of a single Palestinian state. 

As you might expect, that motion – which went to the vote on Sunday – dominated much of the conversation throughout the event. Supporters argued that it was the natural conclusion of the party’s position on Palestine. Opponents made the case that adopting this position would alienate parts of the electorate and undermine the party’s ability to be taken seriously as a fierce advocate for Palestinian liberation (see our breakdown of all the arguments here).

Ultimately, the motion passed, with 55% of members in favour and 45% against. Arguably more important than the raw numbers, though, is the rifts within the party that the debate exposed. 

Much of the party’s establishment was opposed to the motion – at least in its unamended form.

On the eve of the vote, three of the party’s five MPs released statements seeking to stop the motion passing. On the day, Ellie Chowns MP and the former Green MP Caroline Lucas spoke against the motion. Hannah Spencer was the only current or former Green MP to stay silent on the whole affair.

Zack Polanski – the party leader – said he wanted to see two amendments to the motion pass – one to safeguard Jews from disciplinary action for membership of synagogues affiliated to denominations that describe themselves as Zionist, and another to remove the explicit commitment to a one-state solution (neither of which passed). 

Rachel Millward, one of the party’s two deputy leaders said in advance of the vote that she couldn’t back it without those amendments passing. On the other hand, her fellow deputy Mothin Ali spoke in favour of the motion during the debate.

Despite these disagreements, the whole leadership team released a joint statement alongside all the Green MPs following the motion passing. That statement included the lines: “We will continue to stand in opposition to genocide, ethnic cleansing, apartheid and the illegal occupation. We will continue to call out the heinous crimes of the Netanyahu government. And we will continue to work to ensure that the Green Party is an anti-racist party in every way.”

The ramifications of the motion for the Greens are as of yet unclear. Without doubt, it has generated far more media interest than the party has ever had outside of a general election campaign. In a fast-moving news cycle and with Tory party conference also kicking off today, it’s possible it could fall out of the public memory fairly quickly. It’s also possible that it could be high on voters’ minds in the upcoming Holborn and St Pancras by-election, where Polanski is the Greens’ candidate – and could influence how they intend to vote. (Incidentally, the polling expert John Curtice told the conference that the by-election was a substantial challenge for the party).  

Despite much of the focus being on the Greens’ stance on Zionism, there was one other hugely consequential motion the party backed at its conference. That was the decision by members to abandon the party’s longstanding opposition to nuclear energy. The motion passing now sees the party describe nuclear energy as ‘low carbon’ and has led the party ditching its commitment to phase it out. 

The gravity of this shift in the Greens’ policy shouldn’t be understated. Previous attempts to change the party’s stance on nuclear have repeatedly been defeated, often by huge margins. If the party’s position on this can change so drastically, what’s next?

On the basis of these two motions alone, this conference may well go down as one of the most significant in the party’s history. 

And outside of the big policy debates, there was a whole lot of other things that went down. Here’s the full rundown: 

The interviews

The motions

The speeches

The rest

The stuff that’s still to come

We’re not quite done yet! We’ve still got one more interview to publish – with former North of Tyne mayor Jamie Driscoll. 

We’re proud to have provided some of the most comprehensive coverage of TUC Congress, Labour conference and Green Party conference of any media outlet in the UK. But this reporting doesn’t come cheap.

If you haven’t already done so, please consider chipping in and donating today to help fund our conference season coverage.

Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward

The post Anti-Zionist and pro-nuclear: Inside Green Party conference appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

This is the full statement from Green Party MPs and leaders on Zionism is racism motion

The Green Party’s five MPs, leader and deputy leaders have all released a statement following the Green Party’s autumn conference passing the ‘Zionism is racism’ is motion.

The full statement reads: “As Greens, we will always uphold universal human rights. We will never tolerate any form of discrimination or harassment.

“We will continue to stand in opposition to genocide, ethnic cleansing, apartheid and the illegal occupation. We will continue to call out the heinous crimes of the Netanyahu government.

“And we will continue to work to ensure that the Green Party is an anti-racist party in every way. We know there is no conflict between supporting the rights of Palestinians and the rights of Jewish people.”

The statement is signed by:

  • Zack Polanski (Green Party leader)
  • Rachel Maskell (Green Party deputy leader)
  • Mothin Ali (Green Party deputy leader)
  • Sian Berry MP
  • Ellie Chowns MP
  • Carla Denyer MP
  • Adrian Ramsay MP
  • Hannah Spencer MP

A separate statement was also released by a Green Party spokesperson following the vote. It read: “Speaking following the motion passing, a Green Party spokesperson said: “This has been a serious and deeply felt debate within our membership. Our members value the ability to bring forward and decide party policy, and conference has now made its decision.

“The Green Party is an anti-racist party and has consistently opposed the illegal occupation of both Palestinian and Syrian land, called for an end to arms sales to the Israeli government and spoken out fearlessly about the devastating situation in Gaza and the West Bank. Those positions remain central to our approach. So too does our deeply held commitment to equality, justice and human rights for all and opposition to racism in all its forms.”

Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward

The post This is the full statement from Green Party MPs and leaders on Zionism is racism motion appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Green Party abandons opposition to nuclear power

The Green Party has voted through a new policy on electricity generation which abandons the its blanket opposition to nuclear power.

Party members voted for a motion at the party’s conference which amended the party’s policy so as to describe nuclear fission as a form of ‘low-carbon electricity generation’. It also removed nuclear power from the list of electricity generation sources that the Green Party would seek to ‘phase out’. Instead, the party says it now only seeks to phase out fossil fuels.

The Green Party has long opposed nuclear power, instead favouring an approach to decarbonisation which relies on a rapid and overwhelming shift to renewable energy.

The party’s previous policy stated “Other industries can never be sustainable and must be phased out, for example, the nuclear industry.”

That wording has been changed, so it now refers to fossil fuels instead of nuclear.

Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward

The post Green Party abandons opposition to nuclear power appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Green Party votes for ‘Zionism is racism’ motion

Members of the Green Party of England and Wales have voted to brand Zionism a racist ideology following a heated debate at the party’s autumn conference in Brighton. The motion was carried with a relatively narrow margin – 1,022 votes in favour and 813 votes against. That’s 55 per cent of votes in favour, and 45 per cent against.

The motion begins with a definition of Zionism: “a political ideology which called for the creation – and, now it exists, the continuity – of an ethnonationalist Jewish State in historic Palestine to the exclusion and/or domination of the non-Jewish population.”

It then continues by arguing: “The real, material manifestation of Zionism has been the historic and ongoing dehumanisation, displacement, dispossession, disenfranchisement and destruction of Palestinians. This is based upon European settler-colonial systems of domination and oppression, which has also created racial hierarchies between Jews of different ethnicities in Palestine.”

Alongside this, the motion commits the Green Party to supporting a ‘one-state solution’. The motion will see the Greens support: “the establishment of a single democratic Palestinian State in all of historic Palestine with Jerusalem as its capital, equal rights for all, and the right of return for Palestinians and their descendants.”

In advance of the conference, the motion’s proposer Lubna Speitan told LFF: “This motion is merely a means of identifying the root cause of the problem, which is the racist ideology of Zionism – a settler colonial ideology – and its practice, which is resulting now in our erasure. Under Israel, Palestinians do not have rights. There is no such thing as equal rights under Israel’s boot. What we are asking for is for our mere basic human rights to be acknowledged.”

The motion has been highly contentious within the Green Party. In advance of the motion being debated, three Green MPs released public statements seeking to stop it from passing.

The party’s leadership were divided on the motion, with deputy leader Mothin Ali supporting it, but the party’s other deputy leader Rachel Millward, alongside leader Zack Polanski publicly calling for the motion to be amended in order to protect Jewish members from facing disciplinary action for being members of synagogues that are affiliated to Zionist denominations and to remove the commitment to a one-state solution.

The main amendment to remove the commitment to a one-state solution was rejected with 742 votes against and 695 in favour of those attending the conference either in person or remotely. However, the amendment went to a ‘card vote’ which means that members who aren’t able to attend conference and have given their proxy vote to another member who is able to attend are also able to participate in the vote. On the card vote, there were 920 votes against, and 821 in favour.

The amendment designed to explicitly state that the motion would be used to to take disciplinary action for membership of Jewish organisations that describe themselves as Zionist was defeated by 1,026 votes to 684 on a card vote. That amendment sought to add text into the motion which read: “This motion shall not be used to pressure, proscribe or discipline members based on affiliation with Jewish community institutions, such as synagogues, community centres or denominational groups, that describe themselves as Zionist or used to discipline or sanction Jewish members for expressing views that would be non sanctionable if expressed by non Jewish members such as (such as support for a binational state, or two state solution).”

Opponents of the amendment argued that it was unnecessary, as the motion did not relate to disciplinary processes, and therefore could not be used to discipline members.

Green Party MP Ellie Chowns – who is the party’s foreign affairs spokesperson in the House of Commons – spoke against the motion in the debate, as did the anti-Brexit campaigner Femi Oluwole and the former Green Party MP Caroline Lucas.

Mothin Ali was the most high profile person within the party to speak in favour of the motion.

Speaking following the motion passing, a Green Party spokesperson said: “This has been a serious and deeply felt debate within our membership. Our members value the ability to bring forward and decide party policy, and conference has now made its decision.

“The Green Party is an anti-racist party and has consistently opposed the illegal occupation of both Palestinian and Syrian land, called for an end to arms sales to the Israeli government and spoken out fearlessly about the devastating situation in Gaza and the West Bank. Those positions remain central to our approach. So too does our deeply held commitment to equality, justice and human rights for all and opposition to racism in all its forms.”

Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward

The post Green Party votes for ‘Zionism is racism’ motion appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Natalie Bennett interview: Andy Burnham is ‘kicking electoral reform into the long grass’ with National Commission

Former Green Party leader, Natalie Bennett, has said that Andy Burnham establishing a national commission on electoral reform “is a classic government kicking into the long grass scenario”.

Baroness Bennett said a Royal Commission might be necessary to ensure support for electoral reform within the Labour Party, but that it will delay electoral reform for the country.

She said the country needs PR before the next election, adding: “We are now in political crisis” due to the “enormous” level of distrust in politics in the UK. 

Burnham has ruled out changing the voting system before the next election, on the basis that the pledge wasn’t included in Labour’s 2024 general election manifesto.

“We have a Royal Commission and it drags on and we’re here at the next election, and then after the next election, who knows what’s happened,” she said.

The Green peer compared establishing a National Commission to launching an inquiry. “We’ve created an inquiry, put it in that context, how many things have we kicked into the long grass by doing that over the years. In the last century there must be hundreds.”

Bennett said she couldn’t see a national commission on voting reform taking less than 18 months, adding “and that’s at an absolute minimum”.  

“That’s really getting your skates on, appointing people, resourcing it incredibly well, having someone who has the will to operate really really quickly,” she said.

Bennett added that it would likely take two years, by which point it will be the next election. 

Bennett told LFF that she still backs abolishing the House of Lords and making the chamber fully elected, however, she is in favour of the government prioritising changing the voting system first.

“I think my focus would be, because it’s the most important thing, to get PR in the Commons,” she said.

“If you did that, it does make the House of Lords less important in that there would be a very powerful moral force that say the Lords doesn’t overturn what people were elected on,” Bennett added.

Asked about how Burnham’s government is doing so far, Bennett said: “He’s said some vaguely leftist popular things, he hasn’t delivered any of them.”

She backed Polanski’s message in his speech “Vote Green and move the Labour Party”, and said that the Green Party should be in the next government.

