❌

Reading view

There are new articles available, click to refresh the page.

Does opting out of smart TV tracking work? Research finds “suspicious” traffic.

Smart TVs running operating systems from Samsung, Vizio, and Roku continue sending data to automatic content recognition (ACR) endpoints after users opt out of tracking in the devices’ settings, according to research published on Monday. The paper from Northeastern University researchers points to potential privacy violations from some of the biggest TV brands.

ACR captures video screenshots or audio clips from smart TVs and sends the data to remote servers, where it's used for things like measuring content viewership and serving targeted ads.

The paper, "Watching the Watchers: Privacy Analysis of US Smart TV Automatic Content Recognition," examined eight smart TV OSes across 12 smart TVs from 10 manufacturers (Amazon, Hisense, LG, Roku, Samsung, Sony, Supersonic, TCL, Vizio, and Westinghouse) to examine when smart TVs use ACR and how effective opting out of user tracking is.

Read full article

Comments

© https://www.gettyimages.com/detail/photo/modern-living-room-with-smart-tv-and-remote-control-royalty-free-image/2226225055

Plex now helps sell movie theater tickets

Plex, which made a name for itself by letting users share movies they own, is now helping sell movie theater tickets. The company is looking to monetize its content-discovery capabilities and expand its business beyond its media server software.

Plex partnered with Fandango, which has sold movie tickets since 2000, to drive ticket sales from people searching for movies to stream. Per the announcement:

Starting today, Plex users in the US will see a Fandango ticketing option on title pages for movies currently playing in theaters, allowing them to click through to Fandango to find showtimes and purchase tickets. The integration also enables direct attribution through Kochava, giving studios and advertisers greater visibility into how campaigns and audience engagement translate into ticket sales.

Fandango says it sells tickets for 31,000 movie theater screens in the US. The Plex deal allows it to leverage data from Plex’s streaming service (Plex claims users of the service “make more than 100 million streaming decisions each month”), including "ratings and cross-platform viewing" to gain “insight into audience intent," the announcement said.

Read full article

Comments

© Getty

Valuing the Stay-at-Home Dad

As if having ADHD and a history of self-criticism isn’t bad enough, try taking on the role of a stay-at-home spouse and dad. It’s guaranteed to make you question your worth even more.

When you aren’t the primary wage earner, you carry more of the domestic load — but the labor is invisible. An empty sink with no dirty dishes just looks empty. Laundry washed and folded disappears into drawers and closets, effort unseen. Kids arriving at school on time day in and day out — an accomplishment that’s expected.

Because we don’t “see” or acknowledge these results in the same way that we recognize a paycheck, it is easy to discount their value — and this is true for any stay-at-home parent. But here’s where ADHD can exacerbate the lack of appreciation for this invisible labor: We put away the dishes, but the counter didn’t get wiped down. The kids got to school, but their lunch boxes didn’t make it into their backpacks. Taking on the burden of running the household with ADHD can make us feel like we’re failing even when we mostly hit the mark.

Rewriting the Stay-at-Home-Dad Playbook

One of the most pernicious feelings stemming from ADHD is inadequacy; no matter how much effort we put in, it doesn’t measure up. And because I’m no longer the breadwinner in my house, what was once an easy metric of how well I’m supporting my family — a paying job — is now gone.

[Free Webinar: “The Hidden Complexities of Men with ADHD”]

We, stay-at-home husbands and dads, need to reframe our definition of success. Instead of measuring our worth in dollars, we need to measure it in impact. Because when we set up systems that work with our brains instead of against them, we can be that rock for our families.

That might mean:

  • using timers for tasks and appointments
  • creating family checklists
  • finding sensory-safe cleaning products
  • giving yourself grace when mistakes happen
  • finding support with people in similar situations

Making peace with this shift in traditional marital and parental roles isn’t about ignoring discomfort; it’s about finding your own version of thriving. For men with ADHD, this is a powerful opportunity to rewrite your story of worth – not tied to money or status but to connection, presence, and growth.

Stay-at-Home Dads: Next Steps

William Curb is the host of the Hacking Your ADHD podcast, where he shares practical, compassionate strategies for navigating life with ADHD. He is a husband and father of two.


