❌

Reading view

There are new articles available, click to refresh the page.

EHRC writes to Reform after complaints ‘alleging unlawful activity’ following undercover ITV investigation

The equalities watchdog, the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) has written to Reform UK, asking what measures Nigel Farage’s party is taking to ensure it is complying with the Equality Act, after receiving complaints “alleging unlawful activity” in the party.

The complaints come following the airing of an undercover ITV documentary, A Year in Reform, which showed party members and councillors expressing racist and misogynistic views.

In one example, councillor Alan Feeney in Solihull, was recorded saying that the area had been “infested” with Asian families, who he referred to as “absolute parasites”.

Mr Feeney also said of Asian people: “Drag them out of their homes, stick them on planes and f*** them off to Pakistan.” In another example, a Reform activist is filmed saying Muslims can’t be British.

A spokesperson for the EHRC is quoted in the Independent as saying: “We have written to Reform UK regarding concerns expressed following ITV News’ investigation, Undercover: A Year In Reform, which aired last month. We have asked for more information including what action the party is taking to comply with the Equality Act 2010.

“Following the broadcast of ITV’s documentary, we received complaints alleging unlawful activity under the Equality Act 2010, including concerns about racial and sexual remarks expressed by councillors, prospective councillors and members. As with every complaint we receive, we will assess the information provided carefully and, following that consideration, take action where appropriate.”

The EHRC said that political parties must comply with the Equality Act, and “take steps to avoid discrimination or harassment including on the grounds of race, religion or belief and sex”.

The post EHRC writes to Reform after complaints ‘alleging unlawful activity’ following undercover ITV investigation appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Full list of councils where Labour is ending coalitions with the Greens over ‘Zionism is racism’ motion

The Labour Party has ended its participation in ten local council coalitions following Green Party members voting to brand Zionism a racist ideology at its conference in October.

Labour said it would withdraw from local council administrations if the local Green group did not disown the motion.

The party’s deputy leader Bridget Philipson said: “This isn’t an issue of party politics; it’s about doing what is right and upholding the values anyone holding public office should share.

“The Labour party fought hard to root out antisemitism within our own party and ensure it had no place in our politics. Our action is a demonstration of how today’s Labour party will not shirk from the responsibility we have to uphold those same standards in our relationships with other parties.”

The full list of councils Labour has withdrawn from coalition with the Greens in is as follows:

  • Arun District Council
  • Derbyshire Dales District Council
  • Havant Borough Council
  • Lewes District Council
  • Sheffield City Council
  • Stafford Borough Council
  • Warwick District Council
  • Wealden District Council
  • West Devon Borough Council
  • West Suffolk Council

It remains unclear what will happen next in each of these councils. In some, Labour will seek to continue running the council as a minority administration. In others, the party will seek to work with groups other than the Green to continue in power. And in councils like Lewes, the Greens are the largest party, meaning it will likely be up to them to seek to cling on in administration.

There are six other councils where Labour and the Greens will continue to participate in joint administrations, as Labour has decided that the local Greens have sufficiently distanced themselves from the motion. These are:

  • Broadland District Council
  • Monmouthshire County Council
  • North Somerset Council
  • Rother District Council
  • West Oxfordshire District Council
  • West Sussex County Council

The Green Party has responded with heavy criticism of Labour’s decision. In a statement, the party said: “The Green party, and the Green group office, representing Green councillors across the country, have been hugely disappointed in moves designed by national parties to force local council leaders into jeopardising successful progressive partnerships that are delivering benefits for residents.

“Across the country, Green, Labour, independent and Liberal Democrat councillors have worked together to provide stable local government, protect services and deliver positive change. Leaders across these parties are rightly proud of what those partnerships have achieved.

“Those who issued ultimatums that destabilised power-sharing agreements have often ignored the judgements of their own local leaders, failed to respect the choices made by local voters, and are disrupting successful partnerships.”

Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward

Image credit – Public domain (Polanski), Lauren Hurley / Number 10 – Creative Commons (Burnham)

The post Full list of councils where Labour is ending coalitions with the Greens over ‘Zionism is racism’ motion appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Labour ends coalition with Greens in Sheffield over ‘Zionism is racism’ motion

Labour has terminated its cooperation with the Greens on Sheffield City Council following the passing of the motion ‘Zionism is racism’ motion at the Green Party’s autumn conference in Brighton last month.

Until today, Sheffield was run by a joint administration of Labour and the Greens, with the former having 26 seats on the council and the latter 19.

