Normal view
-
Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate
- Why John Healey should prioritise the arts in the budget
Why John Healey should prioritise the arts in the budget
Tom Peters is Head of Policy & Public Affairs at Equity
The 1997 Labour government brought about something of a golden age in public support for the arts. Then culture secretary Chris Smith MP, with the help of a young special adviser called Andy Burnham, began to increase the Arts Council England’s grants budget substantially every year. It was nearly twice the size when Burnham was himself appointed secretary of state for culture a decade later.
It is often heard among the arts sector today that such a big investment was an anomaly. That our industries were the passive beneficiaries of a period of unprecedented growth, which provided lots of cash for ‘nice to haves’. But now there are too many other priorities and too few resources to consider the arts.
The pessimists have short memories. Chancellor Healey, our eighth in ten years, would do well to ask his new boss in No.10 why it was that he was so committed to investing in the arts in his early political career and what the last Labour government felt our creative industries could contribute. The new prime minister’s reply might address three themes.
First, the arts are a producer of growth, not just a product of it. In 2022, the UK arts sector alone contributed £49billion GVA to our economy. Every creative job generates an additional two jobs in the local area over twenty years. The Society of London Theatre finds that every £1 spent on theatre generates £1.40 in the local economy. Our film and TV workforce attracts £7bn in inward investment and generates £1bn at the UK box office. Creative industry exports are worth £60bn. A government seeking growth cannot ignore the role that arts and entertainment investment plays in delivering it.
The government is not just seeking growth however, but ‘growth in every post code’. The last Labour government recognised the critical role that the arts could play in driving devolution, through regional creative industries policies, the Regional Development Agencies, screen agencies and Arts Council England. Over the period, the arts became an important medium for the transfer of power and decision-making away from Westminster and national recognition for the full diversity of places and cultures across the UK.
The expansion of strategic authorities today and the inclusion of ‘culture’ within their competencies presents an opportunity to progress this project further. Strategic authorities should have a greater role in coordinating and developing their arts and entertainment economies, drawing Arts Council England grant spending, local government arts funding, support for Culture Priority Places, local jobs plans, and Public Service Broadcasting investment together into a coherent economic framework. One that would generate jobs through increased artistic production and offer more opportunity for local people to see themselves reflected in cultural life. Decent arts provision was once devolution’s forerunner and should now be so again.
Finally, the last Labour government recognised that public support for the arts could help to realise social policy objectives, whether through economic regeneration, tackling social exclusion, strengthening community bonds or fostering diverse local cultures and pride of place. Though the far-right’s recent precipitous rise appears to have plateaued for now, the drivers of their support, and the threat that they pose to our social fabric, have not gone away. The arts has a role here, in revitalising economically depressed areas, providing a new focus for communities to rally around and offering a chance for all to share in the cultures and experiences of others. This seems more important now than ever.
Each of these themes has been tried and tested by the previous Labour governments in which Andy Burnham served. The academic analyses are already published and the evidence bases built. So next time the chancellor asks colleagues in No.11 why he should prioritise the arts in his budget, perhaps the best person to answer is the man living next door.
Image credit: Simon Dawson / Number 10 – Creative Commons
The post Why John Healey should prioritise the arts in the budget appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.
-
Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate
- We need a budget to save our shops, make work pay and tackle the cost of living crisis
We need a budget to save our shops, make work pay and tackle the cost of living crisis
Joanne Thomas is the general secretary of Usdaw
The UK economy continues to struggle after the legacy of an incompetent and chaotic Conservative government, which left us in a weak position to deal with global events. Tory and Lib Dem austerity, Boris’ bad Brexit deal and Liz Truss’ disastrous budget all contributed to leaving the UK economy vulnerable to the impact of conflicts across the world and climate change. We welcome the steps that Labour has already announced to help save our shops, tackle the cost of living crisis, help make work pay and reform Universal Credit, but there is still much more to do.
Usdaw members, who are key workers serving their communities, continue to suffer as a result of the cost of living. This is reflected in our most recent cost of living survey results from over 7,500 Usdaw members, highlighting a worrying number of low-income workers relying on unsecured loans to meet the cost of everyday essentials: 1 in 4 have struggled to pay everyday bills in the last 12 months and have had to rely on borrowing. A quarter of this was using unsecured borrowing such as payday loans or buy-now-pay-later services. 59% said financial worries are having an impact on their mental health.
Listening to our members’ very real experiences illustrates the scale of the problem: “We are in debt with essential household bills such as energy costs and council tax. We’re now stuck in a never-ending cycle of not being able to gain control of our debts, despite earning enough on paper, as we’re constantly chasing our tails and so overwhelmed”. “Wages stay the same, yet bills go up, food goes up; it makes it hard to be able to pay bills and for travel to work and then comfortably afford to buy a food shop”. “There’s no cushion. If something happened to my car, how would I get to work? I start at 5:30am and public transport doesn’t run that early. How would I pay to get it fixed? I’d have to spend £20 on a taxi to work knowing in my mind that my 5.5-hour shift has just been cut to 3.5 hours’ worth of pay because I’ve spent £25-£30 on transport. It’s a real worry”.
In the last 12 months, nearly a quarter of Usdaw members have had to cut back on heating or electricity use, as a result of financial pressures. With energy prices rising, we are extremely concerned that this pressure will be exacerbated and more low-income households will be forced to choose between heating or eating. We welcome the government’s action to cut VAT on electricity bills but we believe that this does not go far enough, nor is it sufficiently targeted. The government must put in place support for households facing energy debt and help with bills for those who need it most.
The Employment Rights Act will help make work pay and improve job security if delivered in full, and we will be looking to the chancellor to announce another substantial increase in minimum wage rates to reflect the cost of living and end rip-off youth pay. Usdaw has participated in the government’s review of paid parental leave, to help transform the support working parents receive, and we welcome the expansion of childcare provision delivered by Labour. We are calling for substantial reform of Universal Credit to build on the success of abolishing the two-child limit.
Job security is a key priority for our members. We support the government’s commitment to ‘growth in every postcode’ and the retail sector has a significant role to play in delivering this. We welcome the action the government has already taken in reducing business rates for pubs, clubs and live music venues. Alongside this, Labour has a manifesto commitment to level the playing field between the high street and online giants. So, confirmation from the chancellor that the government will be producing a high streets strategy is welcome, but it is essential that it is linked to the wider industrial strategy, including exempting large physical retail premises from the higher rates multiplier.
