❌

Reading view

There are new articles available, click to refresh the page.

Open Source’s Anti-AI Sentiment Has Real Reasons, and So Does The Other Side

ai opinion, two opposing sides banner

A request to ban AI-written code from ImageMagick stayed open for about eight months, until a maintainer closed and locked it this week because it had largely run its course and moved into a broader ideological debate.

Around the same time, a developer on X was telling followers to join the pushback.

Days earlier, Asahi Linux began moving its code from MIT to GPLv2 after finding that people were lifting its unreleased work and, in some extreme cases, having an LLM rewrite it to hide where it came from.

AI in open source has turned into something people pick a side on. Many have grown to dislike it, and the reasons are easy enough to see.

Others back it to varying degrees, and the more grounded among them make a case that holds up too.

With this piece, I want to go through the first group's complaints, then the louder end of the other camp, and then the careful argument for supporting AI.

Why so many are fed up

The most common complaint is review burden. Rust's LLM policy announcement said a clean, tested PR used to be good evidence that its author had put in real effort and understood the change. LLMs, it says, have broken that link.

It also calls pasting reviewer comments into a chatbot and the reply back onto GitHub, a waste of time for both sides.

cURL hit the same wall, but from a security perspective. The project ended its bug bounty at the end of January after the share of reports that were real vulnerabilities dropped, and AI-generated slop became the majority.

The project's lead, Daniel Stenberg, said that the constant slop wore the team down.

Codeberg, whose members voted 358 to 144 in July to stop hosting projects that are mostly AI-written, cited crawlers straining its servers, spiraling storage requisition costs, and one-person projects eating resources similar to large community ones as its motivating factors.

Then there is the legal worry. Asahi's LLM policy says an LLM can break the rules that keep reverse engineering work clean. The risk grows when an AI agent does the digging and the human cannot see how the knowledge was obtained.

Codeberg's Terms of Use call the copyright status of AI-written projects unclear. GCC says no to legally significant contributions that involve LLM output, with test cases as an exception. Legally insignificant ones can go in if clearly marked.

Trust and principle come into it too. Asahi's policy lists wider harms, including to the environment, privacy, user consent, and software developers themselves.

Rust's announcement says pasted LLM text leaves a reviewer wondering whether anyone is on the other end at all. Codeberg adds that people who put real effort into analyzing issues or sharing suggestions are being accused of using an LLM when they did not.

Even Linus Torvalds sees where the anger comes from. He told The Register that AI-found bugs piling work on maintainers and patches from people who do not understand the code are both real problems.

He understands why people come to dislike or even hate AI because of them, but he does not think AI itself is the issue.

The last entry on the no list is r/opensource. That is a subreddit, not a project. A moderator wrote that projects that use AI, are built with it, or are aimed at it are not welcome there, and said AI as it exists today does not fit the community.

Not everyone is staying calm

The anti-AI cult is harassing and pressuring open-source projects such as `curl` and `ImageMagick` to outright ban LLM usage.

If you care about the open-source ecosystem and humanity's technological progress, fight back with me:https://t.co/A9DwO0KMNxhttps://t.co/ZgmPwWDqdp https://t.co/8U06KvmyEx

— Vittorio Romeo (@supahvee1234) November 11, 2026

Not every supporter of AI is making a grounded case. Developer Vittorio Romeo accused an "anti-AI cult" of harassing and pressuring projects such as cURL and ImageMagick into banning LLMs and asked followers to join the pushback.

The threads that post links to are filled with some drama. The curl discussion opened in March with a long, sourced list of worries about plagiarism, code quality, and legal risk. Daniel Stenberg replied the same day that curl could not accept a ban on everything LLM.

The ImageMagick request (linked earlier) started from one merged commit that used Claude Opus.

The ImageMagick thread did get heated. Some anti-AI commenters were dismissive and insulting, and Vittorio's own reply there accused them of ad-hominem attacks.

Peter Steinberger of OpenClaw fame also chimed in, saying that reading some of the comments made his brain hurt and that open source is hard enough without politics.

The grounded yes

Daniel says ignoring AI is not a sound approach since brushing off a real vulnerability because an AI found it puts users at risk. He says the onslaught of slop has mostly dried up since spring, and recent AI-assisted reports have been high quality, if wordy.

Debian's approved resolution stays neutral on the tools and asks contributors to read, test, and understand AI output before submitting it. The kernel's guidance is similar, with the human submitter accountable for the code.

Rust’s policy accepts LLMs for answering questions and reviewing work, bans LLM-created comments, docs, and diagnostics, and allows LLM-written code only under a disclosed experiment.

It also says harassing someone for using an LLM is not okay.

What Debian and the kernel share is a named human who answers for the change. That answers the review burden well, but not Asahi’s clean room problem, and the values complaints sit mostly outside what a policy can reach.

Closing thoughts

None of these approaches are final. GCC says it will review its policy by the start of 2027, Rust expects to change its policy as it learns how LLMs are used, and Debian’s statement can evolve without another vote.

That leaves contributors needing to consult a wide range of rulebooks for every project they send a patch to. Annoying, but this is what an unsettled debate looks like. 🤷

Mayors are out of control

Tom Brake is chief executive of Unlock Democracy

Last month’s Budget granted England’s mayors more power over the money their regions raise. The question is, will the public be any more in control than when Whitehall was in charge?

The Chancellor announced £285 million for new Good Growth funds and areas preparing for devolution, alongside a £1.5 billion borrowing facility for mayoral authorities. From 2027, mayors will receive 20% of business rates revenues – with 100% of business rates to be retained by local and regional governments by 2030 – followed by a share of income tax receipts in 2028. They will also be able to charge a tourist tax.

Together with the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act, which extends the map of mayoral government and deepens its powers over housing, planning and transport, this represents a substantial transfer of power from Whitehall.

So far, so good, right? The Prime Minister shares Unlock Democracy’s enthusiasm for devolution. We both believe communities should have much greater control over their own affairs, with decisions made as close as possible to the people they affect.

But giving mayors more power does not necessarily give the public more control. That depends on whether people can hold them to account. The Devolution Act makes some provision in this space, beefing up local scrutiny committees. That is welcome. But scrutiny can only go so far, particularly when establishing something as basic as who a mayor has met, and what they discussed, is far harder than it should be.

Take Andy Burnham’s foray into the Manchester City cheating scandal as an example. Only following the PM’s intervention – made in the wake of City being found guilty of colossal, systematic cheating – was the fact of a formal meeting in 2021 between Burnham, then Greater Manchester mayor, and City’s chairman made public. Meanwhile, records of two matchday dinners with the chairman had to be unearthed by the BBC, having been removed from the Greater Manchester authority website.

None of this is to allege wrongdoing by Andy Burnham. The issue is different, and it extends further: why was it so difficult to extract such information? In Whitehall, ministers must publish quarterly reports listing their meetings with outside organisations. Admittedly, their contents and the frequency leave a lot to be desired, but at least they establish minimum standards of transparency. England’s metro mayors face no equivalent obligation.

Research by Unlock Democracy found no regularly published diaries of external meetings for the mayors of Greater Manchester or Liverpool City Region. We could find none for West Yorkshire, either. The Mayor of London does publish a diary of formal engagements every six months, though publication stalled for two years after Mayor Khan’s re-election in May 2024 (this has since been rectified). Even then, entries can be remarkably perfunctory, revealing little to nothing of what was discussed.

Declarations of gifts and hospitality are just as inconsistent. The Local Government Association’s model code recommends declaring gifts worth £50 or more within 28 days, but authorities adopt their own codes. As a result, what the public knows about those in power depends on where they live.

Of course, the existence of disclosure rules does not guarantee their application. A recent investigation by the BBC and the Bedford Independent uncovered records suggesting that Bedford mayor, Tom Wootton – owner of land worth more than £2.7 million affected by the proposed East West Rail route – failed on 15 separate occasions to declare an interest when necessary. Tom Wootton disputes this assessment.

The rights and wrongs of the case will not be settled here. What’s crucial to note is it took a team of journalists examining court documents, land records and meeting minutes to bring these questions to light.

And here lies a second problem. Since 2005, at least 293 local newspapers have closed. In Birmingham, the National Union of Journalists warns that major job cuts will render once proud local papers “irrelevant to their communities.” And the BBC, already under severe financial pressure, plans to merge its education and social affairs editor roles, another sign of the squeeze on resource-intensive reporting that seeks to bridge the gap between abstract policy and on the ground experience.

Not only is the hollowing out of local media bad for accountability, it’s bad for governance. A healthy local media is one way that authorities get their message out and discover where they’re going wrong: where services are failing, which grievances are going unanswered and what citizens actually make of their priorities.

Without it, mayors risk gaining powers while losing touch with the communities they’re there to serve. The resulting distrust and alienation will serve nobody except bad-faith actors looking to make political capital – or simply a quick buck – off people’s discontent.

Devolution promises greater local control, and rightly so. But bringing power closer to people is only one part of the picture. Giving mayors the means to act must go hand in hand with giving the public the means to hold them accountable. Otherwise, we risk fixing one democratic deficit only to create another.

The post Mayors are out of control appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Dawn Butler MP: It’s Time the Law Caught Up With AI

Dawn Butler is MP for Brent East and Chair of the London Parliamentary Labour Party

Artificial intelligence is advancing at extraordinary speed. It offers enormous opportunities, from medical breakthroughs to scientific discoveries that could transform our lives. But we cannot allow ourselves to be so caught up in the possibilities that we lose sight of the real risks. I am clear that as AI rapidly develops, protecting our digital rights must be our priority.

That is why I recently introduced my Artificial Intelligence (Consent and Misuse) Bill, which would establish a clear requirement for consent before someone’s likeness is generated using artificial intelligence. It is a straightforward principle: nobody should be able to take your face, replicate your voice or create a convincing digital version of you without your permission.

Our identity is not a free resource for others to exploit. Yet the law has not kept pace with the advancing technology that makes this exploitation possible. We know where this can lead.

Deepfakes can already be used to create convincing images, videos and audio of people. Someone could use your voice to make it sound like you have endorsed a product or made offensive remarks. Your face could be placed into an intimate image without your consent. The consequences for a person’s reputation, livelihood and mental wellbeing can be devastating.