A YouGov MRP poll last month indicated that if a general election were held tomorrow, there would be a hung Parliament, with Labour estimated to win 241 seats. 

Bennett said that the Greens would consider entering a coalition with Labour, “If it was needed to stop Reform and the Tories, we would certainly do whatever we could.”

Olivia Barber is a reporter at Left Foot Forward

The post Natalie Bennett interview: Andy Burnham is ‘kicking electoral reform into the long grass’ with National Commission appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Exclusive: LGBT Greens protest Green Party women’s group platforming of gender-critical speaker at conference event

Green LGBTQ activists have disrupted a Green Party women’s event after they platformed a gender-critical speaker.

Green Party Women organised an event at conference this morning about pelvic health, with physiotherapist and gender critical activist Elaine Miller as keynote speaker. 

While the session was underway, a group of around 15 Green Party members from groups including LGBTIQA+ Greens and Greens Organise silently entered the room holding a long trans banner. 

The protest comes after another gender-critical group, Green Women’s Declaration, were banned from attending this year’s Green Party Conference. 

A woman from Green Party Women, who called herself Babs, walked over to the group and told them to leave.

She could be heard saying to the protesters: “You are right-wing authoritarians and you need to get the f*** out.”

Babs also shouted: “Men men men.”

She later told LFF that the protesters were “authoritarians” because “they’ve come into a women’s space to cause trouble and they’re trying to impose their views on us”.

Reade Layton, a member of the Trans Greens committee, said that the group was protesting because Miller is “a very loud TERF [Trans Exclusionary Radical Feminist]”. 

During a Gender Recognition Reform debate in the Scottish Parliament, Miller lifted her skirt and flashed MSPs, revealing what appeared to be fake pubic hair.

The bill sought to lower the age limit for applications for a gender recognition certificate from 18 to 16.

Miller, who opposed the bill, staged the protest in the public gallery in December 2023, saying: “If you will not be decent, then I will be indecent.”

Layton said: “We have no problem with the topic of the event, we have an issue with the group platforming Elaine Miller.”

Dylan Lewis-Creser, a member of the Green Party Executive, called women’s pelvic health “a very important topic”, adding “we support all discussions on women’s health, but we shouldn’t be platforming people like Elaine Miller”.

Lewis-Creser said that “They’re framing it as a women’s rights issue but it’s just about demeaning trans people and creating a more hostile environment.”

Hannah Collison, a Green member in Sheffield, said that “The Green Party is an inclusive space and makes a point of including all trans people in that inclusive space.”

She said that, by contrast, Green Party Women “are known to be transphobic and exclusionary”. 

Collison alleged that a member of Green Party Women pushed her and shouted at her. 

She said that the group had planned to walk silently to the front of the room with the banner and then leave, but that they were blocked from passing. 

Security removed the protesters from the meeting, citing safety grounds.

Olivia Barber is a reporter at Left Foot Forward

The post Exclusive: LGBT Greens protest Green Party women’s group platforming of gender-critical speaker at conference event appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Equity launches network of local councillors to support arts and entertainment at Green Party conference

Performing arts and entertainment trade union Equity has launched a new network of local councillors to support the arts and entertainment sectors. The union launched the network at the Green Party’s autumn conference in Brighton.

Equity says that “local government has a vital role to play in sustaining creative communities”, and that “local authority funding for arts and culture across Britain has fallen by 55 per cent since 2010”.

Speaking at the launch, which was attended by dozens of Greens in local government, including the elected mayor of Lewisham Liam Shrivastava and the mayor of Lambeth Paul Valentine, Equity’s general secretary Paul W Fleming said: “We have faced the same struggles as every other part of the economy over the last 15 years. We see local authorities in particular having been cut and cut and cut, and arts and culture being very much [at the] front of the firing line.”

He continued by highlighting the impact this has had on his union’s members, telling the event: “We’ve seen a 40 per cent reduction in the amount of work in subsidised theatre since 2017 – an extraordinary plummet in those opportunities to work – but also in the pay they receive in an incredibly precarious, overwhelmingly freelance workforce.”