In a statement, the Labour leader of Sheffield council – Fran Belbin – said: “Since the Greens passed the “Zionism is Racism” motion at their conference at the start of October, Sheffield Labour has been trying to find a way to address the concerns of many of our citizens about the motion and to enable us to continue to work together. However we now feel we are at the end of the road with the joint administration, and the people of Sheffield deserve to know why.”

Belbin went on to add: “The Greens that we formed a joint administration with feel like a very different organisation now – while many individual Green members/ex-members and administrations around the country have put out clear statements that address the problems with the motion, including most of their MPs, in Sheffield there has been no movement at all.”

The statement concluded: “Sheffield Labour will put Sheffield first, we will fight ALL forms of racism, and we will put all our focus on the issues that matter most to our citizens, including tackling poverty, improving our neighbourhoods and creating opportunities for young people. We will never stop calling for justice for Palestinians, that matters so much to so many of us.

“I do not want to lead an administration that is characterised by division and hatred. We are one Sheffield made up of many communities, and Sheffield Labour will keep working to bring communities together to overcome differences, not entrench them.”

Elsewhere in the statement, Belbin said Labour would seek to form a minority administration later this week. Labour is 16 seats short of a majority on the council and therefore would need the votes of other parties – either Liberal Democrats (who have 22 seats) or Reform and independents (who together have 17 seats) in order to take control of the council on their own without the Greens.

Labour’s decision to cease running Sheffield jointly with the Greens comes as a result of the party centrally instructing all local Labour groups to terminate joint-administrations where the local Green group has not publicly condemned the ‘Zionism is racism’ motion.

Sheffield Green Party has responded fiercely to Labour’s decision. In a statement, the Green councillor group said: “It is so sad to hear that Sheffield Labour have failed to stand up for Sheffield. They are throwing away our joint working agreement because of top-down demands from London.

“Labour’s ultimatum was never really about the conduct of Green Councillors in Sheffield, who are wholeheartedly committed to this city. It came from Labour HQ in London and is a really troubling attack on local democracy.

“Sheffield deserves so much better than a Labour council leadership decided by national party management who are happy to play political games with all our futures.

“Over the last few years, we have disagreed with many Labour policies, such as cutting vital support for disabled people and pensioners, their acts of climate vandalism and obsession with fossil fuels and airports, cutting funding for warm homes, arming Israel’s genocide in Gaza and jailing people for supporting Palestinians by protesting peacefully.

“Yet we have put our responsibilities to the people of Sheffield first – by working cross-party and having a positive influence on delivering local policy.”

The statement went on to read: “We have offered to work through this. We are willing to keep talking and, from our perspective, the door remains open. It seems clear, however, that the decision about Sheffield Council was not a decision the Sheffield Labour Leader was allowed to make in the interests of Sheffield residents.

“Local people have just been used as pawns in a cynical political game being played by Labour at a national level.

“Labour owns the consequences and they alone will have to explain to the people of Sheffield why they’ve put party politics over local residents.”

Sheffield Labour’s decision follows a similar move in Lewes, where the Labour and Green groups have ‘mutually’ ended their joint administration, citing ‘national context’ and ‘unnecessary pressures’ from outside the council.

The ‘Zionism is racism’ saw the Green Party argue: “The real, material manifestation of Zionism has been the historic and ongoing dehumanisation, displacement, dispossession, disenfranchisement and destruction of Palestinians. This is based upon European settler-colonial systems of domination and oppression, which has also created racial hierarchies between Jews of different ethnicities in Palestine.”

Alongside this, the motion committed the Green Party to supporting a ‘one-state solution’. The motion saw the Greens support: “the establishment of a single democratic Palestinian State in all of historic Palestine with Jerusalem as its capital, equal rights for all, and the right of return for Palestinians and their descendants.”

Labour is expected to soon announce which other local coalitions with the Greens it will end as a result of the motion.

Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward

The post Labour ends coalition with Greens in Sheffield over ‘Zionism is racism’ motion appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Robert Jenrick in meltdown after ITV presenter asks if he has ‘defector’s remorse’

Reform UK MP Robert Jenrick had a meltdown during a live interview after being asked if he had defector’s remorse following his switch from the Tories to Reform earlier this year.

Jenrick, who was elected a Tory MP and who served in Kemi Badenoch’s shadow cabinet, joined Farage’s party in January when Reform were riding high in the polls.

However, Reform have been defined by scandal and have seen their position in the polls deteriorate, going from highs of around 30 points last year to dropping to the low 20s in third place, behind both Labour and the Tories.

In recent weeks Reform has also been engulfed in a racism scandal, after an undercover ITV documentary showed party members and councillors making racist and misogynistic comments. Farage is also awaiting the outcome of a standards committee probe into his failure to declare a £5million gift he had recieved from a crypto billionaire.

