How to improve the user experience of videos and images
In September’s Content Improvement Club, we looked at how we use videos and images on our websites. We covered how to improve the accessibility and usability of embedded media and we discussed the role that videos and images play in making our sites more sustainable.
Examples of pages with and without images
Images and videos are common features on University websites.
For example, here’s the University homepage as it looks today:

University of Edinburgh homepage
One click away, we get to a page with an embedded video:

But in the early days of the web, images weren’t so common and videos were more or less nonexistent. Here’s what the University homepage looked like in 1997:

The University homepage archived on the Wayback Machine
This might seem like an outdated way to present a navigational page. But even today, some major public sector websites use a predominantly text-based design without many images or videos.
Here’s the NHS Health A to Z page:

For another example, see Edinburgh Council’s page about council tax:

Edinburgh Council: Council Tax
Aside from the site logo and a few icons in the menu bar, there’s not an image to be seen. Weird, right?
Reducing media use has some benefits
Pages like this can look a bit sparse, but there are good reasons for taking this approach.
One benefit of reducing the amount of media content on your site is that you reduce the amount of data needed for a user to load the page. This means the page loads more quickly, which is useful for anyone on a slow internet connection. Reducing data transfer like this also reduces the carbon cost associated with a site.
Reducing media use also reduces your content maintenance overhead. Like any content, images and videos need to be monitored, kept up to date and replaced every so often.
These screenshots from the NHS and Edinburgh Council are cherry-picked examples, and it’s worth noting that they’re from outside of our context working in higher education. They’re communicating fairly dry information and they aren’t trying to sell anything. Edinburgh Council don’t need to make Council Tax seem interesting or attractive, and the content reflects that.
But pages like this are an interesting provocation. Why do we add images and videos to our sites? What value do they bring for our users?
The University of Bath’s Digital Content Team address these questions in their content guidance. They say: “Only use an image if it directly relates to your content and helps to communicate your message more clearly.”
University of Bath: When to use images on the web
Videos
After our discussion about the purpose of adding media to our websites, we looked at videos.
In the session, attendees discussed what types of videos they have on their websites. These included:
- instructional videos
- events / presentation recordings
- student experience videos
- building / facility tour videos
- short-form videos on services
- staff talking about degrees and facilities
- interviews with supervisors
One attendee suggested that videos add texture to text and image content. We thought this was a neat way of describing the role of a video embedded on a page.
We talked about how people interact with videos
When we add videos to a website, we typically assume that they will be of use to someone visiting the page. We discussed what evidence we have for this. One attendee said that they ask their users about videos on their website in post-event surveys. They reported that recordings of events were popular with people who had wanted to attend the event but hadn’t been able to make it.
Personas can help us think through how users might respond to a video
In an ideal world, we would watch people using our site and observe how they interact with the videos. In the absence of that, one way to quickly assess a page is to imagine how different personas might respond to it. For a page with a video, we presented some statements that could describe four potential user personas:
- I’m happy to watch a short video.
- I’m in a rush and don’t have time to watch a video.
- I cannot watch a video with sound because I’m on a bus.
- I cannot watch a video at all because I have a poor internet connection.
Looking at the content from different angles like this can be useful as part of a website review process. In this case, it can highlight problems with video content where there isn’t an equivalent text alternative.
What we learned from our team’s research into video use
We shared some work that our Green Digital Design intern Dono Abdurahmanova carried out this summer. This was with a small sample of participants, but the findings supported some practices that can improve the usability of videos.
For example, we recommend the following:
- Give the video a clear title.
- Provide a transcript and a written summary of the video.
- Make sure the video has accurate human-corrected captions.
- Use timestamps (chapters) to help users navigate to a particular part of the video.
- Keep autoplay turned off and let users choose when they want the video to start.
You can read more about Dono’s research here:
Do students actually watch videos on websites?
Testing alternatives to video in student communications
We shared guidance on adding timestamps, summaries and captions
We demonstrated how to add timestamps in Media Hopper Create. This option is available under the three-dot menu for a video, in the Edit > Timeline section.

We also watched a short video and worked in groups to write an introductory summary for it.
Some attendees said they had used the human corrected captioning service to improve the accuracy of captions on a video.
Information Services Learning Technology: Our human corrected captioning service
Images
In the final part of the session, we looked at the role of images on our websites. Attendees compared two pages, discussing what value the images are adding and whether they would do anything differently.
We referred attendees to the University’s brand guidance on image use. This outlines some reasons for including images in our content. For example, it highlights that images and videos can command attention and convey emotion.
Brand: Photography and video guidance (University login required)
How to improve the user experience of images
We shared some guidance on how to improve the user experience of our images:
- Add alt text (a text description for anyone who cannot see the image).
- Add image captions where needed (these add context to the image by echoing information elsewhere on the page).
- Avoid using images of text to convey information.
- Think about what the image is adding (sometimes less is more).
We also shared some resources that provide further guidance related to images:
EdWeb 2 Hub: Best practice for adding images (University login required)
Videos and images – when do they add value and not just page weight? (Blog post by Katie Spearman)
BBC: Captions vs text descriptions
Applying what we’d discussed to our own content
In Content Improvement Club, we often make time for attendees to evaluate their own sites in relation to the topic under discussion.
This month, attendees worked in pairs to assess the media on their own sites, and talked about two questions:
- How well are the images and videos working on our own sites?
- Is there anything we could do differently?
Thinking through our use of videos and images like this helps us to ensure that we’re using media effectively in the places where it’s needed.
How to hear about future sessions
We promote these sessions via our mailing list. If you’re interested, please sign up:
Join the UX and Content Design mailing list (University login required)
Suggest a topic for a future session
We’re keen to continue covering topics that colleagues across the University would find useful. It would be really helpful if you could let us know any ideas you have using this form:
Suggest a topic for Content Improvement Club (University login required)
Other training that we offer
More training is listed on the User Experience Service website: