❌

Reading view

There are new articles available, click to refresh the page.

Ruins in the family

Since 2023, when Rupert Murdoch launched an attempt to change his family’s trust and give control of his media empire to his eldest son, the annual net incomes of Fox Corp and News Corp have grown by $2 billion and $79 million, respectively. This week, Murdoch’s wishes were rebuffed by a court in Nevada.

So what? Family-owned businesses might be good for business. But good for families? The jury’s out. The list of dynasties recently embroiled in costly legal disputes over succession and commercial control is lengthy and includes the household names of Murdoch, Agnelli (Fiat), Ambani (Reliance) and Redstone (Viacom). 

The scripts write themselves. As Jesse Armstong, creator of HBO’s Succession has said, you don’t need to have talked with James Murdoch or Shari Redstone to taste the acrimony. Just “look at what their PRs are saying everyday about each other. It’s all there, it’s no secret”.

The business case. Having “skin in the game” does, however, seem to reap rewards. 

By the numbers:

  • 4.5 – factor by which returns from investing €100 in a mega-cap family business exceed those from investing in a non-family business over an 18-year period, according to the Carmignac Family 500 database.
  • 70 – per cent of global GDP accounted for by family businesses, according to the 4,000-member Family Business Network.
  • 14 – per cent outperformance in shareholder returns vs non-family businesses, according to McKinsey.

Investors generally view family businesses as capable long-term stewards. But every dynasty has its twilight. Data shows that shares in companies run by the first generation gain almost twice as much as those run by the fifth generation. 

Preserving power. All family businesses face choices about org charts and ownership structure. Shares are typically dual-class, allowing family members to hold outsize voting control – a perk they will often go to great lengths to retain (the Agnellis, for example, moved Exor’s headquarters from Milan to Amsterdam, where vote structures are more flexible). 

Bridget Kustin, an economic anthropologist at Oxford’s Saïd Business School, has identified three main approaches to family ownership: autocratic, bureaucratic and democratic (the examples are Tortoise’s).

  • Autocratic. Murdoch’s bid to cement the right-wing slant of Fox News and Lachlan’s position as executive was described by the case’s commissioner as a “carefully crafted charade” made in “bad faith”. But there’s an alternative view: investors buying Fox are also buying Lachlan,  who has been chair and CEO since 2019. A battle between the siblings over Fox’s ideological soul might hit the share price. For Claire Atkinson, the author of a forthcoming biography of Murdoch, Rupert’s controlling approach speaks to his own experience of succession: “I’m sure Rupert has it in his mind that when his father passed away, there was a frenzy of claims about who was getting what, and it ended up with Rupert losing some of his inheritance.  He doesn’t want a repeat of that.” Murdoch’s lawyer has said he will appeal the ruling.
  • Bureaucratic. Over the last few years Bernard Arnault, the 74-year-old CEO of LVMH, has been carefully appointing his five children to management positions across his €400 billion stable of luxury brands. In 2022, the French fashion king announced a change to the structure of LVMH’s controlling company to split power equally between his children and ban them from selling shares for three decades. But questions remain over whether Delphine, Arnault’s eldest, will replace him as CEO. 
  • Democratic. Kustin says she’s interviewed representatives of families with “thousands” of shareholding members. She describes one in particular as “a mini city state” with  sophisticated mechanisms to deal with planning, organization and equity. 

What’s more… In his annual letter to shareholders the revered investor Warren Buffett offered family businesses a simple piece of advice: “When your children are mature, have them read your will before you sign it,” he wrote. “You don’t want your children asking ‘Why?’… when you are no longer able to respond.”

As another episode in the Murdoch saga begins, it’s not just his children asking that question.


Thanks for reading. Please tell your friends to sign up and tell us what you think.


The post Ruins in the family appeared first on Tortoise.

Money flows to Reform UK thanks to Candy – and more from Musk could follow

Nigel Farage’s “startup” party Reform UK is attracting the attention of prospective mega-donors on a scale that could change the face of British politics.

So what? This is about Elon Musk, but not just Musk. This week the property tycoon and former Tory donor Nick Candy became the party’s treasurer, pledging £1 million of his own with plans to raise up to £40 million in total.

For what? Reform wants to freeze all “non-essential” immigration, leaving the European Convention on Human Rights if necessary. Other pledges in its 2024 campaign “contract” with voters included lower taxes, less business regulation and an end to net zero levies.

With what? Musk, with whom Candy has already started conversations, is reportedly considering a “f*** Starmer” donation of up to $100 million (£80 million). For context, Britain’s biggest non-union donors in the last parliament were:

  • Frank Hester and his company The Phoenix Partnership – £20 million to the Conservatives
  • Lord John Sainsbury – £10.2 million to the Conservatives
  • Gary Lubner – £5.5 million to Labour
  • Mohamed Mansour – £5.27 million to the Conservatives
  • Graham Edwards – £5.2 million to the Conservatives

Reform, which until July had no elected MPs, is a relative minnow, having raised £1.6 million of which £500,000 was from a business owned by the party’s deputy leader Richard Tice.

Value added. Farage has shown a talent for generating a lot of media attention with relatively little money, forcing the Brexit referendum and, ultimately, the UK’s departure from the EU. Now his party has

  • five MPs;
  • solid double-digit polling; and
  • its sights on 98 seats in which it came second in the 2024 election (in 89 of them to Labour).

A step change in Reform’s funding could give Farage an even more influential voice.

Ways to spend. Political parties can’t buy TV time in the UK, but they can buy eyeballs on social media, where well-crafted videos spread the word far more effectively. With more money Reform could also be expected to pay for Farage to travel the country, improve vetting procedures for prospective candidates and promote successful candidates with more sophistication than this year.

The next general election may not be until 2029 but there are local elections in May.

If Musk gave even a quarter of the rumoured £80 million sum, he would change the fortunes of the party – and the likely direction of the country – forever. And as things stand, there is nothing stopping the world’s richest person giving as much as he likes. 

Under UK law:

  • Individuals can donate if they are eligible to vote, even if they don’t live in the UK.
  • Donations can also be made through UK-listed companies – even those that don’t make a profit or have opaque funding.
  • Donations can also be made through unincorporated associations and opaque membership groups, which can be set up to advance almost any cause.
  • There is no cap on the total sum donated.

Even if there was a breach of the rules, the maximum fine that can be imposed by a weakened Electoral Commission is £20,000 – back-of-the-sofa change for Musk.



So fit a cap. Some campaigners argue for a cap of £10,000 a year for donations, as well as a rule that only resident UK citizens can donate to UK parties. 

Unlock Democracy wants only firms that are in profit and active in the UK to be allowed to donate. It argues that if the UK fails to reform rules on donations it will be “skewing power towards those with the deepest pockets, without any strengthening of the transparency mechanisms to hold them accountable”.

Is the government listening? In its manifesto, Labour promised to tighten the rules. Officials are examining options, but concrete proposals aren’t likely to be brought forward in the next year – by which time Reform UK could be the best-funded party in the country.

What’s more… At least some of that money could be from a man whose interest in British politics appears limited to what he reads on his own social media platform.



Thanks for reading. This article is part of our Daily Sensemaker, a free newsletter from Tortoise. Take once a day for greater clarity.

Click here to sign up and email sensemaker@tortoisemedia.com to tell us what you think.


Choose which Tortoise newsletters you receive


more from tortoise

The post Money flows to Reform UK thanks to Candy – and more from Musk could follow appeared first on Tortoise.

France is in a funk. So is much of Europe

Ten weeks ago Michel Barnier told French MPs a sword of Damocles was hanging over them that could push France “to the brink of the abyss”.

So what? The sword fell and so did Barnier’s government, leaving President Macron racing yesterday to form another one. His difficulties are the tip of an iceberg that could sink the European ship. 

Hyperbole? It may be needed. The EU in general and its Franco-German engine in particular need an urgent course correction.

  • France and Germany are coasting politically. Olaf Scholz’s coalition collapsed last month, so Europe’s two great liberal democracies are without functioning governments.
  • They’re coasting economically too – in recession (Germany) or flirting with it (France) while the US and China prepare to tear up what remains of the globalist playbook in pursuit of short-term growth.
  • In its own pursuit of growth, security and a coherent response to mass migration, the EU has questions but few convincing answers.


Francofunk. For seven years, Macron has been trying to persuade his country to live within its means. He has largely failed. This year’s Olympics and the reopening of Notre-Dame have shown what France can do when national pride is at stake, but the national balance sheet is another matter. 

  • France added €1 trillion to its national debt to fund Covid relief in 2020 and electricity subsidies when Russia invaded Ukraine two years later.
  • That debt now stands at 110 per cent of GDP, and the deficit is predicted to exceed 6 per cent this year.
  • Barnier’s plan to start paying these down with €40 billion in spending cuts and tax rises prompted a parliamentary rebellion from the left and right and the collapse of his administration.

En plus. Macron hasn’t helped himself politically by refusing to abandon his goal of raising the national retirement age to 64 even if it’s the right thing to do; nor by calling and losing a snap parliamentary election in July. That instability helped raise France’s cost of borrowing higher than Spain’s for the first time since 2008.

En fin. Macron has taken on a broad but unruly coalition of voters whom Sébastien Maillard of Chatham House characterises in the Sensemaker podcast as 

  • people who feel they’ve lost out from globalisation, inflation and the transition to green energy;
  • the “culturally insecure”, who “feel they don’t recognise themselves in their home country”; and
  • those who simply don’t like Macron’s style – “too top down, too vertical”.

Between them they have fought him to a standstill.

Bad timing. France has been left looking inward when it should be leading the EU response to US and Chinese threats to free trade and Russia’s assault on European security. 

France = Europe. Much of the paralysis that afflicts France afflicts the EU too.

  • The eurozone’s 0.8 per cent projected growth rate for 2024 won’t pay for the safety net the EU’s ageing citizens have come to expect, or the increased defence spending they need.
  • Nor will it fund the €800 billion investment gap identified by Mario Draghi, the former European Central Bank president, as a basic reason for slack European productivity.
  • Macron’s mission is to keep Marine Le Pen and her National Rally out of power, just as the EU’s is to stop its illiberal members (Hungary, Slovakia, potentially Romania) pulling it apart.

Cheer up. European start-ups raised more than $400 billion between 2015 and 2024 – more than ten times as much as in the previous decade. China will need EU trade as much as vice versa, says Charles Grant of the Centre for European Reform, especially if Trump starts closing off access to US markets. And Germany will get a centrist government of some sort by February, even if Scholz is not in charge.

But… nations. Eurosceptics and Europhiles alike agree the EU has a fundamental problem. As Timothy Garton Ash puts it: “The policies we need now are European, but the politics remain national.” The bloc needs solutions that transcend those politics, and the stakes are high if they’re not found. Nick Clegg, the former deputy prime minister and MEP, says the bloc has to reform or die.

What’s more… France is getting a reminder of the price of not reforming. The first major French production of Les Misérables in 44 years opened in Paris last week.



Thanks for reading. This article is part of our Daily Sensemaker, a free newsletter from Tortoise. Take once a day for greater clarity.

Click here to sign up and email sensemaker@tortoisemedia.com to tell us what you think.


Choose which Tortoise newsletters you receive


more from tortoise

The post France is in a funk. So is much of Europe appeared first on Tortoise.

Families flock to Syria’s prisons looking for released inmates

As the Assad regime relinquishes control of Syria, hundreds of people have been flooding to its prisons hoping to find their loved ones.

So what? Most Syrians know – or know of – someone jailed by their deposed dictator. A complex security apparatus that arrested, imprisoned, tortured and executed anyone suspected of disloyalty was key to maintaining regime control. It’s estimated that there may have been up to 150,000 people in Assad’s prisons at any given time.

  • People were often grabbed in the street by plainclothes police, and their families never informed as to their whereabouts.
  • A semi-official extortion racket evolved as a result, with families sometimes selling their homes in attempts to buy information about their loved ones.
  • Multiple overlapping security services operated their own prisons in most major cities. One of the most notorious, Sednaya in Damascus, held up to 20,000 people including women and children.

Syria’s security and prison industrial complex became a central fact of life under Assad – an instrument of terror but also a major employer, especially for members of Assad’s own Alawite sect. It was set up after the Second World War with help from German émigrés:

  • The Nazi. Alois Brunner, a senior SS officer and Adolf Eichmann’s right-hand man, sought refuge from Nazi-hunters in Syria in the 1950s. Living under an alias, he was employed as an adviser to the regime, helping to set up its security services and prisons. He later fell out of favour and ended his days in a prison basement.
  • The Stasi. In the 1960s and 1970s Syrian intelligence operatives were regular visitors to East Berlin. Stasi files show they received equipment and instruction in interrogation techniques; Stasi employees noted the extreme brutality of their apprentices.

By the 1980s Amnesty International had documented the systematic use by Syrian security forces of 35 torture techniques. Prisoners were often kept in cells so overcrowded they had to take it in turns to sit down, and were forced to rape or murder one another or be killed themselves.

Unimaginable suffering. As prisoners emerge from their cells, the medieval barbarity of these institutions is coming into focus. Some freed inmates are so traumatised and damaged by torture that they are unable to say who they are or where they come from.

The prisoners. Those who suffered incarceration include

  • Adnan Qassar, imprisoned for 21 years after beating President Assad’s brother, Bassel, in an equestrian event.
  • Raghid al-Tatari, imprisoned for 43 years after refusing orders to bomb the city of Hama in the early 1980s.
  • Ali Hassan al-Ali, who vanished from a checkpoint when he was 18. He emerged days ago from Sedanya prison aged 57.
  • Dr Rania al-Abbasi, a chess champion arrested in 2013 in Damascus with her six children, all teenagers or younger. They are still missing.


Mass murder. According to the Human Rights Data Analysis Group, at least 17,723 people were killed in government custody from the start of the uprising in March 2011 to December 2015 – an average of 300 deaths each month. There are no figures for subsequent years but there is no reason to believe the killings stopped.

In 2021 a government grave digger testified in a court in Germany, describing nightly deliveries by refrigerated meat trucks of hundreds of bodies, including women, children and the elderly. He said he helped bury them in mass pits on the outskirts of Damascus. These have yet to be dug up.

The employees. If there were tens of thousands of prisoners, then there were thousands of workers involved in maintaining the prisons. So far the Syrian rebels, Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS), have arrested some senior prison staff and vowed to pursue those responsible for torture. But most have been allowed to flee in exchange for opening the prison gates.

What’s more… The Assad regime kept Soviet-style records, meaning almost every death will have been documented (even if in some cases the cause of death will be listed as the heart stopping). So far HTS has prevented government buildings being looted – a vital step towards preservation of documents, which will be essential if those responsible for Assad’s reign of terror are ever to be held to account.



Thanks for reading. This article is part of our Daily Sensemaker, a free newsletter from Tortoise. Take once a day for greater clarity.

Click here to sign up and email sensemaker@tortoisemedia.com to tell us what you think.


Choose which Tortoise newsletters you receive


more from tortoise

The post Families flock to Syria’s prisons looking for released inmates appeared first on Tortoise.

Romania re-runs its election after Moscow TikTok interference

Yesterday Romanians should have been voting in the country’s presidential election runoff between far-right populist Calin Georgescu and liberal Elena Lasconi. Instead police were busy arresting dozens of armed men who were travelling to the capital Bucharest to join protests, after the country’s top court cancelled the vote following allegations of Russian interference via social media. The government declassified documents last week alleging that Moscow used 25,000 TikTok accounts to propel Georgescu to victory and arranged for some influencers to be paid in violation of election laws. TikTok said on Friday it had recently removed three “covert influence networks” in Romania. The court’s decision makes Romania the first democracy to cancel an election over alleged Russian meddling, but it has divided the country – though not the presidential candidates. Both have criticised the court’s decision.

The post Romania re-runs its election after Moscow TikTok interference appeared first on Tortoise.

Tortoise Media agrees purchase of The Observer

Tortoise Media is pleased to announce that its offer to buy The Observer newspaper has been approved by Guardian Media Group (GMG), and its owner the Scott Trust.

As part of the agreement, the Scott Trust will take a minority stake in Tortoise Media and a representative will join both the Tortoise company board, chaired by President Obama’s ambassador to the UK, Matthew Barzun, and the editorial board, chaired by former Financial Times editor Sir Richard Lambert.

Tortoise has raised £25m in funding to invest in the renewal of The Observer, the world’s oldest Sunday newspaper, founded in 1791.

Tortoise and The Observer will combine into one newsroom, bringing together the digital-startup’s expertise in podcast story-telling, investigations and data journalism with the paper’s extraordinary strengths in reporting, arts reviews, ideas and, of course, food. The investment will see the creation of at least a dozen new roles for staff reporters and the near doubling of the editorial budget.

Tortoise approached The Guardian earlier this year with a proposal to acquire the Sunday paper with a long-term commitment to maintaining it in print on a Sunday and a plan to build it into a digital brand. The Observer, which was bought by The Guardian in 1993, is currently a print-only title in the UK, which publishes its journalism on The Guardian website.

It is expected the deal will be completed and signed in the coming days. Under the terms of the deal, the investors have committed to the principle of safeguarding journalistic freedom and editorial independence. They include This Day, Gary Lubner’s philanthropic foundation, and Standard Investments, the related investment platform of the global industrial company Standard Industries.

James Harding, editor and founder of Tortoise, said: “We are honoured and excited at the prospect of working together to renew The Observer, a name that represents the best of liberal, pioneering journalism. We admire its temperament, both tolerant and humane. We love its appetite for the arts and, of course, food. We promise its readers we will do all we can to live up to its history as a defender of human dignity and to give it a new lease of life as a powerful, progressive voice in the world.”

Matthew Barzun, chair and founder of Tortoise, said: “This process revealed the enormous regard and passionate connection so many have to the world’s oldest Sunday newspaper. I am deeply appreciative of our investor partners, including the Scott Trust, all of whom expect the highest quality independent journalism. We are filled with an awesome sense of responsibility as we become a part of its long story and participants in sharing the stories it will long keep telling.”

Richard Lambert, chair of the editorial board, said: “The Observer matters. In a noisy marketplace, it has an independent and progressive voice, covering ideas and stories that don’t get proper attention elsewhere. Its editorial comments are shaped by its journalists rather than by other interests. These values must be supported, and I’m keen to do anything I can to help.”

Emma Sullivan, Managing Director of Tortoise, said: “The whole team at Tortoise is excited about bringing together our newsrooms. We recognise the scale of the challenge in creating something whole and brilliant out of two different cultures and backgrounds, but we’ll approach the job optimistically and respectfully and, together with our new colleagues from The Observer, we’re absolutely confident that we can create something much greater than the sum of its parts”.


more from tortoise

The post Tortoise Media agrees purchase of The Observer appeared first on Tortoise.

Crypto and the new pink Jaguar have something in common

This week Jaguar launched a hot pink prototype in Miami and the price of bitcoin passed $100,000 for the first time. It has more than doubled since Donald Trump’s re-election.

So what? Cryptocurrencies are roaring back from near-death. Jaguar is trying to. Both have achieved cut-through in a world of too much everything. 

Having been written off by everyone except die-hards two years ago, crypto is now 

  • embraced by Wall Street;
  • enriching investors;
  • supporting a wave of “memecoins” that usually sink without trace but can conjure large fortunes from thin air; and
  • in the words of Joshua Oliver, “making life easier for criminals”.


The cost of dull. Cryptocoins and memecoins depend on hype and hope to appreciate. Dogecoin – an Elon Musk favourite set up as a joke – has risen even faster in value than bitcoin since the US election, in anticipation of a crypto-friendly presidency.

Their bull run coincides not just with the new Jaguar but also with the sale of a banana at Sotheby’s for $6.2 million (to a crypto multimillionaire). This may not be by chance.

At a time of bland content oversupply “there is a cost to dull”, says Laurence Green, a director at the Institute of Practitioners in Advertising.

“People are chasing excitement, simply because there is so much of everything and most of it is unremarkable. Whether it’s the banana or a meme or a pink Jag, the amount you have to spend to get people’s attention is so, so much less than if you put out something dull.”

The price of excitement. The Jaguar, or something like it, will sell for more than £100,000 – somewhere between one and two bitcoin. That would be easy for Laszlo Hanyecz, a Florida programmer, if he’d kept any of the 10,000 bitcoin he spent on two pizzas in the first recorded bitcoin transaction in 2010. He didn’t, but they would be worth $1 billion now. 

At its current price Bitcoin’s market cap is over $2 trillion. 

There are at least three factors behind its latest surge:

  1. Trump’s conversion. He once called crypto a scam but now says the US needs to lead the world in its adoption.
  2. His election campaign, in which crypto enthusiasts invested about $135 million, contributing to ‘1’ above.
  3. Most importantly, the decision by the US Securities and Exchange Commission in January this year to allow exchange-traded funds (EFTs) based on cryptocurrencies. 

Crypto EFTs submit to precisely the sort of regulation cryptocurrencies were designed to avoid, but they earn fees for banks and give institutional and retail investors exposure to big upswings while mitigating risk. 

More than $100 billion has poured into these funds this year.

Irrational exuberance. There is no such institutional backing for memecoins, which are entirely unregulated, based on passing internet fads and can be set up by anyone with a laptop. Between 20,000 and 40,000 are created each year. A tiny proportion catch fire and make real money for those who get in and out fast. As of Wednesday

  • BONK, based on a cartoon dog, was worth $3 billion;
  • CHILLGUY, boosted by the YouTuber Mr Beast, was worth $466 million; and
  • PEPE, based on a cartoon frog, was worth $8.2 billion, which as the FT noted was more than Sainsbury’s market cap.

There is no memecoin based on the pink Jaguar – yet – but there is one based on the $6.2 million banana. Like the original artwork, it’s called Comedian. If that feels appropriate in an age of monetised ephemera, be assured there’s also a memecoin based on Trump, called MAGA.

What’s more… MAGA wasn’t worth much until a $30 million investment in it by Justin Sun, buyer of the original Comedian banana. He has since been placed under investigation by the SEC, and eaten the banana.



Thanks for reading. This article is part of our Daily Sensemaker, a free newsletter from Tortoise. Take once a day for greater clarity.

Click here to sign up and email sensemaker@tortoisemedia.com to tell us what you think.


Choose which Tortoise newsletters you receive


more from tortoise

The post Crypto and the new pink Jaguar have something in common appeared first on Tortoise.

China adds love lessons to student timetable

China is urging its colleges and universities to introduce lessons on love to promote positive views of marriage and starting a family as it looks to reverse its declining population. Reuters reports that China Population News, a state-run publication, found that 57 per cent of college students said they did not want to fall in love, citing difficulties balancing time between their studies and relationships. The publication said university students had a “vague understanding of emotional relationships”, and the new measures would help create a “positive marriage and childbearing cultural atmosphere”. China’s population is ageing and its population is declining, a demographic trend that will strain government spending. To combat this, Chinese authorities have launched various strategies, including a proposal to make marriage easier and divorce harder. But experts are sceptical about whether they will resonate with China’s youth.

The post China adds love lessons to student timetable appeared first on Tortoise.

South Korea bounces back from martial law in six short hours

In the space of six hours last night, South Korea experienced a declaration of martial law, the arrival of military helicopters on the roof of its parliament, a vote to reverse the declaration and a climb-down by the president as dawn broke over Seoul.

Yoon Suk Yeol, a former prosecutor, now faces urgent calls to resign or face impeachment. Mired in scandal and with historically low approval ratings, he stunned his country with the announcement of a military takeover shortly before midnight.

If taken seriously it would have banned “fake news” and outlawed opposition politics in defence against North Korean infiltrators and “anti-state elements”.

Instead, MPs voted overwhelmingly against and South Korea’s relatively young democracy held firm. Yoon’s true motive seems to have been a bitter row with the opposition for voting down his budget.

The post South Korea bounces back from martial law in six short hours appeared first on Tortoise.

Syria’s rebels say Assad forces ‘melted away’

Syrian rebels’ surprise advance on Aleppo was so successful because, they say, President Assad’s forces just “melted away”.

So what? The Syrian army may regroup but so far there is little sign of that.

  • That doesn’t mean Assad is about to relinquish power.
  • It does mean he is acutely vulnerable without the backing of Iran and Russia. 

Since 2020 most of the world has considered the Syrian war over or in abeyance. But the Middle East is so interconnected that the ripples spreading out from the Hamas attack on Israel on October 7th 2023 had to reach Syria eventually, and now they have.  

Why now? While the world’s attention was focused on Gaza, the rebels saw an opportunity.  Assad has held onto power only because of Russian air support and Iranian-backed militias including Hezbollah. But…

  • Over the last year the Lebanese militia has been distracted by the war with Israel. 
  • It’s likely that rebel commanders believed the ceasefire with Israel meant Hezbollah might return to help Assad on the frontlines.
  • A window of opportunity was therefore closing; the rebels attacked the day the ceasefire came into force. 


Which rebels? The most powerful faction, Hay’at Tahrir al’Shams, is a coalition of jihadist groups led by Syrian-born Abu Mohammed Al Jolani. He fought coalition forces during the Western occupation of Iraq, returning to Syria in 2011 to join the effort to overthrow the Assad regime and replace it with a hardline Sharia state. Jolani’s jihadist faction in the Syrian civil war, Jahbat Al Nusra, pledged allegiance to Al Qaeda and quickly attracted fighters from around the world including from the UK. 

Jihadist-light. In 2016 Jolani broke ties with Al Qaeda and merged with five more jihadist groups to form Ha’yat Tahrir al Shams. HTS now controls around four million people in Idlib province. It still cleaves to fundamentalist Salafi principles but has gone to great lengths to rebrand itself, in one expert’s phrase, as “jihadist-light”.

Unlike most jihadist leaders Jolani, now in his early 40s, is media friendly.

  • He gives interviews in which he’s insisted on his respect for the sanctity of human life and the protection of minorities.
  • HTS has a press office and a civilian government running a roster of ministries overseeing public services.
  • That said, under HTS governance women’s rights have been severely restricted, and there are reports of journalists and pro-democracy activists being arrested and in some cases tortured.

The lesser of two evils. Even so, more Syrians have fled from Assad-controlled parts of the country to rebel-held areas than the other way around. Why? 

  • Assad’s forces and allies have been responsible for far more civilian killings than all the jihadist groups in Syria combined.
  • There have been reports of mass graves on the outskirts of Damascus.
  • And it’s estimated that at least 150,000 people are still being held and tortured in Assad’s prisons. 

Russia in or out? Since the rebel offensive began last week there have been credible reports that Russian troops and diplomats have been fleeing Damascus. Even so…

  • In public at least, Moscow insists it will continue to back Assad.
  • In the last 24 hours Russian planes have launched a fresh wave of bombings on Idlib.

Facts on the ground. It won’t be easy for Assad to win back territory. HTS has used the last four years to develop its armed forces, opening a military academy and equipping itself with armed drones which it has been using to take out senior Syrian commanders. 

Threats in the air. In the past when Assad has been squeezed militarily he has resorted to chemical weapons, killing hundreds of civilians. Analysts don’t rule out more of the same – chemical weapons drive out people without destroying infrastructure. But a return to such tactics would reignite the anger of Arab populations around the world and make it difficult for governments to do business with him

What’s more…  Assad has had some success persuading neighbouring states including Saudi Arabia that he has won the war and should no longer be treated as a pariah. He won’t want to be sent back into the cold.



Thanks for reading. This article is part of our Daily Sensemaker, a free newsletter from Tortoise. Take once a day for greater clarity.

Click here to sign up and email sensemaker@tortoisemedia.com to tell us what you think.


Choose which Tortoise newsletters you receive


more from tortoise

The post Syria’s rebels say Assad forces ‘melted away’ appeared first on Tortoise.

Trump proposes family felon as US ambassador to France

They don’t take kindly to tax evasion in France, but now they’ll have to make nice with a convicted tax evader and jailbird whom Donald Trump has proposed as US ambassador to Paris.

Charles Kushner is also Trump’s son-in-law’s father and “a tremendous business leader, philanthropist and dealmaker,” the next president claimed on Truth Social.

The first holder of the Paris job, Benjamin Franklin, was a great thinker who took up vegetarianism to save money for books.

Kushner served two years in federal prison for witness tampering and illegal campaign contributions (as well as tax fraud). Trump later gave him a presidential pardon, so Kushner owes him.

It is possible but rare for a host country to decline to approve another country’s ambassadorial nomination. Test case?

The post Trump proposes family felon as US ambassador to France appeared first on Tortoise.

Britain’s big job hunt

Keir Starmer says Britain “simply isn’t working” and has launched welfare reforms aimed at getting two million of the country’s nine million economically inactive people back into work.

So what? Growth won’t happen without them. But incentivising the unemployed and long-term sick to find a job is only half the battle. Ultimately it’s employers who decide whether to hire someone who has been out of work for a while – and right now they’re feeling pinched. 

  • Nearly half of UK businesses surveyed by the CBI say that they plan to reduce rather than increase their headcount due to tax rises in the budget. 
  • Bloomberg analysis says the hike to employer National Insurance could cost 130,000 jobs.

Sick notes. Starmer has at least identified a metastasizing problem: Britain is struggling with sickness. 

By the numbers:

1 in 15 – people of working age now off work owing to long-term illness, a rate 69 per cent higher than Germany’s and more than twice Italy’s.

£101 billion – estimated cost of sickness benefits by the end of this parliament.

£4,320 – increase in annual Universal Credit if a claimant is long-term sick with no work requirements.

Long Covid and long waiting lists have clearly contributed to a rise in sickness claims, but experts also say there’s a “structural incentive” to claim the benefits that require a diagnosis and fewer forms. 

First steps. Getting two million people back into work could take a decade, but the “Get Britain Working” whitepaper is a sorely needed start. Proposals include:

  • rebranding and expanding job centres;
  • a “Youth Guarantee” offering every 18 to 21-year-old in England an apprenticeship, training or help to find a job;
  • providing cash for the North East and Yorkshire to stop people leaving work because of ill health; 
  • expanding mental-health support and efforts to tackle obesity; and
  • a review of what employers are doing to promote health and inclusive workplaces.