YouGov puts Reform in third place on 20% behind the Conservatives on 22% and Labour 27% in its most recent survey.

Appearing on ITV’s Good Morning Britain programme, Jenrick was asked by presenter Paul Brand: “I just wonder overall, Robert Jenrick, whether you’ve got defector’s remorse.

“You know you’re trailing in the polls now… you gave a speech to half-empty hall this week.

“Councillors have been revealed to be racist within your party. This is not quite the career move you’d hoped it would be, surely.”

Jenrick hit back: “Paul, you’re a left-wing commentator and activist.”

Brand asked where the proof for such a claim was, but Jenrick interrupted: “You obviously don’t want Reform to succeed. Because you always just ask negative questions about Reform like that.”

Brand replied: “We ask robust questions of all the political parties you’re talking to the journalist who helped reveal the partygate scandal.

“I’ve investigated anti-semitism in the Labour Party. This is this is what parties say when they feel uncomfortable, quite frankly, Mr Jenrick.”

Jenrick has also been criticised in recent weeks for refusing to condemn remarks from a Reform associate, Raheem Kassam, after he called Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch a “Nigerian scammer”.

Co-presenter Ranvir Singh once more asked Jenrick if he would condemn the comments.

Jenrick doubld down and said he did not think that remark was racist.

He insisted: “I don’t think it was and what you want to do, let’s be clear, is waste the whole of this interview when we could be talking about all the things that actually matter to people.”

The post Robert Jenrick in meltdown after ITV presenter asks if he has ‘defector’s remorse’ appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Nigel Farage says candidates won’t be banned from standing if they’ve liked posts by far-right thug Tommy Robinson

A racism scandal continues to engulf Reform UK after party leader Nigel Farage refused to confirm that his party would ban candidates from standing for office if they had liked posts made by far-right thug Tommy Robinson.

Farage was asked by the BBC’s Nick Robinson if it would be ok for members and candidates in Reform UK to like posts by Robinson, founder of the far-right English Defence League (EDL) to which Farage replied: “That depends what the post is to a large extent.”

He went on to add: “I’m not going to run a party where we say you can’t talk about that person or that person, we have to be sensible about vetting.”

Farage has always tried to insist that vetting is at a high standard for Reform and yet the party’s candidates, councillors and members continue to be exposed for expressing racist, Islamophobic and misgoynistic views.

A recent undercover ITV documentary exposed party activists and councillors for harbouring racist views. Councillor Alan Feeney in Solihull, was recorded saying that the area had been “infested” with Asian families, who he referred to as “absolute parasites”.

Mr Feeney also said of Asian people: “Drag them out of their homes, stick them on planes and f*** them off to Pakistan.”

An unnamed Reform activist said that Muslims like the party’s home affairs spokesperson Zia Yusuf, could not be British and also claimed that asylum seekers should be put in “concentration camps”

Rather than tackling the widespread racism in Reform, Farage now says he won’t automatically ban candidates from office who have liked posts by Robinson.

Robinson was the leader of the EDL, which often organised protests that descended into violence and thuggery against Muslim communities. He was also a member of the BNP and has served time in prison for contempt of court.

The post Nigel Farage says candidates won’t be banned from standing if they’ve liked posts by far-right thug Tommy Robinson appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Key bombshells from the ITV undercover sting operation into Reform UK

Reform UK continues to lurch from one scandal to the next, as a series of damning revelations continue to emerge about the party’s activists and members expressing racist, misogynistic and hateful views following a year-long undercover investigation by ITV.

Several Reform members have been suspended or resigned following the revelations, however rather than taking swift and decisive action to deal with the racism in his party, Farage has sought to claim that his party is the victim of an ‘estbalishment stitch up’.

So what are some of the most damning cases exposed so far as part of the documentary, here’s a roundup of some of them below:

Mayoral candidate accused of using racist slur against David Lammy

One of the undercover clips shows a senior Reform official accusing Farage of “protecting” a mayoral candidate who said David Lammy should “go back home to the Caribbean”.

Farage was urged to sack Chris Parry last December after he said that was where the then justice secretary’s “loyalties lie”.

However, despite the pleas, Parry, a former Rear Admiral, survived as Reform’s candidate to be mayor of Hampshire and the Solent.

Reform councillors made racist and sexist remarks

Undercover ITV journalists recorded a number of the party’s councillors making sexist and racist remarks, including Councillor Alan Feeney in Solihull, who was recorded saying that the area had been “infested” with Asian families, who he referred to as “absolute parasites”.

Mr Feeney also said of Asian people: “Drag them out of their homes, stick them on planes and f*** them off to Pakistan.”