ADDITUDE IS HUMAN
Artificial intelligence does not create or edit any written content published by ADDitude. Our editorial team is 100% human, and our mission is simple: listen to and serve our readers with hand-crafted, expert-informed resources. To support ADDitude, please consider subscribing. Your readership and support help make our commitment possible. Thank you.

What Terrifies Men? Vulnerability.

Fathers are prompted, prodded, and pushed to share their emotions. Yet, when we do, it seldom works out as we hoped.

My client, Bill, told me about a time he asked his teen to move their dirty dishes from the living room to the kitchen sink. Over the following hour, frustration building, he asked a couple more times, but to no effect. Bill, who has ADHD, started yelling, which triggered more conflict with his teen. Bill expressed deep regret for his outburst during our session and sought ways to avoid similar situations in the future.

What went wrong? Bill showed his emotions, sure, but he waited too long to do so. Things didn’t escalate from 0 to 10 in just a few minutes, as it may have seemed; the emotional volcano built up steam for more than an hour.

[Watch This Free Webinar: “The Hidden Complexities of Men with ADHD”]

Like Bill, many people with ADHD struggle with interoception — the ability to recognize and understand internal signals like hunger, thirst, and, yes, emotions. Bill’s weak interoception meant that his escalating feelings were easily ignored because he barely noticed them in the first place. As he became increasingly frustrated, he failed to register the mounting pressure or communicate his feelings to avoid conflict.

Anger Erupts from Hidden Emotions

If we ignore emotions that are growing stronger, and instead try to hide them, we end up looking volatile, even explosive. And that can leave our friends and family walking on eggshells because they never know when we’re going to pop.

Recognizing and communicating our emotions early helps us avoid that trap.

Bill could have said to his teen, “This is the second time I’ve had to ask you to put the dishes away. I’m getting annoyed. When can I expect you to get this done?”

[Get This Free Resource: 15 Ways to Disarm (and Understand) Explosive ADHD Emotions]

Men, and especially fathers, are taught that our role is to keep everyone safe. Often, when we find our emotions escalating, it’s coming from a place of vulnerability. We may feel scared for our kid, disregarded by our spouse, or insecure about our parenting skills. Because we are not practiced at recognizing nuanced emotions, we mistake vulnerability for anger or feel the fight-or-flight impulse.

We, as men, need to do the work to gain the emotional intelligence and become the people we want to be.

ADHD Symptoms in Men: Next Steps

Brendan Mahan, M.Ed., M.S., is the father of two teen boys with ADHD.


ADDITUDE IS HUMAN
Artificial intelligence does not create or edit any written content published by ADDitude. Our editorial team is 100% human, and our mission is simple: listen to and serve our readers with hand-crafted, expert-informed resources. To support ADDitude, please consider subscribing. Your readership and support help make our commitment possible. Thank you.

This Year’s Long Drive South

I prepare for my annual southern migration, this time with a purpose.

I go south every year for the winter. Although I love my home and I’d like nothing more than to be able to spend the winter here in comfort — writing at my desk, making jewelry in my studio, editing video at my computer, and maybe even hitting the cross-country ski trails around Mazama and Winthrop — I find the short daylight hours and dreary weather depressing. It starts as soon as we change the clocks — I’m firmly in the DST year-round camp — and by the first of December, when Shadow Time starts, I’m going nuts with SAD. The only solution is to go south, so that’s what I do. I pack up my camper and drive to Arizona, where I have some friends and favorite campsites, and California, to hit my favorite hot spring.

(I should mention here that while I was in the middle of cruising the Great Loop in my boat from October 2022 to August 2024, I spent both winters on my boat on the east coast cruising on the coastal waterways of Florida, Georgia, and South Carolina. I made it all the way down to Key West where I spent New Years 2024 with my friend and fellow boater Jason. But I digress. This winter, my boat is resting up in the garage for another season as a charter boat in the San Juan Islands starting in April 2026.)