Margaret Casely-Hayford, former Chancellor of the University of Coventry and non-executive director at the Co-op Group, welcomed the package but said that “resources will be stretched very thinly” and “important detail is missing”, particularly regarding

  • how the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) will partner with skills and education bodies;
  • how the Apprenticeship Levy will be reformed; and
  • whether panels will be set up to gauge sentiment for the reforms among young and disabled people.

Poor from giving. DWP secretary Liz Kendall’s target of 80 per cent employment won’t be met through these measures alone. Employers have to be on board. But a rise in the minimum wage and a looming package of employee rights (which the CBI chair calls an “adventure playground for lawyers”) have made them more hesitant to hire.

Meanwhile, pain from the NI increase is being felt across sectors. Some, including social care and charities, have tried to argue for an exemption – but the chancellor has made it clear she’s not for turning.

“The National Insurance increase will cost us a considerable sum of money,” says Paul Taylor, Director of Finance at NSPCC. “These crucial funds, which would have been spent supporting babies, children and young people, will now have to go directly to the Treasury instead. We face a huge challenge just to stand still.”

What’s more… Employers may squawk that the budget will affect hiring in the short term, but the reality is many sectors – especially hospitality, construction and agriculture – are still facing worker shortages. Starmer’s choice is simple: get Britain working or continue relying on high net migration to fuel the economy.


Thanks for reading. Please tell your friends to sign up and tell us what you think.


The post Britain’s big job hunt appeared first on Tortoise.

Europe has to defend itself

In the past week Nato has announced a new scheme for channeling aid to Ukraine that doesn’t involve the US, and Poland’s defence minister has said Europe must think about its own security “above all”. 

So what? He’s right. Trump’s re-election is forcing Europe – in a way that even the invasion of Ukraine did not – to take full responsibility for its own security for the first time since World War Two.

  • That will require a step change in European production of artillery, tanks and ships.
  • That in turn will require European Nato members to double defence spending to 3 or 4 per cent of GDP.
  • Shared security needs give the UK an opening to rebuild its relationship with Europe.
  • But meeting those needs could take ten years.

Such are the views of experts and think tanks scrambling to reassess Europe’s security architecture in light of America’s choice of an isolationist as president.



Ten years is too long. Russia is already waging a hybrid war on Europe. Acts of violence and sabotage, violations of air space and constant propaganda and disinformation are Russia’s weapons in this war. The former Dutch defence minister Kajsa Ollongren says: “If Ukraine itself is not a reason enough for Europeans to act – then the fact that we are already under attack should be a reason to act”. 

European intelligence agencies believe those acts of violence may include

  • the recent crash of a DHL cargo plane in Vilnius;
  • the dispatch of two incendiary devices on DHL planes flying to the US and Canada; and 
  • the cutting of two under-sea fibre-optic cables in the Baltic by a Chinese ship sailing from a Russian port.

Asymmetric numbers. Russia has nearly twice as many fast jets and naval vessels as Germany, France and the UK combined, and more than three times as many tanks and infantry fighting vehicles. It is producing roughly three times as many artillery shells per year as the entire EU at one tenth the cost per shell (and has received more in addition from North Korea than Ukraine has received from Europe).

The central question. Would Russia ever use this arsenal to mount a conventional attack on a Nato member?

Answers, various. In April the inspector general of the German army, Carsten Breuer, said Putin would be ready to attack Nato within five to seven years. Norbert Röttgen, a former chair of the Bundestag’s foreign affairs committee, writes that “without strong defences standing in his way, Putin will have no reason to stop at Ukraine”.

This we know. The Baltic states have argued for years that it’s complacent to believe Putin would be deterred by Nato’s Article 5 collective defence guarantee if he thought the alliance lacked the will to enforce it – as he will if Trump equivocates in his support. And Putin has ridiculed rumours of an impending Russian invasion before – in February 2022. 

What to do? Build up Europe’s defence capabilities within Nato even without US support. Rather than try to build a new European structure, make use of Nato’s integrated command structure, procurement processes and common funding, says Ivo Daalder, a former US ambassador to the alliance.

In addition to the extra spending and defence production this will require, Nato’s European members will need to

  • fill gaps in Europe’s air lift, intelligence and surveillance, and missile defence capabilities; and 
  • treat security as an emergency, thinking of the US and Canada as a “bonus but not a gift”.

The British problem. The UK’s is the only non-US nuclear deterrent in Nato and its armed forces are among the most advanced in Europe – but 

  • they’re still so depleted after decades of cuts that the respected academic Robert Johnson has said “they cannot defend the British homelands properly”; and
  • outside the EU single market there are limits to what Britain can contribute to an integrated European rearmament plan.

But even without the UK, the EU’s combined GDP is ten times Russia’s.
What’s more… With the addition of Sweden and Finland as members, Nato is bigger than before the war.



Thanks for reading. This article is part of our Daily Sensemaker, a free newsletter from Tortoise. Take once a day for greater clarity.

Click here to sign up and email sensemaker@tortoisemedia.com to tell us what you think.


Choose which Tortoise newsletters you receive


more from tortoise

The post Europe has to defend itself appeared first on Tortoise.

Peer uses Kremlin talking points and considers Russian ambassador a “nice chap”

A peer who has repeatedly echoed Kremlin talking points in the House of Lords has joined a new parliamentary group formed to fight “disinformation in the public discourse”.

Last week Lord Balfe was named vice chair of the new Fair Elections APPG, a cross-party group that also seeks to tackle “dark money and undemocratic influence” in UK politics.

A Tortoise analysis of Balfe’s statements in the upper chamber shows the Conservative peer has mirrored arguments made by Russian president Vladimir Putin and foreign minister Sergey Lavrov at least a dozen times since Crimea was invaded in 2014.

cards visualization

While describing himself as “bitterly disappointed that [Russia’s] categorical denials of any intention to invade Ukraine have been torn up,” Balfe has also: 

  • said the war was “undoubtedly illegal, but it was not unprovoked”, and urged colleagues to “maybe understand the context in which it happened”;
  • blamed the invasion on Ukrainian “provocation”, for example by attempting to “outlaw” the Russian language in Crimea;
  • claimed Ukraine was the “creation” of Winston Churchill and Joseph Stalin and that locals believe they are Russian; and
  • argued against NATO expansion, the use of Storm Shadow missiles and the use of sanctions imposed on Russians.

