❌

Normal view

There are new articles available, click to refresh the page.
Before yesterdayThe Knowledge

Britain’s genius for not overthinking

8 January 2024 at 12:47
Rishi Sunak and his wife Akshata Murty celebrating Diwali at No 10. Henry Nicholls/AFP/Getty

The most remarkable thing about Britain’s prime minister, London’s mayor, Scotland’s first minister and the probable next head of the BBC all being Asian, says Janan Ganesh in the FT, is the overwhelming “lack of domestic interest in that trend”. I am often asked to go on TV to comment on this or that, but I have “never been invited to discuss this subject”. It is virtually never spoken about, either in the form of “conservative misgivings” or “liberal self-congratulation”. Plenty of places are as diverse as Britain, but few are so indifferent to that diversity. Why?

The simple answer is that “we aren’t very reflective people generally”. The old attack line that the English are “anti-intellectual” is basically right. That’s not to say the nation has any less “cognitive processing power” than the next, merely that we are impatient with – even suspicious of – abstract thought. Consider our greatest minds. Shakespeare wrote 38 plays and 150-odd poems without giving “the slightest hint of an overarching worldview”. David Hume, “the most important philosopher to have written in English”, practised a kind of “anti-philosophy”, which emphasised experience, not reason, as the basis of knowledge. In his penetrating book on British art, Sensations, the critic Jonathan Jones argues that one theme runs from Thomas Gainsborough to Lucian Freud and beyond: “empirical observation”. So yes, we “skirt the subject of identity”, but then we skirt most disembodied concepts. “In the end, Britain is cosmopolitan because it doesn’t overthink.”

The post Britain’s genius for not overthinking appeared first on The Knowledge.

Let’s stop mollycoddling our children

8 January 2024 at 12:45
When kids could be kids: a Saturday Evening Post cover from 1935

I recently got into weightlifting, says Matthew Syed in The Sunday Times, and discovered that you only get the full benefits by making your muscles hurt – if they “tear a bit”, they’re stronger when they heal. It strikes me that this concept of “self-repair” is one we’re forgetting when it comes to our children. We increasingly coddle them, thinking it’s “a form of kindness”, when in fact it undermines their “resilience, robustness and flourishing”. A “recent seminal paper” in the Journal of Paediatrics found that there are now record rates of anxiety and depression among American kids, and that suicide rates among under-15s rose sixfold between 1950 and 2020. The authors blame this development not on social media, but on a shift in the 1980s, when we went from seeing our progeny as “tough cookies” to “Ming vases”.

In England, the number of primary school pupils who walked home from school plummeted from 86% in 1971 to 25% in 2010. Children are increasingly confined to soft-play areas rather than exploring local fields; in classrooms, they are shielded from failure and even barred from playing games that involve winners and losers. It’s no surprise that when these coddled kids reach university, they demand all kinds of protections: after a “mildly controversial” female speaker gave a talk on sexual violence at Brown University in the US, for example, students were comforted with colouring books, cookies and a video of frolicking puppies. As with so many things, “overprotection is perilous”.

The post Let’s stop mollycoddling our children appeared first on The Knowledge.

Why I was wrong about climate change

5 January 2024 at 17:37
Barbara Alper/Getty

Just a few years ago, says data scientist Hannah Ritchie in The Guardian, I thought climate change would completely destroy the planet. Widespread crop failures; island nations totally submerged; the whole shebang. But then I started looking at the data, “not newspaper headlines”, and my perspective totally flipped. What few people realise is that if countries all stick to their climate pledges – a task that’s getting easier and easier, thanks to fast-improving technology – the temperature rise by the end of the century won’t be much above 2C. That’s still not terrific, obviously. But it’s not the “devastating” outcome most of us have been led to expect.

That’s not the only preconception that needs changing. Most people don’t realise that we passed peak per capita carbon emissions about 10 years ago, and that we’ll probably pass peak total emissions at some point in the 2020s. Or that our carbon footprints are considerably smaller than those of our grandparents at the same age. Here in the UK, thanks to the decline of coal power and advances in energy efficiency, “we now emit about the same as someone in the 1850s”. There is also a tendency to underestimate how quickly things can change. In just a decade, between 2009 and 2019, solar and wind went from being the most expensive energy source to the least expensive. There is still much more to be done, of course. But the “doomsday thinking” that dominates so much of the climate change conversation is doing us no good at all.