Not Just Sitting Around

This year has extra purpose. I’m participating in two art shows with my artist friend Janet LeRoy. We applied to three shows together and I managed to get into two of them and be added to the waitlist for the third. (Janet seems to think I’ll get into that one, too, but jewelry is an over-crowded field, as I learned earlier this month in Seattle.) After a lot of internal fighting in my brain, I finally decided to bring along my utility trailer, where I can set up my mobile jewelry studio. This relieved me from having to spend the last three weeks before departure in my home studio making inventory — which was a good thing because I’ve been dealing with a bad cold since November 5. The added benefit of having the utility trailer in tow is that I don’t have to store all my show gear inside my truck and camper. It’s a tight fit, to say the least. But the trailer has plenty of space and I don’t have to live with all that stuff for three months. This will be the first time I took the trailer south since winter 2020/21. I don’t like towing — it really takes away the benefit of having a truck camper — but I’ve dealt with it before so I can deal with it again.

Parked Camper
Here’s my camper where I parked it for 2 1/2 months out in the desert on the Colorado River in winter 2020/21. I had a sweet campsite that season on BLM land.

My truck camper, which I’ve been trying to sell for the past few years — some years more seriously than others — is a comfortable, fully self-contained rig with plenty of space and all the amenities I need. It’s remarkably similar to my boat, but has a bigger refrigerator, more solar power, fewer batteries, and no inverter. And it doesn’t float. (At least I don’t think it does.) It’s 18 years old but in excellent condition and has a lot of extras, including a fitted canvas “room” that can be installed when I take the camper off the truck. I almost had it sold last year but the idiot who wanted to buy it asked his wife and she said no. The reason it’s hard to sell is because it requires a full long bed pickup. That means a pickup with an 8-foot bed. These days, people buy little wimpy trucks that simply can’t handle a rig the size of this one. My truck, however, has no trouble at all.

The Route

Apple Maps Suggested Routes
Apple Maps suggests two routes. The shorter one is 1283 miles; the other one is 50 miles longer.

I’ve driven the distance between the Phoenix area of Arizona and North Central Washington State twice a year almost every year since 2008. Back then, I lived in Arizona with my future wasband and came north ever summer for cherry drying work. In summer 2012, when my marriage fell apart, I came home, packed up, and prepared to move to Washington. I arrived in the Wenatchee area in spring 2013 with my old 5th wheel (the “mobile mansion.” The ink wasn’t even dry on the divorce papers in May when I closed on the 10 acres in Malaga where I’d build my home. Since then, I’ve gone south for the winter instead of north for the summer.

So yeah, I’ve done the trip a few times. And yeah, I know the pros and cons of each route.

The best route, so far, is I-84 to US-93. About a third of it is on freeways, mostly I-84 south of Kennewick to Twin Falls and then I-15, etc. in the Las Vegas area. The other two thirds is on two-lane desert roads with 65 mph speed limits, mostly US-93 through Nevada and Arizona. You have to know when to stop for fuel and not skip a stop. (You also need a good roadside assistance provider just in case.)

This year I’ll be leaving around Thanksgiving, which is when I’ve arranged for my winter house-sitter, John, to start his annual gig. This year he’s thrilled to get a full three months; last year I was gone just five weeks, which was barely enough for him to take advantage of the ski pass he buys for Mission Ridge.

My only concern with driving this route as winter approaches is snow in the Blue Mountains between Pendleton and Baker City OR. Way back in 2012, in October, I hit a nasty snowstorm up there where the freeway was down to one lane with trucks installing chains in the slow lanes. The truck I was driving held the snowy pavement well, but not good enough to keep going. I was forced to stop for the night at Baker City, when I’d hoped to get all the way to Boise. So I’ve been checking the forecast regularly, starting yesterday. The forecast for La Grande is looking iffy the beginning of next week, but Thanksgiving day looks good, with rain and daytime temperatures in the upper 40s and lower 50s. That might be my perfect weather window.

The Stops

Although I can cover this distance in two days — I’ve done it before more than once — I prefer to take my time and avoid driving in the dark. I’ve got four stops planned.

