❌

Reading view

There are new articles available, click to refresh the page.

TUC’s Paul Nowak and John Amaechi perfectly dismantle anti-immigration rhetoric on Question Time

The general secretary of the Trades Union Congress, Paul Nowak, and psychologist John Amaechi delivered powerful rebuttals of anti-immigration narratives on Question Time last night. 

In a discussion about whether Labour’s new immigration policy is ‘yet another U-turn’, Nowak highlighted the importance of treating migrants with dignity. 

Nowak welcomed the home secretary Shabana Mahmood’s decision to scrap plans to make foreign care workers who are already in the UK wait 15 years to qualify for settlement.

Under the revised policy, care workers who earn at least £25,000 a year and arrived in the UK before May 2025 will continue to qualify for settlement after five years.

Nowak said: “It was a welcome step back, 200,000 people responded to the government’s consultation, I think it’s the second biggest consultation response in history after equal marriage.”

Turning to the debate around immigration, the TUC boss said: “I’ll get to the policy issues in a moment but I’ll tell you this about migration. Quite often it turns into a political ping pong match, and what we’re actually talking about is people.”

Speaking about Liverpool, where Question Time was held yesterday, he added: “This is a city that was built on migration. Both my grandads came to this country during the Second World War, one with the Polish RAF, one from Hong Kong.”

Nowak said both of his grandfathers had met Liverpool Irish women and they stayed and settled in the UK.

“I think it would have been untenable for them to be in a situation when they were in Liverpool and told, well it doesn’t matter, you could be here 15 years, 20 years and we’ll decide when you can stay,” he said.

Nowak questioned: “How do you plan your life, buy a house, put the kids in school, decide what you’re going to do about work?”.

He said Mahmood was “right” to “take a step back” and said it was “untenable” for the government to change the rules for migrants already living in the UK. 

Nowak said he’d like to see the government extend the policy for prison and transport workers and those working in research and development.

Host Fiona Bruce asked Nowak who should not be allowed to enter the country. 

Nowak said “I think people should be able to apply to come to this country and then the government has got to set the guidelines for who can stay and work.”

Amaechi, a former basketball player and psychologist, also challenged anti-migrant rhetoric during the discussion.

He said: “Can I suggest that when we have this conversation sometimes no one I think is arguing there should be just an open door for anybody, but at the same time you listen to this conversation and it’s like the policy was made for the apocryphal grotesque stereotype of what an immigrant is.”

To a round of applause, Amaechi added: “Yes there are fraudsters in this world and guess what they aren’t all just black and brown people coming to this country.”

Speaking about having worked in the NHS for 10 years, Amaechi said that many people doing the jobs “we would find the most undesirable did it with passion and we stood by as they protected our loved ones in their most vulnerable moments”.

He added: “And I’m not saying that that is the picture of all migrants too, but surely a more charitable picture than the fraudsters and the connivers and the criminals, as if we do not have them here in aplenty”.

Amaechi also challenged government policies that require migrants to earn a certain amount to be able to settle.

He said: “Any time that you look at a policy that starts to tell people coming here that they’re only valuable if you make more than this amount of money, then all of us here should look out.”

A young woman in the audience said Amaechi had “hit the nail on the head” with his comments, and asked: “When do we stop scapegoating immigrants in general?”.

She added: “When is there a reflection on the government to put out to people that ‘hang on, immigration isn’t actually this massive issue that it’s made out to be, there’s a lot of fearmongering going on.”

The audience member said that as a student her issue isn’t “someone who is coming here as a migrant to work hard, my issue is getting graduate roles”.

She said she doesn’t view an immigrant “as the reason why I can’t get a graduate job” or “the reason why mincemeat costs £7 and petrol prices are constantly increasing”.

She finished by asking: “So is the government ever going to do something to sort of stop that narrative and tell people ‘actually immigrants are regular people like you and me’?”.