A fairer tax system is needed so that we can rebuild our public services without placing additional burdens on low-paid workers. There is strong public support for the wealthiest paying their fair share of tax. The freezing of thresholds until 2031 brings millions of workers and pensioners into either paying tax for the first time or increasing the amount they pay, putting more strain on low-income households. The government needs to take the impact of this into consideration and look at whether there are alternative ways to raise the much-needed funding for investment in our public services.
Times are too tough for too many and this needs to be a Budget that addresses the very real issues that impact workers. Pay, hours and job security are the real priorities for our members.
The post We need a budget to save our shops, make work pay and tackle the cost of living crisis appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.
-
Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate
- John Healey must use the budget to deliver breathing space, not just promise it
John Healey must use the budget to deliver breathing space, not just promise it
Daisy Cooper MP is deputy leader of the Liberal Democrats and the party’s treasury spokesperson
When Andy Burnham became prime minister in July, he said he wanted to give people breathing space. He was right to name the problem.
People are working harder, paying more in tax and getting less in return. For too many families, by the time the bills are paid and the essentials are covered, there is almost nothing left. Nothing for the little things that make life worth living: a pint in the pub with a mate, a takeaway with the kids, a coffee and cake in town, an ice cream on the beach.
None of this is extravagant. It’s normal life, and people who work hard should be able to afford it.
Tomorrow, the government faces its first big test. The budget will show whether that promise of breathing space means something, or whether it was just a good line.
A brutal double whammy
Families are facing rising bills and disappearing support at the same time. Energy costs are going up. So are petrol prices, and so is the cost of eating out.
Between January and March next year, the energy price cap is expected to rise. Fuel duty and rail fares are set to increase, and the Government’s cut to VAT on electricity bills could end.
That is the test. If the chancellor stands by while families are hit with another cost-of-living squeeze, his budget fails, whatever else is in it.
I’m not dismissing the long term. We must get Britain growing again. A stronger economy is how we raise living standards and bring down the cost of essentials like energy, travel, food and rent. But nobody can pay next month’s energy bill with the promise of growth over time. Growth is the long-term answer, but families need a short-term lifeline too.
So our message to the chancellor is simple. Don’t just promise breathing space. Deliver it.
What a ‘Breathing Space Budget’ looks like
The Liberal Democrats are calling for a £14 billion ‘Breathing Space Budget’. Over the next year and a half, it would save households £350 on average. It does three things: it cuts your energy bill, cuts the cost of travel, and cuts the cost of going out.
Energy. We would introduce an Essential Energy Guarantee, cutting average annual electricity and gas bills by £100. There would be additional support for households with children and disabled people, who so often face the toughest choices when the bills land.
Our high streets. We would cut hospitality VAT from 20% to 15% for the same period. That gives pubs, restaurants, and cafés room to keep prices down, protect jobs and stay open. It also makes a meal with the kids, a coffee with a friend, or a pint at the local a little more affordable. Anyone who has watched their local high street decline knows just what’s at stake.
Travel. For an initial three months, we would cut fuel duty by 10p, cut rail fares by 10%, introduce £1 bus fares and cut VAT on kerbside EV charging to 5%. We want public transport to be cheaper and easier to choose. But we also know not everyone has that choice. For millions of people, particularly outside our biggest towns and cities, leaving the car at home simply isn’t an option. They shouldn’t be left out of the help.
Fully funded, and paid for fairly
The Essential Energy Guarantee would be funded by clawing back excess support handed to monopoly energy operators and using that money to cut household bills instead.
The hospitality package would be funded by a one-off, time-limited windfall tax on the unexpected and unearned profits of the big banks.
The emergency travel package would be funded through additional Treasury receipts as petrol prices rise, triggered by Trumpflation.
A choice to act
This budget comes down to a choice. The chancellor can stand by while households and businesses are squeezed again, or the government can act. He can cut energy bills, cut the cost of travel, give our high streets a fighting chance, and give people something to look forward to at the end of the month. We’ve shown that it can be done and how to pay for it.
The prime minister promised breathing space. Tomorrow, the chancellor has the chance to deliver it and we Liberal Democrats have shown him how.
Image credit: Simon Dawson / Number 10 – Creative Commons
The post John Healey must use the budget to deliver breathing space, not just promise it appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.
-
Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate
- Jamie Driscoll interview: How the UK can make the economy work for everyone
Jamie Driscoll interview: How the UK can make the economy work for everyone
Jamie Driscoll served as Labour mayor of the North of Tyne from 2019 to 2024. Since then, he’s joined the Green Party and serves as a councillor on Newcastle City Council.
Since his election as a Green councillor, he’s been pushing for the Greens to up their game on economic policy. Part of this has been the release of a detailed new report – Hostage Nation – which seeks to make the case for a new approach to the economy.
LFF spoke to Driscoll at the Green Party’s autumn conference in Brighton about that report and his wider views on how Greens in local government can deliver transformative agendas in the context of more than a decade of austerity.
At the beginning of our conversation, Driscoll explained the underpinning issues the report seeks to address. He told LFF: “Pretty much everyone with any kind of social conscience knows we have serious problems with poverty – we have a housing crisis. Anyone who’s scientific literature knows that we are in a serious era of climate change.
“Yet we keep being told we haven’t got any money to build council houses, we’re going to have to wait for the market to sort us out on clean energy, we can’t build youth clubs or swimming pools anymore. So any idea of public luxury is out.
“And that’s told to us as if it’s scientific fact as if it’s a law of nature. The reality is we’ve got loads of money.”
He went on to argue that the UK government should be able to utilise the wealth that exists in the country to invest in public services and take the measures needed to address the climate emergency. Driscoll said: “There’s £70 billion a year goes in cash ISAs. We’ve got a pension pool of over two trillion in occupational pensions. Only 5 per cent of that is invested in British companies, and yet you get tax relief on it.
“So why don’t we just change it so that you can’t have tax relief for investing in silicon valley or fossil fuel exploration in the Middle East? If you want tax relief from British taxpayers, that money has to be invested in something socially useful for Britain – which is the building of council houses, retrofitting every home.”
He continued: “So if you went street by street and retrofitted every home in Britain, every pound you spend would get 40p back in tax immediately. And you can’t outsource this stuff. A crew of people working down Cedar Avenue in Leeds – that can’t be outsourced to a factory in China. So you crank the jobs, and if you crank the jobs, you’ve lowered the welfare bill.”
Some of the rhetoric that Driscoll uses is similar to that being used by the prime minister Andy Burnham. Burnham has spoken about ending neoliberalism, about bringing more control into the economy, and about not being ‘in hock’ to the bond markets.
What does Driscoll think of the early days of the Burnham government and its direction on the economy? He started his response by questioning the veracity of Labour leaders’ public rhetoric and pledges.
