❌

Reading view

There are new articles available, click to refresh the page.

Mayors are out of control

Tom Brake is chief executive of Unlock Democracy

Last month’s Budget granted England’s mayors more power over the money their regions raise. The question is, will the public be any more in control than when Whitehall was in charge?

The Chancellor announced £285 million for new Good Growth funds and areas preparing for devolution, alongside a £1.5 billion borrowing facility for mayoral authorities. From 2027, mayors will receive 20% of business rates revenues – with 100% of business rates to be retained by local and regional governments by 2030 – followed by a share of income tax receipts in 2028. They will also be able to charge a tourist tax.

Together with the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act, which extends the map of mayoral government and deepens its powers over housing, planning and transport, this represents a substantial transfer of power from Whitehall.

So far, so good, right? The Prime Minister shares Unlock Democracy’s enthusiasm for devolution. We both believe communities should have much greater control over their own affairs, with decisions made as close as possible to the people they affect.

But giving mayors more power does not necessarily give the public more control. That depends on whether people can hold them to account. The Devolution Act makes some provision in this space, beefing up local scrutiny committees. That is welcome. But scrutiny can only go so far, particularly when establishing something as basic as who a mayor has met, and what they discussed, is far harder than it should be.

Take Andy Burnham’s foray into the Manchester City cheating scandal as an example. Only following the PM’s intervention – made in the wake of City being found guilty of colossal, systematic cheating – was the fact of a formal meeting in 2021 between Burnham, then Greater Manchester mayor, and City’s chairman made public. Meanwhile, records of two matchday dinners with the chairman had to be unearthed by the BBC, having been removed from the Greater Manchester authority website.

None of this is to allege wrongdoing by Andy Burnham. The issue is different, and it extends further: why was it so difficult to extract such information? In Whitehall, ministers must publish quarterly reports listing their meetings with outside organisations. Admittedly, their contents and the frequency leave a lot to be desired, but at least they establish minimum standards of transparency. England’s metro mayors face no equivalent obligation.

Research by Unlock Democracy found no regularly published diaries of external meetings for the mayors of Greater Manchester or Liverpool City Region. We could find none for West Yorkshire, either. The Mayor of London does publish a diary of formal engagements every six months, though publication stalled for two years after Mayor Khan’s re-election in May 2024 (this has since been rectified). Even then, entries can be remarkably perfunctory, revealing little to nothing of what was discussed.

Declarations of gifts and hospitality are just as inconsistent. The Local Government Association’s model code recommends declaring gifts worth £50 or more within 28 days, but authorities adopt their own codes. As a result, what the public knows about those in power depends on where they live.

Of course, the existence of disclosure rules does not guarantee their application. A recent investigation by the BBC and the Bedford Independent uncovered records suggesting that Bedford mayor, Tom Wootton – owner of land worth more than £2.7 million affected by the proposed East West Rail route – failed on 15 separate occasions to declare an interest when necessary. Tom Wootton disputes this assessment.

The rights and wrongs of the case will not be settled here. What’s crucial to note is it took a team of journalists examining court documents, land records and meeting minutes to bring these questions to light.

And here lies a second problem. Since 2005, at least 293 local newspapers have closed. In Birmingham, the National Union of Journalists warns that major job cuts will render once proud local papers “irrelevant to their communities.” And the BBC, already under severe financial pressure, plans to merge its education and social affairs editor roles, another sign of the squeeze on resource-intensive reporting that seeks to bridge the gap between abstract policy and on the ground experience.

Not only is the hollowing out of local media bad for accountability, it’s bad for governance. A healthy local media is one way that authorities get their message out and discover where they’re going wrong: where services are failing, which grievances are going unanswered and what citizens actually make of their priorities.

Without it, mayors risk gaining powers while losing touch with the communities they’re there to serve. The resulting distrust and alienation will serve nobody except bad-faith actors looking to make political capital – or simply a quick buck – off people’s discontent.

Devolution promises greater local control, and rightly so. But bringing power closer to people is only one part of the picture. Giving mayors the means to act must go hand in hand with giving the public the means to hold them accountable. Otherwise, we risk fixing one democratic deficit only to create another.

The post Mayors are out of control appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Fabian’s column: Burnham’s vision for mayors needs an accompanyng vision for councils 

At Labour conference, we heard more of the Prime Minister’s vision for the country with mayors at its heart. Burnham has a clear concept of place, seeking to drive growth in every postcode and end Britain’s stark regional imbalances. 

It builds on his speech in Manchester on good growth and devolution before he became prime minister, and the groundbreaking ‘rewiring the state’ cabinet statement after.

But Burnham’s vision for mayors demands an accompanying vision for councils too. Because only together can they deliver the change he has promised. Labour’s new agenda requires strong local government, whether devolution, the biggest council house-building programme since the Second World War, or reforming social care. 

But councils are more than delivery bodies for central ambition. They are democratically accountable, visible guardians of their localities, running crucial public services, maintaining the public realm, and shaping housing and high streets’ futures. 

The government’s model of devolution, through strategic authorities, embeds a strong role for councils. Outside of London, strategic authorities are integrated ‘combined authorities’ with formal relationships and joint decision-making between constituent councils, including their mayor in the mayoral strategic authorities.