Olivia Barber is a reporter at Left Foot Forward

The post TUC’s Paul Nowak and John Amaechi perfectly dismantle anti-immigration rhetoric on Question Time appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

What are the Right-Wing press and think tanks up to this week?

The big themes of the week

1. Immigration and asylum: keeping the pressure on

The asylum debate remains a major focus, with coverage of proposed accommodation for asylum seekers near Piddington and Bicester, residents’ concerns and calls for tougher action. The Daily Express framed local objections around whether women were being listened to, while the wider debate has included proposals from Reform UK to suspend the asylum system for five years.

2. Tax, spending and the case for a smaller state

With the Chancellor’s Budget approaching on 28 October, arguments about taxation, welfare and business costs are intensifying. The Sun has attacked the prospect of further tax rises and argued for welfare cuts, while business groups have called for changes to employer National Insurance to encourage recruitment.

3. Andy Burnham under sustained political attack

The Sun‘s 15 October editorial attacked Burnham over sluggish economic growth, welfare reform, his dealings with Manchester City executives and the prospect of tourist taxes. The Daily Mail has also pursued questions about his relationship with the club’s ownership. They are so ratteld by Labour’s improvement in the polls they’re doing all they can to smear him.

4. Culture-war issues remain part of the agenda

On 16 October, the Daily Mail led with criticism of government proposals to improve pupils’ speaking skills.

Rather than welcoming the improvement, promoted by Lucy Powell, which aims to reform the national curriculum so that verbal fluency and communication skills are embedded alongside traditional academic subjects, the Mail is having a meltdown.

5. The future of the Telegraph and media ownership

On 16 October, Reuters reported that the UK government had cleared Axel Springer’s planned acquisition of Telegraph Media Group from a further competition investigation. This is a significant development for the ownership of one of Britain’s most influential right-leaning newspaper groups.

Why it matters: newspaper ownership affects the long-term institutional landscape in which political arguments are produced. The immediate question is what the change means for editorial independence, newsroom priorities and the paper’s future direction.

The blogs, campaign groups and think tanks behind the headlines

The newspaper stories are only one part of the picture. Campaign organisations and policy institutes help develop the arguments, statistics and proposals that can subsequently enter political debate and media coverage.

TaxPayers’ Alliance — welfare and the public finances

The organisation’s recent output includes a report arguing that Britain’s fiscal problems are worse than those of the 1970s, a critique of tax rises and constituency-level analysis of benefit spending. Its 12 October material claimed benefit costs had risen faster than median pay in 502 of 526 constituencies across England and Wales.

The argument to watch: welfare spending is becoming unaffordable and tax increases risk undermining growth.

The questions to ask: which benefits are included, how the figures are calculated, whether higher spending reflects inflation or increased need, and how the proposed alternatives would affect household incomes.

Read: TaxPayers’ Alliance blog  · Fiscal policy report 

Migration Watch UK — immigration and border control

Campaign and research organisation

Migration Watch’s recent commentary has returned to the question of whether the post-Brexit immigration system has delivered meaningful control over migration. Its September analysis, Ten Years Since Brexit, We Still Have Not Taken Back Control, questions the record on immigration numbers.

The argument to watch: governments have failed to deliver the immigration controls promised after Brexit.

The questions to ask: are the figures about net migration, work visas, asylum applications or settlement? These measure different things, and a claim about one should not automatically be treated as a claim about all the others.

Read: Migration Watch UK blogs 

Policy Exchange — the policy development pipeline

Policy institute · Public services and the economy

Policy Exchange’s recent publications include The Rural Penalty, examining how NHS funding formulas affect rural and coastal communities, and Legislating for Candour?, published on 14 October. Its broader programme addresses productivity, housing, healthcare and regulatory reform.

The argument to watch: how institutional reform, changes to public-service delivery and economic restructuring might improve outcomes.

The questions to ask: what evidence supports each proposed reform, who gains or loses from it, and whether the analysis adequately accounts for regional inequalities.