First is the Three Island Crossing State Park on the Snake River in Glenns Ferry, ID. That’s just off I-84 between Boise and Twin Falls. I have been stopping here southbound since maybe 2020. I like it because it’s an affordable state park campground with pull-through sites and it’s basically deserted in November and December when I come through. Last year, around Christmas, I was literally the only person there. Although the water is turned off and the bathrooms are locked, the electricity is on and sites have sewer dumps. (I don’t usually dump here; it’s the first night of my trip.) I pull in, plug in, walk to the pay station to pay, and then settle in for what’s usually a cold night. With an electric heater on board, I don’t have to run my propane heater. I an also use my microwave and coffee maker. It’ll make a great spot for Thanksgiving dinner if I prepare the food on Wednesday and just heat it up at the campsite. (Heck, I’ll just have thanksgiving dinner on Wednesday at home and leftovers that first night.)

At Three Island Crossing
Sunset at 5:10 PM on December 10, 2021 at Three Island Crossing State Park. I was able to make it before dark that day; I should be able to do it again.

The drawback to this as a first stop is that it’s nearly 500 miles, which means I need to get a very early start with minimal fuel stops to get there before dark. Apple Maps calculates about 7 1/4 hours but it expects me to do the speed limit, which gets up to 85 in Idaho. I usually keep it around 70. Add an hour for 2 fuel/bathroom stops and I’m looking at a 9-hour drive.

The second stop is Pahranagat National Wildlife Refuge just south of Alamo, NV. I’ve been stopping here since maybe 2010? I remember stopping here on my way north with my big 5th wheel. This is a wildlife refuge with about a dozen campsites right on a lake. There’s lots of birds, making it an excellent spot for bird watching. Camping is free, although I usually mail in a donation. It used to be easy to get a site here, but it’s tougher now. I think it’s been “discovered.” Although it’s a lower elevation that other places along the way, it can get wicked cold here, as I discovered in maybe 2022. If I get a good site and the weather is nice, I’ll spend two nights and do some hiking or take my bike out while I’m there. It’s 468 miles from the previous night’s stop, so again, I’ll need an early start.

Pahranagat Sunset
Sunset the next evening at Pahranagat. This was a 4:37 PM. I know from other photos that I arrived at least an hour before that.

The third stop really depends on whether a friend of mine who lives in Las Vegas is available to meet up. I met with Jim last year, learned about the changes in his life since I’d seen him back in 2021, and had lunch with him. He’s 86 now and was on the verge of retirement from the company he’d built after taking early retirement from Eastern Airlines long before I met him in the early 2000s. (We used to go on helicopter outings together in the desert — him in his Hughes 500 and me in my R-22.) I’ll get in touch before I head south to make sure (1) he’s still alive and (2) he’s available.

Then, with that third day taken up mostly by our time together, I’ll head over to Boulder Beach campground on Lake Powell where I can get a campsite for $10 thanks to my National Parks Senior Pass. That’ll make about 100 miles of driving for the day. I don’t like that campground — too much like a subdivision for me — but there is water to top off my fresh water tank and fill two 6-gallon jugs and a free dump station to empty my tank before I start serious boondocking. I’ll probably treat myself to a nice hot shower before I top off the tank.

If Jim is not available, I’ll go a little farther, to Willow Beach Campground on the Colorado River. This is also inside the Lake Mead National Recreation Area, but it’s a concession campground and, without that senior pass, would cost $80 per night for a full hookup. With the pass, it’s a slightly more affordable $40. There’s a fish hatchery there and some hiking trails. I can rent a boat to go up to the Arizona Hot Spring if I’m feeling ambitious and rich. (The boat rentals aren’t cheap.) The site is full hookup — it should be for that price! — so I can top off my fresh water tank and dump my waste tanks before I go. I remember the showers there being VERY good. And there’s a laundry room if I need to wash anything.

Willow Beach
The view down into Black Canyon at the Colorado River from the main road above Willow Beach.

From wherever I end up on my third stop, I’ll head to my destination in Wickenburg, AZ, which is 323 miles from the wildlife refuge or 190 miles from Willow Beach. Along the way, I’ll stop at the Kingman Mine store, which is along the way but closed on weekends. I buy a lot of turquoise for my jewelry making endeavors there and I prefer to buy in person instead of online.

