❌

Normal view

There are new articles available, click to refresh the page.
Yesterday — 21 November 2026Main stream

Appreciative Inquiry

20 November 2026 at 10:02

Appreciative Inquiry

Back when I was coaching teachers, I think it’s safe to say we went through a period when positive feedback was seen as soft, fluffy and ineffective for the purposes of improving the quality of teaching. Instead, the order of the day was direct, often directive, constructive feedback, aimed at identifying teachers’ blind spots and changing their practice for the better. The core underlying assumption seemed to be “there’s always something they can do better.”

At this time, I had a colleague who went against the grain. She was brought in to observe a teacher who was very new but had already been flagged as ‘underperforming’ and resistant to feedback, and she visited their school and watched them teach. The expectations could not have been clearer: my colleague was meant to go in, identify clear areas for development and put together a clear action plan (SMART goals, anyone?) for how that teacher could improve. However, she walked into that lesson and saw something very different. She saw a teacher who, yes, was undoubtedly struggling. But she also saw something far more important: a teacher who was still there, turning up, trying every day to improve. A teacher who had a challenging class, but who had already learned every one of their students’ names, who had carefully labelled each drawer in the classroom with pictures to help those who were not yet reading, and who had planned a lesson that tried to engage with topics relevant to the class’s interests. A teacher who, despite being sworn at in their lesson, kept their composure and continued to speak to every child with respect and kindness.

So when it came to sharing the feedback, my colleague put the carefully planned feedback proformas, and the instructions to devote the time to direct instruction and coaching, to one side. Instead, she relayed back to the teacher everything she had seen that was good, in an appreciative way. She didn’t lie about the lesson. She didn’t pretend it had all gone well. But she chose, on purpose, to notice and give attention to all the little things the teacher had done really well.

What this did was transformational (an overused word, I know, but in this case it applied) for their relationship and for that teacher’s development. When they were seen doing all the small things that had gone unnoticed before, the teacher relaxed and opened up. They began, without prompting, to speak about the challenges in the class, to ask for advice and to share some of what they were already working on. They proactively invited my colleague back to see them again on a different day, with a bit of time to make some of the changes they had spoken about.

Resistance, or self-protection?

The teacher’s apparent ‘resistance to feedback’ had been, in large part, an understandable defensive response to feeling scrutinised and picked at. When it comes to fostering psychological safety, we know that feeling judged, critiqued and scrutinised does little for anyone’s sense of being safe to explore, to try things, to talk about our mistakes and to learn and grow. The areas for development hadn’t gone anywhere. The difference was that the teacher brought them to the table themselves, once they trusted the person they were bringing them to.

What my colleague’s appreciative approach made space for was something closer to what we would call appreciative inquiry. Appreciative inquiry (often shortened to AI, an acronym which probably causes more confusion these days than it is worth, so I’ll avoid it) is essentially an approach to creating change which, instead of focusing on fixing problems, explores what is working and builds from there. While I don’t think many of us would disagree that there is always something we could be doing better, appreciative inquiry offers an alternative underlying assumption: that in any system, there will be something that works well. Instead of leading with criticism, the idea is to use our understanding of what is going well as a window onto where we would like to get to.

From noticing to asking to building

Something most appreciative inquiry advocates agree on is that it has to be more than just noticing the positives though, as in the case of my colleague, that was a great place to start. True appreciative inquiry goes beyond listing the good stuff and opens up space for dialogue. In my example, that might look something like:

  • You’ve learned every name in a week, in a class where students swear at you. How did you do that?
  • I notice you’ve labelled all the trays. What told you this was needed?
  • You’re maintaining remarkable composure even while being challenged. Can you say more about how you manage that?

The answers to questions like these hold know-how that nobody else in the building can see, and asking for them treats the person as someone with expertise to share.

These would all fit into the first stage of a framework often used to support appreciative inquiry work (please forgive the slightly life-coachy alliteration): Discover, Dream, Design, Destiny. We find a simpler version easier to hold in mind: Notice, Ask, Build. Notice what is going well, ask how it happened, and build what comes next together, led by the person doing the work.

So from our appreciative noticing and asking, the conversation moves towards imagining what the future could be, with questions such as “What would an amazing lesson with this class look like?” or “What response would you love to see from these changes?”, and then into the practicalities of how to get there and make it happen. In my colleague’s case, the teacher largely took themselves through those stages, naming what they wanted to change, planning how to do it and inviting her back to see them try.

