AI and Psychological Safety
AI and Psychological Safety
When we opened this research pulse in March, we had some expectations about where we thought it would land. For individuals, especially neurodivergent folks, we expected AI to sometimes make speaking up a little easier; we’ve had many conversations in workshops with folks who have said they use AI tools as a way to rehearse a difficult conversation, or to find the words for something they want to say and aren’t sure how to put. For organisations though, we expected AI might pull us in the opposite direction, with the risk of jobs being replaced by AI and raising expectations about pace and quality of work leaving people feeling more precarious and that they have less room to get things wrong.
We asked three questions: whether you use AI tools at work, how that has affected how psychologically safe you feel with colleagues, and what’s behind your answer. 110 people replied. Some of what people told us matched our hypotheses closely, some of it somewhat complicated them, and one theme turned up that we hadn’t thought to look for at all.
The headline figures
Of the 90 people who use AI at work and answered our main question, the largest group said AI had made no real difference to how safe they feel with colleagues. The rest split in both directions, with about a third feeling safer and about a fifth feeling less safe.

For us, that spread is more interesting than the average. It points to several different experiences sitting side by side, and the comments people left to elaborate on their responses give an indication of what those experiences are.
AI is a place to rehearse
This was the clearest pattern in the comments, and it held up across people who otherwise appeared to have little in common. Those who said AI had made them feel safer mostly described using it to get ready for interacting with a colleague. One person has built meeting simulations and profiles of colleagues they find difficult, and now goes into tense meetings feeling much more prepared. Another asks it for “lines to take” because, in their words, “sometimes in the heat of a conversation I can’t immediately frame what I want to say well.” Someone else gets it to think like their manager and point out what they’re missing. One respondent described the whole cycle: practising emails, being coached through a situation with a colleague before speaking to them and stress-testing ideas before sharing them.
Only one person connected this to neurodivergence directly, explaining that they have ADHD and use AI to practise what they want to say.
All of these examples speak to change that happens in the person rather than in the team. Rehearsal helps us feel more prepared to walk into the room, and perhaps better able to predict what will happen next, even though the room itself, and what happens there when we say the thing, hasn’t changed.
One respondent raised a concern though around what might happen if rehearsal turns into replacement. A colleague had told them they talk things through with an AI chatbot, and this led them to wonder whether people who feel unsafe at work are now working through it with AI instead of raising it with a person, and whether that may leave them feeling more isolated. Rehearsal that leads into the real conversation looks like a potential benefit of using AI, but replacing interaction with AI conversation instead may leave the team less connected, and potentially feeling less safe than before. Interestingly, no one in our research described actually doing this, but the concern was there that others might.
AI leaves less room to get it wrong
Our second prediction, that AI might make people feel less secure in their roles held up too, though the comments were actually a little more nuanced than we’d anticipated. Very few people who felt less safe said they were frightened of AI itself. What came through instead was a sense that their own value had become harder to see. One person summed it up in a phrase they’d heard from colleagues: “You can use AI for that.” Someone working with developers described the boundary between their roles blurring, so that it was suddenly obvious how little they knew about code, and the power, along with some impatience, now sat with the developers. Others wrote about AI adding strain to existing overload, feeling that it was “yet another thing to learn and be good at, just to prove I can do my job”. In a similar vein, others described feeling pushed into using it, and feeling that it was leading to workplaces where there was “more pressure and less time to think”.
Admitting you don’t know something is one of the everyday risks that a psychologically safe team makes affordable. When AI seems to make those gaps in knowledge less forgivable, and is perceived to be continually raising the bar for performance at work, understandably people are going to find it harder to admit when they don’t know.
One comment pointed to where this might lead: “There’s worry about competence gap, there’s more isolation, more ‘team of one’ than before.” If people respond to feeling exposed by withdrawing, the team loses the conversations that would help everyone work out how best we work with this rapidly evolving technology.
Keeping it to yourself: stigma around AI use
Separate from worries about jobs, a handful of people described AI use as something they keep from colleagues, perhaps because in certain areas it is considered lazy, or even a form of cheating. Someone in academia put it bluntly: “everyone is using AI, but nobody dares admit it. The choice is either to use it and pretend we’re not, or not use it, and be left behind.” Another, also from higher education, said AI can feel like cheating, and wondered whether acknowledging it diminishes their capabilities in the eyes of their team. Given that so much of the discussion in higher education has been around detecting and potentially punishing students for inappropriate AI use, it makes sense that staff would find it hard to say openly that they use it themselves.