This is not simply a question of technological misuse. It is about dignity, privacy and control over our own identities. And it raises a fundamental question: if someone can reproduce your face and voice with a few clicks, what meaningful protection do you have? Right now, not much.

My Bill would address this by establishing a consent requirement, providing for civil action where that requirement is breached, creating offences relating to the creation or dissemination of unauthorised likenesses, and placing duties on providers of AI technology to address its misuse by actors giving them commands that breach these rules.

It is designed to ensure that responsibility does not rest solely with the individual whose identity has been exploited. This is about ensuring responsible use of artificial intelligence and I’m urging the Government to adopt these proposals and work with me towards legally binding protections that keep pace with technological change.

I know that this is part of a much wider challenge. We must also confront the danger that AI will automate discrimination, embedding existing inequalities into systems that influence our lives.

I am concerned that AI systems can reproduce or amplify existing societal biases that affect people from minoritised backgrounds, women, disabled people and more. I am particularly concerned about the implications for policing, where bias and flawed algorithms risk reinforcing existing racial inequalities.

If discrimination is automated, it can become harder to identify, challenge and correct.

We must ask difficult questions about the data used to train these systems, where it comes from, whose experiences it represents and who is accountable when things go wrong. If the answers remain unclear, the people most likely to suffer are often those who already face discrimination.

The way facial recognition is used also raises serious questions about privacy and surveillance, particularly when people’s images are retained or used without proper justification. The fact that technology makes something possible does not mean that it should be permitted without limits.

Consent matters because people should have a say in how their identities and personal information are used. We need a framework that protects these rights while allowing innovation to flourish. Working together with the sector, London can be that leader in responsible, ethical and values-based AI.

That means transparency about how AI systems operate, implementing meaningful guardrails against discrimination, clear accountability when harm occurs, and effective remedies for those affected. It also means ensuring that people are alerted when AI has been used to create or manipulate content involving them – and have means to challenge it.

We are at a crossroads, and we must seize this opportunity to provide that leadership before it’s too late. Voluntary principles are not enough, they leave fundamental gaps in protection. I am clear that we cannot allow the industry to regulate itself, on its own terms. That has been tried before with other industries, and it simply does not work.

I have long argued that technological progress must go hand in hand with protecting people’s rights and freedoms. My Bill prioritises one essential principle: my likeness, my consent. This means clear, legally binding rules, backed by effective enforcement.

This is not about stopping AI or standing in the way of innovation. It is about seeing around corners and building public trust in a technology that will increasingly shape our lives. Responsible businesses should welcome clear rules, and people should be able to benefit from AI without fearing that their identity can be stolen or their rights disregarded.

The question is not whether AI will change our future. The question is whether we will shape that change in the public interest, or leave people exposed while the law struggles to catch up.

I’m asking the Government to adopt my Bill and introduce strong, enforceable protections. I’m proud to work alongside organisations that are also working hard in this space such as My Name, My Face, plus ControlAI, Equity, Demos and more. I hope readers will join me in calling for action by signing my declaration for responsible AI on my website and helping spread the word.

These challenges are not straightforward, and we have to get this right, but we cannot afford to wait until the harm becomes entrenched. With my Bill, we start that process now.

Our faces, our voices and our identities belong to us. The law must reflect that. The first rule of Government is to protect its citizens. Right now, we need protecting.

The post Dawn Butler MP: It’s Time the Law Caught Up With AI appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

First-time buyers should be an integral part of the government’s plan to ‘bring back hope’

Palma Oxley is a Researcher at the Fabian Society, working at the Fabian Housing Centre

In his first speech as Prime Minister, Andy Burnham promised to ‘bring back hope’. For many, the opportunity to own a home is an important part of that promise, offering greater financial security, lower housing costs and a better quality of life. 

Young people across Britain find it harder than ever before to become homeowners. The price of the average home has grown by almost 20 per cent in real terms between 2005 and 2025, while wages have grown by just 6 per cent. The average property in England is now 7.6 times average income, compared to 6.8 twenty years ago. Even regions with historically low house prices have faced rapid house-price inflation, with prices rising by 10 per cent in the East Midlands and 15 per cent in the North West over the past decade. 

Today, people have to save more and for longer. The average first-time buyer deposit has grown by 38 per cent in real terms in the past 10 years alone, reaching over £78,000. Yet the majority of renters (64 per cent) have fewer than £16,000 in savings. For someone able to put away half of their income after essential costs, it would take more than 12 years to save for the deposit on an average new build. In London, this could take 30 years. Of course, few people are able to save at this rate, as rents, student loan repayments, and the cost of living constrain their ability to save. Aspiring buyers on low incomes and with children are even more disadvantaged.

As house prices become increasingly divorced from average incomes, people are becoming more reliant upon the ‘bank of mum and dad’ to buy their first home. Analysis by Savills found that the number of first-time buyers receiving family assistance has risen from 47 per cent to 53 per cent over the past 10 years. It estimates that £8.3bn was paid out by parents in 2025, compared with £5.7bn in 2015. Increasingly, the ability to buy a home depends less on how hard someone works and more on the wealth and support of their family. It is no surprise that aspiring buyers are losing faith in the system, politics and the future of the country. 

In response to the challenges facing aspiring first-time buyers, the government has announced Your First Home, a deposit support scheme designed to help people onto the property ladder. The scheme will provide aspiring first-time buyers with a 2.5 per cent deposit with an equity loan of 20 per cent of their property’s value. The government estimates that this will help 70,000 households to become homeowners. 

However, more needs to be done to ensure that homeownership is not an opportunity reserved for those from more affluent backgrounds. In Keys to the Future, the Fabian Housing Centre sets out a package of measures to help aspiring first-time buyers overcome the remaining barriers to homeownership.

The government should introduce a renter savings scheme that would allow tenants to save an additional 5 per cent of their rent, matched by their landlord and the government. Modelled on workplace pensions, the scheme would turn regular rental payments into an opportunity to build a deposit. Over 13 years, this could help tenants save £20,000 in England and almost £32,000 in London. The government should also introduce a junior housing ISA, helping families to save for their children’s future deposit. This would be backed by government contributions for children from low-income families.

Aspiring buyers also need access to, and awareness of, more affordable mortgages with lower interest rates. The government should improve access to mortgages with just a 5 per cent deposit by reforming the guarantees it provides to lenders. It should also establish a national first-time buyer advice service to help people navigate the mortgage market and understand the homeownership schemes available to them. Taken together, these proposals would help make homeownership less dependent on when someone was born or how much their parents earn. 

A country that offers hope to young people is one where homeownership is an achievable ambition, bringing greater financial security, lower housing costs and higher life satisfaction. Your First Home is a welcome first step, but the government must go further. By helping people to build savings and access affordable mortgages, it can ensure that the opportunity to own a home depends less on the ‘bank of mum and dad’ and more on their own hard work and ambition. 

The post First-time buyers should be an integral part of the government’s plan to ‘bring back hope’ appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Community Union column: ‘The budget was a success for working people but there remains more to be done’

BUDGET VERDICT: ALASDAIR MCDIARMID, COMMUNITY UNION GENERAL SECRETARY

In an era where we often bemoan a lack of public engagement in our political processes, Budget Day remains a rarity. All eyes are firmly fixed on the dispatch box, and the Chancellor of the Exchequer briefly shares the media spotlight with Celebrity Traitors contestants and footballers.

It’s something of a poisoned chalice too.

Every business, charity, think-tank and indeed, every trade union – including Community – has a checklist of asks that it would be impossible for any government to satisfy completely.

And political opponents – particularly those on the right, and their allies in the media – will leap at the opportunity to tear apart a progressive budget in bad faith. It is to John Healey’s great credit that few, if any, of the post-budget barbs dished out by the Tories or Reform landed.

The Chancellor is a proud Community member, and over many years of working together – including on behalf of his constituents at Speciality Steels in South Yorkshire – we have found him to be a considerate thinker and a hard worker. His political antennae and priorities in government revolve around the needs of ordinary working people, and that shone through in the budget.

The autumn budget was very much attuned to the traditions of the Labour movement; minimising damage to the wallets of working people and continuing on the path of re-balancing the economy to the benefit of all nations and regions.

We welcomed the immediately impactful measures that the Chancellor has prioritised, such as capping bus fares, removing charges on household energy bills and granting thousands of our members a £100 energy payment this winter. These are all concrete measures which will give millions of workers some much-needed breathing space this winter.

As a union representing thousands of self-employed workers, we also warmly welcomed the extension of parental pay for the self-employed – 150,000 of whom will now be eligible for two weeks’ support worth up to £194 a week. We have long argued that the self-employed require greater protections in times of need, and Labour has shown that it is listening.

Elsewhere, the extension of the 5p fuel duty freeze and red diesel cut will benefit our members in the logistics sector, and we appreciate the stronger commitments to ensuring that procurement boosts jobs in British manufacturing, supporting our members in steel and light industries.

We also share the Early Education and Childcare Coalition’s view that our members in the Early Years sector can benefit from devolving more power to local leaders, connecting early education and childcare provision with jobs and skills, and tackling child poverty and health inequalities.

Staying with education, we know that many of our teacher members will also welcome the new £15millon fund to tackle misogyny, particularly in schools where it has seen a troubling resurgence over recent years.

Whilst we welcomed many of the measures contained in the budget, we would still like to see the government go much further, particularly in its support for foundational industries like steel. We hope that future fiscal statements will build on the good work that has already been delivered by ministers to support our steel sector and drive the reindustrialisation agenda that the Prime Minister has championed.

This must include decisive action to tackle the UK’s sky-high industrial energy costs – it simply cannot be right that our steel producers are paying over the odds compared with competitors in Europe. The backdating of energy cost relief for 10,000 manufacturing firms through the British Industrial Competitiveness Scheme is a positive step – but fails to address the wider elephant in the room.

Our steel makers currently pay 49% more in industrial electricity costs than their counterparts in France, which equates to an annual cost burden of £66 million. With wholesale energy prices rising again, the Gallic energy gap will only grow. British steelmakers cannot continue competing with one hand tied behind their backs.

This isn’t a new problem, and Community has been banging the drum on industrial energy costs for steel over many years. However, with increased pressures facing the sector – including failing trade measures which are resulting in an influx of cheap imported steel from South-East Asia – the threat posed to the industry is becoming increasingly acute across multiple fronts.