Chris Whelan, a Reform election candidate in Solihull, said of a female Reform candidate: “If she was my daughter, it would still be bath night on a Thursday. I’ll wash you properly this time.”

Dean Miller, a Reform councillor for Bromley, was filmed undercover calling for King Charles to be beheaded.

“Apparently King Charles is a f***ing Muslim… someone from the inside saw a f***ing prayer mat and all that in one of his f***ing rooms … I think that’s f***ing traitorous,” he said.

Reform activist and MP hopeful said Muslims like Zia Yusuf ‘cannot be British’

In footage broadcast yesterday, an unnamed Reform activist said that Muslims like the party’s home affairs spokesperson Zia Yusuf, could not be British and also claimed that asylum seekers should be put in “concentration camps”.

He said: “If a Muslim’s prepared to de-convert, I’m happy.

“But if they want to remain faithful to Islam, then this would be, I would have disagreements, especially with, um, I mean, as far as I understand, (Reform home affairs spokesman) Zia Yusuf is a Muslim.

“To me… you cannot be a Muslim and British… it’s like oil and water.”

MP Sarah Pochin said the party was ‘f***ing chauvinistic’

Reform MP Sarah Pochin was secretly recorded by an undercover ITV reporter saying the party has a ‘male issue’, and that it ‘excludes you if you’re a woman’.

Speaking to an undercover reporter acting as a press officer at Reform, Pochin says the party “so needs women press officers.”

She goes on to label Reform colleagues as “f***ing chauvinistic,” continuing: “I go out on all the shows to go ‘Oh no, it’s lovely, they’re all so welcoming.’ S***.”

The post Key bombshells from the ITV undercover sting operation into Reform UK appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Nigel Farage says Reform racism and sexism down to ‘not going to Oxford or Eton’

It just goes from bad to worse for Nigel Farage. The Reform UK leader has implied that the reason his party members and councillors have expressed racist and bigoted views is because they didn’t go to Eton and Oxford University.

Reform is currently engulfed in a racism scandal after a year-long undercover ITV investigation exposed party members for expressing racist and misogynistic views.

Last week, it was revealed that councillors described Asian families as “parasites” and said the government should “stick them on planes and **** them off to Pakistan”.

In footage broadcast yesterday, an unnamed Reform activist also said that asylum seekers should be put in “concentration camps” and that Muslims could not be British.

On Thursday, party officials are captured telling Farage they have to “defend the indefensible” and explain to him how he would be “protecting” a Reform candidate from being sacked.

Rather than dealing with the racism, misogyny and bigotry in his party which is widespread and systemic, Farage has once more claimed that his party are the victims of an ‘establishment stitch up’.

In a statement to the Express, Farage said: “Maybe what I’ll do is I’ll commission a team of undercover [operatives], and we’ll go and speak to a thousand Tory councillors. You’ll find worse. You’ll find it everywhere. You’ll find it in the pub tonight.

“It’s people, and particularly if they’re provoking conversation. Not everyone’s been to Oxford University. Not everyone’s been to Eton. Not everyone expresses themselves in very carefully formulated language.”

His comments were ridiculed online, with one social media user writing: “I never went to Oxford and Eton either but still managed to not tell my coworkers that I’d like to molest my daughter in a bath or rape my colleagues. It’s actually quite easy.”

Another added: “I don’t think you need to go to Eton to realise being misogynistic, racist & xenophobic is a Bad Thing!”

The post Nigel Farage says Reform racism and sexism down to ‘not going to Oxford or Eton’ appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Reform activist and MP hopeful said Muslims like Zia Yusuf ‘cannot be British’

The racism scandal engulfing Reform UK continues as further revelations are made by ITV’s undercover investigation, with now a Reform activist and aspiring MP claiming that Muslims like the party’s home affairs spokesperson Zia Yusuf cannot be British.

ITV had previously exposed Reform councillors expressing racist and misogynistic views. The revelations are part of a year-long undercover investigation carried out by the channel. Last week, it was revealed that councillors described Asian families as “parasites” and said the government should “stick them on planes and **** them off to Pakistan”.

In footage broadcast yesterday, the unnamed Reform activist also said that asylum seekers should be put in “concentration camps”.

He said: “If a Muslim’s prepared to de-convert, I’m happy.

“But if they want to remain faithful to Islam, then this would be, I would have disagreements, especially with, um, I mean, as far as I understand, (Reform home affairs spokesman) Zia Yusuf is a Muslim.

“To me… you cannot be a Muslim and British… it’s like oil and water.”

Discussing asylum seekers crossing the English Channel in small boats, the activist said: “In the first week of election, build concentration camps, and everyone who comes across on the Channel, you’re in there.”

The post Reform activist and MP hopeful said Muslims like Zia Yusuf ‘cannot be British’ appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Undercover reporter shows Nigel Farage being accused by aide of protecting candidate who told David Lammy to go home

The racism scandal engulfing Reform UK is growing after a senior Reform UK official accused Nigel Farage of “protecting” a mayoral candidate who said David Lammy should “go back home to the Caribbean”.

The revelations were made as part of an undercover ITV investigation into the party, which also recently exposed councillors making racist and misogynistic remarks.

Farage was urged to sack Chris Parry last December after he said that was where the then justice secretary’s “loyalties lie”.

However, despite the pleas, Parry, a former Rear Admiral, survived as Reform’s candidate to be mayor of Hampshire and the Solent.

ITV recorded Ed Sumner, the director of communications, saying Parry would be sacked, but he was over-ruled by Farage.

Rather than listen to his advisor, Farage said that Parry should “apologise to Lammy… if David Lammy’s taken offence”.

Sumner told Farage: “You’re protecting him.”

Farage replies: “It’s showing a bit of sorrow … trouble is he’s a Rear Admiral, that’s the problem.”

The latest incident once more shows how widespread racism and bigtory are in Reform UK and how Farage has refused to deal with it.

The revelations are part of a year-long undercover investigation carried out by ITV. Earlier this week it was revealed that councillors described Asian families as “parasites” and saying the government should “stick them on planes and **** them off to Pakistan”.

The post Undercover reporter shows Nigel Farage being accused by aide of protecting candidate who told David Lammy to go home appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Labour minister says investigation into Reform racism is a ‘good reminder’ of what is the central political question facing Britain

Labour minister Kanishka Narayan has said it is ‘hard for him to seperate the personal from the political’ after being asked to comment on ITV’s investigation exposing Reform councillors for their racist and hateful views.

Three councillors have already stood down from the party, which said it was conducting an investigation over the first revelations from an ITV undercover investigation that aired on Wednesday.

Further damaging revelations for Reform from ITV’s year long investigation are expected, with the initial report showing Alan Feeney, a Reform councillor and deputy mayor of Solihull, calling Asian homeowners “parasites,” and stating that “no more than 1% of [the] British population can be non-white”.

Other candidates were recorded making comments of extreme violence and sharing deeply misogynistic and racist views, including a Bromley councillor calling for King Charles to be killed and another councillor who made disturbing sexual and misogynistic comments about female colleagues.

Appearing on ITV’s Peston programme, Narayan, Minister for AI, said: “On occasions like this, it’s quite hard for me to seperate the personal and political.”

He went on to add: “The thing I take away from it is, it’s not just an isolated incident, an example in Bromley, an example in Solihull an example in Hounslow, and example in Wales, not just individual examples, senior branch officials, treasurers of the party branch, staff members, the Senedd candidate, to me when you combine the personal and political to me it’s really the central question in British politics.

“Which is, are people like me able to be a part of a collective national identity and have security of stay here or not, so to me it’s a good reminder of what we’re fighting for is the central political question facing Britain.

The post Labour minister says investigation into Reform racism is a ‘good reminder’ of what is the central political question facing Britain appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Reform deputy mayor resigns after saying mass deportations must make Britain 99% white

Alan Feeney, the Reform deputy mayor of Solihull Borough Council has resigned from Nigel Farage’s party after he was filmed saying mass deportations must make Britain white. 

In the footage taken by ITV undercover reporters, Feeney said he believed that “no more than one percent of the British population can be non-white”.

Feeney added: “When a house comes up for sale, white people need to be in there. You almost need to out-Muslim the Muslims.”

He also used violent language to talk about deporting Muslims, stating: “You’d need a proper nuclear option, like literally drag them at their homes, stick them on planes and f*** them off to Pakistan. Which you’ll never do in a month of Sundays.”

He told undercover reporters Solihull had been “infested” with Asian families, who he called “absolute parasites”. 

When out knocking on doors, Feeney said “if it’s an Asian name, I’m not even knocking at the door, they’re not voting Reform and I ain’t wasting my time”. 

He called his approach to campaigning “Alan’s racist canvassing”.

On Facebook, Feeney said he had “mutually agreed with Reform UK that, for personal reasons, I will be leaving the party”.

He will now sit as an independent councillor. 

Discussing a female Reform candidate from Solihull, Whelan and Reform councillor Chris Whelan used sexist and sexually aggressive language. 

“That’s reminded me, I need to buy an orange in a sock,” said Feeney. 

“If she was my daughter, it would still be bath night on a Thursday. I’ll wash you properly this time,” added Whelan.