Driscoll told LFF: “I thought Keir Starmer’s 10 pledges were very good. I still think they’re good pledges. My opinion of Keir Starmer is somewhat different”.
He then continued: “How can you say we’ve got to get past this thing of being in hock to the bond markets and then say we will follow the fiscal rules?” before adding: “These are a political fiction not for managing the economy but for managing public opinion. If they’re going to lock themselves in a room and pretend they’re hostages then they’re not getting rid of neoliberalism.”
What should the Green Party do in light of Driscoll’s view that Burnham’s rhetoric doesn’t match reality?
Driscoll told LFF: “We should call it out. But you don’t call it out by saying that’s not ending neoliberalism because then the public will say ‘I don’t know what neoliberalism means’.
“So this is why you say look Andy, are you actually going to build 100,000 council houses every year? Are you going to make sure that everybody is on a living wage not a minimum wage? Anyone who’s serious about reducing the welfare budget has to get serious about structural wealth inequality.”
For the Greens, questions of national economic policy are – for now at least – a question of what concessions they can secure from the government, what they want to offer the electorate, and possibly what they would seek to deliver in the event they end up a partner in government after the next election.
But economic policy on a local level is a different matter entirely. The Greens are in sole or joint administration in dozens of councils across the country. In the context of more than a decade of austerity, rising costs of social care and temporary accommodation, and the reduction of economic levers at their disposal, delivering the kind of radical agenda Driscoll supports is a challenge.
He nonetheless thinks there are opportunities to utilise local government to improve people’s lives.
Driscoll told LFF: “The climate they’re operating in is extremely difficult, because not only is the financial effect of austerity on their services, on their staff extremely difficult, we’ve also stored up a huge amount of problems there. There are more people with mental ill health. There are more people who have been in financial distress for a much longer period of time. So the pressures are greater.”
He went on to say: “So you’ve got to be realistic. You are not going to build a people’s republic anywhere under the current financial system.
“That said, there are things you can do about engaging communities directly. There are things you can do about leaving money in. And there are still substantial budgets that are not procured in a way that either create the best possible jobs, the best environmental outcomes, or the best social outcomes”.
Driscoll would later add: “So it is about coming up with a manifesto and looking at the things that don’t cost a lot of money that at least signal that you’re doing the right things and will make people’s lives better. So it may be that there’s a park where the cafe’s been closed for ages – we’ll find a way to give that lease for peanuts to a local charity and get something out.”
Driscoll then argued that councils should be looking to bring public services back in house. He told LFF: “Perhaps you should be looking at a different procurement framework – if you are one of these councils that’s previously outsourced to Capita and the contract’s coming to an end, how are we actually going to not just roll that over again, how are we going to do some decent insourcing? Those are the kinds of things you can do.”
Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward
The post Jamie Driscoll interview: How the UK can make the economy work for everyone appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.
-
Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate
- Wales Green Party deputy leader resigns over Zionism is racism motion
Wales Green Party deputy leader resigns over Zionism is racism motion
One of the two deputy leaders of the Wales Green Party – Philip Davies – has resigned from his post and from the party following the passing of the ‘Zionism is racism’ motion at the Green Party of England and Wales’ autumn conference in Brighton.
The Greens passed a motion which described Zionism as an ethnonationalist political project and a racist ideology. It also called for the establishment of a single democratic Palestinian state with equal rights for all.
In his resignation statement, Davies made clear that the motion was “merely the final nail in the coffin”, before saying that it is one of three reasons for his departure.
Davies said: “We as a party have always supported Palestinian rights and been clear in our position that the Israeli state is committing a Genocide of the Palestinian people. This motion to me achieves nothing materially to help people in Palestine and by committing us to a single state solution act against one of our 4 pillars of Green Politics of Grassroots Democracy. It feels very imperialistic to me for us in the UK to be telling people in the middle east what their futures should look like. Much in the same way that as a proud Welshman I wouldn’t want people in England telling me what Wales future should look like.”
Alongside this, Davies said that he felt that Wales Green Party and his position as deputy leader were not sufficiently respected by the Green Party of England and Wales, and that the party lacked a “long-term strategy for gaining power”.
Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward
The post Wales Green Party deputy leader resigns over Zionism is racism motion appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.
-
Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate
- Palestine Solidarity Campaign sends message of solidarity to Green Party over Zionism is racism motion
Palestine Solidarity Campaign sends message of solidarity to Green Party over Zionism is racism motion
The Palestine Solidarity Campaign has sent a message of solidarity to the Green Party and its members following the party’s autumn conference voting to back a motion declaring Zionism to be a racist political ideology.
The motion passed by the conference saw the Green Party describe Zionism as an ethnonationalist political project and explicitly endorse the creation of a single Palestinian state with equal rights for all.
In their statement, Palestine Solidarity Campaign said that it “extends its solidarity to the Green Party of England and Wales and its members who are facing a barrage of media smears and abuse following their democratic conference decision to pass the ‘Zionism is Racism’ motion.”
The statement also explicitly endorsed a number of the elements of the motion. It read: “The motion supports the call from Palestinian civil society to impose boycotts, divestment and sanctions against Israel similar to those applied to apartheid South Africa and calls for the release of all Palestinian political prisoners, the de-proscription of Palestine Action and the release of all those currently imprisoned in Britain for nonviolent direct action in support of Palestinian rights – all of which we fully endorse.”
Later in the statement, Palestine Solidarity Campaign made the case for the party adopting an explicitly anti-Zionist position. The group said: “Critics of the Green Party motion have stated that Zionism is nothing more than the desire for self-determination for Jewish people. That is just not true. Zionism as a political project has been used to justify over a century of Palestinian dispossession and continues to underpin Israel’s genocide in Gaza today.”
It continued: “Palestine was never ‘a land without a people.’ Zionism’s founding ideology and political movement entailed the violent colonisation of Palestine and the establishment of a ‘Jewish state’ by removing or eliminating the indigenous Palestinian population from some or all of their homeland. Since its creation, consecutive Israeli governments have enacted a raft of policies that aim to take control of the maximum amount of land with the minimum number of Palestinians, denying their fundamental rights. No other interpretation is consistent with the history and reality of Zionism. Anti-Zionism is our opposition to that project and support for the rights of the Palestinian people.
“Any political project that relies on ethnic cleansing, settler-colonialism and the imposition of a system of apartheid, which Zionism fundamentally does, and which is responsible for genocide, is self-evidently racist. We welcome the decision of Green Party conference to declare this truth.”