Ultimately, the Chancellor promised a budget that would provide breathing space, and he delivered on that last month. In a challenging global context, and with this Labour government still grappling with the Conservative legacy of underinvestment and economic mismanagement up to 2024, the budget was a success. 

Crucially, its main beneficiaries were ordinary working people: not the billionaires, tax-dodgers and corporate cronies who clinked champagne glasses every Budget Day for fourteen long years.

But there is still much more to do, and the government’s response to upcoming Millburn Review and 2027 Spending Review will be crucial.

The post Community Union column: ‘The budget was a success for working people but there remains more to be done’ appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Did the budget deliver for women?

Viktoria Szczypior, Women’s Budget Group

The chancellor promised a Budget that would give families “breathing space”. After four years of a cost of living crisis, preceded by a pandemic and a decade of austerity, women needed far more than that. What we got was a Budget of small measures and incremental tweaks: a “picky bits” Budget, complete with a record number of policy announcements, but little sign of a coherent plan to tackle the economic pressures bearing down on women.

Women are still bearing the brunt of the cost of living crisis. Because women earn less than men on average, and continue to carry out around 50% more unpaid care and domestic work, they have less financial resilience when prices rise. More of their income is already spent on essentials, leaving less room to absorb higher costs.

Earlier this year, debt charity StepChange reported that 71% of its clients with energy arrears were women. Single-parent families, the vast majority headed by women, have energy arrears at three times the national average. With interest rates expected to rise again, the cost of servicing those debts will only increase.

Against that backdrop, action on household bills was particularly important. The Chancellor’s package on energy costs – the removal of VAT on energy bills and standing charges on gas bills, and a £100 council tax rebate – will undoubtedly help shield many from even steeper energy bills.

Yet a closer look reveals that the support is not particularly well targeted. According to the Resolution Foundation, higher-income households will benefit almost as much in cash terms as lower-income households. At a time when public finances remain tight, the government should have provided more meaningful support to those struggling most, rather than offering modest help to millions.

Housing is perhaps the clearest example of a missed opportunity.

The Chancellor announced several measures to help people onto the housing ladder. But for many women, the pressing question is how to pay next month’s rent. Our analysis showed that women now spend an average of 57% of their earnings on private rent, compared with 41% for men. For many, housing costs have become the single biggest pressure on household budgets.

That is why the decision not to unfreeze Local Housing Allowance (LHA) is so disappointing. More than 900,000 low-income private renting families now face a gap between the housing support they receive and the rent they are expected to pay.

While additional funding to tackle rough sleeping is welcome, preventing homelessness is every bit as important as responding to it. Single mums already make up the majority of statutory homeless families. But keeping housing benefits frozen will put more families at risk of losing their home.

While the Chancellor did say extending paternity pay to self-employed fathers was a ‘downpayment’ on wider reforms to parental leave, he also needed to address the inadequacy of maternity pay. At less than half the minimum wage, it continues to put many mothers under severe financial pressure. Our analysis has shown that improving maternity pay would put more than £1bn in families’ pockets and deliver social and economic gains.

This highlights a wider persistent blind spot in British economic policymaking: the tendency to overlook the social infrastructure that makes economic participation possible. Investment in care, education and local government services is too often treated as secondary to traditional physical infrastructure spending. That comes at a significant cost. We estimate that the UK loses £113 billion in economic output because women’s skills and labour are underutilised. If the Chancellor wants to unlock growth in every postcode and boost living standards across the UK, women must be at the heart of economic policy.


And while a new fund to tackle misogyny is welcome, £5 million a year for three years is a drop in the ocean. It is, notably, just half the amount allocated to a single new parkway station in Cardiff. Violence against women and girls is a national emergency, and it needs to be treated as such. 1 in 4 women in England and Wales will experience domestic abuse in her lifetime and one woman is killed by an ex/partner every five days. 

The biggest question left unanswered at the dispatch box was what will happen to the spending envelopes for most departments including those covering justice, education and local government. While health and defence absorb the vast majority of spending growth, other departments face growing pressure on their existing budgets from inflation and rising costs. The Chancellor’s promise of efficiency savings may reassure the Treasury, but it will raise concerns for those who remember how similar language paved the way for austerity. Cutting waste is one thing; asking overstretched services to do more with less is another. Women are likely to bear the consequences most acutely, both as the majority of users of public services and as the majority of the workforce that delivers them. When public services are stretched beyond capacity, women are often the first to fill the gaps.

The forthcoming spending review is an opportunity to address current shortfalls, but without commitment to spending increases, we are looking at real-terms cuts. That is why it is disappointing that more ambitious revenue raising measures were left on the table. Doubling the bank levy was a welcome step and a recognition that sectors which have benefited from higher interest rates should contribute more. But the increase is temporary and remains below previous levels. Similarly, not raising capital gains tax rates to align with income tax rates is a huge missed opportunity to bring in much-needed tax revenue.

No one expected this Budget to dismantle 40 years of neoliberalism overnight. But it could have started shifting priorities.

So, while this Budget may have offered some breathing space, it did not deliver a convincing answer to the question of how women’s living standards will improve over the long term.

The Women’s Budget group is a feminist economics think tank that raises awareness of and provides evidence for a gender equal economy. We put feminism into economics and economics into feminism. www.wbg.org.uk 

The post Did the budget deliver for women? appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

The midterm monsters: A moment of danger — and opportunity for Europe and democracy. 

Stockholm Syndrome provides a useful metaphor for the world’s infuriating relationship with Trump. It’s almost a relief to arrive at that moment when the abuser behaves so outrageously that even the victim has to concede he’s a ‘bastard’, that they’ve been manipulated all along with false flattery, comforting familiarity (the special relationship) and coercion (tariff threats), whilst coasting on the ‘good chaps’ delusion that ‘he just wouldn’t do that (would he?)’. 

But he just has. Trump has just clarified that his true affinity lies, not with protecting Western democracy, but with Putin, the world’s leading strongman “criminal” and “thug”. ‘Melodramatists’ who, along with Mary Trump, spotted this years ago, feel grimly vindicated. 

Hearing Zelensky quietly acknowledging Trump’s alignment with Putin is heartbreaking. It’s also a historic moment in which we are finally cut loose from ‘the big deception’.

Flouting the Graham Act, Trump has relaxed sanctions on Russia and forged a diesel deal. He has also authorised delays to Ukraine’s supplies of patriot missiles, and is planning joint nuclear-powered data centres with Russia. He has defined Zelensky as the aggressor and punished Ukraine by playing with the Starshield surveillance flip-switch. When it’s off, the Ukrainian military fly blind, with devastating consequences for Ukraine’s citizens.

Russia’s mission to undermine Europe is long-standing. But it now looks clear that the White House plans to join the venture to replace the European liberal, rules-based order with ethno-nationalist, Christo-fascist, white supremacism. 

The midterms

In this context, the US midterm election is a two-act play (on 3 November and 3 January) representing the battle over liberal democracy. Trump has fallen from grace but still has numerous levers (including delaying election court cases and calling a state of emergency) to prevent a just result. And, since he has stuffed the Supreme Court with Republicans, we cannot be certain how the court will respond. 

If Trump succeeds in barring elected Democrats from being seated on 3 January, his mission alignment with Putin will place Europe and other middle powers under new pressure and send a deep, corrosive chill through the Western rules-based order. Europe will want to hasten its independence from the US, and strengthen military and economic cooperation, internally, and with sympathetic nations like Canada. But European military self-sufficiency alone is predicted to take 25 years and cost $1tn. 

Meanwhile, Russia could become a US proxy – an attack weapon against Europe which allows the US to maintain distance and continue fudging its NATO commitments. With US sanctions lifted, Russia is in a stronger position to attack countries beyond Ukraine. This aggression would unify Europe but also generate division around the crippling costs of defence in deeply cash-strapped countries. 

Europe is already embattled. Far-right parties are poised to take France, Spain and key parts of Germany. The mission to undermine Europe is under way. If Trump steals the midterms, European pro-Russia countries, factions and parties wanting protection are likely to step up their collusion with Russia in challenging ‘the corrupt West’. So, Europe could become even more vulnerable to internal extreme right, fascist take-overs.

We hope, but can’t assume, that Europe will remain united against an emboldened Russia that’s bolstered by backdoor US funding and propaganda assistance. Nor is Trump’s Russia alignment a fanboy quirk. If in doubt, listen to presidential wannabies, JD Vance and Marco Rubio, delivering menacing ‘civilizational erasure’ attacks on Europe in recent speeches.

Trump stealing the midterms may quicken the spread of fascism in Europe and impede the wider existential fight to preserve democracy. 

The perfect moment

Trump may have chosen this moment to abandon his thin veneer of loyalty to the rules-based order because his midterm polling is terrible. What better time to wrap oneself vicariously in the strength of a mafia strongman?

But it’s also a moment of unrest fomenting across Europe, that’s ripe for exploitation. Citizens of France, Spain, Albania, Italy, and Portugal are pushing back against neoliberalism’s broken promises (on housing, public services, living costs, and education). Feelings of anger and betrayal over governmental failure to deliver are spreading like summer wildfires, breeding riots and receptivity to the strongman solutions of fascism in equal measure.

The neoliberal ethos appears to be creaking under the weight of its own avarice, with the pernicious role of the super-wealthy becoming increasingly clear. Oligarchs, notably tech giants, are buying ideologies, governments and elections in order to block regulation and protect their assets against fair distributions of wealth. By aligning with fascist strongmen they seek to prevent democratic values from obstructing their financial interests. In this regard, Trump is just a predictable consequence, a sad puppet, of wider ideological forces. 

Fascist noise and voting from experience

We cannot know how US events will unfold between 3 November 2026 and 3 January 2027. But this week’s remarkable election results from Serbia and Brazil give pause for thought. Against the odds, they followed Hungary’s earlier achievement and voted in progressive democratic leaders. Brazil’s election, for one, echoes America’s struggles – Lula’s win might have been considerably larger had his Trumpesque opponent, Flavio Bolsonaro, not meddled with the progressive vote (by, for example, halting buses to polling stations).

But there’s one pattern here that seems clear. On the one hand, European countries such Germany, Italy, France and Spain are courting extreme right parties because many of their citizens, especially the younger demographic, have no first-hand experience of fascism in living memory. They direct their hostilities instead to their incumbent leaders, the neoliberal ‘centrists’ (Macron, Merz, Sanchez, and the increasingly centrist Meloni) whose low growth, high public debt economies have crippled public trust.