Whelan said of another female Reform candidate in Birmingham that he “would have been sniffing that seat as soon as she got up. If she’d have given me a hug I’d have f****** fingered her”.

Dean Miller, another Reform councillor in Bromley, South London, was recorded calling for King Charles to be decapitated because he “is a Muslim” and referred to black children as “animals”.

Miller told undercover journalists: “Apparently King Charles is a f****** Muslim. Someone from the inside saw a f****** prayer mat and all that in one of his f****** rooms. 

“I think that’s f****** traitorous. Cut the c***’* head off, sorry.”

The Reform councillor claimed children had been committing vandalism in Bromley, and said: “Like all the ethnic f****** kids, they’re not white, they’re all f****** black, and they’re like f****** animals. 

“It’s horrible to say it. I’m not racist.”

Miller claimed he was “heavily medicated” due to chronic pain at the time, and has now resigned from Reform UK. 

This week, LFF revealed that Nigel Alderson, a Reform councillor in Lancashire had reposted an image of a pig defecating on a Quran and commented on posts by Only Fans and other female adult content creators soliciting pictures from them.

Olivia Barber is a reporter at Left Foot Forward

The post Reform deputy mayor resigns after saying mass deportations must make Britain 99% white appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Green Party complains to the Telegraph over ‘racist and antisemitic’ cartoons

The Green Party has issued a complaint to the Telegraph over two cartoons it published of the party’s leader Zack Polanski and deputy co-leader Mothin Ali.

The Greens say the images used “well-known racist and antisemitic tropes” and have called on the Telegraph to immediately delete them and apologise.

The artwork by cartoonist Patrick Blower depicts Ali wearing a “Zionism is Racism” badge and a Palestinian flag.

The image also includes the message “Eat your Greens” as Ali appears to prepare to eat the severed head of Polanski, whose is depicted with a large hooked nose.

The Muslim Greens and Jewish Greens put out a joint statement yesterday condemning the “deeply offensive cartoon”, which was published on 10 October.

The statement said: “The depiction of a Muslim political figure as menacing, violent and grotesque, alongside imagery reminiscent of antisemitic caricatures of a Jewish political leader, raises serious concerns about Islamophobia, antisemitism and anti-Palestinian racism.”

It adds: “As Muslim and Jewish members of the Green Party of England and Wales, we reject attempts to pit our communities against one another.”

In another cartoon by Christian Adams, also published in the Telegraph on Saturday, Polanski is again depicted with an exaggerated, large hook-shaped nose.

The Green Party has said that until the Telegraph retracts the cartoons and apologises, it will not cooperate with its journalists.

A spokesperson for the Green Party said: “The depictions of Zack and Mothin are instantly recognisable as racist and antisemitic, and we will always challenge this kind of behaviour wherever we see it. 

“The Telegraph has previously called out other papers for giving space to similar tropes, so we insist it practices what it preaches and acts immediately to address the harm it has caused. 

“Until this is resolved and the paper is once again acting in line with accepted editorial standards, we refuse to support its journalism.”

Olivia Barber is a reporter at Left Foot Forward

The post Green Party complains to the Telegraph over ‘racist and antisemitic’ cartoons appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

This is the full statement from Green Party MPs and leaders on Zionism is racism motion

The Green Party’s five MPs, leader and deputy leaders have all released a statement following the Green Party’s autumn conference passing the ‘Zionism is racism’ is motion.

The full statement reads: “As Greens, we will always uphold universal human rights. We will never tolerate any form of discrimination or harassment.

“We will continue to stand in opposition to genocide, ethnic cleansing, apartheid and the illegal occupation. We will continue to call out the heinous crimes of the Netanyahu government.

“And we will continue to work to ensure that the Green Party is an anti-racist party in every way. We know there is no conflict between supporting the rights of Palestinians and the rights of Jewish people.”

The statement is signed by:

  • Zack Polanski (Green Party leader)
  • Rachel Maskell (Green Party deputy leader)
  • Mothin Ali (Green Party deputy leader)
  • Sian Berry MP
  • Ellie Chowns MP
  • Carla Denyer MP
  • Adrian Ramsay MP
  • Hannah Spencer MP

A separate statement was also released by a Green Party spokesperson following the vote. It read: “Speaking following the motion passing, a Green Party spokesperson said: “This has been a serious and deeply felt debate within our membership. Our members value the ability to bring forward and decide party policy, and conference has now made its decision.

“The Green Party is an anti-racist party and has consistently opposed the illegal occupation of both Palestinian and Syrian land, called for an end to arms sales to the Israeli government and spoken out fearlessly about the devastating situation in Gaza and the West Bank. Those positions remain central to our approach. So too does our deeply held commitment to equality, justice and human rights for all and opposition to racism in all its forms.”

Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward

The post This is the full statement from Green Party MPs and leaders on Zionism is racism motion appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Green Party votes for ‘Zionism is racism’ motion

Members of the Green Party of England and Wales have voted to brand Zionism a racist ideology following a heated debate at the party’s autumn conference in Brighton. The motion was carried with a relatively narrow margin – 1,022 votes in favour and 813 votes against. That’s 55 per cent of votes in favour, and 45 per cent against.

The motion begins with a definition of Zionism: “a political ideology which called for the creation – and, now it exists, the continuity – of an ethnonationalist Jewish State in historic Palestine to the exclusion and/or domination of the non-Jewish population.”

It then continues by arguing: “The real, material manifestation of Zionism has been the historic and ongoing dehumanisation, displacement, dispossession, disenfranchisement and destruction of Palestinians. This is based upon European settler-colonial systems of domination and oppression, which has also created racial hierarchies between Jews of different ethnicities in Palestine.”

Alongside this, the motion commits the Green Party to supporting a ‘one-state solution’. The motion will see the Greens support: “the establishment of a single democratic Palestinian State in all of historic Palestine with Jerusalem as its capital, equal rights for all, and the right of return for Palestinians and their descendants.”

In advance of the conference, the motion’s proposer Lubna Speitan told LFF: “This motion is merely a means of identifying the root cause of the problem, which is the racist ideology of Zionism – a settler colonial ideology – and its practice, which is resulting now in our erasure. Under Israel, Palestinians do not have rights. There is no such thing as equal rights under Israel’s boot. What we are asking for is for our mere basic human rights to be acknowledged.”

The motion has been highly contentious within the Green Party. In advance of the motion being debated, three Green MPs released public statements seeking to stop it from passing.

The party’s leadership were divided on the motion, with deputy leader Mothin Ali supporting it, but the party’s other deputy leader Rachel Millward, alongside leader Zack Polanski publicly calling for the motion to be amended in order to protect Jewish members from facing disciplinary action for being members of synagogues that are affiliated to Zionist denominations and to remove the commitment to a one-state solution.

The main amendment to remove the commitment to a one-state solution was rejected with 742 votes against and 695 in favour of those attending the conference either in person or remotely. However, the amendment went to a ‘card vote’ which means that members who aren’t able to attend conference and have given their proxy vote to another member who is able to attend are also able to participate in the vote. On the card vote, there were 920 votes against, and 821 in favour.

The amendment designed to explicitly state that the motion would be used to to take disciplinary action for membership of Jewish organisations that describe themselves as Zionist was defeated by 1,026 votes to 684 on a card vote. That amendment sought to add text into the motion which read: “This motion shall not be used to pressure, proscribe or discipline members based on affiliation with Jewish community institutions, such as synagogues, community centres or denominational groups, that describe themselves as Zionist or used to discipline or sanction Jewish members for expressing views that would be non sanctionable if expressed by non Jewish members such as (such as support for a binational state, or two state solution).”

Opponents of the amendment argued that it was unnecessary, as the motion did not relate to disciplinary processes, and therefore could not be used to discipline members.

Green Party MP Ellie Chowns – who is the party’s foreign affairs spokesperson in the House of Commons – spoke against the motion in the debate, as did the anti-Brexit campaigner Femi Oluwole and the former Green Party MP Caroline Lucas.

Mothin Ali was the most high profile person within the party to speak in favour of the motion.

Speaking following the motion passing, a Green Party spokesperson said: “This has been a serious and deeply felt debate within our membership. Our members value the ability to bring forward and decide party policy, and conference has now made its decision.

“The Green Party is an anti-racist party and has consistently opposed the illegal occupation of both Palestinian and Syrian land, called for an end to arms sales to the Israeli government and spoken out fearlessly about the devastating situation in Gaza and the West Bank. Those positions remain central to our approach. So too does our deeply held commitment to equality, justice and human rights for all and opposition to racism in all its forms.”

Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward

The post Green Party votes for ‘Zionism is racism’ motion appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Green MPs make last-ditch attempt to stop Zionism is Racism motion

Green Party MPs have made a last ditch attempt to stop the Zionism is Racism passing at Green Party Conference. The vote on the motion is expected to take place tomorrow (Sunday 4 October).

The motion begins with a definition of Zionism: “a political ideology which called for the creation – and, now it exists, the continuity – of an ethnonationalist Jewish State in historic Palestine to the exclusion and/or domination of the non-Jewish population.”

It then continues by arguing: “The real, material manifestation of Zionism has been the historic and ongoing dehumanisation, displacement, dispossession, disenfranchisement and destruction of Palestinians. This is based upon European settler-colonial systems of domination and oppression, which has also created racial hierarchies between Jews of different ethnicities in Palestine.”