However, Palestine Solidarity Campaign stopped short of backing the Green Party’s support for a single Palestinian state. The group said: “PSC is an anti-Zionist organisation. As a solidarity campaign, it is our core aim to support the Palestinian struggle for freedom and justice – to end the systems of oppression that prevent the Palestinian people from realising their inalienable rights, including their right to self-determination and right of return. Our longstanding policy, shaped in dialogue with our Palestinian partners, is that it is for the Palestinian people as a whole, rather than the solidarity movement in Britain, to decide what form Palestinian self-determination should take, but this does not diminish our opposition to Zionism.”
Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward
The post Palestine Solidarity Campaign sends message of solidarity to Green Party over Zionism is racism motion appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.
-
Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate
- Zack Polanski’s full statement following Zionism is racism motion passing at Green Party conference
Zack Polanski’s full statement following Zionism is racism motion passing at Green Party conference
Members of the Green Party voted for a motion this weekend which described Zionism as ethnonationalist political project and a racist ideology. Alongside this, the motion also committed the party to advocate for the creation of a single democratic Palestinian state with equal rights for all.
55 per cent of attendees at the party’s autumn conference in Brighton backed the motion, with 45 per cent voting against it.
That decision has – as you might expect – attracted substantial media attention and public debate.
Criticism of the position has primarily centred around suggestions that it is antisemitic in nature, and that it brands substantial portions of British Jews – two thirds of whom describe themselves as Zionist according to opinion polls – as racist. Proponents of the motion deny this, making the case that the motion refers only to the political ideology of Zionism, that not all Jews are Zionists, and that opposing Zionism is not in itself antisemitic.
Following the passing of the motion, the party’s leadership team and MPs released a statement which read: “As Greens, we will always uphold universal human rights. We will never tolerate any form of discrimination or harassment.
“We will continue to stand in opposition to genocide, ethnic cleansing, apartheid and the illegal occupation. We will continue to call out the heinous crimes of the Netanyahu government.
“And we will continue to work to ensure that the Green Party is an anti-racist party in every way. We know there is no conflict between supporting the rights of Palestinians and the rights of Jewish people.”
Since then, the Green Party leader Zack Polanski has released an additional statement. That statement reads in full:
“Antisemitism and criticism of the Israeli state are, and must always be, completely distinct – blurring the line between the two is not only wrong but antisemitic, and makes Jewish people less safe. It’s our role as a movement for justice to protect both the rights of Palestinians and our Jewish communities here in the UK. As leader I will not accept any exclusion, or refusal to engage with anyone, because of the religious or communal body they are part of.
“I take seriously my responsibility to make sure everyone feels safe and welcome in our party. Under my leadership, no-one will be made unwelcome because of their background, their faith, or where they worship. As leader, my role is to bring people together and ensure we are all working in unity for the things we believe in and care about: freedom and safety for all.
“I am proud of our party’s principled position on fighting for freedom and justice for Palestinians.
“In the UK and across the world people have been horrified by the atrocities carried out by the Israeli government in Gaza – with a classroom of children being killed every day.
“Through the Green Party’s unified stance and dedicated pressure, we have begun to shift this government away from its complicity with the Israeli government’s atrocities in Gaza, with the Foreign Secretary now taking the long overdue step of ending trade with illegal settlements.
“When I was elected leader of the Green Party of England and Wales, I was so proud to stand as a Jewish party leader, side by side with my deputy leaders Mothin and Rachel. Together, we exemplify everything this party stands for: we come from different backgrounds, faiths and traditions, but we share our deeply held values of compassion, fairness and equality for all.”
Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward
The post Zack Polanski’s full statement following Zionism is racism motion passing at Green Party conference appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.
-
Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate
- Anti-Zionist and pro-nuclear: Inside Green Party conference
Anti-Zionist and pro-nuclear: Inside Green Party conference
Just a few short years ago, Green Party conference attracted very little interest from the media. This year was very, very different.
What’s changed? First, the Greens now have five MPs, more than 200,000 members and a poll rating that is rarely out of double digits.
Second, because of a motion proposed to the conference titled ‘Zionist is racism’. The motion – which was unsurprisingly highly contentious – called for the party to formally condemn Zionism as a racist ideology and to explicitly endorse a ‘one-state solution’; ie. the creation of a single Palestinian state.
As you might expect, that motion – which went to the vote on Sunday – dominated much of the conversation throughout the event. Supporters argued that it was the natural conclusion of the party’s position on Palestine. Opponents made the case that adopting this position would alienate parts of the electorate and undermine the party’s ability to be taken seriously as a fierce advocate for Palestinian liberation (see our breakdown of all the arguments here).
Ultimately, the motion passed, with 55% of members in favour and 45% against. Arguably more important than the raw numbers, though, is the rifts within the party that the debate exposed.
Much of the party’s establishment was opposed to the motion – at least in its unamended form.
On the eve of the vote, three of the party’s five MPs released statements seeking to stop the motion passing. On the day, Ellie Chowns MP and the former Green MP Caroline Lucas spoke against the motion. Hannah Spencer was the only current or former Green MP to stay silent on the whole affair.
Zack Polanski – the party leader – said he wanted to see two amendments to the motion pass – one to safeguard Jews from disciplinary action for membership of synagogues affiliated to denominations that describe themselves as Zionist, and another to remove the explicit commitment to a one-state solution (neither of which passed).
Rachel Millward, one of the party’s two deputy leaders said in advance of the vote that she couldn’t back it without those amendments passing. On the other hand, her fellow deputy Mothin Ali spoke in favour of the motion during the debate.
Despite these disagreements, the whole leadership team released a joint statement alongside all the Green MPs following the motion passing. That statement included the lines: “We will continue to stand in opposition to genocide, ethnic cleansing, apartheid and the illegal occupation. We will continue to call out the heinous crimes of the Netanyahu government. And we will continue to work to ensure that the Green Party is an anti-racist party in every way.”
The ramifications of the motion for the Greens are as of yet unclear. Without doubt, it has generated far more media interest than the party has ever had outside of a general election campaign. In a fast-moving news cycle and with Tory party conference also kicking off today, it’s possible it could fall out of the public memory fairly quickly. It’s also possible that it could be high on voters’ minds in the upcoming Holborn and St Pancras by-election, where Polanski is the Greens’ candidate – and could influence how they intend to vote. (Incidentally, the polling expert John Curtice told the conference that the by-election was a substantial challenge for the party).
Despite much of the focus being on the Greens’ stance on Zionism, there was one other hugely consequential motion the party backed at its conference. That was the decision by members to abandon the party’s longstanding opposition to nuclear energy. The motion passing now sees the party describe nuclear energy as ‘low carbon’ and has led the party ditching its commitment to phase it out.