Councils have a crucial role in strategic authority accountability, which the government rightly wants to strengthen. As Mayors become increasingly powerful, taking on fiscal powers, they will need a new local accountability architecture. This will provide strong democratic counterweights for better decisions, a culture of improvement, and confidence to the public and Parliament. Well-resourced local democratic processes, involving councils and councillors, are the right mechanism to provide this.

The Conservative government proposed a role for Members of Parliament in local oversight, but this is not the role that best suits them. Strategic authorities are a local government body, that need to be held to account by local politicians. Detailed scrutiny of strategic authority decisions will never be a primary function of MPs, who are intensely busy national legislators scrutinising national policy or serving as Ministers or Shadow Ministers. Instead, MPs’ role is strategic and system wide. They ought to design the system of local government and scrutinise its overall effectiveness.

That system needs capacity and clarity to support its potential. Structural financial problems constrain this. Over the austerity years, cuts to central grants shifted more of the funding burden onto local taxpayers while statutory duties expanded to eat more of the dwindling pie. Social care is the only category of local authority spending that rose since 2014/15, while all others fell. Funding settlements under Labour have helped, boosting funding and providing multi-year certainty. But councils still face severe pressure, and remain reeling from the Tory years of increasing council tax while cutting services. Pressure on statutory services risks deciding councils’ role by default. 

For councils and councillors alike, devolution strengthens their hands after decades of corrosion. Since the 1970s, both have had powers and autonomy eroded. Building stronger strategic authorities in which councils and councillors have active roles is a course correction. 

In Burnham’s Labour Conference speech, he showed how political control has been corroded in recent decades with the hollowing out of councils. Repairing this damage, alongside devolution, starts to put that right.

The government will soon publish a white paper on devolution. It promises fresh powers, including fiscal devolution for strategic authorities. But it is also an opportunity to set out a vision for councils, and councillors, in a more devolved system – to put councils on the same purposeful, reforming path Burnham wants for the country. 

With the National Care Service brought forward and local government reorganisation paused, now is a moment to step back and evaluate how England’s tiers of government will work, have agency, and relate to one another. 

If the government wants to rewire the state, they must not overlook councils, but back them as partners with purpose of their own and fix the funding challenge that holds them back. Good growth in every postcode requires a capable council in every postcode. 

The post Fabian’s column: Burnham’s vision for mayors needs an accompanyng vision for councils  appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Andy Burnham’s ambition on devolution is the right one. Now Labour has to make it last

Andy Burnham has staked his premiership on rewiring the state. In his first speech in Downing Street he promised to take power out of Westminster and carry it into every postcode in the land, and on 30 July his government put the first real detail behind it: Mayors keeping a share of income tax and business rates, and a new rule that Whitehall must justify holding on to any power rather than handing it down. He has said the days of Whitehall fighting devolution are over for good. For a party that has argued for decentralisation for a decade, this is the moment it becomes real.

The ambition is not in doubt. What matters now is making it a success: a settlement that outlives this government, not a burst of energy that fades with it. Our new paper looks at six European countries that have decentralised, and together they point to one conclusion. Ambition alone does not make devolution succeed. Leaders devolve with conviction, and then the money is quietly clawed back, or the next government unpicks it, or the reform stalls once the political attention moves on.

Burnham’s instincts already match what worked abroad. His “devolve by default” principle, that the question should be why a power cannot be devolved rather than why it should, is almost exactly the reform that set French decentralisation alight in 1982, when one law abolished central sign-off and made councils self-governing overnight. His promise that every department will lend staff and resources to local areas is the lesson Germany proved after reunification, where seconding officials in their thousands is what made devolution actually work.

But in every country that succeeded, the leader did one thing more. They made the settlement permanent before the political moment passed. That is the step ambition tends to skip, and the one that decides whether devolution lasts.

For Britain it means a Fiscal Devolution Act, giving the strongest mayors the power to set a real tax of their own, paired in the same law with an equalisation formula that tops up areas with a weaker tax base, so a poorer place is never left behind when richer ones raise more. This is the Danish model, and Denmark succeeded precisely because it legislated the tax power and the protection together, each making the other work. And it means writing the funding formula into primary legislation, so reversing it takes a public fight in parliament, not a quiet Treasury decision.

For a Labour audience the reason is plain. Reform now runs councils, and could one day run the country. The way to protect devolution from a future hostile government is not to hope, but to build it on rules that bind whoever inherits it, with no discretionary pot a later minister could turn against Labour areas. France shows the danger: it wrote financial autonomy into its constitution, then abolished the local taxes underneath it anyway. Devolved money has to be an entitlement set in law, not a grant that can be taken back.

Andy Burnham has spent a decade arguing that power belongs closer to people. He now has the rare chance to make that permanent. The clearest lesson from Europe is to legislate early, while the government is strongest and the ambition is fresh. Do that, and rewiring the state becomes not just this government’s mission, but part of Labour’s lasting legacy.

Mike Buckley leads the Independent Commission on UK EU Relations. Their new report, ‘How to devolve: What Europe’s transitions teach a new Government’, is available here. 

The post Andy Burnham’s ambition on devolution is the right one. Now Labour has to make it last appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

❌