By contrast, the citizens of Brazil, Serbia and Hungary have had recent experience of corrupt right-wing populist governments and extreme right dictatorships. They understand the painful consequences of falling for the remedies of these spin doctors. The US is on the same trajectory, with recognition gradually dawning over the midterms. 

And yet citizens seem to have difficulty extrapolating from the experience of other countries to their own. The US is an insular nation. So, perhaps we wouldn’t expect it to look outwards to the uncomfortable parity between its own Republican administration and the governance of other countries? But why aren’t those European countries currently toying with fascism learning from the ruinous experiences of Hungary and Brazil? 

The loud noise of propaganda and social discontent is difficult to escape. Also, fascism, as Melanie Klein notes, isn’t static; it’s a dynamic spiral which evolves to match the societies in which it occurs. Its latest iteration arrived by stealth because, contra the 1930s, modern societies disguise it better. We have algorithms instead of marching boots, bot propaganda farms instead of Nazi rallies, and predominantly right-wing press classified as ‘impartial’. Escaping the cunning of modern fascism is not straightforward.

A modern monster

Yet, each fascist phase, despite its changing historical face, has a shared feature. It is an expression of our ‘worst version of ourselves’. Matt D’Ancona 

“We are a demon-haunted species, striving to embrace the better angels of our nature” (Matt D’Ancona).

Trump, as a ‘demonic worst version of ourselves’ may be US fascism’s undoing. 

His recent abominations have tested even MAGA loyalty. Half-empty Trump rallies are testimony to the red lines being drawn against a leader who supported the live streaming of an execution, who shared a video, against the parents’ express wishes, of their mentally ill son being killed by a tiger, then mocked the event with his own AI version. America is finally stalling over a man who has violated the ‘America First’ ideal with flagrant expansionism and aggression (Venezuela, Greenland, Iran), who advocated “obliterating Iran”, who betrayed Ukraine, and who has littered the US with data centres and detention camps. 

To be candid, these actions may have appalled US voters less if the price of oil was lower. Let’s just be grateful for the co-incidence of high oil prices and Trump’s moral travesties. 

But Trump’s demonic extremism ultimately makes him a progressive asset. He has inadvertently fast-tracked the corruption and hollowness of neoliberalism and its failures. Symbolically, he’s an incarnation of ‘the thing in the raw’ – stripped of the ‘good chaps’ niceties, the pretend deference to the rules, and cod moral thinking, which together masked the system’s real incentives and successfully conned citizens into viewing it as the only and best way forward.

Now the world is seeing the bare-faced monster in all its glory. Trump has done us the favour of comprehensively removing the gloss – accelerating the truth by standing as a naked, ugly symbol of where unfettered neoliberalism ultimately leads – to world domination by an army of glitzy, shallow, dangerous, insane, uncontrolled menaces.

Like Francis Bacon’s ‘Pope’, he is screaming at us that change is now unavoidable if we want to survive.

Cliff-edge

America has repeated Klein’s nightmare spiral of fascism with ‘evil chaps’ now mocking their ‘good chaps’ theory of governance. Yet, despite the grip and creep of fascism, we have reasons for optimism – citizens can learn from experience, fascism can overreach and expose itself. 

As we barrel towards the midterms, we are by-standers waiting to see if the outcome will strengthen or undermine Europe and the international rules-based order. We are also observing a momentous symbolic power struggle between progressive liberal values and their opponents.

If the Republicans fail to win the House and even the Senate, then in the run-up to the new legislative session on 3 January 2027, Trump’s backers will do their utmost to manoeuvre the Supreme Court towards a swamp of legal grey areas. At this point, the fate of US and European democracy will be down to the wire, potentially hanging on whether Republican Justices of the Court listen to the better angels of their nature, stand their ground, and resist huge pressure to make partisan verdicts. The world’s eyes will be on them.

Image credit: Gage Skidmore – Creative Commons

The post The midterm monsters: A moment of danger — and opportunity for Europe and democracy.  appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

The budget is a missed opportunity for the government to loosen the shackles of neoliberalism

Prem Sikka is an Emeritus Professor of Accounting at the University of Essex and the University of Sheffield, a Labour member of the House of Lords, and Contributing Editor at Left Foot Forward.

Chancellor John Healey has delivered his first budget statement as he seeks to reset the UK economy. Amidst trade and military wars, there is an urgent need to make the economy and households more resilient.

Successive governments have sought to increase economic growth but the economy remains sluggish. It is expected to grow by about 1.2% in 2026. One of the reasons is that people lack good purchasing power. Some 25.3m people (37.5% of the population) live below the Minimum Income Standard. Their ability to fuel economic growth is also hampered by regressive tax system. The poorest 20% pay a higher proportion of their income in direct and indirect taxes than the richest 20%.

For over 30 years the UK’s investment in productive assets has been low. As a percentage of GDP, it is the lowest among G7 countries . It has ranked at or near the bottom of the OECD investment league. Manufacturing sector has propelled economic growth in China and elsewhere. However, the UK manufacturing sector has shrunk from 30.1% of economic output (gross value added) in 1970 to 8.3% in 2026. Infrastructure woes are all too evident in potholed roads, crumbling schools, NHS queues and universities in crisis.

Neoliberal economics has squeezed households and failed to deliver beneficial economic growth.  Redistribution of wealth and investment are key requirements. However, the Chancellor’s ability to carve a new path is severely constrained by self-imposed constraints. These include subservience to fiscal rules which limit government borrowing, and Labour’s 2024 election manifesto pledge to not increase national insurance, the basic, higher, or additional rates of income tax, VAT, and corporate tax rate. In addition, successive governments have been keen to appease corporations and the super-rich.

Against, the above background, the budget is disappointing.

The Budget

Corporations will be pleased. Water companies won’t be nationalised. There is no windfall tax on energy companies and no curbs on profiteering which is pushing millions into poverty.

The increase in surcharge on bank profits from 3% to 6% is less than the 8% expected hike. Over the next 15 months a total of £1.5bn is expected to be raised. There is an increase in machine games duty from 20% to 25% and could raise about £720m. The gambling industry was expecting the increase to 40%. Around £2bn will be raised from additional taxes on landlords and rental income. There are no rent controls or other measures to prevent the rise to be passed to tenants.

Redistribution is mostly absent and the super-rich remain largely unscathed. Wages will continue to be taxed at marginal rates of 20%-45%. Earners will also pay national insurance. Capital gains accruing to less than 1% of the population will continue to be taxed at 18% to 24%. Dividends, mostly accruing to the richest, will continue to be taxed at marginal rates of 10.75% to 39.35%. The Chancellor chose not to align the dividend and capital gains tax rates with wages, preferring to tax labour at higher rates than return on wealth. A new Founders’ Relief offers a 10% rate on life time capital gains of up to £10m. The tax avoidance industry must be salivating at how it can exploit this.

The biggest tax rise on households is through continuation of the freeze on income tax thresholds. The personal allowance was frozen at £12,570 in 2021. If it had risen in line with inflation, then for the current tax year it would have been £16,070. Due to the freeze, a minimum wage earner is paying additional £980 in income tax and national insurance in 2026-27. Assuming an inflation rate of 3.5%, the personal allowance for 2027-28 should be £16,632. However, because of the freeze someone on minimum wage will pay additional £1,137 in income tax and national insurance in 2027-28.  This is the cost of appeasing the rich.

Due to the freeze, millions more would become liable to pay income tax. One such group is pensioners. The state pension is due to rise by 3.9% from April 2027. The full post-2016 state pension, received by a small number of pensioners, will be £13,036.40, which is above the personal allowance of £12,570. The government has announced that pensioners with income of £13,036 (state pension plus other income) there would be a new Pension Tax Allowance i.e. pensioners will not pay income tax, a concession worth up to £94. To prevent a cliff-edge, for pensioners with income between £13,037 and £13,319 there would be a taper. For every £3 of income above £13,036, Pension Tax Allowance will be reduced by £1. The net result is that pensioners with incomes between £13,036 and £13,319 will effectively be paying tax at a marginal rate of 53%. 

This is complicated and divisive. A worker with income of £13,036 would pay income tax and national insurance. It would have been far better to increase the personal allowance for everyone.

Risk-averse individuals tend to put their savings in banks and building societies, the resulting interest income is taxable. £1,000 of interest is tax free for basic rate taxpayers. The limit is £500 for higher and additional rate taxpayers. After that and the £12,570 personal allowance, the amounts are taxable at the appropriate marginal rates. That is set to change. From next April, a 2% extra tax will be levied to interest income. Form April 2028, this will rise by another 2% i.e. there will be 4% additional income tax on savings income. So, a basic rate taxpayer will pay 24% income tax on taxable interest income, higher rate taxpayers will be taxed at 44% and additional rate taxpayers at 49%. This is expected to raise around £2.4bn by 2031-32. Perhaps, the change is intended to encourage people to put savings into ISA accounts. Nevertheless, many don’t want their cash tied for longer periods. Meanwhile dividends will be taxed at rates between 10.75% and 39.35%, capital gains at 18% to 24%. Is this part of a government plan to push people into gambling on stocks and shares? Why are cash savers penalised?

There is some relief for savers. The chancellor has reinstated the limit of £20,000 on cash ISAs. This will do little for 39% of adults with savings of £1,000 or less.

Form April 2027, the headline rate of the national minimum wage for workers age 21 or over will increase by 3.9% to £13.21 per hour. The acceleration of wage rate for younger workers towards £13.21 per hour has been halted even though they pay full rent, food, travel and other costs, and the output of their labour is not sold at a discount.

There is some relief for households in the form of £100 energy bill discount for people living in homes in council tax band A to D. Gas standing charge would be absorbed into the main unit price, which would help light users of energy. The average household bill is expected to rise by 16%-27% in January, adding £276 to £469 to the cost. The Chancellor is looking at the energy contracts, pricing and possibilities of moving levies out of bills on to general taxation.

The Chancellor has provided extra £1.5bn for the Social and Affordable Housing Programme to build 10,000 new home skin England, taking the council housing commitment to £40bn.  Some 1.3m households are waiting for a social home. Successive government have failed to hit housebuilding targets as the UK lacks the infrastructure to provide materials and skilled labour.

£190m extra is provided to NHS England to manage the winter pressures. Another £100m is provided to accelerate the adoption of robotically assisted surgery. It will do little to reduce the backlog of 7.37m hospital appointments. There is a £17.3bn maintenance backlog, including £3.7bn of work classified as “high risk”. The NHS budget is also being squeezed by the deal with the US on drug pricing that will strip £44.7bn out of the NHS budget between now and 2036.

Reform of business rates would be welcomed by small businesses, but they will continue to be buffeted by high energy and water costs, poor infrastructure and low consumer purchasing power.

The government continues to guarantee corporate profits. The Chancellor said “we will expand our defence industrial base by getting the maximum amount of private investment into defence, including through public private partnerships”. This confirms a deeper role of private finance initiative (PFI) now rebranded as public private partnerships. For PFI every £1 of private investment resulted in £6 payment from the public purse. Such indulgence is the inevitable result of fiscal rules which constrain direct state investment.

The budget is a missed opportunity for the government to loosen the shackles of neoliberalism. Corporations and the super-rich have been appeased. The spending power of most households will be further eroded. Regressive tax policies continue to penalise workers. This does not provide a good basis for fuelling economic growth. Within the neoliberal logic, the forthcoming spending, Milburn and Timms Reviews are expected to herald cuts. Maybe the new Chancellor is saving good news for households until 2028/29, just before the next general election. 

The post The budget is a missed opportunity for the government to loosen the shackles of neoliberalism appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Layla Moran MP: Ignoring young people once again in this Budget would be a mistake

Layla Moran is the Lib Dem MP for Oxford West and Abingdon.

A budget is many things. It is an economic blueprint and tax policy document yes, but it is also a signal of Government priorities and a shout-out to the causes it believes in.

From the pre-budget whispers I’m hearing, the main signal seems to be “don’t rock the boat!”. Tinkering around the edges with a small tax on banks here, a tax on online marketplaces there, a small giveaway to pensioners, and some measures to tackle the cost of living.

The ‘everyday fixes’ expected in the budget include measures such as the removal of import tariffs on gherkins. Cheaper gherkins are all well and good, but do not address the major structural problems in our country.

It contrasts with the bold rhetoric of the Prime Minister in his first few months in office. Proportional Representation, the end of the triple lock, a new deal with Europe, with free Movement and maybe even rejoining on the cards.

Biggest of all, he has promised a National Care Service. As Chair of the Health and Social Care Committee, I have shouted loudly for action on Social Care.

The costs of inaction are enormous; unpaid carers under enormous strain to the extent they are
unable to hold onto their jobs, delayed discharges costing the NHS a fortune, and millions simply not having their needs met. But warm words alone aren’t going to cut it.

Like so many of Burnham’s promises, it is planned after the next election. Why
wait 3 years, why not take action now?

And some things really can’t wait at all – young people being top of that list. It is worth putting yourself in the shoes of someone who is in their early twenties. At the pointy end of school when Covid hit, they suffered through the uncertainties of GCSEs and A-Levels under lockdown. University places, apprenticeship and employment opportunities were snatched away at the hands of an unfair, opaque, and systematically biased algorithm.

For those who went to university, what should have been some of the best years of their lives were reduced to zoom lectures and confinement to the bubble of their flat. Isolated, dealing with the toxicity of social media without the escape normally available.

Now, just emerging blinking into the job market, they are hit with a Government made crisis, between the Tories botched Brexit deal to the Reeves budget that hiked National Insurance contributions small businesses just don’t have the headroom to offer those precious first jobs anymore. Where is the future which was promised to them by their elders for getting good grades and working hard?

Many are burdened with student loans which are manifestly unfair, with spiralling debts, excessive interest rates and frozen repayment thresholds. We should be lowering the monthly payments, increasing repayment thresholds, and supporting public service workers and disadvantaged students who desperately need relief. 

It is no wonder that the mental health of our young people is suffering. The Health and Social Care Committee’s current inquiry is examining mental health support and services provided in education and community settings. The picture is bleak. 

Waiting times are so high that in some cases with a years-long wait list the service may as well not exist. The severity of needs is continuing to rise, and a large proportion of people never receive the help they need. 

What is so frustrating is that I have seen best practice which shows that it does not have to be this way. In the East Midlands, one CAMHS service has reduced referral wait times to less than five days. Early Support Hubs such as the one I visited in Devon, with a walk-in, holistic service for young people’s mental health have made a huge difference to young people. But the Government drags its feet over funding the limited number that exist every year. 

Best practice should instead be rolled out nationwide.  This would require the Government to look at long term benefits, rather than short term balance sheets. For young people who contact me, it is often the long term that really concerns them. 

The destructive and remorseless juggernaut of climate change, the effects of which are being felt ever more keenly. The worry over job prospects in a world being overtaken by AI. A world that feels less safe, and less secure every day. 

To tackle these require long term thinking. Investment in services such as those Early Support Hubs, whose benefits won’t be felt tomorrow, or even in five years time, but in the long run we know that it will make all the difference in the world. 

I challenge the Chancellor to do today what very few Governments have the courage to do. Avoid the short-term sugar rush of fleeting measures that look good in a newspaper. Instead, think long-term.

The post Layla Moran MP: Ignoring young people once again in this Budget would be a mistake appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

How to Start Ending Neoliberalism at this Budget

Joe Wright is policy and advocacy manager at Tax Justice UK

Compared to last year, this Budget season has been remarkably quiet – dozens upon dozens of floated tax policies replaced with almost deafening silence, save Chancellor Healey’s ruling out of Capital Gains Tax equalisation (despite this being called for by large swathes of his own party, leading economists and investors themselves). At the same time, we now have a Prime Minister with vast ambitions compared to his predecessor – ending 40 years of Neoliberalism, creating a National Care Service, investment and growth in every postcode.

To raise the funds needed to turn these words to action and tackle the wealth inequality gripping this country, the Government must use this week’s Budget to tax extreme wealth and corporations profiting off a cost of living crisis. This will require structural tax reform, which means going much further than simply reversing a cut to the banking surcharge imposed under former Tory Chancellor Jeremy Hunt. 

Nigel Lawson equalised Capital Gains Tax with Income Tax rates, rightly understanding that there was no moral or economic reason for different kinds of income to be taxed differently. Healey must look at this option, alongside applying employee NICs to income from wealth and partnerships, following the same logic – equal treatment of income regardless of source. These two measures would raise £19.7bn and £6.1bn respectively by the end of the parliament – more than enough to fully fund a National Care Service, free at point of use (£18.5bn), as well as promoting economic growth by reducing distortions in the tax system. 

Importantly for a government that needs to build unity across the factions of the Labour Party and the broader progressive side of politics; CGT equalisation is backed by both the centre Growth Group, the Soft Left Tribune Group, the Socialist Campaign Group and many Liberal Democrats – this can unlock billions in revenue, promote growth and unite the Labour Party – which has been wracked by division since coming to power. 

Healey must also get our tax system and administration in order. We spend more than £200bn a year on tax reliefs, many of which like the Patent Box are unjustified giveaways to global multinationals, and have a £60bn tax gap – the difference between what HMRC should be collecting and what it actually receives. 

By getting our leaky sieve of a tax system in order, and investing in HMRC capacity and powers over the remainder of the parliament, the government would be in position to implement an annual wealth tax of 2% on those with more than £10m in assets, raising over £24bn a year – even accounting for any behaviour responses. Whilst not possible at this Budget, this would be achievable within 3 years – in time for the next General Election.  

Collectively, these measures could raise upwards of £70bn a year – enough to fully fund a National Care Service, build 100,000 council houses a year, restore central government funding to local government back to 2010 levels, fully fund sure start, fill the core schools funding gap, introduce free school meals for all pupils, and fund a cost-of-living package, with several billion left to spare. 

Burnham came into No10 with big promises about how he’d do things differently, to reset Britain and end neoliberalism. And the scale of the problem is widespread – from the cost of living crisis to profiteering in almost every aspect of our lives. So this Budget can’t be about half measures or poster campaigns to tackle minor annoyances. This has to be a moment that kickstarts a rewiring of the economy and the state. Failing to deliver this will spell trouble and could quickly deflate Burnham’s bounce.

The post How to Start Ending Neoliberalism at this Budget appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Millionaires are ready to pay more – this Budget should let us

Phil White is an engineer, consultant and member of Patriotic Millionaires UK

Before it’s even happened, this week’s Budget is being labelled low-key and boring. After three months of big promises under Andy Burnham’s new leadership, the mood around the country’s biggest fiscal event feels remarkably flat. 

Now is not the time to slow down. There is no doubt that people and small businesses need breathing space from the cost-of-living crisis and I would welcome a Budget that delivers on that – but crumbs of support are not going to fix this country long-term. If the Prime Minister and the Chancellor are serious about giving people a better future, they need our country to be built on a fair, thriving and sustainable economy, with a tax system that makes sure those who can most afford to, pay their fair share. But right now taxes are the opposite of this, asking too much of small businesses and working people, and too little of the very richest, like me.

Taxing wealth properly isn’t radical or even controversial, in fact, it is widely supported. Three quarters of UK millionaires polled said that to ensure the UK is a place they are proud to live in, they would be willing to pay more tax. And 75% of the public support a 2% tax on wealth over £10 million.

We should all feel hope and pride about the country we live in. But when income from work is taxed higher than income from wealth, it’s no wonder the public feel ripped off. The Chancellor has the opportunity to unlock an economy that works for everybody, by delivering on the Prime Minister’s pledge to draw a line under trickle down economics once and for all. 

Equalising Capital Gains Tax with Income Tax and closing loopholes should be step one. Not only would it level the playing field, by taxing wealth like work, this reform would raise £19.7bn for our country by 2029-30 according to CenTax’s latest estimate. The Chancellor should also forge a clear pathway towards a 2% annual wealth tax on assets over £10 million, raising around £24 billion a year and affecting only the very wealthiest 0.04% of the UK’s population. 

This is about so much more than just raising revenues – it’s about tackling the deep-rooted inequality which is holding this country back and building a more equal future for everyone. 