The gravity of this shift in the Greens’ policy shouldn’t be understated. Previous attempts to change the party’s stance on nuclear have repeatedly been defeated, often by huge margins. If the party’s position on this can change so drastically, what’s next?
On the basis of these two motions alone, this conference may well go down as one of the most significant in the party’s history.
And outside of the big policy debates, there was a whole lot of other things that went down. Here’s the full rundown:
The interviews
- Natalie Bennett interview: Andy Burnham is ‘kicking electoral reform into the long grass’ with National Commission – Olivia Barber
- Sadiq Khan has overseen people being ‘priced out of London boroughs’ – Green London Assembly member Benali Hamdache interview – Chris Jarvis
- I’m taking a “really hard stance against landlords” – Hackney mayor Zoë Garbett interview – Chris Jarvis
- Caroline Lucas interview: “A lot of policies that Andy Burnham has announced are due to Green pressure.” – Olivia Barber
The motions
- This is the full statement from Green Party MPs and leaders on Zionism is racism motion – Chris Jarvis
- Green Party abandons opposition to nuclear power – Chris Jarvis
- Green Party votes for ‘Zionism is racism’ motion – Chris Jarvis
- Green MPs make last-ditch attempt to stop Zionism is Racism motion – Chris Jarvis
- Green members vote for councils to support BDS in show of solidarity with Palestine – Olivia Barber
- Green Party votes to endorse Nature, Biodiversity and National Security Act – Chris Jarvis
- Green Party conference votes for new health policy to safeguard the NHS “against undue commercial influence” – Chris Jarvis
- Green Party backs policy to cut amount of animal farming in half – Chris Javis
- The Zionism is Racism motion has left the Greens with no good options – Lev Saul
- Rachel Millward “certainly wouldn’t” vote for unamended Zionism is Racism motion – Chris Jarvis
- The media is using the ‘Zionism is Racism’ conference motion to attack the Green Party, members say – Olivia Barber
- Will Green Party members vote to call Zionism racism? – Chris Jarvis
The speeches
- Mothin Ali calls for government to declare national emergency on racism and blasts Reform’s Suella Braverman in conference speech – Olivia Barber
- Green Party calls on government to nationalise water companies with no compensation for shareholders – Olivia Barber
- Water campaigners back Green Party’s ‘no-compensation’ public ownership plan for water firms – Chris Jarvis
- “Inspirational” and “everyone loved it” – Green Party members react to Zack Polanski’s conference speech – Chris Jarvis
- Wales Green Party leader celebrates “historic breakthrough” in Senedd election in message to Green Party conference – Chris Jarvis
- Zack Polanski calls on Labour to introduce three-year cap on private rent rises in conference speech – Olivia Barber
The rest
- Exclusive: LGBT Greens protest Green Party women’s group platforming of gender-critical speaker at conference event – Olivia Barber
- Equity launches network of local councillors to support arts and entertainment at Green Party conference – Chris Jarvis
- Demonstrators at conference rally against anti-Zionism have ‘extremist views’, says Green member – Olivia Barber
- ‘Labour made active decision to tax income rather than take on the richest in this country’, Faiza Shaheen says – Olivia Barber
- Polling guru John Curtice says it will be ‘substantial challenge’ for Greens to win Holborn and St Pancras amid Burnham bounce – Olivia Barber
- Green Party must ‘up its game’ on economic policy, Jamie Driscoll says – Chris Jarvis
The stuff that’s still to come
We’re not quite done yet! We’ve still got one more interview to publish – with former North of Tyne mayor Jamie Driscoll.
We’re proud to have provided some of the most comprehensive coverage of TUC Congress, Labour conference and Green Party conference of any media outlet in the UK. But this reporting doesn’t come cheap.
If you haven’t already done so, please consider chipping in and donating today to help fund our conference season coverage.
Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward
The post Anti-Zionist and pro-nuclear: Inside Green Party conference appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.
-
Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate
- This is the full statement from Green Party MPs and leaders on Zionism is racism motion
This is the full statement from Green Party MPs and leaders on Zionism is racism motion
The Green Party’s five MPs, leader and deputy leaders have all released a statement following the Green Party’s autumn conference passing the ‘Zionism is racism’ is motion.
The full statement reads: “As Greens, we will always uphold universal human rights. We will never tolerate any form of discrimination or harassment.
“We will continue to stand in opposition to genocide, ethnic cleansing, apartheid and the illegal occupation. We will continue to call out the heinous crimes of the Netanyahu government.
“And we will continue to work to ensure that the Green Party is an anti-racist party in every way. We know there is no conflict between supporting the rights of Palestinians and the rights of Jewish people.”
The statement is signed by:
- Zack Polanski (Green Party leader)
- Rachel Maskell (Green Party deputy leader)
- Mothin Ali (Green Party deputy leader)
- Sian Berry MP
- Ellie Chowns MP
- Carla Denyer MP
- Adrian Ramsay MP
- Hannah Spencer MP
A separate statement was also released by a Green Party spokesperson following the vote. It read: “Speaking following the motion passing, a Green Party spokesperson said: “This has been a serious and deeply felt debate within our membership. Our members value the ability to bring forward and decide party policy, and conference has now made its decision.
“The Green Party is an anti-racist party and has consistently opposed the illegal occupation of both Palestinian and Syrian land, called for an end to arms sales to the Israeli government and spoken out fearlessly about the devastating situation in Gaza and the West Bank. Those positions remain central to our approach. So too does our deeply held commitment to equality, justice and human rights for all and opposition to racism in all its forms.”
Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward
The post This is the full statement from Green Party MPs and leaders on Zionism is racism motion appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.
-
Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate
- Green Party abandons opposition to nuclear power
Green Party abandons opposition to nuclear power
The Green Party has voted through a new policy on electricity generation which abandons the its blanket opposition to nuclear power.
Party members voted for a motion at the party’s conference which amended the party’s policy so as to describe nuclear fission as a form of ‘low-carbon electricity generation’. It also removed nuclear power from the list of electricity generation sources that the Green Party would seek to ‘phase out’. Instead, the party says it now only seeks to phase out fossil fuels.
The Green Party has long opposed nuclear power, instead favouring an approach to decarbonisation which relies on a rapid and overwhelming shift to renewable energy.
The party’s previous policy stated “Other industries can never be sustainable and must be phased out, for example, the nuclear industry.”
That wording has been changed, so it now refers to fossil fuels instead of nuclear.
Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward
The post Green Party abandons opposition to nuclear power appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.