A trainer who has seen similar fears play out with e-learning described themselves as a “quiet AI enthusiast”, because their colleagues are scared enough that discussing how to use AI at work doesn’t feel safe. A team leader told us their own position makes it less risky for them to be honest about using AI, while recognising that people in their team seem nervous about saying what they use it for.
This isn’t the case across all teams and organisations, and indeed some respondents described a very different experience. One respondent who felt much safer wrote: “We all use AI in some form and discuss our use openly. We have frameworks to govern how we use it.” Another team treats anything from AI as not fully credible by default, which they said gives them an easy way to start conversations and question assumptions together.
It seems openness and transparency around use, and guardrails of using AI help to make it a safe conversation.
The biggest group: no change, for now
The largest single answer was to how AI was affecting people’s psychological safety was “no change”, and the reasons people gave for it fall into two camps. One was the people who are using AI but not in a way which has (yet) impacted on their interactions with colleagues, the things that actually shape psychological safety. One person, for instance, uses AI only as a starter for ideas and then abandons it; others said they’re “still at the experimenting stage” or that it’s early days where they work. For them, AI hasn’t yet reached the part of work that happens between people, so it’s had little chance to change how safe that feels. One respondent also captured the job security angle of this, saying fear of being fired isn’t a threat for them, “yet”.
The second camp said their team was already a safe place to speak up, and AI hadn’t shifted that. One described a very psychologically safe culture where the conversation about AI had been transparent from the start; another said their workplace had given people time in workshops to explore it together. That fits the pattern in the previous section. Where AI arrives into a team that already talks openly, and people are given time and space to explore AI, people can then talk openly about AI too.
Psychological Safety by proxy
Writing in HBR, Jayshree Seth and Amy Edmondson describe what they call safety by proxy: people using AI to surface a concern when they don’t feel safe enough to raise it directly. They argue that when that happens, it tells leaders something about the culture.
Nobody in our survey described passing a concern onto the team through AI in place of saying it themselves, but the person who described their team openly acknowledging the fallibility of AI as an easy way into questioning assumptions hits on an important point. If the idea on the table belongs to the tool and not to a colleague, it can be easier to critique it without worrying about the interpersonal cost. It is easy to see how that may extend to presenting your own ideas or concerns through AI as a way of slightly distancing yourself from them and lowering the perceived interpersonal cost of raising them.
A group that needs a proxy at the interface before it can disagree is a group where disagreeing directly still feels risky. Safety by proxy might become a rehearsal for the ‘real thing’ of disagreeing person to person. It might just as easily become a more comfortable way to avoid it completely.
What this means for teams and managers
One interpretation of this is that AI amplifies whatever a team already does with uncertainty. Where people can say what they’re trying, what they don’t understand and what worries them, AI becomes one more thing to learn about together. Where they can’t, it becomes one more thing to manage alone.
For managers, that points to a few practical suggestions:
- Go first. Say how you use AI, including where it has gone wrong for you. The team leader in our survey noticed that seniority made disclosure less risky for them, which makes them the person best placed to take the first step.
- Make “I don’t know how to do this yet” an ordinary thing to say. The people who felt least safe were the ones who felt exposed by having gaps in their knowledge.
- Agree how the team uses AI, explicitly. Several of the people who felt safest had shared ground rules, or a shared habit of treating AI output as a starting point for discussion. Shared norms make the space more predictable and therefore (usually) safer.
- Notice if anyone has gone quiet or appears to be pulling away from the team. If someone has become a “team of one”, ask what’s changed for them.
- Welcome the rehearsal, whilst encouraging people to make sure the real conversation still happens afterwards.
The most hopeful comment in the whole survey was also one of the shortest. “We all use AI in some form and discuss our use openly.” What matters when it comes to psychological safety perhaps isn’t the use of AI as much as the habit of talking about it; making AI itself a safe topic of conversation.
About the data
This research pulse ran on an open survey link from 25 March to 6 October 2026, with a sticker-pack prize draw as a thank you. We received 110 responses (97 complete and 13 partial). 96 people said they use AI tools at work, and 90 of them answered the question about psychological safety. Around 60 left a comment.
It’s a small, self-selected sample, and people who already care about psychological safety are more likely to have taken part, so we should read the findings as a snapshot of experiences rather than a measure of how universally common they are. The themes above reflect our reading of the comments. Quotes have been lightly tidied for typos, and we’ve left out anything that might identify the person who wrote them.
Thank you to everyone who took the time to answer, and especially to those who told us what was behind their answer.
Further reading:
What leaders need to know about AI and psychological safety
Academic integrity has become a pedagogy of suspicion
The post AI and Psychological Safety appeared first on Psych Safety.