I was going to skip Wickenburg for now and return later on in the winter, but I’m having a problem with the water pump in my camper. It’s working but it sounds like it’s sucking air and it won’t shut off on its own like it should. I looked everywhere I could see a pipe and don’t see a leak. Janet’s significant other, Steve, is a certified RV repairperson so he’ll take a look and hopefully resolve the issue. I’m hoping it just needs a new pump, which looks pretty easy to get at. I’d like to get it repaired without spending a fortune on it.

And Then Showtime!

Setup for the Wigwam Holiday Festival for the Arts is on Thursday in Litchfield Park, AZ. (The show runs December 5 – 7.) So that’s the only solid thing on my calendar determining when I must get to Arizona. The sooner I leave here, the more time I have to screw around on my way south. There should be RV parking for artists at the show; Janet will camp with me.

Afterwards, I’ll boondock out in the desert for a while. The next solid thing on my calendar is a tour of Rio Grande’s Albuquerque facility on the morning of December 18. I’m hoping to park the utility trailer somewhere before I do that and spend about a week touring western New Mexico. But maybe I’ll take it with me and spend some quality time in the desert making jewelry along the way. Who knows?

The next show is the Cave Creek Fine Art & Wine Winter Festival on January 9 1 11. So I have time to wander around a bit. Or, if I find a good BLM campsite, park myself for a while.

The final show is the Tubac Festival of the Arts on February 4 – 8. I’m on the waitlist, but Janet is invited. I’ll go down there and hang out. I’ve told the promoter that I’m available as a volunteer if I don’t get off the list. I haven’t spent significant time in Tubac for many, many years, although I did stop for a few hours to see this particular show about 5 years ago. The town has changed. I look forward to exploring it. I’m not opposed to finding a new home there, either — but that’s another story.

Those are the plans, subject to change. I think I’m really going to enjoy this season in the desert.

Forced Vulnerability

Forced Vulnerability

One of the most persistent patterns in organisational change and dynamics is the search for a shortcut: the belief that if we can just find the right lever to pull, the right activity or artefact, we can bypass the slow, ecological and evolutionary work of building safety and performance. It begins, however, with the best of intentions.

Imagine that you’re at a company all-hands event, a new-hire orientation, or a leadership away day. The facilitator invites everyone to “get real” with one another. Perhaps you’re asked to share your biggest failure, the hardest challenge you’ve ever faced, or a personal trauma. Maybe even the last time you cried. Around the table, everyone dutifully takes turns to offer up (or very likely, fabricate) something raw and vulnerable.

This is forced vulnerability: when disclosure is less an act of choice and more of an obligation.

The allure of these exercises is compelling. They’re intended to accelerate trust, foster psychological safety, and build teams that are more cohesive and authentic. They often borrow their legitimacy from popular leadership books: Patrick Lencioni’s Five Dysfunctions of a Team places “absence of trust” as the foundational dysfunction, and his recommended antidote (and anecdote) is called a “trust” exercise, where team members are asked to share weaknesses, mistakes, or childhood experiences as a way to short-circuit the long, slow process of genuine trust-building.

It’s an appealing shortcut. After all, if Brené Brown is right that “Vulnerability is the birthplace of love, belonging, joy, courage, empathy, and creativity”, then why not engineer it directly?

Forced vulnerability flips causality

The problem is that this flips causality. Psychological safety enables disclosure, not the other way around. When people feel respected, fairly treated, and safe, they may choose to share more openly. But when they are pushed or compelled to expose personal details about themselves in a room full of colleagues, superiors, or strangers, it’s not intimacy that emerges. More often, it’s discomfort, resentment, and a hollow, anxiety-filled sense of performative vulnerability. Trying to engineer forced vulnerability as an input to psychological safety is like planting fully grown trees in a desert and expecting a rich, mature forest: instead, you end up with dead trees.

Conditions precede outcomes. Trust, respect, familiarity and interpersonal predictability are necessary preconditions for voluntary disclosure. When we try to reverse that order, we get coercion. Coercion doesn’t create safety; instead it does the opposite – it results in performative honesty: a surface appearance of openness that masks deeper anxiety, and very possibly, harm.