This is an extract from Not the End of the World by Hannah Ritchie, which is available to pre-order here.

The post Why I was wrong about climate change appeared first on The Knowledge.

The covert gourmands who eat out 300 times a year

5 January 2024 at 17:35
A first edition of the Michelin Guide. Apic/Getty

Little is known about the lives of the Michelin Guide’s restaurant inspectors, says Adam Hay-Nicholls in Air Mail. According to Gwendal Poullennec, international director of the 124-year-old gourmand bible, they tell only their nearest and dearest what they really do. They come from all areas of the hospitality industry: chefs; sommeliers; hotel managers. They work full time, eating out 300 times a year and spending around 150 nights away from home. And with some restaurants charging thousands for a single meal, their expenses run to “literally millions”.

Poullennec says many of the claims about Michelin are myths. Those coveted stars have nothing to do with “the spacing between the tables, the amount of cutlery, whether the bathroom sinks are marble” or the napkin material. They are awarded based on five criteria: the quality of the produce; the “mastery” of the cooking; the harmony of the flavours; the personality of the chef represented through the “dining experience”; and the consistency of dishes between visits. Governments pay big money to tempt the inspectors to their shores. South Korea’s tourism board reportedly paid Michelin $1.8m to launch a guide for Seoul; Thailand is said to have forked out $4.4m over five years for its own. Poullennec, 44, is often asked to name his most memorable dining experience. He initially dodges the question (“The best meal is the one to come”), before “speaking wistfully” about ryokans, the traditional Japanese inns accessed through unmarked Tokyo doorways. “Simplicity,” he says, “can be a real luxury.”

The post The covert gourmands who eat out 300 times a year appeared first on The Knowledge.

The joys of reading slowly

5 January 2024 at 17:35
Sydney Sweeney and Brittany O’Grady enjoying a leisurely read in HBO’s The White Lotus

Reading shouldn’t be a chore, says Nilanjana Roy in the FT. A New Year often signals a “fresh TBR (To Be Read) pile”, divided evenly between Christmas gifts and the books you ran out of time to tackle the year before. And so the “endless game of catch-up” continues. But perhaps it’s time to “give yourself the gift of unrushed reading” instead. Slowly working your way through a single book for months, even years, is “a rarity in our hurried age” – but something many writers advocate. Chinese author Yiyun Li spends six months every year reading War and Peace and six months on Moby-Dick, she says, to keep her life “structured”. Writing in 1925, Virginia Woolf urged people to read a book “as if they were writing it”.

The key is not “slowing down for the sake of it”, but in order to sharpen our attention and broaden our understanding – to reach, in Woolf’s words, “the greater intensity and truth of fiction”. If you commit to a single book or author, your relationship with reading itself will “change, quieten and deepen”. But “think carefully about your choice of classic”. In 1995, Gerry Fialka launched a Finnegans Wake reading club at a library in California, navigating a couple of pages of James Joyce’s “notoriously opaque” novel aloud most months. Last October, 28 years after starting, they finally finished – and went straight back to the beginning. As Fialka said: “You don’t ever finish it.”

The post The joys of reading slowly appeared first on The Knowledge.

Lord Elgin didn’t “steal” anything

5 January 2024 at 17:32
The Elgin Marbles: right where they belong? Daniel Leal/AFP/Getty

I wonder if those calling for the Elgin Marbles to be sent to Greece know anything about them, says Jonathan Sumption in The Sunday Times. Many accept the Greek government’s line that the magnificent fifth-century sculptures were “stolen”. But that doesn’t bear “a moment’s examination”. Lord Elgin was British Ambassador to Turkey at the turn of the 19th century, when Greece was part of the Turkish empire. The sultan granted a decree authorising him to remove the stones and workmen spent two years taking them down, in full view of Turkish officials. He then received a second licence to export them to England on the basis that, as the edict said, such sculptures were appreciated by western Europeans “but not by Muslims”. They have been in the British Museum since 1816 – “longer than Greece has existed as a state”.