Why this story?

Drawing on thousands of pages of publicly available information, Tortoise has created the Peer Review, an interactive tool to help the public better understand how the 830 members of the House of Lords spend their time, what interests they represent, and whether they’re fulfilling their constitutional role of advising on policy and holding government to account.

This story is one of a series we’re publishing over the next two weeks to illuminate the workings of an upper chamber that exists to serve a democracy but isn’t democratic; a chamber that Labour governments have repeatedly – but with limited success – tried to reform. The House of Lords is 1,000 years old. It’s about time we knew what made it tick.

See the full series.

He has tabled multiple questions on the conflict, including: 

  • seeking an estimate of British fatalities in the Russia-Ukraine war
  • challenging the UK government’s decision to revoke the broadcast licence for RT, formerly Russia Today 
  • questioning the UK’s approach to sanctions, and 
  • urging the government to encourage “peace talks” between Russia and Ukraine. 

Last month, Balfe told fellow peers that Andrey Kelin, the Russian ambassador to the UK who has been banned from the parliamentary estate, was a “nice chap”, about whom he had “warm words to say”. 

Balfe was complaining about a Sunday Times report revealing that he and fellow peer Lord Skidelsky had attended Kelin’s Russia Day celebrations last June. He argued: “What is one person’s reputational damage is another person’s legitimate political expression of belief.”  

He has also frequently given interviews to Russian news outlets such as TASS and Izvestia, telling the former: “President Putin is right, of course. The easiest way to end the ongoing conflict is to stop the proxy war waged by Western powers, especially the United States, by ceasing to arm Ukraine.” 

Contacted by Tortoise, Balfe accepted that he, President Putin and Mr Lavrov had said “similar things”. He called Ukraine “a mess of a country” and repeated his view of Ambassador Kelin as “a nice chap”, adding that Kelin would be “welcome in my kitchen”. (The ambassador has been banned from the parliamentary estate since 2022.)

Balfe said he visited Ukraine several times between 1999 and 2014, learning about what he called the internal dynamics of the country from former President Leonid Kuchma. He said he gave up visiting after another former president, Viktor Yanukovych, was “hounded out of office [as] its days as one country were clearly numbered”. 

Kuchma is closely associated with the retreat of democracy and the spread of corruption and censorship in Ukraine in the late 1990s. Yanukovych was a staunch Kremlin ally who was removed from office by the Ukrainian parliament and fled to Russia after the Euromaidan protests of 2014.

A visual guide to one of the world’s largest unelected chambers

The post Peer uses Kremlin talking points and considers Russian ambassador a “nice chap” appeared first on Tortoise.

Music keeps making more money – but artists aren’t seeing it

This is a financial boom time for music – though many musicians may not feel like it is.

A new report from the economist Will Page found that the global value of music copyright (including sales, licensing and streaming revenues) was a gigantic $45.5 billion last year.

That’s $20 billion more than music made ten years ago, and nearly $12 billion more than global box office revenues at cinemas in 2023. Cinema used to trounce music on this metric, but since Covid, the tides have turned.

Music labels hoovered up roughly 63 per cent of that $45.5 billion, while only the biggest acts are benefitting from an arena music boom.

Smaller established artists are turning to other revenue streams, including OnlyFans, to make touring work, and independent live music venues are shutting at alarming rates.

The path to a decent living for new artists is wearier than ever, save for a viral TikTok song or pre-existing connections to springboard onto the charts. Welcome to the machine.

The post Music keeps making more money – but artists aren’t seeing it appeared first on Tortoise.

Algerian author Kamel Daoud accused of stealing war survivor’s story

Kamel Daoud is the first Algerian author to win France’s most prestigious literary award, the Prix Goncourt.

But he faces two legal complaints alleging that his winning novel, Houris, tells someone’s real story without consent and allegedly violates medical confidentiality; and that he learned of it through his wife, who is also the survivor’s psychiatrist.

The novel depicts a young woman who loses her voice after an Islamist cuts her throat during Algeria’s civil war in the 1990s. Saada Arbane told Algerian TV that the book mirrors traumatic experiences that she shared in psychiatry sessions with the author’s wife, Aicha Dahdouh.

These include details of her assault, her injuries, the tube she now uses to speak, her tattoos and her relationship with her mother.

In Algeria, the couple is accused of violating medical confidentiality and breaching the law on national reconciliation, which bans all publications on the civil war.

They haven’t commented yet, but Daoud’s publisher claims the novel’s plot and characters are “purely fictitious”.

The post Algerian author Kamel Daoud accused of stealing war survivor’s story appeared first on Tortoise.

Education expert seems to forget the rules

A former education secretary has spoken dozens of times in the House of Lords without declaring his interest as chairman of a chain of technical colleges. 

Lord Baker, who served in Conservative governments under Margaret Thatcher and John Major, co-founded the Baker Dearing Trust, a charity which operates 44 university technical colleges (UTCs), a type of secondary school.

This unpaid role is listed on his register of interests, but Baker frequently fails to mention it during debates in the House of Lords, including when discussing new laws. 

Why this story?

Drawing on thousands of pages of publicly available information, Tortoise has created the Peer Review, an interactive tool to help the public better understand how the 830 members of the House of Lords spend their time, what interests they represent, and whether they’re fulfilling their constitutional role of advising on policy and holding government to account.

This story is one of a series we’re publishing over the next two weeks to illuminate the workings of an upper chamber that exists to serve a democracy but isn’t democratic; a chamber that Labour governments have repeatedly – but with limited success – tried to reform. The House of Lords is 1,000 years old. It’s about time we knew what made it tick.

See the full series.

Since December 2019, Baker has spoken at least 68 times, mainly on educational matters. Around 30 of those interventions were on occasions when his interest was directly relevant, and another 20 on educational issues more broadly, but he has only declared an interest seven times, and not at all since June 2021. 