Many of us have been in these situations. Perhaps you felt, in the moment, that it didn’t sit right. Perhaps you convinced yourself you were the problem: that you were too guarded, too afraid, and “bad at being vulnerable.” But in reality that unease that you felt was probably a healthy signal that something was off. The recognition that authentic connection can’t be manufactured on demand.

In fact, forced vulnerability is not only ineffective: it can be incredibly harmful. It exploits power gradients, disproportionately burdens marginalised and under-represented folks, risks retraumatisation, and undermines genuine psychological safety. It promises trust but often leaves people feeling more vulnerable than before.

So why do organisations keep doing it? And if we want to build stronger, safer, more connected teams, what should we do instead?

Why Organisations Use Forced Vulnerability

Forced vulnerability survives for the same reasons as many management fads. It offers a simple solution to a complex problem. In complexity terms, this is an attempt to “seed” an attractor without first creating the requisite conditions. Unsurprisingly, the system responds with shallow compliance and, for many, harm. There are several reasons why these sort of practices persist:

The shortcut myth. Leaders want results. Asking people to share their “biggest mistake” or “deepest fear” seems like a quick way to build intimacy. It’s a simple (but wrong) answer to the complex question of “How do we quickly get people to work together effectively?”

The Lencioni effect. The Five Dysfunctions of a Team has been enormously influential. The idea that teams should “get vulnerable” to overcome dysfunction has spread widely, often without nuance. Exercises where colleagues reveal traumatic childhood experiences or personal failures are recommended in too many corporate training programmes.

Misreading of vulnerability. Brené Brown’s insights have been simplified and repackaged. What often gets lost is her crucial emphasis on boundaries and consent. Vulnerability is not oversharing, nor is it a performative exercise.

Performance pressure. Facilitators and consultants sometimes feel they need to create an emotional “high” to justify the value of a workshop. Vulnerability exercises provide a moment of drama, but that doesn’t mean they actually build trust.

The Risks and Harms

While often well-intentioned, forced vulnerability carries significant risks:

Power Gradients

Power dynamics affect everything in organisations – in a system with asymmetric power (all organisations are, to varying degrees, uneven distributions of power), no invitation is neutral. When a senior leader, manager, or facilitator participates in or facilitates a vulnerability exercise, many people may feel unable to opt out. Even if the invitation is framed as voluntary, the implicit expectation is clear: if you want to be included, you’ll do it too.

Some, such as folks in higher status roles, also have the privilege of choosing what kind of “weakness” to disclose. Typically, this results in safe, flattering admissions such as “I care too much about the details”, or they might share an example from many years ago of a mistake they made that has no bearing on how their performance will be judged now, while more junior staff may feel compelled to disclose something more recent, genuinely risky or painful.

Disclosure costs more to some than others.

Inequity and Marginalisation

Disclosure doesn’t carry the same risk for everyone. For some, sharing a personal story may be mildly uncomfortable. For others, it may mean outing their gender identity, disclosing a disability, or recounting a traumatic experience. As Boettcher et al. (2024) showed in Forced Vulnerability: A Dangerous Approach, forced vulnerability places disproportionate burdens on people from marginalised groups.

Inclusion initiatives can unintentionally replicate this problem. Instructing people to share their pronouns may seem like positive modelling, but for someone not ready to disclose their identity, it can feel coercive. Share your own, but don’t force others to do the same. Similarly, asking people to “bring their whole self to work” sounds supportive, but it can pressure people into revealing aspects of themselves they may wish to keep private. It’s ok to have a work self and a home self (and a friend self, and the self you show to your grandmother – we all have multiple identities). The people for whom disclosure is most dangerous are often those whose voices most need to be heard.

Trauma and Mental Health

For people with a history of trauma, coerced disclosure can be retraumatising. Psychotherapy practice warns against conflating vulnerability with healing: without skilled support and proper boundaries, disclosure can reinforce maladaptive coping strategies such as people-pleasing or co-dependence.