Admittedly, for most people the issue is “moral and cultural, not legal”. But what would be morally or culturally admirable about moving the statues from the British museum to a museum in Athens? “Cultural artefacts have always moved around the world.” The Romans were keen importers of Greek architectural sculpture, much of which is now in Italian museums. The bronze horses in St Mark’s Basilica in Venice were originally taken from the Hippodrome in Constantinople. “Panels from Duccio’s altarpiece in Siena Cathedral can be seen in Siena, London, Brussels, Madrid, Budapest, New York, Philadelphia, Washington and Fort Worth, Texas.” Besides, the British Museum is a universal museum of humanity, “the oldest and greatest in the world” – a place visited, for free, by more people from more countries than any other museum of its kind. It would be an act of “gross cultural vandalism” to break up its collection for no better cause than “modern Greek nationalism”.

The post Lord Elgin didn’t “steal” anything appeared first on The Knowledge.

The Kleptobrats living off plundered loot

5 January 2024 at 17:30
Wanted by Interpol: Isabel Dos Santos (left) with Nicki Minaj. Instagram/@nickiminaj

If you thought nepo babies were bad, says Jackson Garrett in Vice, try “kleptobrats”. These are the sons and daughters of the world’s dodgiest oligarchs and dictators, who are not just living off mum and dad – they’re living off loot plundered by mum and dad, usually from a country that could really do with the money. Take Equatorial Guinea’s playboy prince Teodoro Nguema Obiang Mangue, who went to a posh boarding school in Normandy before moving into a suite at the five-star Beverly Wilshire hotel while enrolled at Pepperdine University in Malibu. He dropped out after five months, and bought a nearby mega-mansion, a private jet, a speed boat and the world’s largest collection of Michael Jackson memorabilia.

Since the home countries of kleptobrats tend to be unsafe, they’re mostly sent away for their education. At his Swiss boarding school, North Korea’s Kim Jong-un earned the nickname “Dim Jong-un”. Bo Xilai, the “notoriously corrupt and powerful” Chinese politician, sent his son to Harvard – “with a Porsche” – and then to Oxford, where he “partied on stage with Jackie Chan”. And the parties are definitely part of the kleptobrat vibe. Mutassim Gaddafi, the late son of Muammar Gaddafi, paid Beyoncé $1m to perform at his New Year’s Eve party in St Barts, which was also attended by Usher, Jay-Z and Jon Bon Jovi. Kazakhstan’s dictator paid Kanye West $3m to perform at his grandson’s wedding and Elton John $1.5m to play at his son-in-law’s birthday. Isabel Dos Santos, the wanted-by-Interpol daughter of Angolan dictator José Eduardo Dos Santos, has hosted concerts by Mariah Carey and Nicki Minaj. Of course, everyone wants to give their kids the best lives possible. “Most of us just don’t impoverish and brutalise an entire population to do it.”

The post The Kleptobrats living off plundered loot appeared first on The Knowledge.

Perhaps I should have been a burglar

5 January 2024 at 17:29
Nick Frost and Simon Pegg hard at work in Hot Fuzz (2007)

Tucked away between Christmas and New Year, says Douglas Murray in The Spectator, was some “happy new guidance” from the National Police Chief’s Council. Police officers, said the new advice, “ought to try to go to properties that have been burgled”. Even better, they should try to do so “within an hour of the burglary being reported”. After all, if you turn up at a burgled house soon enough, you might be able to log evidence while the crime scene is still fresh, “or even – imagine – find a burglar”. With more than 1,000 break-ins a day in this country, you might wonder why such advice had to be given in the first place. But in England and Wales, three-quarters of burglaries result in no suspect being identified, and just 4% end up with someone being charged.

So what are the police up to? Well, if you fly into Heathrow Terminal 5, you might notice a “rather surprising sign” they’ve put up, asking anyone who has witnessed “terrorism, war crimes or crimes against humanity” in Israel or Gaza to report it to the UK police. What officers plan on doing about these crimes, which took place thousands of miles from their jurisdiction, is anyone’s guess. But all this has made me wonder “why I chose to make a living as a writer”. If I had decided instead to go into burglary, the odds would be “overwhelmingly on my side”. I could break into someone’s house and make off with their best cutlery, with a 96% chance of not being caught – far easier than a normal day’s work. “And I could do with some new cutlery.”

The post Perhaps I should have been a burglar appeared first on The Knowledge.