The Prime Minister knows the tax system is broken – and has said so himself. Almost 12 months ago, ahead of the 2025 Autumn Budget, Patriotic Millionaires UK toured the country on our “tax us the super-rich” campaign bus, urging the Chancellor to tax our wealth. When we stopped in Manchester, Andy Burnham, then Mayor of Greater Manchester, came to meet us. In an interview, he told us: “In this country we overtax people’s work and we undertax wealth.” Now he leads our country and has the power to fix it. That fix to our economy should start this week, with this Budget.

The post Millionaires are ready to pay more – this Budget should let us appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Why John Healey should prioritise the arts in the budget

Tom Peters is Head of Policy & Public Affairs at Equity

The 1997 Labour government brought about something of a golden age in public support for the arts. Then culture secretary Chris Smith MP, with the help of a young special adviser called Andy Burnham, began to increase the Arts Council England’s grants budget substantially every year. It was nearly twice the size when Burnham was himself appointed secretary of state for culture a decade later.

It is often heard among the arts sector today that such a big investment was an anomaly. That our industries were the passive beneficiaries of a period of unprecedented growth, which provided lots of cash for ‘nice to haves’. But now there are too many other priorities and too few resources to consider the arts.

The pessimists have short memories. Chancellor Healey, our eighth in ten years, would do well to ask his new boss in No.10 why it was that he was so committed to investing in the arts in his early political career and what the last Labour government felt our creative industries could contribute. The new prime minister’s reply might address three themes.

First, the arts are a producer of growth, not just a product of it. In 2022, the UK arts sector alone contributed £49billion GVA to our economy. Every creative job generates an additional two jobs in the local area over twenty years. The Society of London Theatre finds that every £1 spent on theatre generates £1.40 in the local economy. Our film and TV workforce attracts £7bn in inward investment and generates £1bn at the UK box office. Creative industry exports are worth £60bn.  A government seeking growth cannot ignore the role that arts and entertainment investment plays in delivering it.

The government is not just seeking growth however, but ‘growth in every post code’. The last Labour government recognised the critical role that the arts could play in driving devolution, through regional creative industries policies, the Regional Development Agencies, screen agencies and Arts Council England. Over the period, the arts became an important medium for the transfer of power and decision-making away from Westminster and national recognition for the full diversity of places and cultures across the UK.

The expansion of strategic authorities today and the inclusion of ‘culture’ within their competencies presents an opportunity to progress this project further. Strategic authorities should have a greater role in coordinating and developing their arts and entertainment economies, drawing Arts Council England grant spending, local government arts funding, support for Culture Priority Places, local jobs plans, and Public Service Broadcasting investment together into a coherent economic framework. One that would generate jobs through increased artistic production and offer more opportunity for local people to see themselves reflected in cultural life. Decent arts provision was once devolution’s forerunner and should now be so again.

Finally, the last Labour government recognised that public support for the arts could help to realise social policy objectives, whether through economic regeneration, tackling social exclusion, strengthening community bonds or fostering diverse local cultures and pride of place. Though the far-right’s recent precipitous rise appears to have plateaued for now, the drivers of their support, and the threat that they pose to our social fabric, have not gone away.  The arts has a role here, in revitalising economically depressed areas, providing a new focus for communities to rally around and offering a chance for all to share in the cultures and experiences of others. This seems more important now than ever.

Each of these themes has been tried and tested by the previous Labour governments in which Andy Burnham served. The academic analyses are already published and the evidence bases built. So next time the chancellor asks colleagues in No.11 why he should prioritise the arts in his budget, perhaps the best person to answer is the man living next door.

Image credit: Simon Dawson / Number 10 – Creative Commons

The post Why John Healey should prioritise the arts in the budget appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

We need a budget to save our shops, make work pay and tackle the cost of living crisis

Joanne Thomas is the general secretary of Usdaw

The UK economy continues to struggle after the legacy of an incompetent and chaotic Conservative government, which left us in a weak position to deal with global events. Tory and Lib Dem austerity, Boris’ bad Brexit deal and Liz Truss’ disastrous budget all contributed to leaving the UK economy vulnerable to the impact of conflicts across the world and climate change. We welcome the steps that Labour has already announced to help save our shops, tackle the cost of living crisis, help make work pay and reform Universal Credit, but there is still much more to do.

Usdaw members, who are key workers serving their communities, continue to suffer as a result of the cost of living. This is reflected in our most recent cost of living survey results from over 7,500 Usdaw members, highlighting a worrying number of low-income workers relying on unsecured loans to meet the cost of everyday essentials: 1 in 4 have struggled to pay everyday bills in the last 12 months and have had to rely on borrowing. A quarter of this was using unsecured borrowing such as payday loans or buy-now-pay-later services. 59% said financial worries are having an impact on their mental health.

Listening to our members’ very real experiences illustrates the scale of the problem: “We are in debt with essential household bills such as energy costs and council tax. We’re now stuck in a never-ending cycle of not being able to gain control of our debts, despite earning enough on paper, as we’re constantly chasing our tails and so overwhelmed”. “Wages stay the same, yet bills go up, food goes up; it makes it hard to be able to pay bills and for travel to work and then comfortably afford to buy a food shop”. “There’s no cushion. If something happened to my car, how would I get to work? I start at 5:30am and public transport doesn’t run that early. How would I pay to get it fixed? I’d have to spend £20 on a taxi to work knowing in my mind that my 5.5-hour shift has just been cut to 3.5 hours’ worth of pay because I’ve spent £25-£30 on transport. It’s a real worry”.

In the last 12 months, nearly a quarter of Usdaw members have had to cut back on heating or electricity use, as a result of financial pressures. With energy prices rising, we are extremely concerned that this pressure will be exacerbated and more low-income households will be forced to choose between heating or eating. We welcome the government’s action to cut VAT on electricity bills but we believe that this does not go far enough, nor is it sufficiently targeted. The government must put in place support for households facing energy debt and help with bills for those who need it most.

The Employment Rights Act will help make work pay and improve job security if delivered in full, and we will be looking to the chancellor to announce another substantial increase in minimum wage rates to reflect the cost of living and end rip-off youth pay. Usdaw has participated in the government’s review of paid parental leave, to help transform the support working parents receive, and we welcome the expansion of childcare provision delivered by Labour. We are calling for substantial reform of Universal Credit to build on the success of abolishing the two-child limit.

Job security is a key priority for our members. We support the government’s commitment to ‘growth in every postcode’ and the retail sector has a significant role to play in delivering this. We welcome the action the government has already taken in reducing business rates for pubs, clubs and live music venues. Alongside this, Labour has a manifesto commitment to level the playing field between the high street and online giants. So, confirmation from the chancellor that the government will be producing a high streets strategy is welcome, but it is essential that it is linked to the wider industrial strategy, including exempting large physical retail premises from the higher rates multiplier. 

A fairer tax system is needed so that we can rebuild our public services without placing additional burdens on low-paid workers. There is strong public support for the wealthiest paying their fair share of tax. The freezing of thresholds until 2031 brings millions of workers and pensioners into either paying tax for the first time or increasing the amount they pay, putting more strain on low-income households. The government needs to take the impact of this into consideration and look at whether there are alternative ways to raise the much-needed funding for investment in our public services.

Times are too tough for too many and this needs to be a Budget that addresses the very real issues that impact workers. Pay, hours and job security are the real priorities for our members.

The post We need a budget to save our shops, make work pay and tackle the cost of living crisis appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

John Healey must use the budget to deliver breathing space, not just promise it

Daisy Cooper MP is deputy leader of the Liberal Democrats and the party’s treasury spokesperson

When Andy Burnham became prime minister in July, he said he wanted to give people breathing space. He was right to name the problem.

People are working harder, paying more in tax and getting less in return. For too many families, by the time the bills are paid and the essentials are covered, there is almost nothing left. Nothing for the little things that make life worth living: a pint in the pub with a mate, a takeaway with the kids, a coffee and cake in town, an ice cream on the beach.

None of this is extravagant. It’s normal life, and people who work hard should be able to afford it.

Tomorrow, the government faces its first big test. The budget will show whether that promise of breathing space means something, or whether it was just a good line.

A brutal double whammy

Families are facing rising bills and disappearing support at the same time. Energy costs are going up. So are petrol prices, and so is the cost of eating out.

Between January and March next year, the energy price cap is expected to rise. Fuel duty and rail fares are set to increase, and the Government’s cut to VAT on electricity bills could end.

That is the test. If the chancellor stands by while families are hit with another cost-of-living squeeze, his budget fails, whatever else is in it.

I’m not dismissing the long term. We must get Britain growing again. A stronger economy is how we raise living standards and bring down the cost of essentials like energy, travel, food and rent. But nobody can pay next month’s energy bill with the promise of growth over time. Growth is the long-term answer, but families need a short-term lifeline too.

So our message to the chancellor is simple. Don’t just promise breathing space. Deliver it.

What a ‘Breathing Space Budget’ looks like

The Liberal Democrats are calling for a £14 billion ‘Breathing Space Budget’. Over the next year and a half, it would save households £350 on average. It does three things: it cuts your energy bill, cuts the cost of travel, and cuts the cost of going out.

Energy. We would introduce an Essential Energy Guarantee, cutting average annual electricity and gas bills by £100. There would be additional support for households with children and disabled people, who so often face the toughest choices when the bills land.

Our high streets. We would cut hospitality VAT from 20% to 15% for the same period. That gives pubs, restaurants, and cafés room to keep prices down, protect jobs and stay open. It also makes a meal with the kids, a coffee with a friend, or a pint at the local a little more affordable. Anyone who has watched their local high street decline knows just what’s at stake.

Travel. For an initial three months, we would cut fuel duty by 10p, cut rail fares by 10%, introduce £1 bus fares and cut VAT on kerbside EV charging to 5%. We want public transport to be cheaper and easier to choose. But we also know not everyone has that choice. For millions of people, particularly outside our biggest towns and cities, leaving the car at home simply isn’t an option. They shouldn’t be left out of the help.

Fully funded, and paid for fairly 

The Essential Energy Guarantee would be funded by clawing back excess support handed to monopoly energy operators and using that money to cut household bills instead. 

The hospitality package would be funded by a one-off, time-limited windfall tax on the unexpected and unearned profits of the big banks. 

The emergency travel package would be funded through additional Treasury receipts as petrol prices rise, triggered by Trumpflation. 

A choice to act 

This budget comes down to a choice. The chancellor can stand by while households and businesses are squeezed again, or the government can act. He can cut energy bills, cut the cost of travel, give our high streets a fighting chance, and give people something to look forward to at the end of the month. We’ve shown that it can be done and how to pay for it.