-
Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate
- Green Party votes for ‘Zionism is racism’ motion
Green Party votes for ‘Zionism is racism’ motion
Members of the Green Party of England and Wales have voted to brand Zionism a racist ideology following a heated debate at the party’s autumn conference in Brighton. The motion was carried with a relatively narrow margin – 1,022 votes in favour and 813 votes against. That’s 55 per cent of votes in favour, and 45 per cent against.
The motion begins with a definition of Zionism: “a political ideology which called for the creation – and, now it exists, the continuity – of an ethnonationalist Jewish State in historic Palestine to the exclusion and/or domination of the non-Jewish population.”
It then continues by arguing: “The real, material manifestation of Zionism has been the historic and ongoing dehumanisation, displacement, dispossession, disenfranchisement and destruction of Palestinians. This is based upon European settler-colonial systems of domination and oppression, which has also created racial hierarchies between Jews of different ethnicities in Palestine.”
Alongside this, the motion commits the Green Party to supporting a ‘one-state solution’. The motion will see the Greens support: “the establishment of a single democratic Palestinian State in all of historic Palestine with Jerusalem as its capital, equal rights for all, and the right of return for Palestinians and their descendants.”
In advance of the conference, the motion’s proposer Lubna Speitan told LFF: “This motion is merely a means of identifying the root cause of the problem, which is the racist ideology of Zionism – a settler colonial ideology – and its practice, which is resulting now in our erasure. Under Israel, Palestinians do not have rights. There is no such thing as equal rights under Israel’s boot. What we are asking for is for our mere basic human rights to be acknowledged.”
The motion has been highly contentious within the Green Party. In advance of the motion being debated, three Green MPs released public statements seeking to stop it from passing.
The party’s leadership were divided on the motion, with deputy leader Mothin Ali supporting it, but the party’s other deputy leader Rachel Millward, alongside leader Zack Polanski publicly calling for the motion to be amended in order to protect Jewish members from facing disciplinary action for being members of synagogues that are affiliated to Zionist denominations and to remove the commitment to a one-state solution.
The main amendment to remove the commitment to a one-state solution was rejected with 742 votes against and 695 in favour of those attending the conference either in person or remotely. However, the amendment went to a ‘card vote’ which means that members who aren’t able to attend conference and have given their proxy vote to another member who is able to attend are also able to participate in the vote. On the card vote, there were 920 votes against, and 821 in favour.
The amendment designed to explicitly state that the motion would be used to to take disciplinary action for membership of Jewish organisations that describe themselves as Zionist was defeated by 1,026 votes to 684 on a card vote. That amendment sought to add text into the motion which read: “This motion shall not be used to pressure, proscribe or discipline members based on affiliation with Jewish community institutions, such as synagogues, community centres or denominational groups, that describe themselves as Zionist or used to discipline or sanction Jewish members for expressing views that would be non sanctionable if expressed by non Jewish members such as (such as support for a binational state, or two state solution).”
Opponents of the amendment argued that it was unnecessary, as the motion did not relate to disciplinary processes, and therefore could not be used to discipline members.
Green Party MP Ellie Chowns – who is the party’s foreign affairs spokesperson in the House of Commons – spoke against the motion in the debate, as did the anti-Brexit campaigner Femi Oluwole and the former Green Party MP Caroline Lucas.
Mothin Ali was the most high profile person within the party to speak in favour of the motion.
Speaking following the motion passing, a Green Party spokesperson said: “This has been a serious and deeply felt debate within our membership. Our members value the ability to bring forward and decide party policy, and conference has now made its decision.
“The Green Party is an anti-racist party and has consistently opposed the illegal occupation of both Palestinian and Syrian land, called for an end to arms sales to the Israeli government and spoken out fearlessly about the devastating situation in Gaza and the West Bank. Those positions remain central to our approach. So too does our deeply held commitment to equality, justice and human rights for all and opposition to racism in all its forms.”
Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward
The post Green Party votes for ‘Zionism is racism’ motion appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.
-
Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate
- Natalie Bennett interview: Andy Burnham is ‘kicking electoral reform into the long grass’ with National Commission
Natalie Bennett interview: Andy Burnham is ‘kicking electoral reform into the long grass’ with National Commission
Former Green Party leader, Natalie Bennett, has said that Andy Burnham establishing a national commission on electoral reform “is a classic government kicking into the long grass scenario”.
Baroness Bennett said a Royal Commission might be necessary to ensure support for electoral reform within the Labour Party, but that it will delay electoral reform for the country.
She said the country needs PR before the next election, adding: “We are now in political crisis” due to the “enormous” level of distrust in politics in the UK.
Burnham has ruled out changing the voting system before the next election, on the basis that the pledge wasn’t included in Labour’s 2024 general election manifesto.
“We have a Royal Commission and it drags on and we’re here at the next election, and then after the next election, who knows what’s happened,” she said.
The Green peer compared establishing a National Commission to launching an inquiry. “We’ve created an inquiry, put it in that context, how many things have we kicked into the long grass by doing that over the years. In the last century there must be hundreds.”
Bennett said she couldn’t see a national commission on voting reform taking less than 18 months, adding “and that’s at an absolute minimum”.
“That’s really getting your skates on, appointing people, resourcing it incredibly well, having someone who has the will to operate really really quickly,” she said.
Bennett added that it would likely take two years, by which point it will be the next election.
Bennett told LFF that she still backs abolishing the House of Lords and making the chamber fully elected, however, she is in favour of the government prioritising changing the voting system first.
“I think my focus would be, because it’s the most important thing, to get PR in the Commons,” she said.
“If you did that, it does make the House of Lords less important in that there would be a very powerful moral force that say the Lords doesn’t overturn what people were elected on,” Bennett added.
Asked about how Burnham’s government is doing so far, Bennett said: “He’s said some vaguely leftist popular things, he hasn’t delivered any of them.”
She backed Polanski’s message in his speech “Vote Green and move the Labour Party”, and said that the Green Party should be in the next government.
A YouGov MRP poll last month indicated that if a general election were held tomorrow, there would be a hung Parliament, with Labour estimated to win 241 seats.
Bennett said that the Greens would consider entering a coalition with Labour, “If it was needed to stop Reform and the Tories, we would certainly do whatever we could.”
Olivia Barber is a reporter at Left Foot Forward
The post Natalie Bennett interview: Andy Burnham is ‘kicking electoral reform into the long grass’ with National Commission appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.
-
Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate
- Exclusive: LGBT Greens protest Green Party women’s group platforming of gender-critical speaker at conference event
Exclusive: LGBT Greens protest Green Party women’s group platforming of gender-critical speaker at conference event
Green LGBTQ activists have disrupted a Green Party women’s event after they platformed a gender-critical speaker.
Green Party Women organised an event at conference this morning about pelvic health, with physiotherapist and gender critical activist Elaine Miller as keynote speaker.