Nato is hardly a club of saints

5 January 2024 at 17:27
Yanis Varoufakis. Leonardo Cendamo/Getty

During my childhood, Greece was ruled by a “brutish” military junta, says former finance minister Yanis Varoufakis in UnHerd. In 1971, when I was 10, I visited my uncle in a hotel that had been converted into a “holding cell for VIP dissidents”. Before stepping inside, my mother “put her arm around me and whispered words of courage in my ear”. Seeing her brother’s tortured face illustrated, even to a child, what kind of regime we were living under. I remember “be-medalled army officers barking orders at their viewers” on the television news; I remember listening to BBC radio broadcasts under a blanket, to prevent neighbours overhearing and informing on us.

It may surprise younger readers to know that all this took place despite Greece being part of Nato. And we weren’t the only members of the much-feted security alliance living under autocratic rule: the Spanish and Portuguese were in the same boat; Turkey, another member, has long flirted with authoritarianism. Yet there remains the perception that Nato is more or less synonymous with liberal democracy, and that all right-thinking governments – Kyiv, in particular – should aspire to membership. That’s tosh. In reality, Nato has always put America’s interests above high-minded ideals – the junta that tortured my uncle took power in a CIA-backed coup. I once asked a former Nato bigwig – an American – what he thought its purpose was. “First, to keep us in Europe,” he said. “Second, to keep the Russians out. Third, to keep Germany down.” I’ve never heard a more accurate description.

The post Nato is hardly a club of saints appeared first on The Knowledge.

The SAS “Original” who navigated by the stars

5 January 2024 at 17:27
Sadler in his desert days. SAS: Rogue Heroes

The legendary desert navigator Mike Sadler, who died this week aged 103, was the last surviving member of the SAS “Originals”, says The Daily Telegraph. As depicted in the World War Two drama SAS: Rogue Heroes, this ragtag band of buccaneers blindsided the Germans and Italians by attacking their Mediterranean bases from the vast deserts to the south. Sadler, who had trained to navigate by the stars while serving in a reconnaissance outfit called the Long Range Desert Group, was able to drive assault teams across the shifting sands completely undetected. On one occasion, he “astro-navigated” 18 jeeps 70 miles across the featureless desert in the dead of night, with no lamps or maps, and arrived within 200ft of his target.

“Not all the raids were successful.” During another mission led by David Stirling, the founding commander of the SAS, the group “unknowingly camped next to a German unit”. Stirling and most of the others were captured, but Sadler and two sergeants escaped and hid in a ditch until nightfall. With Sadler navigating – and with no compass, food or water – they “followed the lie of the land, aiming for the Allied lines 100 miles away”. One group of Bedouins they met gave them dates and a goatskin of water; another stoned them and stole their warm clothes. After five gruelling days, they eventually reached the safety of the Free French lines. “We had long hair and beards and were looking very bedraggled,” Sadler recalled. “Our feet were in tatters. I don’t think we looked very much like soldiers.”

🧐🤷🏼‍♂️ Sadler wasn’t one for airs and graces. While serving in a Rhodesian artillery regiment early in the war, he was marched before his commanding officer over a disagreement he’d had with one of his seniors. Sadler, at the time a sergeant, was ordered to apologise or risk being reduced to the ranks. “Oh, that’s all right,” he said, “I’ll reduce myself to the ranks.” And he did.

The post The SAS “Original” who navigated by the stars appeared first on The Knowledge.

Our economy’s stronger than the doomsters think

5 January 2024 at 17:25
Leonardo DiCaprio in The Wolf of Wall Street (2013)

Much of the commentary on the UK economy continues to be “very downbeat”, says Jeremy Warner in The Daily Telegraph. But this “unrelenting gloom” overlooks two rather important points: government tax receipts remain strong and businesses are still hiring. Neither would be happening if companies thought a recession was imminent; instead, they reflect a confidence that “things will soon be improving”. And rightly so. Interest rate cuts by the Bank of England later in the year look a “racing certainty”. Inflation is easing. Wage increases are continuing to outstrip price rises. Things just aren’t as bad as the media doomsters make out.