The prime minister promised breathing space. Tomorrow, the chancellor has the chance to deliver it and we Liberal Democrats have shown him how.

Image credit: Simon Dawson / Number 10 – Creative Commons

The post John Healey must use the budget to deliver breathing space, not just promise it appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Fran Heathcote: The Budget must boost pay and tackle the cost-of-living crisis

Fran Heathcote is general secretary of the Public and Commercial Services Union, the biggest British union representing government workers.

This is the cost-of-living Budget. That is the number one issue facing working class people across the country – and this Government needs to find answers.

Energy bills have risen in October and are forecast to rise sharply in January. Inflation has risen to 3.5% and is expected to rise further. Private rents are forecast to increase by 4-5% over the next year and mortgage costs look likely to go up again too.

People can see this tsunami heading towards them and they need a Government that is on their side.

So what should John Healey do on Wednesday? The first thing to do would be to boost pay. The Chancellor is directly responsible for the pay of millions of public sector workers – many of whom have suffered real terms cuts in their incomes since 2010.

You cannot deliver growth in every postcode ifworkers don’t have disposable income. Peopleare cutting back on what they spend in the shops, having a meal out in a restaurant, or a night in the pub because their pay has gone down and their costs have gone up.

PCS commissioned research that proved that increasing the pay of civil servants – especially at the lower end – more than paid for itself in the long run. It does this in three ways:

  1. Firstly, a major part of any increase in public sector pay is recouped in higher tax and national insurance payments. There will also be a reduced entitlement to in-work benefits for some workers, saving the Government money.
  2. Secondly, lower paid workers have a greater propensity to spend and so, if their pay increases, they spend more in their local economy – boosting local businesses. This money spent in a local community recirculates locally instead of leaking out, and this contributes to economic growth and higher tax revenues.
  3. Thirdly, there’s the ratchet effect. A better pay rise in the public sector results in upward pressure in the private sector on pay, as businesses compete for workers. This results in higher tax and national insurance receipts.

The reality is that you cannot deliver a thriving economy without rising real wages. For more than a decade, workers in the public and private sectors have suffered real terms cuts in their incomes, and economic growth has been sluggish.

The academic research we have commissioned demonstrates it clearly. If you boost pay, especially low pay, you grow the economy. That economic growth brings increased tax revenues that outweigh the cost of boosting pay.

So what the Chancellor needs to set out in the Budget is a long-term policy of pay restoration to improve living standards and economic growth.

Boosting household incomes and economic growth are inextricably linked. So the Chancellor should use the Budget to set a new target of increasing disposable incomes for lower and middle earners to help strengthen economic growth, and ask the OBR to report annually on progress.

This would act as a benchmark to measure Government delivery against a far more meaningful measure of economic performance than GDP. It would also act as a guide for future policy interventions, as the OBR report could analyse the pressures on household incomes.

But income only represents one side of the ledger for households. On the other side there is the rising cost-of-living. Recent political history is strewn with the failed careers of short-lived Chancellors and Prime Ministers who didn’t get to grips with this issue.

People are fed up with politicians sitting idly by while they are being ripped by landlords jacking up rent, banks putting up mortgages, and energy and water companies hiking their bills.

When Andy Burnham was Mayor of Greater Manchester he called for a rent freeze and rent controls. Now he is Prime Minister he needs to put that into action, and make clear that profiteering from the British public must come to an end – whether that’s by banks, landlords, energy companies, water companies or supermarkets.

The post-war Churchill government in the early 1950s implemented an excess profits levy in the 1952 Budget under Rab Butler, who told the House of Commons, “we are not prepared to see excessive profits being made”, announcing “it is our intention that an Excess Profits Tax should operate from 1 January of this year”. The Conservative Chancellor declared he was “redistributing public money to those in need”.

If an Excess Profits Levy to fund redistribution was good enough for Churchill’s government, it is good enough for a Labour government today – especially one that is committed to “ending 40 years of neoliberalism” and delivering “growth in every postcode.”

If the Chancellor fails to grip this issue, millions of people face a very tough year and, less importantly, he faces joining the scrapheap of ex-Chancellors who failed to tackle the cost-of-living crisis.

The post Fran Heathcote: The Budget must boost pay and tackle the cost-of-living crisis appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

The new human-crafted Apple Music brand matters in an AI world

Apple just revealed a new brand identity for Apple Music, with the expected turn to Liquid Glass. I’m not much of a fan of their new design language in general; this is where I admit that I’m still running MacOS Sequoia and have grumpy things to say about rounded corner radii and text legibility.

It’s just a trend, it will pass, and at some point I’ll probably cave and upgrade when it starts actually affecting my ability to get work done, or more importantly get security updates. Once I adjust, I’ll stop noticing it, and life will go on.

As such, I wouldn’t normally find an obvious rebrand like this notable, much less feel like I had much to say about it. But then I happened to catch Apple’s behind-the-scenes video in my YouTube recommendations, and I realized I did have thoughts.

Read full article

Comments

© Apple

Richard Burgon MP: Tax Bank Super Profits to Tackle the Cost of Living Crisis 

We go into the Autumn Budget with millions of people still being hammered by what feels like a never-ending cost-of-living crisis.

But while ordinary people struggle to cover the cost of life’s essentials, and with the fallout from Trump’s war on Iran set to push costs even higher, Britain’s biggest banks are doing very well indeed.

The so-called Big Four banks have been making tens of billions in additional profits from the very same interest rate rises that have left people facing mortgage misery and higher rents. 

That is why I am campaigning for the Government to use the Budget to introduce a windfall tax on bank super-profits similar to that applied to oil and gas companies when their profits soared.

The funds raised could be used to bail out ordinary people, through an emergency cost-of-living package of support.

The scale of the banks’ windfall gains makes the case for action hard to ignore.

The four biggest banks in the UK made £46 billion in pre-tax profits in both 2024 and 2025, according to analysis from Positive Money. 

That’s up nearly 80% on their average annual profits of £26 billion from 2018–2021, before interest rates began rising.

That trend is continuing. In the first six months of 2026 alone, the Big Four’s profits were 21% higher than in the same period last year.

We should be clear. These huge additional profits are not the result of improved services or some great innovation on their part.

They are windfall gains from economic circumstances that the banks themselves did not create.

One key way banks have boosted their profits is through the growing gap between what they charge borrowers and what they pay out to savers.

It’s literally easy money.

And what have they done with those profits?

TUC analysis shows that bankers’ bonuses reached their highest level since the 2008 financial crisis earlier this year.

Shareholders have also benefited handsomely. Between 2022 and 2024, the Big Four handed out £74 billion through dividend payments and share buybacks.

There is something deeply wrong with an economy when the same rate rises that hammer ordinary people lead to higher banking profits and bankers’ bonuses.

There is simply no good reason why the banks should be allowed to pocket all of those gains.

If extraordinary economic circumstances deliver huge gains to major corporations, it is only fair that some of that windfall is returned to the public.

When oil and gas companies made extraordinary profits as energy prices surged, a windfall tax was introduced.

The same principle should apply to banks benefiting from higher interest rates.

It is not even a radical policy. In 1981, Margaret Thatcher’s Conservative government imposed a one-off windfall levy on banks after they had benefited significantly from high interest rates.

TUC analysis suggests that a tax on bank super-profits similar to that on the oil and gas firms could raise around £15 billion a year.

That is a vast sum that could be used to ease pressure on living standards and help rebuild our public services.

We are constantly told there is not enough money for that. 

But it’s clear the money is there.

The banks will, of course, warn that taxing them will somehow damage the economy.

Similar warnings are made whenever powerful interests are asked to contribute more, yet they rarely withstand scrutiny.

Even with an extra tax on windfall profits, banks would still have strong commercial incentives to lend and make a profit, as they did before higher rates led to these windfalls.

And as one ex-City banker quipped: “Banks can’t be too big to fail and too big to tax.”

There is also strong public support for taxing these bank windfalls. A TUC poll found that 66% supported a windfall tax on banks and other financial institutions.

I have put down a parliamentary motion calling for a windfall tax and, ahead of the Budget, I will be presenting a petition to Parliament backed by thousands of people calling for such a tax on bank super-profits.

Andy Burnham has rightly talked about ending 40 years of neoliberalism.

Taxing bank windfall profits to support households and rebuild our public services would be one way to start.

The post Richard Burgon MP: Tax Bank Super Profits to Tackle the Cost of Living Crisis  appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

To win the court of public opinion, Burnham must deliver a cost of living budget – here’s how he can do it

It’s been over three months since Andy Burnham became Prime Minister and the ‘Burnham bounce’ is still bouncing.

Labour’s poll ratings have jumped, Burnham’s party conference speech was hailed as one of the greatest ever, a by-election in Holborn and St Pancras has been won, and Burnham’s popularity has reached heights which Keir Starmer would gladly have given up watching his beloved Arsenal for. 

Or maybe not.  

What’s not to like if you’re Andy Burnham? Labour is ahead in the polls. The mood in the party is positive. Small things, like capping bus fares at £2 have reverberated and big things, like building a National Care Service, have resonated.

Burnham is personable, amiable and likeable and a natural and authentic communicator.  If ever I, or you, were to find ourselves in his company, I’m certain he would be incredibly charming.

However, I can’t help but wonder if there’s a niggle at the back of this charming man’s mind, reminding him that he’s yet to be truly tested in the court of public opinion. 

With the budget just a matter of days away, the cost of government borrowing straining public finances and with Burnham and his Chancellor sticking to Labour’s self-imposed fiscal rules, the scope they have to offer relief on cost of living pressures, could be at best restricted and at worst, removed. 

When life doesn’t feel like it’s improving quickly enough, when change only feels like it is slowing things down, and when working harder feels like it’s providing less and less, the danger for the Prime Minister is the breathing space he’s been offering, will soon run out of air.

The next energy price cap will be announced at the end of November, and is expected, from January 2027, to see a typical annual dual fuel bill rise to over £2000 per annum. That’s around £300 more than now, further suffocating family finances which are already gasping for air.

Whilst a £45 reduction in the annual cost of electricity, which began on 1 October has been welcomed, it will be chewed up, digested and ultimately flushed away by the January energy cap increase.

