|
Should we use our 'platforms'?
Second up was Anthropy founder John O’Brien, questioning whether he should use his ‘platforms’.
It rubbed hard for me, for two reasons.
Partly because I attended a forum last week (unrelated to Anthropy) that was distinctly average - the same old story where it should have been the speakers listening to the folks in the audience rather than the other way around.
Both speakers were jolly nice and by no means terrible - but the question needs to be asked: would they have been on that stage without the privilege of being white, older, educated males?
Would they have been better using their privilege and platform to amplify others, rather than using it to take the stage themselves?
Just because we can occupy a platform, doesn’t mean we should.
It also grated because I was/am sore that Anthropy chose to invite Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch, where she proceeded to lecture the audience - apparently without a fact in sight - on why they didn’t understand Net Zero. To anyone in events and PR, Occam’s Razor leads to the obvious conclusion that she attended on condition that she couldn’t be challenged or asked ’difficult’ questions.
Just because we can elicit the attendance of a high profile politician, it doesn’t mean we should. Particularly if they are not willing to participate in the most basic tenets of democracy - like informed, fact-based debate, questioning and accountability.
Perhaps that’s why the wonderful Jim Lescop’s post resonated so deeply with me.
How and why should we use our platforms?
Jim connected the viral trend of AI action dolls (if you don’t know, your world is better that way...) with the trip into space by some rich folk dressed up like Space Barbies. The connection was this:
“Because both chase status, attention, and novelty.”
This really hit me - both as a communicator and marketer, and as a human being.
How often do we post/comment/share/ take part because of the novelty factor; because we seek status, or because we desire attention?
It is, of course, why so many in the ethical space dislike social media. These traits are the antithesis of enoughism, sufficiency and contentment - fundamental attributes of a just, community-based society that so many of us know to be a ‘better’ way.
Just because we can take part in the latest trend, what happens when we remind ourselves:
“Just because I can, it doesn’t mean I should.”
Perhaps, though, this framing actually helps us reduce the ‘ick’ - because it leads to the question:
“Why am I posting this?”
And if we can answer that comfortably, we gain clarity and confidence; knowing that we’re posting or speaking with purpose.
Training and consulting update
The Ethical Marketing cohort for April is now closed - there was more interest than I expected, so I’m looking to run it again in September. Please do drop me a line if you’d like a heads up when it opens.
The interest list for the LinkedIn for Business cohort in June is also looking pretty long, so again, let me know if you’d like to be on the waitlist for that.
However, like many people in this space, I’ve been hit by funding cuts and general uncertainty, so for the first time in a while I’m unexpectedly open for consultancy and training over the next couple of months.
Let me know if you need some ethical marketing know-how.
In other news
There have been two big releases in the eco and ethical world in the last few days - the new B Corp standards and the UK’s new greenwashing guidance.
Perhaps I should be talking about them. But I’m not - at least, not this week, because I’m still processing them. I could, of course, be ‘timely’ and wax lyrical about both. But I choose not to, until I’ve clarified my own thoughts and processed the reactions of other people.
Just because I can talk about them, it doesn’t mean I should… not yet, at least…
Happy weekend,
Jane
|