It’s a similar story across much of the West. Last year produced one economic problem after another: stalemate in Ukraine, renewed war in the Middle East, a sluggish Chinese economy. Yet with the notable exception of Germany, high-income countries have emerged from all this “battered but still afloat”. Energy prices have abated; the promise of AI has “breathed new life into a previously becalmed tech sector”. The US economy is “positively booming”. If anything, the lesson from last year is a heartening one: big economies can cope with “almost anything that can be thrown at them”.

The post Our economy’s stronger than the doomsters think appeared first on The Knowledge.

Nitwits | Maisie Coutts | Andrew Lloyd Webber’s poltergeist

5 January 2024 at 17:24

Hero
A food delivery driver in India who dropped his orders off by horse to avoid long queues for petrol. After a truckers’ strike resulted in fuel shortages, the unnamed equestrian was pictured trotting through the busy streets of Hyderabad carrying the distinctive red bag of Zomato, India’s equivalent of Deliveroo.

Villains
The “nitwits” who removed road signs for Slag Lane in Wiltshire because they considered it “inappropriate”, says Michael Deacon in The Daily Telegraph. The road has “nothing to do with female promiscuity” – it was named after the slag piles at the nearby Westbury iron works. Besides, we Britons should take pride in our “globally unrivalled” collection of rude-sounding street names, from Spanker Lane in Derbyshire to Hardon Road in Wolverhampton and Crotch Crescent in Oxford.

Hero
Andrew Lloyd Webber’s poltergeist, for being so tidy. Asked in a recent interview about ghosts, the composer said he once had a paranormal housemate who defied the stereotype of noisy, bothersome spirits. “It would do things like take theatre scripts and put them in a neat pile in some obscure room,” he recalled. “In the end we had to get a priest to come and bless it, and it left.”

Hero
An 11-year-old girl in Aberdeen who reunited a handbag with its owner 30 years after it was stolen and dumped in the River Don. Maisie Coutts stumbled upon the accessory, which contained coins, pens, lipstick and long-expired credit cards, on a walk with her parents. After some online sleuthing, she returned the bag to 81-year-old Audrey Hay. “It’s amazing,” Hay tells BBC News. “It’s the only bag I have lost.”

The post Nitwits | Maisie Coutts | Andrew Lloyd Webber’s poltergeist appeared first on The Knowledge.

Where is today’s Tom Wolfe?

4 January 2024 at 12:36
Wolfe in his Upper East Side apartment in 2004. David Corio/Redferns/Getty

Tom Wolfe was the enfant terrible of New York’s literary scene, says Nick Burns in The New Statesman. He sported a “dandyish white suit”, and fired off fiction and non-fiction in “ecstatic, special-effects-laden prose” that satirised the hypocrisies of the liberal establishment – his 1970 essay Radical Chic was about a posh Manhattan party thrown in aid of the Black Panthers. A new biopic, Radical Wolfe, laments how no one today writes quite like Wolfe, who died in 2018 aged 88. Conservatives blame a censorious “woke left”, but really it’s satire that American liberals can’t handle. In Wolfe’s day they were on top – the Democrats had dominated government since the 1930s – and could afford to laugh at themselves. As their power waned in the 1980s, so did their sense of humour.

Another problem is that right-wingers these days are just too angry to muster the wry detachment needed for effective satire. The dry wit of patrician conservatives like William F Buckley seems a world away. Tucker Carlson used to write “clever, outrageous” magazine stories skewering liberals – then he laid down his pen and found fame delivering angry monologues on Fox News. America’s contemporary right has little interest in “novels of manners” or delicate social critique; they don’t respect liberals enough to satirise them. But that’s no reason to give up reading Wolfe – nor to stop hoping that some writer will emerge to dig into the “absurdities” of our own age.

The post Where is today’s Tom Wolfe? appeared first on The Knowledge.

The “trilemma” facing Western democracies

4 January 2024 at 12:34
Miriam Cates: “intellectual energy”. Instagram/@miriamcates_mp

It’s striking how much Rishi Sunak has “bounced from one idea to the next” in No 10, says Tom McTague in UnHerd. He initially presented himself as a “safe pair of hands” who would clean up the mess made by Liz Truss. When that didn’t improve the Tories’ dire poll numbers, he lined up red-meat conservative policies, such as watering down Net Zero commitments, and styled himself as a radical who would break from “a failed 30-year consensus”. And then he hired David Cameron – the epitome of that consensus – as his foreign secretary. Seemingly the one constant has been the PM’s desperation to avoid handing power to the “lunatics” on the right of his party.