Diagram titled “From appreciation to appreciative inquiry”, showing three steps from left to right, linked by arrows. 1, Notice: see what is going well, especially the small things nobody comments on. 2, Ask: get curious about how they did it; the answer holds know-how that nobody else can see. 3, Build: work out what comes next together, led by the person doing the work.

Doing it together

My colleague was one person, noticing on behalf of one teacher. Most of the good work that happens in organisations never gets an observer like her, which is where I think appreciative inquiry has real potential as a team practice, and particularly in retrospectives.

Many retrospectives include some version of “what went well”, but it tends to get a quick pass before everyone settles into the part they think is the real work. A Home Office team writing about their own retrospectives noticed exactly this, with the positives whizzed through and the negatives dwelt on. Even when the good things do get mentioned, they are usually listed rather than explored.

An appreciative retrospective slows that part down and adds the question my colleague’s feedback set up: how did you do that? It might sound like:

  • What have we done recently that’s made our work easier, and how did we go about it?
  • When was the team working at its best this month, and what was different about that period?
  • What did we get right with this project that we’d want to do again on purpose?

Asking someone to explain how they did something, in front of their colleagues, makes visible the kind of work that usually only shows up when it stops happening. It also spreads the craft knowledge, since the person who untangled the handover, or got the awkward machinery working again, or calmed the difficult client is often the only one who knows how they did it. It’s worth keeping an eye on whose work gets named and whose doesn’t, too, because the people doing the least visible work are often the least likely to be mentioned, even in a session designed to notice them.

Where appreciative inquiry works, and where it doesn’t

None of this works if it isn’t honest. My colleague didn’t pretend the lesson had gone well, and that mattered. Appreciation that is used to paper over real concerns, or to steer people away from saying difficult things, teaches them that some things can’t be said, which is the opposite of psychological safety.

This is especially important in the moment someone brings up a problem. If a person in an appreciative retrospective wants to talk about what isn’t working, telling them “we’re focusing on the positives today” is about the best way I can think of to make sure they never raise it again. Gervase Bushe, one of the researchers who has written most carefully about appreciative inquiry, suggests a different response: ask what’s missing, what they’d want more of, or what they’d expect to see if things were working as they hoped. The concern stays in the room, and the conversation turns towards what we’d like to get to. For the teacher in my example, “this class doesn’t listen to me” might become “what would it look like if they did, and have you seen even a glimpse of that yet?”

Some concerns need tackling head on, though, and appreciative inquiry isn’t the right tool for every moment. Bushe also observes that groups carrying a lot of unspoken resentment tend not to take to an appreciative process until those feelings have had some airing first.

But in environments where psychological safety is low, where we want to work on building trust, or where we know there has not been enough attention paid to strengths, appreciative inquiry is a powerful tool in our toolkit. What it does very well is shine a light on the things that are going well that so often go unnoticed in ordinary work. The people who keep the wheels on rarely get the credit they deserve, because we only notice when the wheels come off.

Further Reading

From psychsafety.com

Other sources

  • Bushe, G. R. (2001). Five theories of change embedded in appreciative inquiry. In D. Cooperrider, P. Sorenson, D. Whitney & T. Yaeger (Eds.), Appreciative Inquiry: An Emerging Direction for Organization Development (pp. 117–127). Champaign, IL: Stipes.
  • Bushe, G. R. (2007). Appreciative inquiry is not (just) about the positive. OD Practitioner, 39(4), 30–35.
  • Cooperrider, D. L. & Whitney, D. (2005). Appreciative Inquiry: A Positive Revolution in Change. San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler.
  • Fitzgerald, S. P., Oliver, C. & Hoxsey, J. C. (2010). Appreciative inquiry as a shadow process. Journal of Management Inquiry, 19(3), 220–233.
  • Health Education England (n.d.). Start with what’s working: an introduction to appreciative inquiry.
  • Kelly, N., Blake, S. & Plunkett, A. (2016). Learning from excellence in healthcare: a new approach to incident reporting. Archives of Disease in Childhood, 101(9), 788–791.
  • Sharp, C., Dewar, B. & Barrie, K. (2017). Forming new futures through appreciative inquiry. Iriss Insight 33.
  • Taylor, N. (2014). Agile working: the ‘appreciative retrospective’. Digital Transformation blog, GOV.UK.

The post Appreciative Inquiry appeared first on Psych Safety.

❌
❌