While the session was underway, a group of around 15 Green Party members from groups including LGBTIQA+ Greens and Greens Organise silently entered the room holding a long trans banner.
The protest comes after another gender-critical group, Green Women’s Declaration, were banned from attending this year’s Green Party Conference.
A woman from Green Party Women, who called herself Babs, walked over to the group and told them to leave.
She could be heard saying to the protesters: “You are right-wing authoritarians and you need to get the f*** out.”
Babs also shouted: “Men men men.”
She later told LFF that the protesters were “authoritarians” because “they’ve come into a women’s space to cause trouble and they’re trying to impose their views on us”.
Reade Layton, a member of the Trans Greens committee, said that the group was protesting because Miller is “a very loud TERF [Trans Exclusionary Radical Feminist]”.
During a Gender Recognition Reform debate in the Scottish Parliament, Miller lifted her skirt and flashed MSPs, revealing what appeared to be fake pubic hair.
The bill sought to lower the age limit for applications for a gender recognition certificate from 18 to 16.
Miller, who opposed the bill, staged the protest in the public gallery in December 2023, saying: “If you will not be decent, then I will be indecent.”
Layton said: “We have no problem with the topic of the event, we have an issue with the group platforming Elaine Miller.”
Dylan Lewis-Creser, a member of the Green Party Executive, called women’s pelvic health “a very important topic”, adding “we support all discussions on women’s health, but we shouldn’t be platforming people like Elaine Miller”.
Lewis-Creser said that “They’re framing it as a women’s rights issue but it’s just about demeaning trans people and creating a more hostile environment.”
Hannah Collison, a Green member in Sheffield, said that “The Green Party is an inclusive space and makes a point of including all trans people in that inclusive space.”
She said that, by contrast, Green Party Women “are known to be transphobic and exclusionary”.
Collison alleged that a member of Green Party Women pushed her and shouted at her.
She said that the group had planned to walk silently to the front of the room with the banner and then leave, but that they were blocked from passing.
Security removed the protesters from the meeting, citing safety grounds.
Olivia Barber is a reporter at Left Foot Forward
The post Exclusive: LGBT Greens protest Green Party women’s group platforming of gender-critical speaker at conference event appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.
-
Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate
- Equity launches network of local councillors to support arts and entertainment at Green Party conference
Equity launches network of local councillors to support arts and entertainment at Green Party conference
Performing arts and entertainment trade union Equity has launched a new network of local councillors to support the arts and entertainment sectors. The union launched the network at the Green Party’s autumn conference in Brighton.
Equity says that “local government has a vital role to play in sustaining creative communities”, and that “local authority funding for arts and culture across Britain has fallen by 55 per cent since 2010”.
Speaking at the launch, which was attended by dozens of Greens in local government, including the elected mayor of Lewisham Liam Shrivastava and the mayor of Lambeth Paul Valentine, Equity’s general secretary Paul W Fleming said: “We have faced the same struggles as every other part of the economy over the last 15 years. We see local authorities in particular having been cut and cut and cut, and arts and culture being very much [at the] front of the firing line.”
He continued by highlighting the impact this has had on his union’s members, telling the event: “We’ve seen a 40 per cent reduction in the amount of work in subsidised theatre since 2017 – an extraordinary plummet in those opportunities to work – but also in the pay they receive in an incredibly precarious, overwhelmingly freelance workforce.”
Fleming would go on to say that Equity was launching the councillors network in order to “identify where we’ve got critical masses of support to keep venues open, to give subsidy, and to ensure that our members can have a more stable and productive working life.”
The launch was also addressed by one of the Green Party’s deputy leaders Rachel Millward.
She told the meeting: “There’s something intrinsic about creativity as being part of humanity that we need to really keep centred all the time”, before adding: “Let’s keep centring arts and culture. I think it’s part of our critical infrastructure, part of what’s important to communities.”
Millward would go on to say to Equity: “Thanks so much for setting up this network. It’s great for us always to learn from each other as councillors to think how can we try to save our arts spaces”.
Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward
Image credit: MrsEds – Creative Commons
The post Equity launches network of local councillors to support arts and entertainment at Green Party conference appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.
-
Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate
- Green MPs make last-ditch attempt to stop Zionism is Racism motion
Green MPs make last-ditch attempt to stop Zionism is Racism motion
Green Party MPs have made a last ditch attempt to stop the Zionism is Racism passing at Green Party Conference. The vote on the motion is expected to take place tomorrow (Sunday 4 October).
The motion begins with a definition of Zionism: “a political ideology which called for the creation – and, now it exists, the continuity – of an ethnonationalist Jewish State in historic Palestine to the exclusion and/or domination of the non-Jewish population.”
It then continues by arguing: “The real, material manifestation of Zionism has been the historic and ongoing dehumanisation, displacement, dispossession, disenfranchisement and destruction of Palestinians. This is based upon European settler-colonial systems of domination and oppression, which has also created racial hierarchies between Jews of different ethnicities in Palestine.”
The motion has been highly contentious within the party. Advocates have argued that the motion is the natural conclusion of the party’s existing policies on Palestine and that it would commit the party to an explicitly anti-Zionist position. Opponents argue that it risks alienating large sections of the electorate, could see Jewish members facing disciplinary action for being members of synagogues that are affiliated to denominations which describe themselves as Zionist, and that as it commits the Green Party to a ‘one-state solution’ rather than allowing the Palestinian people to determine which solution they wish to negotiate with Israel.
Three Green MPs have released statements opposing the motion – at least in its current form.
Green MP Adrian Ramsay’s statement reads “We need to be crystal clear as a party that we stand with the ordinary people of Palestine and Israel, and with Jews and Muslims in the UK, many of whom feel unsafe after multiple attacks on their communities.” Elsewhere, he said that he would be voting against the motion on the basis that it went against the Greens’ long-held principles on Palestine.
Carla Denyer – who previously co-led the party with Ramsay – similarly said she was opposed to the motion. In her statement, she said: “In this party, I know we are united in tackling the ongoing and enduring injustices in Gaza and across Palestine. I am proud of the Green Party’s culture of robust political debate coupled with a drive to build positive consensus, so I am confident that it would be possible for us to come to a position and write a motion that addresses the concerns that I and others have raised, while strengthening our support for Palestinian liberation. sadly I do not think this motion is it.”
Sian Berry – the Green MP for Brighton Pavilion – released a statement calling for the motion to be ‘referred back’. Referring a motion back means that conference does not take a vote on the motion, and instead agrees for the proposers to look at it again, revise it, and bring it back to a future conference.