This newsletter is produced with the assistance AI

The post What are the Right-Wing press and think tanks up to this week? appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Right-Wing Media Watch: The right-wing press has already written Sánchez’s political obituary

Spain is heading for a snap general election on November 29, and the right-wing press has wasted no time celebrating what it clearly projects to be the beginning of the end for Pedro Sánchez’s Socialist government.

Sánchez announced the early election after his minority government suffered a parliamentary defeat over emergency measures designed to tackle Spain’s housing crisis, following intense public outrage after a high-profile eviction of an 87-year-old woman in Madrid. The proposals, which included stronger protections against evictions and measures aimed at increasing access to affordable housing, were voted down after the conservative People’s Party (PP), the far-right Vox and the Catalan pro-independence party Junts opposed them.

The PP is currently ahead of Sánchez’s Spanish Socialist Workers’ Party (PSOE) in the polls, while support for Vox has also been rising. If those numbers translate into parliamentary seats, the PP could need Vox’s support to form a government, potentially bringing the far-right party into national government for the first time since the end of Franco’s dictatorship.

For the right-wing media, however, the result is apparently already written.

‘European Left on verge of collapse’

No sooner had the election been announced than the knives were out.

The Telegraph splashed: “European Left on verge of collapse as Spain’s Pedro Sanchez calls snap election.”

Its article presents Sánchez as an increasingly isolated figure on the European Left, highlighting his criticism of Israel’s war in Gaza, his migration policies and his confrontations with Donald Trump over the war in Iran and Nato defence spending.

It also notes Sánchez’s emergence as a prominent figure on the European Left, including how Andy Burnham sought him out at the UN General Assembly in New York, where the two leaders strolled through Central Park.

The piece points to Sánchez’s political survival after previous electoral setbacks, but argues that, this time, the stakes are higher.

“If Mr Sanchez’s gamble backfires this time,” it writes, “the already small number of centre-Left leaders in Europe will be reduced to Mr Burnham, Denmark’s Mette Frederiksen and Malta’s Robert Abela.”

And should the PP and Vox prevail, the Telegraph predicts it would “build momentum behind Europe’s insurgent populist parties”.

The piece looks ahead to elections in France, Italy and Poland, arguing that victories for Marine Le Pen, Giorgia Meloni and Poland’s Law and Justice party would see the EU “swing further to the Right and the Left further diminished”.

The Spectator declares victory before the votes are counted

The Spectator is similarly confident.

Its headline declares: “Sánchez is heading for defeat in Spain’s snap election.”

The right-wing magazine argues Spain now faces the prospect of a “markedly more right-wing government, dependent on Vox’s support”.

It highlights Vox’s calls for “national priority” in access to social housing and benefits, deportation of people living in Spain illegally, and the deportation of legal immigrants who commit crimes.

The article concludes that Sánchez is relying on voters’ fear of bringing a party he describes as “far right” into government overcoming dissatisfaction with his own record.

“On present evidence,” it says, “that looks a forlorn hope.”

There are, of course, serious reasons why Sánchez faces a difficult election.

His minority government has struggled to pass legislation, and his administration has been hit by political and corruption controversies. Social and housing tensions are high following the Ceuta incident with 80,000 migrants from Morocco and rising rents and evictions fuelling large demonstrations across the country.

But there is an important detail that rather gets lost amid the right-wing media’s celebrations.

The election has not happened yet.

Sánchez is undoubtedly taking a political gamble. But the immediate trigger for the election was a housing crisis that has generated huge public anger, and which the right-wing parties themselves helped prevent his government from addressing through the proposed emergency measures.

Sánchez has explicitly framed the election as a choice about whether Spain can continue pursuing progressive policies and secure a broader parliamentary majority capable of delivering reforms on inequality, public services and housing.

The Telegraph and Spectator may have already written Sánchez’s political obituary but on November 29, Spanish voters, not the right-wing press, will decide whether it was premature.

The post Right-Wing Media Watch: The right-wing press has already written Sánchez’s political obituary appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

Isabel Oakeshott’s Arabic lesson comes with a hefty dose of double standards

Isabel Oakeshott recently took to the pages of the Telegraph to proudly announce that she is learning Arabic.

“I’m a foreigner in someone else’s country. It’s only polite that I’m learning Arabic,” was her headline, followed by the pre-header:

“Britons who move overseas should not treat places like Dubai as English-speaking platforms for sunshine and low tax.”

The right-wing journalist and partner of Reform UK deputy Richard Tice begins by explaining that she has lived in Dubai for two years, where she has perfected the art of speaking English in a variety of accents, reflecting the city’s population of “about 200 nationalities.”

“Day to day, Dubai conspires with remarkable efficiency to protect its huge expat population from speaking the official language: Arabic,” she writes.

In other words, Dubai’s knowledge of English is why she hasn’t mastered Arabic but “it seems only right to make an effort in their language.”

And there, of course, is the real point of the article.

Oakeshott is not merely documenting her own linguistic struggles. She is drawing a comparison with immigrants in Britain, and she barely bothers to disguise it.

“Nonetheless, there is a principle at stake when living in someone else’s country – one I am always going on about in relation to immigrants to Britain.”

So far, so predictable.

But rather than simply making the case for learning the language of the country in which you live, Oakeshott spends much of the article taking a swipe at Arabic itself.

Its letters, she complains, “resemble a toddler’s random dots and squiggles,” while its numerals “might as well be hieroglyphics.”

“As for pronunciation, getting it right seems to require the kind of guttural noises an Englishwoman would ordinarily reserve for dislodging a fishbone,” she adds.

She then informs readers of her respectable GCSE grades in two foreign languages and explains that she should have learned Arabic long ago, before admitting that her previous attempts had ended in failure.

While there is of course nothing wrong with admitting that learning another language is difficult, or encouraging people who move abroad to make an effort to communicate in the local language, there is an extraordinary double standard with Oakeshott’s piece.

Oakeshott has chosen to live in Dubai, where she acknowledges that English is widely spoken and that she can comfortably navigate daily life without Arabic. Yet she presents her belated attempt to learn the language as evidence of a moral principle that she routinely invokes when discussing immigrants to Britain.

And while making that point, she cannot resist ridiculing the very language she is supposedly making an effort to respect.

There is also an important fact conspicuously absent from her argument: the overwhelming majority of migrants in Britain do speak English.

Figures from the University of Oxford Migration Observatory show that in 2021, 90%, around nine million, of immigrants living in England and Wales reported that they could speak English without difficulty. Just over half spoke English as their main language, while a further 38% had another main language but spoke English well or very well. Only 1% said they could not speak English at all.

That reality rather complicates the familiar right-wing narrative of immigrants supposedly refusing to learn English.

Oakeshott’s argument might have carried considerably more weight if she had simply reflected on the challenges of learning Arabic as an English speaker and acknowledged the effort involved in adapting to life in another country.

Instead, she manages to turn her own difficulty into a lecture about immigrants, while simultaneously mocking the language she claims to be learning.

Unsurprisingly, the contradiction did not go unnoticed.

Truth Against Hate pointed out the absurdity of moving to an Arab country, waiting two years to learn the language and then describing its alphabet as “a toddler’s random dots and squiggles” and its pronunciation as “guttural noises.”

The campaign group also noted another parallel.

“Imagine an immigrant to Britain writing an article about finally bothering to learn English, while mocking the language and congratulating themselves for making the effort. The Telegraph comments section would spontaneously combust.

“Arabic has been written, studied and used to produce extraordinary works of literature, philosophy, mathematics and science for centuries. It doesn’t become primitive because Isabel Oakeshott finds it difficult.”

Another commenter joked: “I assume she’s learned the Arabic for ‘tax avoider’, then.”

The post Isabel Oakeshott’s Arabic lesson comes with a hefty dose of double standards appeared first on Left Foot Forward: Leading the UK's progressive debate.

❌