Yet for all the madness on the Tory fringes, they boast far more “intellectual energy” than the likes of Sunak and Cameron. The MP Miriam Cates, for example, is “not anachronistic” in her concern about Britain’s falling birth rate: it’s a “distinctly modern problem” affecting almost all Western democracies. The issue no one in the party is properly addressing is what the economist Dani Rodrik calls the “trilemma” of the modern world: governments cannot have all three of democracy, national sovereignty and global economic integration. The more you integrate your economy into the world, the less sovereignty your citizens will enjoy; the less you integrate, the poorer your citizens will be. With Brexit, Britain chose sovereignty over integration, but the trilemma does not go away – it only “emerges in different forms”. Right now, the government is failing to answer it.

The post The “trilemma” facing Western democracies appeared first on The Knowledge.

France and Britain can help save Ukraine

3 January 2024 at 12:20
Volodymyr Zelensky with Emmanuel Macron last year. Alexey Furman/Getty

“Two spectres haunt Europe,” says Michel Duclos in Le Monde: the threat of Ukraine’s defeat by Russia, and Donald Trump’s possible return to the White House. Of course, “the second threat would contribute greatly to the materialisation of the first”, but increasing American “war fatigue” means even a second term for Joe Biden doesn’t guarantee Europe’s safety. And while Vladimir Putin has reengineered Russia’s economy to avoid sanctions and boost military production, Europeans are “toying with the idea of a war economy” but failing to act. Europe needs to develop the French doctrine of “strategic autonomy” – taking responsibility for our own defence – “starting now”.

The top priority should be launching a European fund to arm the Ukrainian military, ideally through a massive loan worth “at least €100bn”. The point of this would not just be to support Ukraine, but to boost Europe’s defence industry. It would have to operate outside the confines of Brussels, to bypass the obstructive antics of Hungary – last month Viktor Orbán blocked a four-year EU package for Ukraine worth €50bn. And, crucially, Britain would have to be involved. It is an Anglo-French-led firm, MBDA, that is best placed to supply the kind of long-range missiles that Kyiv so sorely needs – and which the US and Germany are refusing to hand over. If Putin is to be deterred, Ukraine needs to be able to strike deep inside Crimea, from which Russia launches many of its most devastating attacks. Europe has the tools. It just needs to find the will.

The post France and Britain can help save Ukraine appeared first on The Knowledge.

Let’s not forget the world’s successes

3 January 2024 at 12:17
A child receiving the polio vaccine in Pakistan. WHO

Last year was “notably grim”, says Nicholas Kristof in The New York Times, from war in the Middle East to carbon emissions “cooking our planet”. But it may still have been “the best year in the history of humanity”. Global child mortality fell to yet another record low – a million fewer children died last year than in 2016. It’s the same with extreme poverty, out of which around 100,000 people are emerging every single day. Developments in medicine are similarly encouraging. Two horrifying diseases – polio and Guinea worm disease – are close to eradication, and new jabs have been approved for RSV and malaria, which will save the lives of countless children. The US government recently approved new CRISPR gene-editing techniques for sickle cell disease, and scientists hope similar approaches can “transform the treatment of cancer and other ailments”.

The truth is, I do a version of this column at the start of every year – and every year, readers complain. They think it’s offensive to hail progress “when the future seems so bleak to so many”. But people “tune out and give up” when the news is unremittingly gloomy. “Despair is paralysing, not empowering.” If we want to tackle the likes of climate change and the Israel-Hamas conflict, “it helps to know progress is possible”. That’s why it’s always worth stepping back and acknowledging all the things we’re getting right. Not to distract people from what’s going wrong, but to remind ourselves that “when we try hard enough, we can accomplish amazing things”.

The post Let’s not forget the world’s successes appeared first on The Knowledge.

Has the BBC murdered Agatha Christie?