Fleming would go on to say that Equity was launching the councillors network in order to “identify where we’ve got critical masses of support to keep venues open, to give subsidy, and to ensure that our members can have a more stable and productive working life.”

The launch was also addressed by one of the Green Party’s deputy leaders Rachel Millward.

She told the meeting: “There’s something intrinsic about creativity as being part of humanity that we need to really keep centred all the time”, before adding: “Let’s keep centring arts and culture. I think it’s part of our critical infrastructure, part of what’s important to communities.”

Millward would go on to say to Equity: “Thanks so much for setting up this network. It’s great for us always to learn from each other as councillors to think how can we try to save our arts spaces”.

Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward

Image credit: MrsEds – Creative Commons


The post Equity launches network of local councillors to support arts and entertainment at Green Party conference appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Green MPs make last-ditch attempt to stop Zionism is Racism motion

Green Party MPs have made a last ditch attempt to stop the Zionism is Racism passing at Green Party Conference. The vote on the motion is expected to take place tomorrow (Sunday 4 October).

The motion begins with a definition of Zionism: “a political ideology which called for the creation – and, now it exists, the continuity – of an ethnonationalist Jewish State in historic Palestine to the exclusion and/or domination of the non-Jewish population.”

It then continues by arguing: “The real, material manifestation of Zionism has been the historic and ongoing dehumanisation, displacement, dispossession, disenfranchisement and destruction of Palestinians. This is based upon European settler-colonial systems of domination and oppression, which has also created racial hierarchies between Jews of different ethnicities in Palestine.”

The motion has been highly contentious within the party. Advocates have argued that the motion is the natural conclusion of the party’s existing policies on Palestine and that it would commit the party to an explicitly anti-Zionist position. Opponents argue that it risks alienating large sections of the electorate, could see Jewish members facing disciplinary action for being members of synagogues that are affiliated to denominations which describe themselves as Zionist, and that as it commits the Green Party to a ‘one-state solution’ rather than allowing the Palestinian people to determine which solution they wish to negotiate with Israel.

Three Green MPs have released statements opposing the motion – at least in its current form.

Green MP Adrian Ramsay’s statement reads “We need to be crystal clear as a party that we stand with the ordinary people of Palestine and Israel, and with Jews and Muslims in the UK, many of whom feel unsafe after multiple attacks on their communities.” Elsewhere, he said that he would be voting against the motion on the basis that it went against the Greens’ long-held principles on Palestine.

Carla Denyer – who previously co-led the party with Ramsay – similarly said she was opposed to the motion. In her statement, she said: “In this party, I know we are united in tackling the ongoing and enduring injustices in Gaza and across Palestine. I am proud of the Green Party’s culture of robust political debate coupled with a drive to build positive consensus, so I am confident that it would be possible for us to come to a position and write a motion that addresses the concerns that I and others have raised, while strengthening our support for Palestinian liberation. sadly I do not think this motion is it.”

Sian Berry – the Green MP for Brighton Pavilion – released a statement calling for the motion to be ‘referred back’. Referring a motion back means that conference does not take a vote on the motion, and instead agrees for the proposers to look at it again, revise it, and bring it back to a future conference.

The party’s other two MPs – Ellie Chowns and Hannah Spencer – have not released a statement on the issue at the time of writing. LFF understands, however, that Chowns does not want the motion to pass.

The motion has also divided the party leadership. One of the party’s deputy leaders Mothin Ali has said he will vote for the motion. The other deputy, Rachel Millward, has said that she would not be voting for it unamended. The Green Party’s leader Zack Polanski has said he’s backing two amendments – one around protecting Jews’ membership of synagogues, and the other which would remove the commitment to support a single Palestinian state.

Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward

Image credit: UK Parliament – Creative Commons

The post Green MPs make last-ditch attempt to stop Zionism is Racism motion appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

❌
❌