Baker is now 90 and the Baker Dearing Trust, founded 15 years ago, is not for profit. There is no suggestion of Baker failing to declare his role at the charity for reasons of personal interest. However, one fellow peer told Tortoise that while Baker was knowledgeable and experienced on the education sector, his failure to declare his involvement could be seen as a potential breach of the rules.

The HoL code of conduct states that members should “declare when speaking in the House, or communicating with ministers or public servants, any interest which is a relevant interest in the context of the debate or the matter under discussion… Relevant interests include both financial and non-financial interests.”

Baker did not respond to requests for a comment. 

A visual guide to one of the world’s largest unelected chambers

The post Education expert seems to forget the rules appeared first on Tortoise.

Mahashmashana, Father John Misty

The title for the sixth album from Josh Tillman, aka Father John Misty, is very much on-brand for the poster boy of soft rock. Mahashmashana is an anglicisation of the Sanskrit word for the “great cremation ground” encountered before death, symbolising the cycle of life. You may eye-roll at a Western musician choosing such a title. But, frustratingly, it is the perfect word to embody the eight-track album. Mahashmashana’s 50 minutes pick you up, wrap you in soaring orchestral arrangements effused with soft-jazz melodies and deposit you at the end ready to start the journey all over again. With tongue firmly in cheek, this could be Tillman’s best flexing of his lyrical muscles yet. As he croons, he stabs at the ashtray like it might give up the truth. The only problem with Mahashmashana? You can’t avoid sounding like a twit recommending it. Although you can almost hear Tillman smirking at the thought.

The post Mahashmashana, Father John Misty appeared first on Tortoise.

Disapeering act: some peers hide foreign earnings by going on leave

The number of peers on a formal leave of absence from parliament jumped dramatically after new rules were introduced requiring them to declare income from foreign states. 

So what? This is about who pays peers, and what they’re paid for. 

  • Taking a leave of absence is open to misuse as a way round the rules on foreign income disclosure.
  • It’s a loophole. This is not what absences were meant for.
  • Their abuse by a minority of peers has prompted others to worry about the chamber being used as “a private members’ club”.

Absent with leave. Lords may take a leave of absence without giving a reason as long as they state they have “a reasonable expectation” that they will eventually return and be able to take part in parliamentary proceedings. Although there are no fixed rules on the circumstances in which a peer may take leave, suggested reasons include

  • medical treatment;
  • to care for a family member; and 
  • to take up a diplomatic or “other role of uncertain duration”.

While on leave peers can’t take part in parliamentary proceedings but may keep their titles, use House of Lords facilities and entertain up to six guests on the parliamentary estate.

Money. They’re also exempt from having to declare their interests. 

Time. The scheme is meant to be for temporary periods, and many who use it do so for the reasons for which it was set up. 

Change. But there are growing concerns about possible misuse of the system since the change of disclosure rules in December 2021, when peers had to start declaring income from foreign states or state-owned entities. 

In three months the number of peers taking leaves of absence jumped 48 per cent. It hovered at that level until parliament was dissolved for the general election this spring. 

  • December 2019 – 4
  • December 2021 – 23 
  • April 2022 – 34 
  • July 2023 – 38 
  • May 2024 – 31 
  • Now – 21 

In July, the senior deputy speaker told peers 18 colleagues had been on leave for at least two years – far longer than the measure is intended for. 

Included among those who have taken a leave of absence in the last five years are

  • at least four peers who have worked or are still working for Russians or Russian entities;
  • at least six peers who have worked or are still working other foreign states including China and Kazakhstan; and
  • at least four peers who are or were under investigation for standards breaches.  

Some of those who took a leave of absence while working overseas include

  • Lord Neuberger, while working for the Hong Kong Final Court of Appeal;
  • Lord Mance, while working for the Astana International Financial Centre Court in Kazakhstan;
  • Lord Livermore, now Financial Secretary to the Treasury, while working for McKinsey;
  • Lord (Peter) Goldsmith, a lawyer who has “personally provided” services to the Russian Federation;  
  • Lord Davies, who also works for Fridman’s L1 Group, and was simultaneously the prime minister’s trade envoy to Sri Lanka; and
  • Lord Barker, who has been on a leave of absence since 2019, including a period when he served as chairman of Oleg Deripaska’s En+ Group.


Others have taken leaves of absence during or shortly after investigations by the parliamentary commissioner for standards. These include

  • Michelle Mone, currently under investigation over Covid PPE contracts agreed through the VIP fast lane;
  • Lord Barwell, who was previously found to have breached the members’ code of conduct for not having declared his clients; and 
  • Lord Geidt, Boris Johnson’s former ethics adviser, who failed to declare he was being paid by a satellite company during a meeting with the Ministry of Defence. 

Access all areas. Active peers have repeatedly spoken out against colleagues for their approach to the system, and called for it to be reformed. 

Labour peer Lord Mann has called for an official inquiry to address this “loophole”, which is already being looked at as part of a wider review of peers’ code of conduct. 

“It should be that you either take it or leave it, either do the job or don’t,” he told Tortoise. The House of Lords was being treated as “a private members’ club,” Mann said. “That’s its weakness, but it’s part of the culture – it’s absurd that you can be on a leave of absence and still have access.”

Last year the Conservative peer Lord Cormack said there were “big question marks” over some individuals’ use of the system, while Labour’s Lord Foulkes said it was being “exploited in an unfortunate way”. 

Last month Lord Kirkhope of Harrogate called for a change to the system, saying the leave of absence provisions were being abused.

Not everyone agrees. Baroness Noakes recently said she “very much” regretted the new rules, precisely because they had caused several peers to take a leave of absence. 

What’s more… Noakes, a former president of the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales, said of the rules: “Those of us who had careers in professions that regard client confidentiality as sacrosanct were frankly appalled by them.” 



Thanks for reading. This article is part of our Daily Sensemaker, a free newsletter from Tortoise. Take once a day for greater clarity.

Click here to sign up and email sensemaker@tortoisemedia.com to tell us what you think.


Choose which Tortoise newsletters you receive


more from tortoise

The post Disapeering act: some peers hide foreign earnings by going on leave appeared first on Tortoise.

❌