The party’s other two MPs – Ellie Chowns and Hannah Spencer – have not released a statement on the issue at the time of writing. LFF understands, however, that Chowns does not want the motion to pass.
The motion has also divided the party leadership. One of the party’s deputy leaders Mothin Ali has said he will vote for the motion. The other deputy, Rachel Millward, has said that she would not be voting for it unamended. The Green Party’s leader Zack Polanski has said he’s backing two amendments – one around protecting Jews’ membership of synagogues, and the other which would remove the commitment to support a single Palestinian state.
Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward
Image credit: UK Parliament – Creative Commons
The post Green MPs make last-ditch attempt to stop Zionism is Racism motion appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.
-
Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate
- Green members vote for councils to support BDS in show of solidarity with Palestine
Green members vote for councils to support BDS in show of solidarity with Palestine
Green Party members have voted for councils to support the “boycott, divest and sanctions movement” and not invest in “complicit organisations”.
The motion means Green Party councillors will now introduce motions to their respective councils encouraging them to support BDS.
Members voted through the motion this afternoon.
The text outlining the motion included clauses on carrying out “regular risk assessments and due diligence on council contracts” to check whether they have links to “complicit organisations”.
It also included a line on “divesting” from and ceasing “contracts, investments and relationships with complicit organisations”.
In addition, the motion calls for councils to “use ethical banks, and move away from complicit banks such as Barclays”.
Olivia Barber is a reporter at Left Foot Forward
The post Green members vote for councils to support BDS in show of solidarity with Palestine appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.
-
Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate
- Sadiq Khan has overseen people being ‘priced out of London boroughs’ – Green London Assembly member Benali Hamdache interview
Sadiq Khan has overseen people being ‘priced out of London boroughs’ – Green London Assembly member Benali Hamdache interview
Sadiq Khan’s time as mayor of London has seen people be ‘priced out of London boroughs, a Green Party London Assembly has argued. Benali Hamdache made the comments in an interview with LFF at this Green Party’s autumn conference in Brighton.
Asked what he viewed as Khan’s failings as mayor of London, Hamdache said: “We haven’t seen the amount of affordable housing that we need to see. We are seeing Londoners priced out of boroughs. We’re seeing primary schools shut down because families just can’t afford to have kids.
“London is increasingly feeling like somewhere that isn’t enabling people’s dreams to live a happy, secure life in this city. And I think we will look back at a mayor who has failed to address that tide.”
Elsewhere in the interview, he added: “The biggest thing on the horizon is the London plan. For the next 10 years, Sadiq Khan is going to lay down the planning policy that determines whether or not we get enough affordable housing for London. And right now, we have a plan that is selling out to developers that is neither meeting the need and also isn’t really viable either.
“And it’s full of contradictions, and so leading that kind of charge to say that Londoners deserve a London plan that meets their needs should be pretty uncontroversial.”
Unsurprisingly, given Hamdache’s role as a London Assembly member means that he is currently spending quite a lot of time in Camden. That borough contains the Holborn and St Pancras parliamentary constituency. Voters there will be going to the polls on October 8 to elect a new MP following Keir Starmer’s resignation, with the Green Party leader Zack Polanski in the running.
What does Hamdache make of the Greens’ chances in the by-election?
Hamdache told LFF: “You’ll be surprised to hear I’ve spent quite a lot of time in Camden over the last month. And I think it’s a hugely competitive election.
“And I think just saying that should be recognised as so seismic. Keir Starmer in 2017 under Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership got 70 per cent of the vote in that constituency. So the idea that the Greens are in the running is hugely positive for our party’s prospects.
“I’ve met lots of residents who I think feel quite disenchanted by politics overall. They’re dealing with a broken lift, damp, mould, estates that don’t feel look after. They feel like Camden is pushing them out in lots of different ways.”
Hamdache would go on to say that he thinks the Greens can win the constituency. He said: “I think we can win. I think it is competitive.” He later added that it would be wrong to count either Labour or the Greens out in the by-election.
He told LFF: “I do think anyone would be wrong to count out either party. I’m confident to say that the Tories will come behind Reform, that the Lib Dems won’t be a presence.
Hamdache became a London Assembly member in May this year, following Zoë Garbett being elected as mayor of Hackney and subsequently resigning her seat on the Assembly.
Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward
The post Sadiq Khan has overseen people being ‘priced out of London boroughs’ – Green London Assembly member Benali Hamdache interview appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.
-
Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate
- Demonstrators at conference rally against anti-Zionism have ‘extremist views’, says Green member
Demonstrators at conference rally against anti-Zionism have ‘extremist views’, says Green member
A Green Party member at the party’s conference has described the views of Stop the Hate members protesting against the Zionism is Racism motion as “extremist”.
From around 11am this morning, people from Stop the Hate, a group that says it “the largest Jewish-led direct action campaign group” gathered outside the Brighton Centre to protest.
John Mayford, a Brighton Green Party member, said he had seen “quite a few” of the protesters last week, and that some of them said “‘the genocide in Gaza is a media construct, saying things like ‘the UN is a left-wing organisation’.”
Mayford said that “of course the UN is a member organisation made up of governments from around the world”.
He added: “A lot of these people here today are extremists.”
Mayford added: “Likud under Netanyahu is a fascist organisation, with people openly saying they want to carry out ethnic cleansing.”
He said that the people from Stop the Hate he had spoken to at a protest last week had indicated support for Likud’s ideas.
“One of the premises that is false about these kinds of protests is the conflation of religion with condemnation of a fascist state that is committing genocide,” he said.
The Green Party member called it “ridiculous”, adding: “That’d be like saying it would be anti-Christian of me to criticise Maggie Thatcher.”
Mike Davies, a member of the Palestine Solidarity Campaign in Brighton, said members of the group are “just nasty” and that he doesn’t think they have any “legitimate concerns” about the motion.
Davies added: “Where they’re coming from is support for Israel, but they have a lot of things they invent to prop that up, because of course support for Israel is support for the genocide, support for the eviction of Palestinians, and support for two laws, ones for Israelis, and one for non-Jewish Israelis.”
One person protesting with Stop the Hate said he didn’t know what the motion was, but that he was there to support Israelis and Jews.
On the situation in Gaza, he said the IDF was “killing not murdering people”, adding that it is “not a genocide”, but “a military campaign”.
“Hamas have not laid down their weapons and they’ve promised to do it again, another October 7th at their earliest opportunity,” he stated.
He added: “You don’t understand what Israel is up against.”
Image credit: Cameron Baillie
Olivia Barber is a reporter at Left Foot Forward
The post Demonstrators at conference rally against anti-Zionism have ‘extremist views’, says Green member appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.