A typical weekly food shop now costs around 40% more than it did just six years ago. Your water bill, your council tax and your monthly direct debits, are all far more expensive than they were back then.

£2 for a litre of diesel is now commonplace and £1.75 or more for unleaded the norm. Just twelve months ago, diesel and unleaded were around 38% and 28% cheaper than today.

Whilst fuel cost increases have been caused by surging oil prices, contributed to by Putin’s illegal war in Ukraine, and the US and Israeli bombing of Iran, it’s worth remembering that for every litre of petrol or diesel you pump, the Treasury pockets 52.95 pence in fuel duty.   

In addition, VAT is then added meaning you are being taxed twice, once from fuel duty and once more from VAT paid on that fuel duty.  

Temporarily removing VAT from fuel duty, until oil prices get back close to pre-war levels, would bring pump prices down by around ten pence per litre, a measure that would positively and proportionately help those on lower incomes the most.

Offering additional targeted help with the cost of energy bills, particularly as winter approaches, would also make a huge difference to those who would otherwise be left out in the cold.

One measure that would do more to help alleviate cost of living pressures than almost any other, would be to raise PAYE allowances, particularly at the lower rate.

The Tories froze PAYE allowances from tax year 2021/22, meaning someone earning just £12,571 began to pay income tax.  

That Tory freeze was due to thaw in 2028 until Labour in government extended it to 2031.  

Yes. You read that right. Labour. Until 2031.

If PAYE levels had risen in line with inflation, as was usually (until 2021/22) the case, someone earning £16,070 today would pay no income tax at all and be £700 better off.

Whilst to some, £700 might only be a drop in the ocean, to others it could be a lifejacket that helps them stay afloat.

Raising PAYE allowances is not just the right thing to do, it is a moral and ethical imperative.  

People with low incomes would pay no income tax at all, whilst at the same time the economy would be stimulated as some of that £700 began to be spent on goods and services.

There are a number of levers the government could pull to pay for raising PAYE allowances and for providing additional targeted energy support.

Capital gains tax could be equalised with income tax, perhaps not in one step, but a marker could nonetheless be set.

A 2% tax could be levied on wealth above £10 million which would only affect a tiny minority of the population but potentially raise as much as £24 billion. 

A relatively small improvement in closing the overall UK tax gap between what is owed and what is collected, could raise £billions, as would clamping down harder on tax evasion.

Scrapping the Bank of England paying interest on central bank reserves could swell the Exchequer’s coffers by up to £30 billion.  

I could go on to mention the potential for billions more from windfall taxes on ‘big energy’, or from increasing the bank corporation tax surcharge, or from a number of other measures, if only word count had not defeated me.

The Chancellor, when delivering his budget, will make the ‘case for the defence.’

The public will deliver their verdict, but it will be the Prime Minister standing ‘in the dock.’

The post To win the court of public opinion, Burnham must deliver a cost of living budget – here’s how he can do it appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Royal financial privileges show that we are not in it together

This week, after perfunctory scrutiny, the UK parliament approved a core Sovereign Grant of £99.9m (from 2027/28) for the King, a 93% increase from the £51.8m for 2024/25 and 65% higher in real terms than in 2016/17. 

The increase will take place against a background where the average real wage has hardly moved since 2008.  Some 13.4m people, including 4m children, live in poverty.  25.3m people, including 14.9m working adults and 7.7m children, live below minimum income standard. Healthy life expectancy is shrinking and around 300,000 people a year die prematurely whilst waiting for a hospital appointment. 

The Sovereign Grant covers the cost of maintaining royal residences, official engagements undertaken by the King and other members of the Royal Family acting on his behalf, and employment costs for Royal Household staff supporting the King as head of state. This is in addition to around £370m spent on refurbishment of Buckingham Palace via higher Sovereign Grants in the last 10 years. The revenue from Buckingham Palace tourism goes to the King. A book by former Liberal Democrat MP Norman Baker stated that the royal family utilizes 21 properties officially categorized as royal residences, alongside 13 additional properties. Inevitably, there are questions about why the royals need 21 properties to fulfil their royal duties. Are any rented out? Where does the income go?

Comparison with other European monarchies is not always straight forward but the royal family seems to receive very generous public funding. It is around £42m in Norway,  £52m in the Netherlands, £18m in Denmark, £13.5m in Sweden, £7.1m in Spain, and zero in Liechtenstein.

In the UK, individuals receiving public money are frequently means-tested. For example, anyone with lifetime savings of over £16,000 is generally disqualified or severely restricted from receiving Universal Credit, Housing Benefit, or Income Support. Such tests do not apply to the royal family which is estimated to have wealth of £21bn.

The Sovereign Grant is meant to cover only the ‘official’ expenses of the Sovereign. However, official’ and ‘personal’ expenses are not easy to distinguish. Are support staff, palaces, various residences, servants, kitchens, chauffeurs for personal or official purposes? Whatever is personal should not be funded by the public purse. During the parliamentary debate Ministers were asked to clarify but did not respond.

The Royal Household does not submit a transparent annual Budget request to the Treasury, detailing what is needs and how it will spend. Instead, the Sovereign Grant is based on a formula linked to profits of the Crown Estate. The amount of the Grant is frozen against losses when profits fall, yet fully open to the upside when they surge. 

The Crown Estate is essentially property and businesses owned by the royal family. Their legal status is contested. Do the Crown Estate, the Crown Jewels, paintings, artworks, antiques, the Duchy of Cornwall and the Duchy of Lancaster belong to the nation and held in trust by the royal family or are they private property? If they are held in trust for the nation, then all revenues must go the public purse, and parliament must then decide what the royal family needs to discharge its public duties. But that is not what happens. If they are private property, then those assets and the related income streams must be taxed in the same way as any other private property is, and the beneficiaries must pay income tax, capital gains tax, corporation tax and inheritance tax. That doesn’t happen either.

The Duchy of Lancaster and the Duchy of Cornwall are major sources of income and wealth for the King and Prince William but are not legally liable to pay income tax, capital gains tax or inheritance tax. However, the King pays income and capital gains tax on a voluntary basis on his assets, a practice started by Elizabeth II in 1993. 

The Sovereign Grant doesn’t count as income for tax purpose but if normal individuals receive money from the state to enable them to make ends meet, such sums are taxable. For example, the state pension, carer’s allowance, contribution-based jobseeker’s allowance, and contribution-based employment and support allowance are all taxable.

To address public concerns, in June 2026, Buckingham Palace announced that “the amount of tax payable by His Majesty since Accession is more than £30 million. In the two full tax years since becoming King, His Majesty’s tax bill was £11.7 million in 2023-24 and £12.9 million in 2024-25 respectively”. 

The Prince of Wales also pays tax voluntarily on his income from the Duchy of Cornwall to the extent that is not used to meet official expenditure. The Prince of Wales declared that he paid £7.76m tax over the same period.

This does not amount to transparency and does not tell us anything about the tax that should or could have been paid. Little is publicly known about the royal family’s total income, wealth, gifts, capital gains, inheritance, dividends or profits. Almost nothing is known about the King’s investments, how they are held, where they are held and income therefrom. Despite the King’s concerns about the environment, no information is provided about the environmental impact of the Royal Households, frequent domestic and foreign flights and multiple residences. Recently, royal family bought two helicopters at £8m each through the Sovereign Grant, whilst air ambulance service relies upon charitable donations.

The Duchy of Cornwall

One of the most anomalous positions in the monarchy is that of the Duchy of Cornwall. It is owned by the Duke of Cornwall (Prince of Wales and heir to the throne). Is it a public organisation, a Crown body, a corporate conglomerate or a private fiefdom?

If it is part of the Crown, then all the checks, balances, scrutiny and accountability that apply to ‘public’ assets should also apply to the duchy and its custodian (i.e. Prince Williams). Its records should be subjected to periodic scrutiny by the National Audit Office to determine whether the organisation is operating efficiently and effectively and that the public is getting value for money. None of this applies to the Duchy, as we are told that it is a private estate.

The Duchy is a giant commercial organisation. Its business extends far beyond the borders of Cornwall. It is one of the biggest landowners spread across 20 counties in England and Wales. Its operations include or have included biscuits, snacks, jam, marmalade, honey, chocolate, organic food, seeds, holiday cottages, farm produce and warehouses. It owns the Oval Cricket ground and receives public money by leasing out Dartmoor prison to the government.

Under archaic laws, the estate of deceased intestates resident in Cornwall and dying without next of kin passes or assets remaining following dissolution of a company registered in Cornwall passes to the Duchy of Cornwall. Similar law applies to the Duchy of Lancaster. The amounts, after deducting costs, are passed to the Duke’s favoured charities. Elsewhere, the amounts go to the state.

Its 2026 accounts show total assets of £1.3bn and financial surplus of £21.55m, which passes to the Duke of Cornwall. The Duchy competes with local and national businesses, but it does not pay corporation tax or capital gains tax because it claims to be a Crown body. This gives it unfair commercial advantage over all its competitors. The UK tax revenues provide for education, pensions and healthcare for workers and social infrastructure used by the Duchy to make profits. However, because of the tax exemptions the Duchy does not bear the social costs. The Duchy and the Duke or Corwall are basically having a free ride on the back of ordinary taxpayers. 

The Duchy also enacts a royal charade. Page 92 of the Duchy’s 2026 accounts state that “Certain Duchy properties were occupied by His Majesty The King and his office staff for living accommodation or commercial activities. These were let at open market values; the total value of annual rent charged amounted to £503,711”. This is a reference to Highgrove House, the King’s preferred residence. So, the King pays rent to the Duchy of Cornwall, out of the Sovereign Grant, which is owned by his son the Duke of Cornwall. Wealth is retained within the family. Did the King really spend public money?

The monarchy is a key part of the contemporary UK state, but its financial affairs remain shrouded in secrecy. There is little transparency or public accountability of its wealth or the inflation-busting rise in the Sovereign Grant. Expenditure is not scrutinised. In the age of deference, parliament rubber-stamps decisions already made. Despite being one of the richest families, the Sovereign and the Duke of Cornwall enjoy tax exemptions whilst someone with income of £12,571 pays income tax. The Duchy of Cornwall enjoys tax advantages not available to any other business. The royals frequently claim that they wish to be treated as normal human beings. That wish should be fulfilled by removing all tax concessions.

The post Royal financial privileges show that we are not in it together appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

❌