Facilitators in corporate settings are rarely trained to handle the psychological consequences of unplanned disclosures. What happens if someone shares a history of serious abuse, grief, criminal behaviour, or terminal illness? Few corporate facilitators are actually equipped to respond responsibly in those moments.

The Myths of Forced Vulnerability

Boettcher et al. also identified three common myths used to justify disclosure activities:

  • “Challenge by choice.” Participants are usually told they can opt out. In reality, social and career pressures make opting out risky or impossible.
  • “What is said here stays here.” This is noble and well meaning, but ultimately unrealistic. Information leaks, even unintentionally.
  • “We’re family.” This is plainly manipulative framing (even if it’s unintentional). Not everyone experiences family as safe, and workplaces are not families (families don’t make people redundant).

Forced Vulnerability is Not Psychological Safety

Psychological safety is not about being emotionally raw at work. Whilst the term ‘psychological safety’ first emerged in a therapeutic context, psychological safety at work is not group therapy.

Psychological safety is the belief that we can take interpersonal risks in a group: asking a question, admitting a mistake, challenging a decision. It is about voice, fairness, dissent, respect, and inclusion. Coercing people into emotional disclosure fundamentally undermines those dynamics. By flipping causality (demanding vulnerability in order to build trust), we’re inadvertently making people feel less safe, not more.

“We establish trust first; then the sharing follows — not the other way around.”

petals open in hands - Photo by Kyle Zheng

Photo by Kyle Zheng

What to Do Instead

Even when used appropriately and voluntarily, self-disclosure should be used sparingly. And if forced vulnerability is harmful, what can we do instead?

  1. Model voluntary vulnerability. Set the tone by admitting fallibility, sharing mistakes, and asking for help; but always without expecting reciprocation. Vulnerability is an invitation, never a demand.
  2. Start with low-stakes risks. Encourage behaviours that build safety and confidence iteratively: asking questions, raising ideas, acknowledging small errors. These are safer and actually far more relevant to work contexts than deep and personal traumas.
  3. Make participation opt-in. Ensure people can decline without penalty. Respect and encourage people to have boundaries. The choice to share or stay silent must be genuinely free, and avoid exercises that put people on the spot. 
  4. Focus on system change rather than theatrics. The organisational substrate of psychological safety is cultivated over time through repeated, consistent demonstrations of positive behaviours and inclusive, power-sharing practices, not manufactured in a single artificial moment.

We can’t force a flower to bloom by pulling its petals open, and we can’t manufacture intimacy or accelerate psychological safety by demanding vulnerability. At best, we build a performative facade of psychological safety theatre, and at worst, we cause genuine and lasting harm.

Vulnerability only matters when it is voluntary: when it is chosen, bounded, and authentic, vulnerability can strengthen relationships and deepen trust. But when it is compelled, it corrodes the psychological safety it claims to build. So we shouldn’t script moments of disclosure, but instead create the conditions in which people may choose to share if, when, and how they wish. 

Further Reading:


Introducing the Trainer Toolkit

We’re excited to share something brand new: the Psychological Safety Trainer Toolkit!

Tom and Jade doing training

This incredible digital resource has already had a fantastic reception from our Train the Trainer course graduates and our Psych Safety community – and now we’re opening it up to newsletter readers too!

The Trainer Toolkit is designed to make it easier for you to deliver impactful, practical psychological safety sessions, whether you’re working with your own team or with clients.

Inside, you’ll find:

  • 11 exclusive training videos, walking you through the key ideas and practices
  • Guidance on marketing psychological safety training to colleagues or clients
  • Advice on tailoring sessions to different contexts and audiences
  • Principles of good design and facilitation to support your delivery
  • Templates, fresh ideas and practical resources to use with teams
  • A ready-made slide deck to support your sessions
  • It also comes with a commercial licence, so you can use it both in-house and externally.

Get the Trainer Toolkit here 

We hope the Trainer Toolkit helps you gain more clients and deliver more value to existing clients – and we can’t wait to hear how you use it.

psychological safety trainer toolkit

The post Forced Vulnerability appeared first on Psych Safety.

❌