2 January 2024 at 12:46
David Jonsson in Murder is Easy. Mark Mainz/BBC/Mammoth Screen

This year’s “dose of Christmas homicide”, Agatha Christie’s Murder is Easy, has received a pasting in the likes of the Mail and the Telegraph, says Martha Gill in The Observer. The problem? A black actor, David Jonsson, has been cast in the lead role. This doesn’t affect the plot, which is still thick with vicars, hat paint and characters keeling over while playing tennis. But the BBC has still been accused of “walloping us round the head with a lecture”. What these critics miss is that all adaptations “tamper” with the classics, otherwise there wouldn’t be any point making them. And other “updates” – such as women grumbling about being underpaid – passed without comment. Anyway, Murder is Easy doesn’t “berate modern audiences for their values” so much as “reassure them of their superiority” – they are so much more enlightened, it tells them, than 1950s bigots. What could possibly be wrong with that?

The problem, says Philip Patrick in The Spectator, is that the BBC has “retrofitted” Christie’s novel to suit its own “obsession with racism and colonialism”. The corporation defends this “Orwellian” practice with the old “relevant to a modern audience” line. In its original Diversity and Inclusion Strategy document of 2016, then director-general Tony Hall declared: “We must make sure we tell stories that people all across the country will recognise, will understand and will relate to.” By making this mandatory, Hall was effectively announcing the death of the “reasonably authentic, respectful dramatisation”. Today, it seems, any drama that doesn’t promote the “approved message” must be substantially rewritten to fit the new morality – or “consigned to the memory hole”.

The post Has the BBC murdered Agatha Christie? appeared first on The Knowledge.

Are we wrong about Biden and Starmer?

2 January 2024 at 12:33
Biden and Starmer: what does the future hold? Getty

Here are a couple of predictions for 2024, says Janet Daley in The Sunday Telegraph. “First, Joe Biden will not run for a second term.” This is something he and his team know they cannot admit until “very late in the day” – it would “instantly render him a lame duck president”, which would be extremely dangerous given the critical wars under way in Gaza and Ukraine. But it will be easy enough, at the right moment, to blame Biden’s state of health for a “sudden” change of plan, and replace him with a candidate who can prevent the “moral catastrophe” of Donald Trump returning to the White House. “We have to believe that there are already steps to do so in operation.”

My second prediction is that Labour will not win a landslide in the UK general election. I say this as someone with an “uncanny ability to predict the most apparently unlikely outcomes”. I foresaw the Tories’ shock victories in both 1992 – a prediction considered “so preposterous” that the newspaper I worked for wouldn’t even print it – and 2015. After the latter, the successful Tory team even called me into Downing Street to ask the obvious question: “How did you know?” In both cases, “I didn’t know anything that anybody else didn’t know”. I simply couldn’t see the then Labour leaders, Neil Kinnock and Ed Miliband, as prime ministers. And right now, Keir Starmer – a man with the “blank, startled gaze of a badger in the headlights” – evokes the same reaction.

The post Are we wrong about Biden and Starmer? appeared first on The Knowledge.

“Mankind’s most noble goal”

29 December 2023 at 10:51
The ticker-tape parade for the Apollo 11 astronauts in August 1969. NASA/Newsmakers/Getty

Someone should compile a book of great speeches that were never delivered, says Alastair Campbell in The New European. What gave me the idea was reading the “beautifully written” address drafted for US president Richard Nixon in 1969, in the event that the first men on the moon never made it back to Earth. Here it is, in its entirety:

“Fate has ordained that the men who went to the moon to explore in peace will stay on the moon to rest in peace. These brave men, Neil Armstrong and Edwin Aldrin, know that there is no hope for their recovery. But they also know that there is hope for mankind in their sacrifice. These two men are laying down their lives in mankind’s most noble goal: the search for truth and understanding. They will be mourned by their families and friends; they will be mourned by their nation; they will be mourned by the people of the world; they will be mourned by a Mother Earth that dared send two of her sons into the unknown.

“In their exploration, they stirred the people of the world to feel as one; in their sacrifice, they bind more tightly the brotherhood of man. In ancient days, men looked at stars and saw their heroes in the constellations. In modern times, we do much the same, but our heroes are epic men of flesh and blood. Others will follow, and surely find their way home. Man’s search will not be denied. But these men were the first, and they will remain the foremost in our hearts. For every human being who looks up at the moon in the nights to come will know that there is some corner of another world that is forever mankind.”

The post “Mankind’s most noble goal” appeared first on The Knowledge.

❌
❌