The motion has been highly contentious within the party. Advocates have argued that the motion is the natural conclusion of the party’s existing policies on Palestine and that it would commit the party to an explicitly anti-Zionist position. Opponents argue that it risks alienating large sections of the electorate, could see Jewish members facing disciplinary action for being members of synagogues that are affiliated to denominations which describe themselves as Zionist, and that as it commits the Green Party to a ‘one-state solution’ rather than allowing the Palestinian people to determine which solution they wish to negotiate with Israel.

Three Green MPs have released statements opposing the motion – at least in its current form.

Green MP Adrian Ramsay’s statement reads “We need to be crystal clear as a party that we stand with the ordinary people of Palestine and Israel, and with Jews and Muslims in the UK, many of whom feel unsafe after multiple attacks on their communities.” Elsewhere, he said that he would be voting against the motion on the basis that it went against the Greens’ long-held principles on Palestine.

Carla Denyer – who previously co-led the party with Ramsay – similarly said she was opposed to the motion. In her statement, she said: “In this party, I know we are united in tackling the ongoing and enduring injustices in Gaza and across Palestine. I am proud of the Green Party’s culture of robust political debate coupled with a drive to build positive consensus, so I am confident that it would be possible for us to come to a position and write a motion that addresses the concerns that I and others have raised, while strengthening our support for Palestinian liberation. sadly I do not think this motion is it.”

Sian Berry – the Green MP for Brighton Pavilion – released a statement calling for the motion to be ‘referred back’. Referring a motion back means that conference does not take a vote on the motion, and instead agrees for the proposers to look at it again, revise it, and bring it back to a future conference.

The party’s other two MPs – Ellie Chowns and Hannah Spencer – have not released a statement on the issue at the time of writing. LFF understands, however, that Chowns does not want the motion to pass.

The motion has also divided the party leadership. One of the party’s deputy leaders Mothin Ali has said he will vote for the motion. The other deputy, Rachel Millward, has said that she would not be voting for it unamended. The Green Party’s leader Zack Polanski has said he’s backing two amendments – one around protecting Jews’ membership of synagogues, and the other which would remove the commitment to support a single Palestinian state.

Chris Jarvis is head of strategy and development at Left Foot Forward

Image credit: UK Parliament – Creative Commons

The post Green MPs make last-ditch attempt to stop Zionism is Racism motion appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Demonstrators at conference rally against anti-Zionism have ‘extremist views’, says Green member

A Green Party member at the party’s conference has described the views of Stop the Hate members protesting against the Zionism is Racism motion as “extremist”.

From around 11am this morning, people from Stop the Hate, a group that says it “the largest Jewish-led direct action campaign group” gathered outside the Brighton Centre to protest.

John Mayford, a Brighton Green Party member, said he had seen “quite a few” of the protesters last week, and that some of them said “‘the genocide in Gaza is a media construct, saying things like ‘the UN is a left-wing organisation’.”

Mayford said that “of course the UN is a member organisation made up of governments from around the world”.

He added: “A lot of these people here today are extremists.”

Mayford added: “Likud under Netanyahu is a fascist organisation, with people openly saying they want to carry out ethnic cleansing.”

He said that the people from Stop the Hate he had spoken to at a protest last week had indicated support for Likud’s ideas. 

“One of the premises that is false about these kinds of protests is the conflation of religion with condemnation of a fascist state that is committing genocide,” he said.

The Green Party member called it “ridiculous”, adding: “That’d be like saying it would be anti-Christian of me to criticise Maggie Thatcher.”

Mike Davies, a member of the Palestine Solidarity Campaign in Brighton, said members of the group are “just nasty” and that he doesn’t think they have any “legitimate concerns” about the motion. 

Davies added: “Where they’re coming from is support for Israel, but they have a lot of things they invent to prop that up, because of course support for Israel is support for the genocide, support for the eviction of Palestinians, and support for two laws, ones for Israelis, and one for non-Jewish Israelis.”

One person protesting with Stop the Hate said he didn’t know what the motion was, but that he was there to support Israelis and Jews.

On the situation in Gaza, he said the IDF was “killing not murdering people”, adding that it is “not a genocide”, but “a military campaign”.

“Hamas have not laid down their weapons and they’ve promised to do it again, another October 7th at their earliest opportunity,” he stated.

He added: “You don’t understand what Israel is up against.”

Image credit: Cameron Baillie

Olivia Barber is a reporter at Left Foot Forward

The post Demonstrators at conference rally against anti-Zionism have ‘extremist views’, says Green member appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

❌